6 ms·
This logic is why so many Web sites today won't let you use a plus sign in email addresses, which ruins a really nice Gmail feature.
by josephcsible 5y ago
This logic is why so many Web sites today won't let you use a plus sign in email addresses, which ruins a really nice Gmail feature.
- kyrra 5y agoAs people said, true spammers know to just strip off the "+" in the email address. This is actually a fun reason to set up your own domain and set up email forwarding for *@example.com to go to your main gmail or whatever account, then the "username" part of the email I just set to the domain of the account I'm signing up for. So I'll use amazon@example.com when signing up at Amazon (or whatever site).
- judge2020 5y agoNote that you should only do this for maybe 6-18 characters, some sites will test send an email to [30-100 character random string]@example.com and see if it bounces - if it doesn't, it'll suspect that domain to be some spammer with a catch-all email inbox and block it.
- alufers 5y agoDo you know what sites do that? I have my own domain and I haven't seen anybody do that. The obvious solution is to configure your mail server to only accept usernames before the '@' that adhere to some rule which only you know. Like checking if it is a palindrome or something obscure like this.
- bbarnett 5y agoI watch multiple corp's mail logs extensively, this is not even remotely a common thing. Worse, I know at least 5 or 6 people personally, which do catch all. It seems like a very poor method to reliably catch spammers.
- jasonjayr 5y agoThat's a terrible approach, plenty of valid, legitimate non-spamming domains use catchalls of arbitrary length for all sorts of reasons. Additionally, sending a test email like that might also get the sender placed on a black list for triggering a spam trap inadvertently.
- pmontra 5y agoThat's a worrying strategy because there are many reasons for using a catchall. Example: one email per site to track companies selling personal data, then maybe bounce that single email address. Do you know any site blocking domains with a catchall?
- LorenPechtel 5y agoYeah, if you have a domain of your own the sensible thing is a catchall, use a different address everywhere and block the ones that spam.
- megous 5y agoMax local part size is 64 octets. So 100 chars would be out of spec.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> So I'll use amazon@example.com when signing up at Amazon I go a little farther. I figure an attentive spammer might figure out that if I use amazon@johnsmith.net to sign up for Amazon, I may have exactly the scheme where *@johnsmith.net will work, so they can just add that to the spam list as a wildcard and pick a new address every time. So instead, I use john101@johnsmith.net, john102, john103, etc, to try and obscure my strategy and prolong the life of the domain forwarding.
- willcipriano 5y agoI just have a entire domain for the purposes of spam. Anything sent to there ends up in my bulk folder. I use amazon@domain.com so I can tell who sells my email or gets hacked. Never noticed someone trying to send a email to any addresses I haven't previously used.
- wastholm 5y ago> Never noticed someone trying to send a email to any addresses I haven't previously used. At least a few years ago, I noticed a lot of spam to <random first name>@<my domain> -- i.e., completely made-up addresses that I had never used. Since messages sent to those addresses were guaranteed to be spam, I started treating them as free training data for the spam filter. I don't know if this still happens, though, because I haven't looked.
- Grollicus 5y agoThis is currently happening to my email domain. Gets rejected as it doesn't have a valid hash (recipient name), but the logfiles are full of <3 letters>@mydomain.com and <english_word>@mydomain.com rejections.
- klyrs 5y agoYeah, this is an age-old issue -- in the early 00s, my mom got a domain and used the email <first_initial>@<domain>.com. She gave up battling the deluge of spam after about a year. We looked through the logs, and saw that her next choice of handle was also getting tons of spam, too, because it was also short.
- em-bee 5y agowell, you could turn it around and use + addresses everywhere, so that any legitimate response must be to one of your + addresses. then treat anything without + as spam.
- academia_hack 5y agoThe + is also useful for knowing who sold your email address on or was responsible for a data breach. If I start getting spam to <my name>+hulu@gmail.com, then I know I could chase down Hulu on Twitter for an explanation.
- zzo38computer 5y agoI do a similar thing, except that the email is actually hosted at my domain rather than being forwarded, and that I have a list of email addresses that I accept and reject all others; if I receive too much spam at one address, I disable receiving at that address. I have found this to work; I hardly receive any spam at all, and do not need any separate spam filter.
- progforlyfe 5y agoAlthough hardly anyone uses yahoo mail anymore, they actually have this feature built in. Basically email aliases.
- frereubu 5y agoDidn't you find you got a deluge of spam to generic addresess like admin@, info@, offers@ and so on? I tried this, although it was probably about 15 years ago now, and reverted it because I got about the same amount of spam as genuine emails.
- shard 5y agoThat makes me want to use an email address of the form +myname@mydomain.com, just to see how websites would handle stripping out everything starting from the +.
- unanswered 5y agoI've run into at least one domain that blocks their own name in your email; that was fun.
- j_wtf_all_taken 5y agoI don't really think that's the same. Forgetting the "+" in the validation regular expression is something else than refusing to implement all kinds of extra checks to support very weird and very unused things.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tyoma 5y agoThe best are sites that let you sign up with a ‘+’ but not log in. Zappos used to be the most prominent example.
- dangoldin 5y agoInteresting. How did that work? Does that mean that they would only create the user account under the + suffix? I imagine they must have had two email fields - the canonical email for login and then a separate notification email?
- tshaddox 5y agoI’ve seen sites send emails where the unsubscribe link doesn’t work because the URL contains the email address I signed up with and that email address contains a character that their web server doesn’t play well with.
- scubbo 5y agoI once had a site _silently strip_ the + from signup email. So when I submitted `myname+yoursite@gmail.com` as my email address, they started sending mail to `mynameyoursite@gmail.com`. Madness.
- not2b 5y agoThis is common; spammers know the semantics of '+' for gmail and will strip it. You need to assume that it will happen.
- cgriswald 5y agoGP said the site stripped the “+” only, essentially sending his email to another address entirely. Spammers strip the “+” and whatever follows it, so the spam ends up at the same address.
- scubbo 5y agoIf spammers are converting from `myname+yoursite@gmail.com` to `mynameyoursite@gmail.com`, they are welcome to spam it as much as they want - it won't get to me. EDIT: moreover, a service is perfectly within their rights to _internally_ store my email as `myname@gmail.com` if they want - but they should still accept `myname+yoursite@gmail.com` as the identifier used to login with.
- raffijacobs 5y agoCan't you use "." Anywhere in your email to use the same multiple times in Gmail?
- josephcsible 5y agoYes, assuming the websites following this logic don't block that too, but then you have to keep track of a mapping of dots to websites yourself instead of it being obvious from what you put after the plus sign.
- alfon 5y agoOr use a password manager.
- toxik 5y agoOTOH, it being a standardized thing, a spammer would absolutely just strip that plus part off. Better do it secretly like a catch-all.
- gxnxcxcx 5y agoI think that when using email aliases to identify spam sources, the crucial part is that you can filter the stripped address (as well as any unapproved alias) to be directly identified as spam and then the +alias part becomes a key to properly get into the inbox. That whole setup for tidiness is broken the moment a desired website does not accept an alias in your address, of course.
- nybble41 5y agoIt's not really all that standardized. The use of a '+' character to indicate an alias or label is merely convention—if you run your own server you can set the separator to any character you wish, or disable the feature altogether. As far as the RFCs are concerned the '+' character is just part of the account name and there is no reason why it cannot be a mandatory part of the account name on any particular server, such that stripping off the '+' and any trailing characters results in an invalid e-mail address, or even someone else's e-mail account. For sending email or using an email address as an account identifier it's definitely incorrect to treat abc+xyz@example.com and abc@example.com as equivalent. The same goes for account names which differ only in capitalization or placement of periods: some servers are case-insensitive and ignore periods in account names (e.g. Google) but these are server-specific traits and compliant email senders should not assume that every server will work the same way. The '+' alias feature is a fairly common configuration, though, so for source labels it's better to either treat all unlabeled messages as spam or else use a more opaque labeling scheme (unique-hash@example.com) which doesn't hint at an alternative untracked email address.
- stonogo 5y agoSubaddressing is standardized in RFC 5233.
- 5y ago
- ridaj 5y agoWhy do so many people responding to this seem to assume the plus sign is to fool spammers? Of course it's not useful for antispam. It's mostly meant to make it easier to trace where a (legit) email comes from, for example to set up filters. https://gmail.googleblog.com/2008/03/2-hidden-ways-to-get-more-from-your.html https://gmail.googleblog.com/2008/03/2-hidden-ways-to-get-mo...
- sellyme 5y ago> Of course it's not useful for antispam. I've received spam emails to at least 70 different +addresses. It is absolutely useful for antispam. Spammers don't care about the reputation of the company they bought or stole the data from.
- alkonaut 5y agoSites likely prefer your canonical/standard email address over any plus version. It would be easy to trim anything after the plus too I guess and just email you at your normal address
- gumby 5y agoI configured my mail server to use _ as a sub mailbox identifier to stop creeps who block +. I assume they are doing it to make sure their precious spam shows up in my inbox.
- mderazon 5y agoSpammers aside, I'm interested to know what strategy different saas companies do in regards to users creating an account with + alias - Do you let users create multiple accounts with the same email but different + alias ? Or do you recognize that it's an alias and say that the account already exists ? Not all email providers support the + notion so you'd have to run domain lookup on some hard coded list
- megous 5y agoWhy should they care though? Anyone with a catchall can create 7 billion normal looking addresses under their domain. It's not like it would prevent anything. Also anyone with gmail address can also place dots almost anywhere into the local part, to create another unique address without using a + sign.
- mderazon 5y agoBecause of spammers creating garbage accounts on your platform
- megous 5y agoYeah, but why care about email address format, if it's not going to stop spammers anyway, and you're just risking losing legitimate customers if you mess up trying to mangle part of an address you should not be touching according to the recommendation in the standard?
- SilverRed 5y agoThe email spec considers these different emails. It's not a websites job to worry about how an individual host treats them. Gmail also treats . in the user section as useless but most hosts do not.
- jjav 5y ago> This logic is why so many Web sites today won't let you use a plus sign in email addresses, which ruins a really nice Gmail feature. Contrary to popular belief, it is not a gmail feature. I first heard of the + as destination filtering in the very early 90s at CMU where it was broadly used. Every single email address I've had since then has support the same (and notably, apart from a test account, I've never used gmail much, so that's not including gmail).
- jimktrains2 5y agoThe plus is a standard feature of email, not a Google specific thing like ignoring dots.
- ipaddr 5y agogmail != email. Breaking gmail features helps ensure a level playing field.
- fomine3 5y agoIt also breaks legit non-gmail address