4 ms·
I spent an inordinate amount of time while watching the show just thinking about how you manage the computer systems on a spaceship, especially if you're a scra
by dekhn 5y ago
I spent an inordinate amount of time while watching the show just thinking about how you manage the computer systems on a spaceship, especially if you're a scrappy crew without a large corp's support.
Presumably, every space ship needs bulletproof software routines for calculating trajectories, making burns at the right time, etc- a combination of real time hardware control and sophisticated math.
But presumably, ships need to get updated in-flight, and upgraded routinely, and presumably, it doesn't make sense for your own ship to drift too far from the common development tree. This is starting to become a major software engineering problem- how do you manage a fleet of ship firmwares across a solar system?
- NotEvil 5y agoIt can be an opensource program or a library that everybody uses. And corps can have there own proprietary program
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoWhy would it need to be upgraded? Does the math of calculating trajectories and timing change that often?
- dekhn 5y agoNo, those don't really change (there might be data updates to include newly discovered celestial objects). But any ship that operates in space will eventually need some custom work and some of that would need to be merged back into mainline or maintained as a patch. It would be necessary to upgrade if, for example, new devices were installed in the ship, which were developed after the original ship firmware was installed. All of this is already a problem, for example for the US Navy, https://news.usni.org/2021/04/12/navy-software-factory-the-forge-wants-to-reshape-how-ships-get-upgraded https://news.usni.org/2021/04/12/navy-software-factory-the-f...
- hrishi 5y agoI imagine some futuristic version of git where... basically git but they've got better merge algorithms after they've solve NP and P. You can sync to the trees of ships near you and catch up, and once in a while one of them gets to a station and updates to the tip of wherever development is at.
- shakezula 5y agoIn the show, they have tight beams for communication. In the Expanse universe, seems like that's how they'd run their updates.
- domano 5y agoWhy would ships need regular upgrades if they work fine? I imagine maintenance would include software updates when docking to a space station
- dekhn 5y agoA ship on the sea (or in space) is independent and things always come up. Pretty much the whole history of ships has shown that you need to make updates and modifications and get tech upgrades as/when possible.
- domano 5y agoWell hardware maybe, but i think that software does not degrade the way hardware does. There is a lot of firmware which never gets updated and devices just keep working as long as the hardware is still ok.
- hef19898 5y agoAnd then even without these updates ships are fine running legacy software controlling obsolete hardware. As long as spares are available. Would a major navy, like the Martian one, keep their fleet up to date? Sure. Would it be done in flight? I don't think so. As today, this stuff is done during major maintenance in shipyards. Same goes for today's planes.
- CleaveIt2Beaver 5y agoImagine a pirate vessel drifting through space, compromising ships' OSes with a LADAR- or comms-based zero-day.
- shakezula 5y agoThere will absolutely be space hackers taking advantage of this type of vulnerability, and I think that's the coolest shit my 12 year old brain could've come up with.