12 ms·
Tesla is found guilty of throttling charging speed
- crazypython 5y agoProprietary software strikes again. It shouldn't be radical to say that you should control the software that runs on physical devices like cars you own.
- bratcomplex 5y agoIs it tho? Battery degradation is a big problem. if your supper charging and doing 0-60 launches often your battery is going to go to shit.
- crazypython 5y agoPeople should be able to control the ratio of battery degradation to charging time. Anyone or their business who depended on the old charging speed for mission-critical functions is screwed.
- Tempest1981 5y agoBut there are more-clear warranty rules about battery degradation/lifetime. They optimized for those.
- akmarinov 5y agoNo car currently has that and there’s no way government safety bodies would just let anyone install whatever they like on their car.
- KirillPanov 5y agoYou obviously do not live in the USA...
- Robotbeat 5y agoI have a Chevy Volt, and there is a recall for them where the range is reduced slightly to protect the battery. It’s partially a longevity issue and partially a safety issue. Tesla just did the same thing with updates. (Comments here seem to not understand this context...)
- jgalt212 5y agoYes, but a primary marketing metric for these vehicles is range. So you if you sold me a vehicle with range X, but it turns out the range is 0.9X, then it's quite right for the buyer to expect some sort of "make good" and the producer to expect the government to force one upon them. It gets even trickier if it can be shown that the producer was aware that such reductions in range would be quite likely to occur in the near future. When likely transitions to certainty, then it's fraud.
- Robotbeat 5y agoBut I’m not given any compensation from Chevy. The range reduction is small, within the warranty (like with Tesla). I wish I had the ability to fix it via software updates instead of having to bring it to a dealer. Tesla has actually INCREASED both range and charge speed via software updates, as well. And there’s no reason to suspect Tesla or Chevy knew for a fact they’d need to do this. People throw “fraud” around way too easily. Usually, when people do that, it makes me think they’re likely perma-skeptics.
- jgalt212 5y ago> The range reduction is small, within the warranty (like with Tesla). Very much like self-driving. The marketing people (Elon) say it's self-driving. The legal people say it's driver assist.
- atatatat 5y agoSimilar to VW reducing the MPG of vehicles after dieselgate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoWas Tesla actually found guilty of something? The article suggests they never responded to the lawsuit and therefore a default judgment was applied: > According to Norway’s Nettavisen, Tesla didn’t respond to the lawsuit and the 30 owners behind the case were automatically awarded 136,000 kroner (~$16,000 USD) each in compensation unless Tesla appeals to the case, which it has a few weeks to do. The award amount comes to half a million dollars total. Might be cheaper to just write checks to the 30 people than to tie up corporate lawyers and possibly set a precedent of admission that could trigger other lawsuits.
- goodcanadian 5y agoThere could be over 10,000 Tesla owners affected by the update in Norway alone I think you have misunderstood the potential consequences.
- jiofih 5y agoThe ruling would not apply to the other 9970 owners unless a class action lawsuit is started.
- asah 5y ago3.. 2.. 1..
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe article specifically says that only 30 owners were involved in the lawsuit and awarded damages. The speculation about 100,000 more owners getting involved is editorialization from this blog, although I suppose some of them will be incentivized to do follow-on suits now that the award value is so high.
- guerrilla 5y agoIt may not be necessary for each individual to file suit or to join a class action lawsuit. It is called a fine in the article. Maybe the blog knows more than we do about the status of that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roflc0ptic 5y ago> Tesla didn’t respond to the lawsuit and the 30 owners behind the case were automatically awarded 136,000 kroner (~$16,000 USD) each in compensation unless Tesla appeals to the case, which it has a few weeks to do. So that's half a million dollars. One wonders if it was incompetence on Tesla's part, or calculated "well, it will cost that in lawyers fees to settle." Dunno. Leaving it unchallenged in court is a terrible look.
- rationalData 5y agoThat's just stockholder money. No big deal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- new_realist 5y agoOr they are straight up guilty and want to avoid any more publicity from skeletons which would turn up in discovery.
- ip26 5y agoGuilty of what though? The interesting question is not ‘did they change charging speed’, it’s whether their motives were good & whether doing so is OK.
- loceng 5y agoI imagine charging speed could influence battery life, likewise if done at charging stations be beneficial to everyone charging at same time?
- JI00912 5y agoWho knows. They could just have missed a letter from the court.
- jve 5y ago>This created a lot of confusion among the owners affected by the update who wanted more details about the sudden need to “protect” the battery pack. They would surely complain if Tesla didn't include any "protections" while charging battery (80% capacity by default, slower charge when capacity approaching full, managing battery temperature, etc.) But can someone explain why some update for charging protections affect mileage? I can understand if they compare capacity per constant time charged and telling us that after x hour charge I could do x miles, but now x-y... but if trying to charge full...? Maybe Tesla just reserves some capacity for longer lifespan of batteries?
- Daho0n 5y ago>Maybe Tesla just reserves some capacity for longer lifespan of batteries? Maybe. But if they cut 10% the owners should get the equivalent of 10% ranges worth in damages (not the charging cost but the price difference in their current car and one with 10% less range). Of course they should also be allowed to sell the car back to Tesla as some of these owners have proven they no longer can bet on always reaching their destination without an extra charge. I would personally have bought another car of I were in that position.
- Traster 5y agoIt's very common to avoid discharging the batteries fully as it has a disproportionate affect on the life of the battery. So this update likely not only changed the rate at which the battery charged to protect it but also raised the minimum charge of the battery needed to drive - thus reducing the range.
- jcims 5y agoThe last part is one thing that occurred to me. I rented a Model X recently via Turo and struggled for an entire day with the car operating at <20 miles of indicated range (due to the long trip to pick it up + no local charging options above 7kW). At the time I wondered if there was 'reserve' range and turns out there is at least one mile left. But it's clear this isn't the healthiest range to run the battery in. It's possible they bumped the minimum charge a bit just to urge people to not dip so deeply into the well as often.
- mavhc 5y agoPeople seem to expect their batteries to work forever at their original capacity.
- nyxtom 5y agoI find it reasonable that given the warranty claims, they should be contractually obligated to provide you with the terms they have agreed upon. If they find out with new research and data that given the usage the battery will not last as long as they claimed, then a warranty claim would fall fairly under that use case. Updating the software to to degrade performance/range as an attempt to meet original warranty guidelines feels very much like misleading and unfair practices. Imagine if any appliance you owned did the same thing. > Sorry you can't keep AC at the temperature you want because doing so will reduce the longevity of this appliance and we can't guarantee it will meet under warranty. You would find this scenario absolutely unacceptable
- theshadowknows 5y agoYou’re right - they do expect that. Regardless of the availability of information, and I agree there is a wealth of it available, companies should work a little harder on explaining this. It’s a new problem for most people. When the batteries in a remote control, clock, or even a car go bad then it’s trivial to change them. So while this problem has existed for as long as battery powered devices have the difference is that no one noticed. Now you can’t change the battery yourself. So it becomes a much bigger burden to understand “oh, the max ability of my battery to charge has degraded.” It’s just a new piece of knowledge for lots of people.
- staticjak 5y agoI think the confusion may lie in the fact that gas powered vehicles do not have the same concern. Sure maintenance is required and all but you don't have the major drop in range just because the manufacturer pushes an update to "protect" your car. People expect their vehicles to work forever at original capacity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- antattack 5y agoEVs in general have ridiculous warranty on range/battery capacity. Consider you have bought 250mile range EV. Most manufacturers will say that there's nothing wrong if your range degrades by up to 30%, down to 175mile range.
- jsight 5y agoAnd there is no consumer visible guage for degradation either. The manufacturer uses their own, inaccessible, approach to validation. This could become a real problem in the future.
- atatatat 5y agoThere was no technical way for them to guarantee otherwise, at the time. This is quickly changing as we comment.
- theshadowknows 5y agoThis one reminds me of the Apple “battery-gate” issue. I’m not going to pick sides or anything but I agree that both Apple and Tesla should have been considerably more clear in their messaging to customers.
- emteycz 5y agoEvery electric car manufacturer (phone/laptop/whatever else) is guilty of throttling charging speed, always. Is this a joke? Was expert witness not questioned, if the judge missed high school physics? The reputation of Norway just went under 0 in my mind. Edit in response to the point about Tesla not answering: That's UK/US legal tradition - but Norway claims (apparently isn't) to be a "rechtstaat"[0]. That means that [the court is legally bound to justice in any case, and that Tesla has constitutional right for justice - best effort must be made even if it didn't respond. This has arisen because many European states of the past abused courts in absence for monetary or political gains, just like this case. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rechtsstaat Edit in response to the point about Tesla having to defend itself: Sure. But they absolutely shouldn't have automatically lost. The judge must consider all available information about the case and make a fair judgement. Here it's a case of basic technological principle - all battery packs are throttled, or the battery wouldn't survive a week; that throttling is adaptive to battery health, battery temperature, surrounding conditions, stability of incoming electricity and so on. Tesla doesn't have to supply this information, all that is basic highschool physics (at least in Europe). // The problem with Apple was about throttling CPU and thus making the device slower in order to make time on battery consistent. This is totally different, and absolutely necessary.
- kryptiskt 5y agoIt's up to Tesla to defend themselves. If they rather play dead than respond to the suit, they will lose by default. The judge isn't supposed to do the work for them.
- asddubs 5y agothey won by default because tesla never responded to the lawsuit
- LightG 5y agoHope the court doubles the fine then. Actions should have consequences.
- chmaynard 5y agoMusk is a sociopath so it's not surprising that all his companies seem to lack a moral compass.
- jcims 5y agoThe article is short on the interesting part. What are the actual charges? If Tesla is openly admitting that they changed range estimates and throttle charging, what is there for the court to determine?
- msh 5y agoIf Tesla was allowed to do that without compensation to the owners.
- everdrive 5y agoI yearn for a simple electric car which is not connected, and does not have a lot of touch screens or features. Can you imagine? A cheap electric car with a radio and crank windows, and basically nothing else? It would be a dream.
- rsynnott 5y agoMost of the stuff in this list (electric cars in the 20k range) probably fits your bill: https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/best-cars/99735/the-cheapest-electric-cars-on-sale https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/best-cars/99735/the-cheapest-e... Though they probably do mostly have electric windows; that's more or less a standard feature these days.
- bratcomplex 5y agoI’m with you on this. The ev convention scene provides just that!
- nyxtom 5y agoJust buy an old Ford Electric. The range is pretty decent and you can sometimes find them for around $13k or less if you're lucky. (Perhaps rarer these days with used car prices going up) The alternative route that I've looking into is to just do the mod myself on an old classic car. There are a few great ev conversion companies like evWest (https://evwest.com/catalog/ https://evwest.com/catalog/) and Electric GT (https://electricgt.com/ https://electricgt.com/) that offer drop in crates and motors that you can mount. It's not "easy" by any stretch of the imagination but it's a great option to have if you have the time and skills to do so.
- yalogin 5y agoI had a similar drop in battery myself. It used be 254 and in a few weeks it dropped to 220. At that time they also changed the representation to show theoretical miles instead of raw miles as the default. So they used some algorithm to show higher range somehow. I didn’t use that representation and instead got the shock of my life when I saw the drop. Tesla support said there is nothing wrong with the battery. I would be really interested in knowing more about this case and what exactly happened.
- Tempest1981 5y agoWas there any up-front communication when this happened? "In order to keep your car's batteries safe, and ensure they have a long life, we're reducing the range a bit". And maybe throw in some free supercharging. Just assuming the surprise made it worse.
- jcims 5y agoHave you been able to determine if the actual range of the vehicle has changed at all? That's not clear to me from the article. I rented a Model X for a day and got about 60% of the estimated range (presumably due to my driving). After this update it would have only been 30% wrong instead of 40%. Not sure what to make of that.
- jonplackett 5y agoThis sounds like a very similar scenario as when Apple throttled iPhones, and also annoyed a lot of people
- rationalData 5y agoHeavily marketed companies can trot on like nothing happened. Their fanboys don't care.
- mfer 5y agoThere is an element about convenience here that comes out when we talk about charging (rather than longevity of battery). People are used to ICE cars where you can fill up rather quickly. Fuel pumps put out fuel at different speeds. It's not the same flow rate everywhere and people have no problem with it. Even big tanks on non-commercial vehicles are filled up in minutes. Refueling an ICE tank is quick and convenient. Electric has not hit that point and comparisons are going to happen. Even if not explicitly.
- CountDrewku 5y agoYes this is my biggest issue with electric vehicles. Charging it overnight to use for day trips is one thing but taking it on a cross country trip or long vacation? No thanks. My time is finite and I do not want to spend it waiting around for my EV to charge.
- asiachick 5y agoI agree with you but I have a friend who tends to look on the bright side of things. He bought a Tesla even though he doesn't have a garage to charge it in, meaning he has to take to the local station once in a while and drink a coffee. He also drives from SF to LA about once a month and said it takes 3 stops (so +3 hours?) but the way he put it is "now I arrive much more refreshed because I took breaks on the long drive"
- mfer 5y agoIt’s wonderful that this works well for your friend. Let’s consider the other end of the spectrum. What about the home of a single mom who needs to get kids off to school, get to work, run errands, and doesn’t have enough time. Also, lives in an apartment. How would this work for her?
- jlbooker 5y agoShe would need to visit a local Supercharger station 1-2 times a week (maybe 3, depending on far the errands are), for about 20 minutes each visit. There are people who do this with Teslas. It's of course not the most convenient charging arrangement, but it certainly can be workable (and is for a good number of current Tesla owners). Also, more apartment complexes are adding EV chargers as amenities to attract EV owners. Hopefully charging at an apartment will be less of an issue in the future as these are added.
- williesleg 5y agoNobody gives a shit except the global warming denialists, they control the narrative at electrek.
- mandeepj 5y agoWhy it's a surprise? They do all sort of things like below https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/10/16283330/tesla-hurricane-irma-update-florida-extend-range-model-s-x-60-60d https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/10/16283330/tesla-hurricane-...
- skjoldr 5y agoThere is info that shows phone Li-Po batteries last much longer if they are always kept at 20-80% charge at least, and that both the default charging settings and the marketing materials advertising battery capacity are biased towards bigger numbers. I'm not sure what is the issue here, then, beyond bad communication, especially if only the older battery packs are affected. It is to be expected that if the customer wants to keep using the pack for a while longer, they need to limit how much they cycle the battery every charge. A better solution would be to advertise the average longevity of the Tesla battery packs along with their mileage, but I'm not sure if their target audience really cares about that.
- RaceWon 5y agoToyota is working on perfecting an ICE that burns hydrogen. Hey, why not have other solutions. "https://www.autoweek.com/racing/more-racing/a36209405/toyota-hydrogen-engine-tech-through-racing/ https://www.autoweek.com/racing/more-racing/a36209405/toyota..."