4 ms·
Imagine in any other industry, where the candidate mentions irrelevant job experience, and expect that to be the criteria for acceptance into the job. For ex
by chii 5y ago
Imagine in any other industry, where the candidate mentions
irrelevant job experience, and expect that to be the criteria for acceptance into the job.
For example, an actor applying for a role in a commercial might cite their side role in doing a theatrical production of hamlet for their community, but the interviewers (an advertising production agency) might only want to care how much professional experience they have shooting commercials.
Sure, these experiences in "unrelated" work might show qualities that could be applied to this job. But you aint paid for your broad and wide interests in the topic - you are paid on being able to implement some work/feature that somebody else told you to do. And in fact, if you require intrinsic motivation to actually perform well, you might end up being a liability to the team, rather than an asset - after all, if the work is boring, and you lack intrinsic motivation for it, you might slack off, or over-engineer it to make the work more interesting to you. Or you might end up being a difficult person to work with for other team members because you sit so far above them intellectually.
- homie 5y agoThe analogy here doesn't make sense. It'd be more like the actor mentioning that he doesn't have any experience doing commercial work, but he has acted in a theatrical production before (suggesting that he's adaptable and willing to do more than just one kind of acting job).
- rjzzleep 5y agoThat's literally what happens for most business or leadership interviews. The only common thread for most of them is that they ran a company. They may know nothing about the market, the customer, the product or anything else related to the business, it may even have failed miserably, but because they have an MBA and hired a handful of people they're somehow competent for the job. How about we hold those people accountable to the same standards? Hell, most of your politicians are that way. You have dentists commenting on how pandemic response should be. For the last 4 years a failed business man con artist destroyed pretty much all he could get his hands on and he's still hailed as some sort of mythical creature. > Imagine in any other industry, where the candidate mentions irrelevant job experience, and expect that to be the criteria for acceptance into the job. Are you f'in kidding me? Either we hold the other useless part of society to the same standards we hold ourselves accountable to or we give each other a break. EDIT: and for all the ignorant folks thinking Trumps schoolyard bully rhetoric did anything but empower the CCP keep in mind that Chinas nickname for Trump is "Chuan Jian Guo". Trump the nation builder(guess who's nation they are talking about). And as much as I disliked Obama and his TPP, it was the answer to the new silk road. Trump basically handed China the entirety of Asias future on a silver platter, and in return the US got what? 10 billion in trade deficit balances? Completely laughable. Or the new Blue Dot(completely fitting name by the way)? https://asiatimes.com/2019/11/a-blue-dot-barely-visible-from-new-silk-roads/ https://asiatimes.com/2019/11/a-blue-dot-barely-visible-from... Blue Dot is described, officially, as promoting global, multi-stakeholder “sustainable infrastructure development in the Indo-Pacific region and around the world.” It is a joint project of the US Overseas Private Investment Corporation, in partnership with Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and the Japan Bank for International Cooperation. Now compare it with what just happened this same week at the inauguration of the China International Import Expo in Shanghai. As Xi stressed: “To date, China has signed 197 documents on Belt and Road cooperation with 137 countries and 30 international organizations.”
- redis_mlc 5y ago> For the last 4 years a failed business man con artist destroyed pretty much all he could get his hands on and he's still hailed as some sort of mythical creature. Nothing could be more wrong. Trump was the best President the US has had in 75 years. He was 100% correct about: 1) The need for a border wall. Biden's poor messaging has resulted in around 100,000 children separated from their parents and warehoused in the US currently. 2) The need to address the CCP. Nobody else was able to oppose the Cold War invasion of US' education and financial institutions until Trump/Pompeo addressed this - a mythical performance. 3) The need to stop flights from China early in the pandemic. The decision is obvious today, but he was called a racist for demonstrating the leadership he was elected for. 4) Europe is now aware of their need to pay their share of defense spending, which historically was half of what was agreed. Some con man. The Dems/Marxists are re-learning the above the hard way. In case you don't understand what MAGA means, it means America First, which should always be our policy. Instead, the current administration is "sisterhood first", which I'm sure delights the CCP, Russia and political Islam - all ideologies against everything that made America great.
- Talanes 5y agoIt would be weird if you brought up your community theater role at a commercial audition and their question was "Is this going to make you any money?" Even if they don't consider community theater roles to be relevant experience, a casting director/interviewer shouldn't be caught off guard by them.
- Haga 5y agoMercenaries hate knights, cause if there is something you can't buy for money, it's passion.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> For example, an actor applying for a role in a commercial might cite their side role in doing a theatrical production of hamlet for their community, but the interviewers (an advertising production agency) might only want to care how much professional experience they have shooting commercials. Does it work like this? I guess it depends on the point in actor's career. If they're 10+ years into commercial acting, then community theare might not be relevant, but at the start of one's career, it seems to me to be highly relevant. At the very least, it demonstrates the person knows the basics of acting, can follow the script, and has experience dealing with the support structure (director, sound/lighting technicians, etc.). This isn't fundamentally different from what they'll face when shooting a commercial. Also: at least over here in Poland, most film actors come from classical theatre background, they study in theatrical schools. Any kind of theatrical background is highly relevant.
- debaserab2 5y agoWow. Talk about missing the forest for the trees. If an interviewee has a pet operating system they've developed they can probably figure out your CRUD app.
- monsieurbanana 5y agoWhether a kernel hobbyist will want to work on your CRUD app is another thing.
- selfhoster11 5y agoSometimes that kernel hoobyist will just want to afford food and rent.