8 ms·
Google to use patient data to develop healthcare algorithms for hospital chain
- chunky1994 5y agoIf I'm reading the article correctly, this is allowed by HIPAA already and is already happening (for research purposes and by third party healthcare companies?). I would much rather google handle this data rather than unknown third parties with their own agendas, at least with google, the data comes with privacy risks that are relatively well known and might actually be useful for clinicians due to google's expertise on AI/pattern classification work which is primarily what medical diagnoses is about now (IANAD so perhaps this is incorrect).
- ladyanita22 5y agooh boy you're gonna be downvoted here...
- tedivm 5y agoHIPAA lets companies share data with other companies as long as it meets two requirements- 1. The company that collects the data (the covered entity) has to have a Business Associate Agreement in place with the company they're sharing it with. This basically affirms that the other company is aware of their HIPAA requirements and intends to follow them. 2. The Business Associate needs to access the data to do the job they were hired for, which in turn should be related to patient care. There are definitely a lot of companies out there doing this already, but I will say that the people with the data are not exactly giving it up easily. HIPAA makes it so that in the event of a breach the Covered Entity is responsible for beach notification to the patients. That means there's a huge incentive for hospitals, radiology groups, and anyone else who collects this data to make sure that the people they share it with have the proper safeguards in place. There are a ton of hoops to jump through, normally including independent third party audits. I've seen a few medical AI companies fail simply because they didn't have the security and no one trusted them with data.
- wins32767 5y agoThat's true if the data is PHI, which means that it's personally identifiable. Per TFA, Google is using anonymized data. There are a bunch of companies that do this already, for example my last startup had anonymized health records from ~240 million Americans.
- tedivm 5y agoMy last startup does this as well, but in our experience deidentification is not nearly as robust as the companies using it claim it is.
- potatoman22 5y agoCase in point: The Netflix prize fiasco.
- wins32767 5y agoWe had biostatisticians on staff as well as third party companies review our de-idenitification regularly. From a population level we were quite solid. That said, were I an attacker trying to re-identify a specific person's data it would be hard to do with just basic demographic information but if you combine some specific health knowledge (a couple health problems you know your coworker has) or appointment info (date, type of doctor, stuff that may also come up in common conversations) it gets a lot easier.
- mfer 5y agoEven though this happens... Google still makes me nervous because... - Other large companies with other big agendas have violated rules on data sharing to improve performance in other areas. Amazon comes to mind with how they used markeplace data on vendors to produce their own competitive products. Rules are regularly broken. - Will Google let auditors really have enough insight to make sure data is kept in a controlled manner? Google is so secretive. If a data broker started a secure file sharing service I wouldn't trust them. That's how I feel about this.
- fmakunbound 5y agoGoogle, an adtech company, should not have access to patient records – anonymized or not.
- yhoneycomb 5y agoFor the unaware - this particular hospital chain (HCA) is super, super shady. It's a for-profit institution, which is alarming in and of itself when the bar for hospitals to be nonprofit is so low (and when most of the "non-profit" hospitals are essentially for profit institutions anyway.)
- wfhbata 5y ago> when most of the "non-profit" hospitals are essentially for profit institutions anyway This sounds worse than a for-profit institution declaring itself as a for-profit institution. What is it about the chain that is “super, super shady”?
- yhoneycomb 5y ago> HCA Inc. (formerly known as Columbia/HCA and HCA - The Healthcare Company) has agreed to pay the United States $631 million in civil penalties and damages arising from false claims the government alleged it submitted to Medicare and other federal health programs, the Justice Department announced today. https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2003/June/03_civ_386.htm https://www.justice.gov/archive/opa/pr/2003/June/03_civ_386....
- clusterhacks 5y agoI work as a data engineer in an academic medical research institution. Most electronic medical records (EMR) systems are really about billing. Yes, there are clinically relevant data fields available but a large amount of what we were after as researchers was only available in free-text. Data abstraction is still mostly a human-expert driven activity. It would be fun if that could be better automated but there is significant ambiguity in clinical notes and pathology reports. And don't get me started on data-ownership "turf wars." We often got significant pushback and simple refusal to have regular data feeds of IRB-approved data fields for collection with patients who were consented to studies. Nothing was more annoying to me to get shot-down when trying to get data from our hospital EMR (again, data that was specifically approved for research use by IRB for patients already consented to studies) only to hear later about private enterprise "partnerships" that had full and unlimited access to all EMR data . . .
- bearjaws 5y agoThis is extremely spot on, Cerner goes to far as to tie almost everything to a billing encounter (FIN). Yet the documents still come over as PDFs that clinicians have to parse through.
- doggodaddo78 5y agoYep. tl;dr : EHR are mostly about charts. EMR are mostly about billing. The risks of unfettered access to EMR is that conditions can be inferred and future profitabilit of patients predicted so that they can be steered to different types and qualities of care (for good or for evil). For-profit healthcare will overall optimize for profits before patient outcomes. It's as certain as gravity. FPH should be illegal.
- adolph 5y agoAny organization that does not optimize value capture will be short-lived. Neither for-profit, nonprofit nor governmental business models are necessarily aligned towards improving patient outcomes over revenue. However revenue is a critical feedback loop to enforce change in the face of poor outcomes. The Medicare agency cut off funding for heart transplants at [a nonprofit hospital] last year after the Chronicle-ProPublica investigation documented an outsized number of patient deaths and unusual surgical complications following the procedure in recent years. https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/investigations/article/Federal-report-details-problems-that-led-to-13645748.php https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/investigations/article...
- doggodaddo78 5y ago"Don't be evil." For-profit healthcare is evil. https://www.pbs.org/video/the-healthcare-divide-rv6npd/ https://www.pbs.org/video/the-healthcare-divide-rv6npd/
- drknownuffin 5y agoWay to oversimplify. Some healthcare is vital (emergency intervention for heart attacks), some healthcare is grey-area quality of life (do I need glasses vs. LASIK?), and some healthcare is pure luxury (cosmetic). These are not all created equal. Additionally, removing the profit motive has its own consequences. Ever notice how the front-desk staff that serves as your docs' connection to the rest of the healthcare sector generally suck? Try to get a preauth, or a drug renewal, or an etc. There's a reason they suck: if your doc is working with a price ceiling (as most are, due to health insurance if not due to socialized medicine), they have a hard cap on their annual income for the year. The difference between a 2/10 and a 10/10 service staff doesn't make a single extra cent of income for the doc, but they have to pay the difference in salary straight out of their annual take-home. How many docs are going to get an 80K/yr front desk vs. a 40k/yr front desk just out of charity?
- albroland 5y ago>Ever notice how the front-desk staff that serves as your docs' connection to the rest of the healthcare sector generally suck? Compare this to for-profit clinics like One Medical, where your appointment typically starts exactly on time and front desk staff are courteous, helpful, and responsive to calls and emails. This holds true to every location of theirs I've used across major US metros (NYC, SF, PHX, CHI) [1]. Anecdotally, one time I forgot my eyedrops on a trip to SF. I tried to get a hold of my ophthalmologist's office back in NYC so they could send a prescription to a pharmacy in SF. On hold for 25 minutes, disconnected, tried one more time then gave up. Opened One Medical app, requested a virtual visit, had a Dr on a video call in 3 minutes who confirmed my eye drops and submitted the prescription to the pharmacy I was sitting in. I'm not sure how much of it is down to profit motive and I'm sure there are tons of other confounding factors, but it's hard to not notice the huge difference in experience. [1] I work in the healthcare industry and I'm a happy One Medical customer; I initially got it as a perk thru work but upon leaving I coughed up the money to continue using them.
- jcims 5y agoI wonder why this is coming out of Google and not Verily.
- dekhn 5y agoThere is a whole division within Research called Google Health led by David Feinberg (https://www.linkedin.com/in/david-feinberg-4b5b76/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/david-feinberg-4b5b76/) which works on these sorts of problems. It's sort of situated between Cloud and Research, as many of the problems they want to solve are... well, research problems that need large real-world datasets to solve. Verily has its own things it wants to focus on, and I don't think large EHR analytics projects are one of them. Their ambitions are probably budget limited now (IE, they have to be selective about which projects to take on) while Google Research and Cloud have a lot of funding to build products like this.
- jcims 5y agoAh! That’s good info, thank you. I applied for a job at Verily a while back out of a desire to pivot out of my current industry. Once I got up close to it though I had a little trouble sussing out how they would operate separate from Google, which I think is going to have to be the case eventually. Stuff like this just makes it even harder to see. (edit: I wonder if it has anything to do with patents/ip) Everyone I actually talked to was great though and I wish then the best.
- adolph 5y agoFor those curious about what it means to anonymize health information this NIST paper provides some context and the range of risk/value options when removing personally identifiable information from healthcare datasets. https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2015/NIST.IR.8053.pdf https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2015/NIST.IR.8053.pdf Additional helpful works: Anonymizing Health Data by Khaled El Emam, Luk Arbuckle Building an Anonymization Pipeline by Luk Arbuckle, Khaled El Emam Practical Synthetic Data Generation by Khaled El Emam, Lucy Mosquera, Richard Hoptroff Accelerating AI with Synthetic Data by Khaled El Emam Khaled El Emam's website: http://www.ehealthinformation.ca/ http://www.ehealthinformation.ca/
- readams 5y agoPretty frequently in these scare-generation articles there's no attempt to differentiate between someone using Google Cloud to do something, and Google itself doing something. Is this just a hospital chain making a deal for Google Cloud services to support their normal IT operations, or is Google actually using this data for something? If so, what is Google using the data for?
- pmccarren 5y ago> Google has made a deal for access to patient records from HCA, which which operates 181 hospitals and more than 2,000 healthcare sites in 21 states, _so the tech company can develop healthcare algorithms_.