3 ms·
I've written before about this: there has long been a "protein orthodoxy" which always defaults to the hypothesis that if something interesting happened, protei
by dekhn 5y ago
I've written before about this: there has long been a "protein orthodoxy" which always defaults to the hypothesis that if something interesting happened, protein did it.
For example when people finally reached the interesting question "what is the molecule which confers heredity", almost everybody thought it had to be proteins, and the mainstream worked hard to ignore the entirely factual and reproducible findings until they couldn't any longer (basically, the period before Avery's experiment, and between it and Hershey/Chase).
The same happened with ribosomes: the community insisted ribosomes were protein machines with some RNA decoration, even though experiments done in the 60s and 70s showed that RNA was the active element. Similarly, with ribozymes- RNA that folds up into structures and carries out specific enzymatic reactions. People worked really hard to avoid changing their mind that only proteins could be enzymes.
Interstingly, the best example I've seen is the opposite: prions. When I was in grad school, the professor who was the expert on prions was at my institution, and had just about managed to run the experiments fully supporting his hypothesis (that prions are infection proteins and the replication process is distinct from that of bacterial or viral replication). The only way you could get the virologists to stop complaining was to point out that it wasn't theoretically impossible that proteins could catalyze other proteins to change shape in a chain reaction, and that Prusiner had reduced everything to a working system in mice that could be reproduced by anybody willing to wait the 60 days a single experiment took.