7 ms·
Our memory is better than experts thought
- TheRealNGenius 5y agovon Neumann's is for sure
- wahern 5y agoIn his classic 1977 work memory researcher Kenneth Higbee describes three classes of memory--recall, recognition, and relearning--as a way to capture the breadth of the meaning of the word but also to explain that as often discussed memory isn't necessarily a singularly discrete concept. In the context of the third class, relearning, there is very little that we outright forget, and forgetting looks more like a continuous function: > The psychologist read passages of Greek to his son from the age of fifteen months to three years. He later tested the boy for retention at ages eight, fourteen, and eighteen by having him memorize the original passages and some comparable new passages. At age eight it took the boy 27 percent fewer trials to memorize the original passages than the new passages, suggesting a considerable savings in relearning effort as a result of retention of the earlier learning. The methods of recall and recognition would likely have shown no evidence of remembering. The savings decreased from 27 percent at age eight, to 8 percent at age fourteen, and to only 1 percent at age eighteen. Higbee, Kenneth L. Your Memory: How It Works and How to Improve It (p. 28). Da Capo Press. Kindle Edition. (citing 21 H. E. Burtt, "An Experimental Study of Early Childhood Memory: Final Report", Journal of Genetic Psychology 58 (1941): 435-39.)
- telesilla 5y agoI also think there are a lot of connections we make in relation to our muscles : after some decades my hands can still play piano pieces I learned when young and my torso and legs can balance and ride on a bicycle immediately after many months of not. Perhaps the brain is not the only store of memory.
- magicalhippo 5y agoNot sure if it's outside of the brain, but it seems to me that indeed different types of memories are stored differently. As an example, I can only recall my own phone number if I try to type it on a keypad, either a real phone or mentally visualizing me hitting the digits. I only have this for a few phone numbers though, and not other numbers in general. I also have some childhood memories that on the one hand seem vivid when I recall them, yet I struggle to describe when I want to tell others about them. Then the memory suddenly feels elusive, like a dream. Yet when I think about them, it's like I'm there in the moment... Other childhood memories are crystal clear and I can tell you all about them in great detail. I also have a sequencing error, I'll fairly consistently swap the last two digits of a sequence when recalling. This was especially annoying when I worked at a grocery store, and would tell the customer the total was 371 say rather than 317 as the register showed. Yet I've never noticed any other sequencing issues, and being a programmer there's plenty of opportunity for noticing.
- HKH2 5y agoYes, there is declarative, procedural and episodic memory, and they are stored in different ways. If you take away the hippocampus (if I'm not mistaken), you can still form procedural memories but not episodic memories. There was a relatively famous case of that happening.
- azeirah 5y agoIt is notable that the cerebellum, a very important part of our brain that controls voluntary movement as well as balance, coordination and posture is incredibly dense. > The cerebellum makes up just 10% of the total volume of the brain, yet it contains an estimated 50% to 80% of the brain's neurons. I wonder if "muscle memories" are just a side-phenomenon of involving more neurons in this densely populated area of the brain.
- wahern 5y agoThe spinal cord does provide autonomous gross stimulus responses, like pulling away a burning hand. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Withdrawal_reflex It doesn't seem surprising that it may exhibit more complex behaviors, such as suggested in this study about learning complex motor tasks: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26125597/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26125597/
- apples_oranges 5y agoWell, I can sing along to probably hundreds of 80s and 90s pop songs. Explain that, science! ;) .. but jokes aside. Science, understandably, seems to have a component view of humans. We have memory, strength, consumption of calories etc etc. We have all these mechanisms and we can quantify a lot of it. But as far as mental capability goes, to me it seems.. unlimited? Well, we will die one day, the body will stop working, that's a limit. But assuming we are healthy... I mean it just seems to me that we are nowhere near finding out the limits of thought.
- bspammer 5y agoI've always thought it strange how much of a "jump" there seems to be in mental capacity between humans and the next smartest species. It feels like there should have been other species along the evolutionary road with culture, basic agriculture and arithmetic etc. Why did something click and suddenly we're smart enough to build rockets, fly to other planets, split the atom, and reason about the very nature of reality?
- medstrom 5y agoBuilding rockets is not only down to mental capacity, but circumstance. If you consider the humans of the last 200,000 years as another species, would you also deduce a huge "jump" in mental capacity between those and the humans of the last 500? And a tickler for thought: Your Dog is Even Smarter Than You Think https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/zbqLuTgTCu365MNu9/your-dog-is-even-smarter-than-you-think https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/zbqLuTgTCu365MNu9/your-dog-i...
- joeberon 5y agoHow do we know how much of it is mental capacity? Obviously we wouldn't have been able to do these things without hands for example, and we can't really communicate with animals in a direct sense, so it's not easy to judge their intelligence
- username90 5y agoIf animals had a language we would have discovered it a long time ago and we would have learned to communicate with them. The reason we can't communicate with them is because they are dumb. Some of them might have big brains, but all of them lacks the kind of rational reasoning needed to learn and speak any language at even the level of a toddler. I mean, you can teach animals words, but you can't teach them how to structure thoughts to create meaningful longer conversations.
- tibbydudeza 5y agoCompared to chimps our short term memory is crap. Watched a video of a Japanese researcher showing a video picture of symbols to a chimp which then faded away within a few seconds. I then got a food treat if it could recall the pattern on the touch screen - on the more difficult levels it had to also remember the sequence of the patterns as well. Chimps always won against a human. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKvX9PPmI-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKvX9PPmI-Q
- throwaway287391 5y agoThat's incredible. I'm particularly blown away by the memorization from a 200 ms observation, and the fine motor skills -- so effortlessly precise with that finger.
- arvinsim 5y agoCouldn't it be that our memory adapted in the sense that we don't really need short term memory as much as our ancestors did?
- username90 5y agoI bet humans would perform just as well if not better if you put them in a box with nothing else to learn than playing that game.
- teachingassist 5y agoI wonder if chimps are also less butthurt than humans.
- bobthechef 5y agoMaybe that's the difference: human beings think abstractly and chimps don't? So we remember the abstract, but they simply retain images? If you think about it, there's nothing especially mysterious about good memory per se if we view it as something like writing things down or a recording. You have to put effort into destroying the memory. Degradation is comparatively slow. So to judge how good (or conversely, bad) memory is, you have to determine what the goal is and the "architecture" implementing it. Recalling recent images that are destroyed shortly after being recorded vs. a mind map of conceptual relations, for example.
- kordlessagain 5y agoMaybe people should stop assuming we all think the same ways. We don’t.
- yboris 5y agoEveryone should know of the work by the cognitive psychologist Elizabeth Loftus. She showed how false memories can be implanted and that our memories work differently from folk psychology (how people generally think the mind works). Her work was and is important with respect to court cases (eyewitness accounts, etc). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Loftus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elizabeth_Loftus