20 ms·
Today's new expensive housing will indirectly create more cheap housing in the pre-existing housing stock, by pulling demand out of the market. Only if people
by onion2k 5y ago
Today's new expensive housing will indirectly create more cheap housing in the pre-existing housing stock, by pulling demand out of the market.
Only if people actually live in those houses, and they're bought by people living in the cheaper houses right now who then move up in to the new housing stock.
If people buy the new houses as investments and leave them empty most of the year then it has no impact on the rest of the housing market, or if people from outside buy them and move to the city then it just increases the population of the city with no effect on the lower social strata. This is precisely what happens in places like London. There's a boom in house building but it's often apartments bought by foreign investors (allegedly for money laundering... ).
Directly building more social housing would have a far greater impact than trying to affect cheap housing stock by 'trickle down' methods.
- alisonkisk 5y agoWhy wouldn't "social housing" get gentrified?
- tylerhou 5y agoWhat concrete data do you have to suggest that luxury homes aren't being occupied at significantly higher rates than general housing stock?
- onion2k 5y agohttps://www.actiononemptyhomes.org/pretty-vacant https://www.actiononemptyhomes.org/pretty-vacant "Wealth investment leaves an estimated 125,000 homes in London without anyone living in them." There are 268,385 empty homes in England according to the government (people get a tax break in most parts of England if they own a property that is unoccupied and unfurnished so its quite easy to track empty homes), and half of them are luxury houses in London. I'm not saying that's definitely the case everywhere, but I am saying it's worth considering.
- maddyboo 5y agoWhat is the rationale for giving such a tax break? That seems ridiculous.
- onion2k 5y agoThe current UK government is full of people who believe rich people keeping their money is how you stimulate the economy in to growth. It's not a completely unreasonable position according to economic theory but there are plenty of reasons to disagree with it.
- imtringued 5y agoIf your economy cannot produce all the products consumers consume then you need to encourage saving. If the economy cannot consume all the products the suppliers produce you need to encourage consumption. If you perfectly hit the balance (unlikely but in theory possible) then you need to do... nothing, neither savings nor consumption increases. It depends on what your economy needs.
- tylerhou 5y agoThe actual report says that there are 125,000 homes in London without permanent residents. Those homes aren't unoccupied; they're often used for AirBnB or temporary rentals. That's not a vacancy. In reality, only a fifth of those homes are empty most of the time. Also, the report doesn't tell us how many non-vacant homes there are in their survey area, so we have to guess. London reportedly has 3.59 million dwellings, so 25,000 vacant homes would only represent 0.7% of homes being vacant. Even if you use the higher 125,000 number, that's still only 3.5% of all homes. That's a fairly low vacancy rate, and about right for a city. Even after the pandemic, housing officials report a 3.4% vacancy rate, which is the highest in eight years. https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/london-apartment-vacancy-rate-hits-eight-year-high-of-3-4-per-cent https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/london-apartment-vacancy.... Before that, it was only at 1.8%. That's extremely low. You can tax vacant homes, but in general, those taxes have a very small effect on housing prices. It's far, far more effective to allow people to build more housing, including luxury housing.
- sp332 5y agoVancouver https://bc.ctvnews.ca/10-800-housing-units-sit-empty-in-vancouver-most-are-apartments-1.2808161 https://bc.ctvnews.ca/10-800-housing-units-sit-empty-in-vanc... Manhattan https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/01/american-housing-has-gone-insane/605005/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/01/american-h... Seattle https://www.seattleweekly.com/news/luxury-apartments-whos-buying-king-county/ https://www.seattleweekly.com/news/luxury-apartments-whos-bu... Melbourne https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/ghost-tower-warning-for-docklands-after-data-reveals-high-melbourne-home-vacancies-20141111-11kkxz.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/ghost-tower-warn... Boston https://bostonagentmagazine.com/2018/09/11/study-bostons-new-luxury-towers-largely-sit-empty/ https://bostonagentmagazine.com/2018/09/11/study-bostons-new...
- epistasis 5y agoThat seems like solid evidence that vacancy is not the problem in the least...
- tylerhou 5y agoNone of the articles support a narrative that there is an epidemic of vacancies among high-end housing. Vancouver: The article claims that there is ~5% vacancy rate. This is actually below the normal rate for vacancies in the US. Condos have a higher vacancy rate, but the article offers a reasonable explanation. Manhattan: Ultra-luxury home vacancies aren't the same as luxury apartment buildings. Most people are not buying $5-$10 million condos. And even if the buildings are unsold, they aren't necessarily unoccupied. Seattle: Again focuses on "foreign investors" and unsold apartments. No concrete data on how many those apartments are actually empty. Melbourne: > Prosper Australia project director Karl Fitzgerald said, based on the water data, Melbourne's actual vacancy rate was closer to 7 per cent. 7% is on the high-end of vacancy rates, but if you reduced that down to 5% then the effect on prices would still be low. Boston: No data on vacancy rates. Again, sale != occupancy. There are plenty of property management companies that build out luxury apartment buildings and directly rent to people. The real issue is lack of housing, which can be fixed by letting developers build more housing, including high-end housing.
- 5y ago
- spfzero 5y agoWow, buying a house and leaving it vacant most of the year doesn't seem like a very good investment. In my experience when people I've known bought an investment property the number one thing on their minds was occupancy, and if they thought it would lie vacant for more than a month or two, they wouldn't buy it. I do see your point about foreign investors though, they will view the house as a bank account, one that won't lose money, and will probably appreciate, and is safe from the corruption (or corruption investigations) of their home country. And they have money they need to put somewhere, so why not there? But even they would probably prefer someone to be living in it and paying them in the meantime, because that improves the return by a lot, and doesn't put the principal at risk.
- dnautics 5y agoIf it's not occupied isn't it losing money at least by bleeding to property taxes?
- onion2k 5y agoYes, but property values in London are increasing at a rate that more than pays for that (many times over actually).
- simfree 5y agoSame in Seattle, my block has a 2017 constructed home that has never had occupants, owned by a non-resident from China. He owns at least a few other empty new homes in the inner suburbs as well. About once every 2 weeks his son pops by to make sure the house has not burned down or had a pipe burst.
- iancmceachern 5y agoCan I rent one of his houses?
- maffydub 5y agoDo you have any data on that? Currently living in zone 2 north-east London and house prices have seemed pretty flat for the last couple of years. Flats have had a surge due to current stamp duty holiday... and prices outside London seem to have increased a lot with people anticipating a permanent move to remote/hybrid working. Taxes on empty properties aren't high, but you still need to consider maintenance... and there's an opportunity cost of leaving a house empty rather than renting it out. Just interested in your data - thanks! Update: found https://www.actiononemptyhomes.org/pretty-vacant https://www.actiononemptyhomes.org/pretty-vacant in one of your sibling posts - was that what you were referring to? I just read it (on my phone, so might have missed it), but didn't see any numbers for investment returns here... and there was a fairly-extensive section talking about London property being used for money-laundering instead - is that what you're referring to?
- throwaway316943 5y agoLuxury second homes should simply be taxed at a high rate, it’s one of the least defensible indulgences so with enough of a campaign it could happen. Ditto for speculative foreign buyers, this is already happening in some cities that have been hard hit by such “investments”.
- BurningFrog 5y agoI'm fascinated by how widespread this weird idea is. Even if we buy the exotic premise that investors would buy houses and leave them empty - generating zero rental income for these greed driven people - as an investment, we still have to explain why they would only do this with new housing stock. Why can't you do the same trick with existing housing?
- vxNsr 5y agoI’ve heard of it too, apparently foreign money (mostly China) needs a legit way to pull the money out of their country and real estate is a good way to do it that doesn’t alarm regulators. Can’t say why it doesn’t make sense to rent it out. But I do know that Vancouver passed laws to limit this type of purchase.
- mactrey 5y agoDid Vancouver pass limits on foreign purchases because that was the underlying reason for the high cost of housing, or did they pass limits because that was easier than actually building new housing?
- imtringued 5y agoBuilding housing must be stopped at all costs.
- andy_jensen 5y ago>Even if we buy the exotic premise that investors would buy houses and leave them empty - generating zero rental income for these greed driven people - as an investment, we still have to explain why they would only do this with new housing stock. Where I live the housing prices are expected to go up roughly 15% this year. So someone buying a house for 600k can expect to sell it for 690k making 90k. That is 7500 USD a month. If you wanted to make that much money from rent you would have to squeeze 4 or 5 tenants into the property. It is simply not worth the hassle trying to rent buildings out when house prices go up at such a high rate
- stale2002 5y ago> If people buy the new houses as investments and leave them empty most of the year Fortunately, this is already a metric that is tracked, called the vacancy rate. And what we see is, that in in-demand cities, that have high rents, the vacancy rate is pretty low. So, if the vacancy rate is 5%, that means that if you build 100 houses, then 95 of them are going to be lived in. Yes, it sucks that those other 5 houses are not lived in, but those extra 95 houses, in our example, are still a good thing. > This is precisely what happens in places like London It is really not. A quick google search shows that the vacancy rate is as low as any other major in-demand city.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoOne factor in vacancy rates at least in SF / NY - rent control. You really CANNOT rent to someone without a big risk - so if you have an elderly parent who might want to move in in the future, you have kids who might want a place - and are wealthy - you really need to keep place empty. So yes, the rich do leave I think more places empty in some places because they can afford to and because the economic calculation is not simple. If you rent and want to end the rental later you end up in a bad spot.
- stale2002 5y ago> more places empty in some places Ok, this is a nice story that one could make up. But once again, my point is that vacancy rate is something that is already tracked. In San Francisco, the vacancy rate is about 3.5%. So, in other words, regardless of whatever story you are making up about parents, or rent control or whatever, the actual data shows, that the vacancy rate is very low, and therefore not much of a problem.
- whoknowswhat11 5y agoI'm not disagreeing at all. But I know of enough unusual vacancies in SF among the rich that it strikes me as a small corner factor. In another city (smaller, parents live there) EVERYONE rents when they are not in their space. I mean, even just for summer if traveling. But when you come back, the tenant must leave (and does). I know someone who sublet an extra room to someone, a year later her wonderful lease was destroyed, landlord sued her and the women never paid a dime, could not be evicted, claimed she felt unsafe and got a restraining order against the person actually paying rent etc so they ended paying rent on two places, one to live in and one for the women. I mean - this stuff does turn you off renting a small bit. That said, supply is REDICULOUSLY constrained around here, red tape is nuts, minimum requirements crazy, affordability payments high etc. So yeah, no question that there is artificial scarcity.
- imtringued 5y agoWhen people buy housing and leave it empty, they are buying the land, the house is a bonus. People never buy housing as an investment unless they use it to reduce the cost of living (pretty much never) or rent it out (happens a lot). Buying land works fine because of rent seeking.