5 ms·
Well, if you have too many, you've done an unregistered securities offering and the SEC will come after you. At 35 investors, the rules change. Read up on Regul
by Animats 5y ago
Well, if you have too many, you've done an unregistered securities offering and the SEC will come after you. At 35 investors, the rules change. Read up on Regulation D.
- huac 5y agoUsually angels invest in an SPV right? So technically the SPV holds your shares, they hold shares of the SPV, and you only have one investor?
- Aperocky 5y agoDread it, run from it, encapsulation always arrive.
- tobyjsullivan 5y agoForgive my ignorance. "encapsulation" is a new term for me in this context. What does it mean?
- Aperocky 5y agoPersonally, I feel like many/all software principals can be applied to other subjects, and it has a tendency to make things simpler. Sometimes it's a joke, but other times it is quite fitting.
- icedchai 5y agoNot in the startups I'm familiar with. You have individuals investing anywhere from 10K to 100K+.
- edoceo 5y agoSPV may take $10k from 50 investors and then make one $500k investment. Then the company as SPOC but the network effect of a larger group. And maybe that investor group makes many SPV, so each player is making 10, $10k plays rather one $100k play
- Jorge1o1 5y agoWell, presumably angel investors are accredited. If they don't have at least a million in net worth, what does that say about their track record? And if that's what it says about their track record... what does that say about your company? ;^)
- jacquesm 5y agoThis all needs the context that it is US specific. Other countries usually do not have this 'accredited investor' limitation, nor do they have low limits on how many named investors can participate in any one undertaking.
- Animats 5y agoMost major countries restrict public equity offerings in some way. Many have an equivalent of a "qualified investor". Here's a partial worldwide list.[1] Islamic banking goes in the other direction, though. In the US, anybody can loan money to anybody. Islam prohibits interest. "Loans" in Islamic banking are more like preferred stock, or a setup where the principal is loaned but anything beyond that is more like an equity stake.
- bpodgursky 5y agoThis does come up in "friends and family" rounds though. It's relatively easy in a tech-dense city to find 35 friends and former coworkers willing to invest $15k, but I wouldn't expect that all of them have accumulated $1mm yet (especially in a high-tax locale, if your coworkers are late-20s/early-30s).
- paxys 5y agoThe rules change at 35 non-accredited investors. This has zero bearing on angel investing.
- edoceo 5y agoOh boy. It really does. If, for example, you've got a pile of non-accredited on your cap-table and then go to the next round, those bigger dogs may (read: likely) won't want the smaller players around. So, they get an exit but your raise is not as large cause some of the money goes to them not your company. Lots of variables in there but "zero bearing" is not correct.
- paxys 5y agoYou are conflating small-time investors with non-accredited investors. Yes you will have trouble if you started a company by borrowing a hundred bucks each from all your friends, extended family and random bystanders, but for almost all startups there are exactly zero non-accredited investors on any cap table. Most investors are accredited without even realizing it.
- andreilys 5y agofor almost all startups there are exactly zero non-accredited investors on any cap table Why is it unfathomable to imagine someone with a $500K NW writing a $5k-20k cheque? To be accredited you either need $1M NW or sustained $200K income (2+ years). Leaves plenty of room for small-time angels who want to invest 1-4% of their net wroth
- paxys 5y agoIt isn't unfathomable, just extremely rare. There simply aren't a lot of people with <$200K/yr total comp who are investing in random pre-seed startups, and even if they exist very few companies will actually take their money.
- 5y ago
- wdaher 5y agoAgreed. The caveat on all of this is "Assuming everyone is an accredited investor." (I've edited the original post to make that clearer.)