9 ms·
There's a 'hot' subculture in our society that says 'if you ain't cheating, you ain't trying', that refers to lies as 'hustle', that rewards and embraces decept
by wolverine876 5y ago
There's a 'hot' subculture in our society that says 'if you ain't cheating, you ain't trying', that refers to lies as 'hustle', that rewards and embraces deception as just agressiveness and boldness, as a norm for life and business and even a celebration of human nature - as if the worst elements of human nature define us any more than the best, as if we don't have that choice (at least, that's how I am trying to articulate it).
It has predictable results. Where are we going to get reliable research, and anything else, if we can't trust each other. Trust is an incredible business tool - highly efficient when you can take risks, be vulnerable, and don't have worry about the other person. Trust is an incredible tool for personal relationships, for the same reasons, and because if you can't trust them and can't be vulnerable, you have a very limited relationship.
- hristov 5y agoUnfortunately it is not even a subculture. It is often openly touted in mainstream culture. Steve Jobs is often brought up as a hero of that type of thinking. You are absolutely right that trust and reliability are very valuable. Societies with high trust tend to be richer and much more productive than societies overriden by cheating and corruption.
- undersuit 5y ago>Steve Jobs is often brought up as a hero of that type of thinking. Like the anecdote that he leased a new car every month so he could avoid registering it with the state.
- woodruffw 5y ago> There's a 'hot' subculture in our society that says 'if you ain't cheating, you ain't trying', that refers to lies as 'hustle', that rewards and embraces deception as just agressiveness and boldness, as a norm for life and business and even a celebration of human nature - as if the worst elements of human nature define us any more than the best, as if we don't have that choice (at least, that's how I am trying to articulate it). I'm not sure that you intended it this way, but this reads as very oblique (i.e., "wink and nudge"). Which subculture are you referring to, and what particular relationship do you think they have to research in Computer Science?
- wolverine876 5y ago> I'm not sure that you intended it this way, but this reads as very oblique (i.e., "wink and nudge"). Which subculture are you referring to, and what particular relationship do you think they have to research in Computer Science? I am referring to no particular subculture. Lots of people around me embrace it, including from all over the political spectrum (if that's what you are thinking). I think the broader society sets the norms for computer science, as with everything else. For example, when star athletes like Barry Bonds, or entire teams like the Houston Astros, or much of college sports, cheat with few reprocussions (and in the past, that wasn't the case - players were banned and school sports programs were basically shut down, etc.) that affects computer science research.
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoYeah, honestly go to any conference in the last decade and you'll see some people who are just... out of place in an academic, like, when they were 19 they listened to a podcast that claimed PhDs made XX% more money, so they decided to do that. These people don't care about research, don't care to understand research, they just want to publish, get their degree, and get paychecks from Google/Facebook/Apple. Luckily I've seen a number of these types of people fail to find any high profile jobs after they graduate, so I guess something is still working.
- charwalker 5y agoCould apply to research, application development, web development, credential management...
- Causality1 5y agoReap what you sow. We spend our whole lives being told it's perfectly OK that every corporation and person in power behaving like a sociopath is totally fine and this is the culture you get in return.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoAcademia WAS designed to be an insulated castle from all that, that's why Newton lived in a shitty apartment while getting money from his mom. The institution of research was supposed to be a rich man's game, people who didn't give a shit about practicality, just one upping each other. Once people realized academics could be leveraged to do cool shit like build A-Bombs, it was over.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> Once people realized academics could be leveraged to do cool shit like build A-Bombs, it was over. Arguably, it's the opposite. Once people realized academics could do this kind of cool shit, they got showered with money and told to do whatever the they want. That's how we got the incredible scientific and engineering advances of the second half of 20th century. Then the beancounters started asking questions about what the money actually buys, and research quickly turned into another short-term, self-contained, profit-chasing game, starved for resources and only occasionally producing something actually useful.
- achillesheels 5y agoNyquist, Bode, Shannon, etc. didn’t need an A bomb to advance their research which is the bedrock of the digital control systems that microcomputers are.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYes. They also didn't need to spend 90% of their time chasing grant money and publishing papers. As it is, if our researchers are spending almost all their time thinking about and doing things other than research, what do we expect? On a tangent, software industry has a bit of similar problem, with the best developers being forced to enter management roles[0] instead of solving technical problems. That is, a developer progresses from doing shoddy work to doing mediocre work and then, just as they start doing high-quality work, they get told to manage a new cohort of juniors doing shoddy work instead. I wonder if that's why so much software is hot garbage these days. -- [0] - Whether proper ones on management path, or "fake" ones like principal developer, where you get all the managerial responsibilities with none of the authority.
- pitaj 5y agoNormalization play a huge role in creating this. There are far too many rules in our society at all levels that make no sense and exist seemingly to benefit the rich and powerful. Highly demanded goods and services are prohibited (drugs, gambling, prostitution). Bureaucratic nonsense at every turn. So much schoolwork that it's practically required to cheat to succeed. Testing with barely any resemblance of real-world conditions. Abstract methods that bore students to death.
- wolverine876 5y agoThose aren't reasons to act dishonestly and abuse other people. In fact, those are reasons to do the opposite - if you find the world so terrible, do something to make it better. It's up to you and me. Nobody else is coming to save us.
- pitaj 5y agoWhen people are surrounded by rules that make no sense, many start to question all rules. It's not a justification for acting dishonestly, but it is the cause. One way we can make the world better is by fixing the rules. Getting rid of ones that are unjust, and making the rest more consistent.
- FpUser 5y ago>"One way we can make the world better is by fixing the rules. Getting rid of ones that are unjust, and making the rest more consistent." I once saw sign on a street: do not do something (do not remember what) and reference to a City Bylaw numbered as 37 thousand and something. That is just for one city. Good luck changing this sheer insanity.
- munk-a 5y agoI don't think the quantity of laws is really an issue as long as they are being applied fairly and (and this is the vague part) society views them as generally just.
- lovich 5y agoIt’s just a general breakdown of the rule of law and trust all over our society. When everyone around you is breaking the rules and receiving no repercussions, then following the rules yourself is equivalent to choosing to lose. We used to have strong institutions that were supposed to help push groups into not choosing the bad corner of the prisoners dilemma, but they all seemed to have degraded. I suppose they could have always been like this and the curtain has just been removed, but I’d argue that the perception that following the rules was the best personal choice is almost as valuable as it being true
- toomim 5y agoYes. Here are some stats on the breakdown of trust in society: https://medium.com/@slowerdawn/the-decline-of-trust-in-the-united-states-fb8ab719b82a https://medium.com/@slowerdawn/the-decline-of-trust-in-the-u... This animated gif makes it clear: https://invisible.college/reputation/declining-trust.gif https://invisible.college/reputation/declining-trust.gif
- slx26 5y agoCan be trusted with what? Given how complicated life is, I'm actually impressed with how morally people behaves. In that sense, I trust that most people are doing what they can, and they are trying to do no harm to others. But that doesn't mean I trust people to be very competent anyway. Trust what.
- aaron-santos 5y agoDo you disagree with either the specific operationalization of trust in the article or even the abstract concept of operationalization of trust in general?
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI think he is just saying that trusting someone with your walley and trusting someome with your life are different benchmarks
- 908B64B197 5y agoReminds me of Jugaad [0] or Chabuduo mindset in mainland China. Basically if all it takes is getting citations, then forming a citation ring is "Chabuduo" and you'll only lose face if you are caught (not good enough). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugaad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugaad
- bakul 5y agoJugaad is very different from this sort of collusion.
- eindiran 5y agoFrom the wiki article it sounds like it just refers to extremely improvised engineering, something akin to "bubble gum and baling wire" or "MacGyvering" something. Something like a kludge, but a bit less pejorative.
- BadInformatics 5y agoThis kind of collusion is driven far more by perverse incentives than some alleged cultural phenomenon of half-assery people like to attach an incorrect but exotic-sounding foreign phrase to. I can't speak for Jugaad, but 差不多 ("Chabuduo") is not at all appropriate here [1]. Just call it what it is: cheating, collusion and conspiracy. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27052249 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27052249. This reminds me of the Japanese buzzword bingo of earlier decades.
- vmception 5y agoLou Pai is the greatest of all time and every man (or breadwinner) would be a fool to blindly follow any other script in society that is presented to them Getting a divorce court judge to force you to sell your Enron shares at the top, nuking the regulator’s ability to charge you with insider trading, while you elope with your younger hotter high libido stripper nymph to the mountain you bought? These are our role models
- omgwtfbbq 5y agoDoesn't this make the case that we should be building institutions and systems resistant to this type of cheating? Why should it be possible at all to game Journals in this way? Particularly in Computer Science journals where people think about edge cases for a living...
- munk-a 5y agoI don't think we can actually solve this on a case by case basis. Other threads in this discussion have highlighted cultural normalization of greed in one of its various forms and I would tend to agree with that angle. Those systems that can be built to be resistant to greed would definitely benefit from it - but I think it's more of an issue with society at large.
- wolverine876 5y agoWe gotta start somewhere, and certainly the place to start isn't naysaying. What should we do?
- bigiain 5y agoHeh. We need to set up a research project that redteam/blueteams various journals and conferences. And bug bounties for disclosing zero-days in peer review processes/practices. (The redeem/blueteam thing is kinda unethical, so maybe the University of Minnesota should do it...)
- wolverine876 5y ago> Doesn't this make the case that we should be building institutions and systems resistant to this type of cheating? Absolutely. I think people are intimidated, demoralized (de-moralized) and where once they believed anything was possible, any social problem could be solved (even those old as history, such as women's rights, human rights, etc.), now they've somehow drunk the wrong Kool Aid, some stuff distributed by Jim Jones. Time to get to work.
- munk-a 5y ago> 'if you ain't cheating, you ain't trying' I'm a US expat and escaping this culture is one of the things that's made me happiest - I tend to call it the bullshit culture because my favorite example is... writing a good paper for class is admired - but what's really praised is writing a paper that gets good marks without ever having read the subject matter. Being able to spin lies about a topic you've no understanding of and turn that into a marketable skill is a dark potent for the future of America. I think it's always been somewhat present, but since emerging strongly out of the business world in the eighties it's gained a lot of steam. We are a society that can benefit from cooperation where everyone gets a fair slice of the pie, but that society is eroded if we praise and not shame those people who betray societal trust and cheat the system.
- wfhbata 5y agoIs this really an American thing? At least in academia, American universities (and Western universities in general) have had a good track record overall with academic integrity, and it has set them apart. This seems to have degraded recently, perhaps because of the increasing pressure of the “publish or perish” system (or dozens of other potential causes). We do celebrate people who excel academically seemingly effortlessly. But we don’t celebrate bullshit artists so much in school. In business, and particularly tech, it’s another story.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> At least in academia, American universities (and Western universities in general) have had a good track record overall with academic integrity, and it has set them apart. The difference is that these collusion rings or bogus studies are discussed and exposed publicly. It's not the case in Asia.
- munk-a 5y agoI don't think it's nearly as prevalent in Academia. I agree that that sort of deception is quickly punished in Academia if it's discovered and publicized, but I think it still is viewed positively in private contexts. I think it's more of a cultural issue in general. You can read a bunch of articles on Bernie Madoff, Martin Shkreli and Billy McFarland that romanticize the cunning with which these folks exploited others. Most pieces on them will present an overall negative tone but often feature some pretty glowing admiration of them. Let's also not forget that tax evasion by Trump was praised repeatedly as him beating the system - that's a pretty common view point, more common (especially when it comes to taxes) than the view that those individuals are failing to pay their fair share from what I've observed at least. Trumps a complicated example due to all the political baggage around him so maybe just look at companies like Apple, Google and Facebook - they regularly offshore large portions of their profits and I really doubt the people working to those ends feel any shame, instead it's likely a "beating the system" motivation.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoYCombinator seems to encourage this. Here's what they say about their dinner events: "Talks are strictly off the record to encourage candor, because the inside story of most startups is more colorful than the one presented later to the public. Because YC has been around so long and we have personal relationships with most of the speakers, they trust that what they say won’t get out and tell us a lot of medium-secret stuff." Anecdotally, I've heard stories about Zuckerberg confessing/bragging about all sorts of nasty things at these dinners. Really, this stuff should just be shamed. Sadly, too often calling out bad behavior just gets you called a "hater"...
- thereare5lights 5y agoLol, they're not even trying to hide it. Do you see what people like Paul Graham tweet? They're pretty open about these nasty things and then they get all surprised when people call them out on it.
- achillesheels 5y agoCould you please give an example for the public audience? Or what is the worst, ie most appalling, you’ve seen?
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoI've actually just encountered this first fucking hand and it disgusted me. I'm an aspiring founder working on something and met a coworker who had been through YC W17. I wanted to pick his brain on his experience, especially since I've been applying to YC myself. This coworker told me he and his "startup": - routinely lied to potential customers on the size of their client list - misled clients on the depth and completeness of their product - blatantly broke CA laws to cut cost corners All of this was done to secure contracts in order to secure more funding. "Always be selling", he said. He literally fucking said to me that he learned to "be dubious, not deceitful" which is probably one of the most deceitful things I've ever heard. Made me sick to my stomach and pretty much validated (1) why I never moved to SF in the first place, instead moved to NYC and (2) how much of a fraud YC has become. Absolute fucking madness.
- SilasX 5y agoDon't forget the big one, "no one knows what they're doing anyway ", a veteran structural engineer has some gaps in his understanding, so that's no different from me, so I should have doubts about launching a skyscraper startup.
- thewarrior 5y agoThis is also often necessitated by brutal evaluation systems that incorporate stack ranking and up or out in their various forms. This almost necessitates some cheating to survive and the only people left are those who survived this system and hence the culture slowly rots.
- ericmcer 5y agoAll the myths and stories of pretty much every culture reinforce these beliefs though. Stories are never about passive people putting in 12 hours a day, day after day building upon honest work. Its about slick instant gratification, getting ahead, winning through cunning, etc. The only way to really do that in the real world is through luck or cheating.
- achillesheels 5y agoWhat myths and stories are you referring to? Hesiod’s Works and Days is opposed to exactly what you suggest. And the Myth of Eden in Judaism - the received tradition of its origin - is a commentary and the need to toil in life. Both “Athens and Jerusalem” are principled according to honest toil. And look at the results!
- wolverine876 5y agoGeorge Washington, Ghandi, MLK, Churchill, Lincoln, Jobs, Torvalds, every religious figure, sports figures, artists, etc. ... they all are about "slick instant gratification, getting ahead, winning through cunning"?
- encryptluks2 5y agoAnytime I see a job description that mentions the world "hustle", and trust me there are quite a few in tech, I immediately discard it... but this description of the culture portrays it more accurately that I could have put into words. I think I shall bring it up next time I see a job description like this and let them know that is the impression they are giving.
- jollybean 5y agoEven though I share your cynicism, 'A Hustle' is very different from 'Having Hustle' i.e. the noun means something from the adjective. Having 'hustle' is actually important at a startup, it's part of the essential aspect of it. I'd argue a 'hacker' has a kind of hustle. I'm pretty suspicious of these things as well, but I've also come to believe in my many years that a bit of koolaid is fine as long as it has self awareness. I wish Elon would stop posting all the stupid things he does, but I think that's what you get with 'all the other stuff'. If Elon were fully polite, conscientious, a 'good listener' I'm not sure Tesla would exist. So we pay for the existence of Tesla by accepting that he's going to do dumb tweets about Crytocoins.
- wolverine876 5y ago> If Elon were fully polite, conscientious, a 'good listener' I'm not sure Tesla would exist. I think that's a BS excuse for bad behavior. How would being polite and concientious harm Tesla? It's simply that he has power and has low standards for his behavior. I know plenty of successful people who do what Musk fails to do.
- jollybean 5y ago"I know plenty of successful people who do what Musk fails to do. " Except you don't know any successful people who've remotely done what he's done either. Talking about 'Dogecoin' is a little unseemly, but it's nowhere in the realm of 'toxic' or 'bad acting' Without massive public support and sympathy, Telsa wouldn't exist, it's a movement as much as anything, and so you need kind of a showman. His appearances on SNL etc. are part of that public drama that keeps Tesla stock going with enough support to keep the legitimacy of the dream alive. I'm seriously doubtful that a quiet, unassuming person would have been able to do most of that. Expressive, bombastic characters will by virtue of the volume of their actions, sometimes creep up to the line. It's normal. There's nothing wrong with Elon, he's just a little cheezy and spouts too hard with some things.
- wolverine876 5y agoIn case others wonder or worry, as I do, that few care about the issues in my parent comment, I'll take the unusual step of reporting that it has more upvotes than much of the front page - far more than I've ever seen. (I'm trying to respect the HN tradition/guideline of not talking about votes. I don't really care about Internet points; I think the implied interest in the issue is worthwhile and applicable in this case.)