22 ms·
Wuhan lab staff sought hospital care before Covid-19 outbreak disclosed
- MilnerRoute 5y agoI read a comment where someone suggested the virus originated at the market -- and was then caught by someone who works at the lab. The interesting thing about that theory is: I don't know how to assess which of those two scenarios is more likely.
- undersuit 5y agoA person gets sick after interacting with bats in the area, and then they talk to their virologist friend who works at the Wuhan Virology Institute and suddenly there are a rash of illnesses. Do we still get to blame the lab for a leak?
- busterarm 5y agoExcept there's no bats in that area. At least not ones with SARS-CoV2.
- undersuit 5y agoThere are no bats in Wuhan? I find that hard to believe. There are no discovered bat populations in the Wuhan region with a SARS-COV2 ancestor, that's more likely. That the only source of bats infected with a SARS-COV2 relative is in the Yunnan province, that's pretty unlikely.
- busterarm 5y agoThere are three bat species with an identified SARS-CoV2 relative (RaTG13, RmYN02, RshSTT182 and RshSTT200) and none of them are found in Wuhan.
- undersuit 5y agoYeah exactly. > With over 100 species recognised, China has one of the richest bat faunas in the Palaearctic. You need to prove a negative. You need to prove the bats in Wuhan don't have Covid. More and more bats in Yunnan doesn't do that.
- lamontcg 5y agoWe know it existed in Wuhan before the superspreading incident at the market, that was not the origin.
- giardini 5y agoRemember that people at the lab were dicking around with bat coronavirus alterations! While one might say that the same thing was happening in the market via natural gene replication and disease transmission, don't you think that someone intentionally altering parts of genes with the sole purpose of "gain-of-function" (making a more deadly virus) would be more likely to generate something like Covid-19 than a fishmonger who slaps another tilapia onto the ice? https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gain+of+function https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gain+of+function ""Gain-of-function" is the euphemism for biological research aimed at increasing the virulence and lethality of pathogens and viruses. GoF research is government funded; its focus is on enhancing the pathogens' ability to infect different species and to increase their deadly impact as airborne pathogens and viruses. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gain+of+function&t=opera&ia=web&iai=r1-0&page=1&sexp=%7B"biaexp"%3A"b"%2C"msvrtexp"%3A"b"%2C"earlydeep"%3A"a"%7D https://duckduckgo.com/?q=gain+of+function&t=opera&ia=web&ia..."
- baylearn 5y agoPrediction: this story will get flagged and removed from the front page very soon.
- waheoo 5y agoWhy can't the Nazi racist trump supporters just leave the poor Chinese alone. It's a cultural thing. Lab leak is a conspiracy tin foil hat story. Just ignore it and move on with your life. - everything I've read here after raising this months ago.
- codegrappler 5y agoThis is from the Wall Street journal. Hardly a tinfoil hat source typically.
- nodesocket 5y agoYou are living in a fantasy land world. My good friend lived in China for five years. Needless to say, he doesn’t speak highly of their ethics, politics, and human policies. I temporally lived in S. Korea for a few months and there were solid blocks of days the air quality was so bad you could barely be outside. Of course the pollution made its way down from China’s unregulated factories. I quickly realized South Koreans are frankly quite racist against the Chinese.
- creato 5y ago> I temporally lived in S. Korea for a few months and there were solid blocks of days the air quality was so bad you could barely be outside. Of course the pollution made its way down from China’s unregulated factories. I quickly realized South Koreans are frankly quite racist against the Chinese. If I couldn't go outside for days in a row because of pollution from China, I'd probably be pretty pissed at them too.
- philliphaydon 5y agoPretty sure they don't like china because china sides with North Korea and fought against South Korea during the korean war. Ironically china citizens just threw a hissyfit at South Korea because one of the k-pop groups thanked the US government for supporting South Korea during the korean war, and didn't thank the china government. I thought that was pretty funny.
- 5y ago
- justapassenger 5y agoThis very irresponsible reporting, that you don’t see often on Reuters. People get sick, especially in autumn. And they infect each other. Reporting that some people working at the lab were sick, without any knowledge about kind of sickness is only going to add fuel to the conspiracy theories.
- pokstad 5y agoAnd what conspiracy theory is that? Are you suggesting that the lab leak is a conspiracy theory? Until it is discredited through contradictory evidence, it is still a plausible theory.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoWhile "conspiracy theory" is often intended to be dismissive of an idea, it does not automatically mean the idea is false. Conspiracy theories occasionally end up being true, or close to the truth.
- fullshark 5y agoThis theory doesn't even involve people conspiring, just an accident occuring. Except I guess if you believe the CCP is conspiring to prevent certain facts related to the early days of COVID's emergence from being known. What an outrageous suggestion that is.
- justapassenger 5y agoYes, virology experts like Vincent Racaniello claim it’s bs conspiracy. I’m not virology expert, but trust people who actually know what they’re talking about vs fear mongers.
- madengr 5y agoSpeaking of conspiracy theories: It’s often stated that the CCP is lying about COVID deaths, as they state there were only a few thousand. Maybe they are NOT lying and the virus was engineered to have minimal effect on Han Chinese.
- DanBC 5y agoA gentle reminder that some of the 2019 flu strains were pretty rough. See eg Australia having a lot of problems with it.
- graeme 5y agoThat was Feburary 2019 in Australia. Wuhan’s flu season would have been November 2019. Different severity, the flu season in the northern hemisphere 2019 was not especially severe. Further, the researchers were surely in the 18-49 age bracket. CDC’s estimates for the 2017-18 flu season in that age bracket were 58.8 per 100,000. That is 0.0588% per person per year. And that’s the whole flu season. To have odds of being hospitalized in november you’d cut that in four at least. And then the odds of three people in the same lab all needing hospitalization also needing hospital treatment? Even less likely. Not impossible, but it’s not so simple as suggesting there was a bad flu season. There wasn’t in china then, and flu hospitalization is damned rare in non elderly. https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2017-2018.htm https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/2017-2018.htm (It is possible that the “hospital care” in the article doesn’t match “hospitalization” as cdc defines it, but any kind of hospital care for a young person from the flu is still rare)
- DanBC 5y agoDon't look at the CDC stats for the previous year. Look at the Australian stats for 2019 -- these were different strains of flu.
- busterarm 5y agoThat was addressed in the very first sentence of their response...
- DanBC 5y agoThey said this: > Further, the researchers were surely in the 18-49 age bracket. CDC’s estimates for the 2017-18 flu season in that age bracket were 58.8 per 100,000. That is 0.0588% per person per year. They're using CDC figure for the wrong year to say that younger people were not particularly affected. The 2019 flu season in Australia was 1) much rougher than the 2018 flu season in the US 2) much earlier than normal Both of these mean that it could well have been an early, rough, flu season in Wuhan that hospitalised these people. I understand that people really want this to be lab escape, but the way to show it's lab escape is to be honest when you're discounting everything else.
- risk 5y agothis article inspires to recollection the editor's note on that article from 2015 https://www.nature.com/articles/nm.3985 https://www.nature.com/articles/nm.3985
- cm2012 5y agoLab leak hypothesis has at least 60% chance of being true. Note the word LEAK though, there's no evidence at all it was designed as a weapon.
- nodesocket 5y agoWhere exactly are you pulling this percentage from?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 5y agoWasn't there some pretty serious stuff going on in Hong Kong in, like, October-ish 2019? Gosh there's been so much virus drama since then that I barely remember: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_Hong_Kong_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_Hong_Kong_pr...
- redis_mlc 5y agoI agree - it's been about 55% in favor of a lab leak for over a year amongst people who follow the origin story, and has increased recently with the former US officials talking about it, and the disclosure that the original doctors criticizing the lab theory as all being WHO staff with links to WIV. There has been no info contradicting the lab theory.
- karmicthreat 5y agoWell, that article was useless. Some people got sick in the middle of flu season. Ok. How about some details like out of how many people that worked there? What did they do? Just more low effort agitprop. Apparently most people in my country (US) will believe anything as long as it wears the correct team jersey.
- gentleman11 5y agoHow often do you and 2 coworkers go to the hospital for seasonal flu?
- bobthepanda 5y agoHow is healthcare normally delivered in China? At least in the US a fair amount of patients show up at the ER first. The Wikipedia page for healthcare in China says there is a tiered system but also a shortage of primary care doctors in clinics. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_China
- gentleman11 5y agoI haven’t known many people who had to go to a doctor of any kind for a flu who weren’t quite old or with a chronic condition. Perhaps the three people in question were all elderly
- slowmovintarget 5y agoThey were researchers. Doubtful they were elderly.
- flukus 5y agoMost people with the flu will go to the doctor here, if only to get a doctors certificate for the week they'll need off work.
- deleted 5y ago
- undersuit 5y agoI'm trying to keep an open mind about things, but I just find is so suspicious that the articles blaming China for Covid get upvoted so enthusiastically that people forget to post in the first 10 minutes before they hit the front page. I'm not trying to reject any hypothesis but I do reject the fervor. And then people come out of the woodwork and try to defend the Wuhan Lab as the source with a load of coincidences that trend to conspiratorial thoughts. Like how we only know of a related Covid strain in bat hundreds of miles away from Wuhan... but bats are not endemic to just Yunnan where the closest Covid-19 match was from. Does Wuhan not have bats?
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoHN tends to upvote counternarratives. The Wuhan lab leak hypothesis was dismissed as either "debunked" or "discredited" in the mainstream media early, but now is considered possible, or even likely.
- undersuit 5y agoUpvotes are free. HN has been upvoting this theory since the beginning.
- redis_mlc 5y agoNo, I lost 100 HN karma in mid-2020 proposing the lab theory.
- rblion 5y agoHow can you upvote 'counternarratives' while going along with what the mainstream media says is the 'real story'? If you lay all the pieces of data out on a table, it's pretty easy to deduce this virus most likely originated from Wuhan. The fact that China is not fully complying with releasing early COVID records and that the WHO is being sued says a lot...
- AzzieElbab 5y agoThat is not true. HN is lagging behind mainstream when it comes to disputed issues. You will be downvoted to hell if you post anything that is only beginning to take a hold in the mainstream
- rblion 5y agoThe way this virus attacks multiple systems and has such a wide range of symptoms, I am convinced it is a man-made supervirus. I am leaning towards it was accidental in how it was released but I have no idea what's going on anymore and the media only confuses me more. There are already variants and these vaccines will need booster shots to stay effective from what I was told. I'm not sure though. Is this true? Covid has taught me a few things: - Health is as important as wealth, living well is making time for both. It takes good health to build lasting wealth and to enjoy it. It takes at least some wealth to invest in good food, living space, life experiences. - Living in Maui and working remotely is like semi-retiring in my 30s. I can make money and enjoy life at the same time without taking years off my life due to commutes and stress. Why didn't I do this in my 20s? I was learning the skills and figuring out what exactly I wanted in life. Now I know. - I don't need a lot of people to be happy, just a handful of high-quality people. More than anything, I should give myself a lot of what I expect from others. - Nature is more resilient than we know, Earth really be fine with or without humans. We can change if we want to but we can't agree on anything anymore. I'm hoping for the best but prepared for the worst.
- graeme 5y agoSARS-COV-1 attacked systems in a similar way. MERS is a multi system virus as well. They are similar to SARS-Cov-2 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_respiratory_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Middle_East_respiratory_synd...
- gentleman11 5y agoMers mortality was really scary, 30-40% I read earlier today. Just imagine what would have happened if that spread
- thowaway959125 5y agoThe big difference here is that now we have the added problem of dealing with ACE2 bindings which affect human lungs/liver/heart/pancreas/etc. This is a dangerous difference. > SARS-CoV recognizes angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) as its receptor, whereas MERS-CoV recognizes dipeptidyl peptidase 4 (DPP4) as its receptor. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41423-020-0400-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41423-020-0400-4
- jp0d 5y agoIs this even a secret anymore? The way China is acting against anyone(Australia) asking questions, says heaps about them.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments to HN, definitely not flamewar comments, and especially definitely not nationalistic flamewar comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- jp0d 5y agoThanks for pointing that out. The first part of my question was only rhetorical. I didn't claim that it was the result of my or anyone's professional journalistic endeavours. If that seemed like a "nationalistic flamewar comment", I sincerely apologise. But the second part of the comment doesn't contain an iota of nationalistic element to it. It simply is a fact as reported by numerous newspapers and felt by many businesses here in Australia. The CCP is punishing Australian businesses as the Australian government is pushing for a proper investigation into a disease that originated in Wuhan and has killed (reportedly) close to a million people so far. In fact It's important to note that it's not a reflection on the people of China, rather the government. I'm happy to be downvoted, probably with nationalist intentions! But I haven't said anything wrong here.
- thowaway959125 5y agoThere are numerous reasons why we need a proper investigation into this. If this came out of WIV, we need to determine exactly why these bat coronaviruses were being studied with regards to human ACE2. This ACE2 binding is causing numerous issues, including damage to human heart, lung, kidney, and pancreatic cell death. This is serious stuff. If anyone is looking at the "low" mortality rate, they are missing the big picture. Role of angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) in COVID-19 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7356137/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7356137/ The genetic structure of SARS‐CoV‐2 does not rule out a laboratory origin https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7744920/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7744920/ SARS-CoV-2 infects human pancreatic β-cells and elicits β-cell impairment https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/fulltext/S1550-4131(21)00230-8 https://www.cell.com/cell-metabolism/fulltext/S1550-4131(21)...
- dzhiurgis 5y agoI'm flagging this obviously troll comment. ACE2 was part of mechanism of action of previous coronaviruses. Here's first search result for SARS and ACE2 - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1287568/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1287568/
- thowaway959125 5y agoIt's absolutely not a troll comment. I stand by the science and I would love any evidence of something like natural zoonotic spillover.
- Dah00n 5y agoIf you stand by it how about posting it from your main account at least instead of a throwaway?
- dang 5y agoYou broke several of the HN guidelines with this. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules, we'd appreciate it. Your comment would be fine without that initial swipe. It should go without saying, but I'll add that I'm not at all commenting on which of you is right or wrong factually. But if you're the one who's right, then you should take better care with the truth, because stooping to cheap attacks discredits what you're saying, and one is responsible for how one handles the truth one's in possession of. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=truth%20discredit%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- gentleman11 5y agoThe wsj article is more specific about the 3 hospital visits: > several researchers at the lab, a center for the study of coronaviruses and other pathogens, became sick in autumn 2019 “with symptoms consistent with both Covid-19 and common seasonal illness.”
- throwaway4good 5y agoI thought this "official" debunk of the article is worth reading: https://twitter.com/ZichenWanghere/status/1396632720944484359 https://twitter.com/ZichenWanghere/status/139663272094448435... It is an old story. Published earlier by Sputnik News last year. Got an official response. And the source is a mistranslated document (samples of sick human misread as sick employees).
- omgwtfbbq 5y agoSurely you are joking? I don't think "Official" statements coming from China carry any weight at all on this particular subject.
- MilnerRoute 5y agoURL for a version of the original WSJ report: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at-wuhan-lab-raises-questions-about-origins-of-covid-19-11621803078 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at...
- ratsmack 5y agoARCHIVE: https://archive.ph/AgpFy https://archive.ph/AgpFy For those that have run out of free articles. Edit: Here's the WSJ article. https://archive.ph/fF82W https://archive.ph/fF82W
- truth_ 5y ago> For those that have run out of free articles. Clear your browser cookies for the site.
- humanistbot 5y ago"with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses" So 3 staff had gotten sick that flu season. Staff who work with infectious diseases and probably get every cough and cold checked out just in case. Seems pretty baseline average to me.
- xyzzy123 5y agoI have no idea if that's baseline average or not, personally I find the article frustrating. There's no discussion of how many people work at the lab, how many staff visited hospital the year before that, whether it is in fact common for those staff to visit hospital when they have seasonal flu, or any other factors that would put this in any sort of context at all.
- bungle 5y agoThis could well be reason to prohibit such research. When things go wrong, they will be covered. It took WHO over a year to be able to enter China. And what did they do? Release a memo denying laboratory theory without any evidence. No bat, nor intermediate has been found (not the case with SARS/MERS). Sure there is no evidence on lab theory either. The Chinese army has been running that lab since this started.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 5y agoIt's a large lab. Perhaps a couple hundred work there. ...but even still, 3 admitted to hospital for flu symptoms in that demographic is very high, statistically - even if literally ALL employees caught the seasonal flu at the same time.
- sudosysgen 5y agoWhat data are you using? In China people go to the hospital for a cold routinely. People also used to do so in my country until the government cracked down on it, fwiw. And no its not a couple hundred. 600 people work at that lab. So 3 people with seasonal illness out of 600 at one time is incredibly unremarkable.
- MilnerRoute 5y agoThe Wall Street Journal's original report (upon which this article is based) adds a really interesting detail about the timing of this story: The disclosure of the number of researchers, the timing of their illnesses and their hospital visits come on the eve of a meeting of the World Health Organization’s decision-making body, which is expected to discuss the next phase of an investigation into COVID-19’s origins. It is just me, or does it seem suspicious to anyone that this information existed, and wasn't reported in 2019 or 2020, or even in early 2021....but only just reached the press on the very evening of the WHO meeting. https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at-wuhan-lab-raises-questions-about-origins-of-covid-19-11621803078 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at...
- tablespoon 5y ago> It is just me, or does it seem suspicious to anyone that this information existed, and wasn't reported in 2019 or 2020, or even in early 2021....but only just reached the press on the very evening of the WHO meeting. Not really. The original source was "a previously undisclosed U.S. intelligence report." It's quite plausible that the report had been on the shelf in 2019 or 2020, or only accessible to people who knew how to keep secrets, but then was more widely disseminated to prepare for this meeting, after which a leaker got hold of it.
- MilnerRoute 5y agoHere's something from the complete story from the Wall Street Journal (upon which Reuters based its report). They spoke to "officials" familiar with the report, one of whom specifically said it was "still in need of further investigation and additional corroboration." https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at-wuhan-lab-raises-questions-about-origins-of-covid-19-11621803078 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/new-report-of-illnesses-at...
- MilnerRoute 5y agoThis all comes from a "previously undisclosed" intelligence report that came from an "international partner." Not disputing that. But it'd be nice to know who that partner was...
- dang 5y agoRecent related threads: How I learned to stop worrying and love the lab-leak theory - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27184998 - May 2021 (235 comments) More Scientists Urge Broad Inquiry into Coronavirus Origins - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27160898 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27160898 - May 2021 (341 comments) The origin of Covid: Did people or nature open Pandora’s box? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27071432 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27071432 - May 2021 (537 comments) Edit: also these: Scientists who say the lab-leak hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 shouldn't be ruled out - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26750452 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26750452 - April 2021 (618 comments) Why the Wuhan lab leak theory shouldn't be dismissed - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26540458 - March 2021 (985 comments) The Lab Leak Hypothesis - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25640323 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25640323 - Jan 2021 (229 comments)
- actuator 5y ago@dang An hour into this submission, this was flagged despite ~100 upvotes. Was there anything off about the flagging behaviour? It seemed like a reputed source article of interest to a lot of folks here, so I was surprised.
- elp 5y agoAnonymous "intelligence sources".... Sounds as legit as the super micro back door. Meanwhile the actual real people on the WHO team said they investigated and didn't find anything more than seasonal flu.
- skinkestek 5y ago> Meanwhile the actual real people on the WHO team said they investigated and didn't find anything more than seasonal flu. The thing is people doesn't trust WHO. I think people have somewhat good reasons not to trust WHO blindly now. I can't say however if this is a good or a bad thing.
- thedrbrian 5y agoEven Fauci thinks something is up https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9610069/Dr-Fauci-says-hes-not-convinced-COVID-19-formed-naturally.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9610069/Dr-Fauci-sa...
- baybal2 5y agoCurrent bottom line: - 1st response to CoVID occurrence was certainly in Wuhan. - The closest wild strain of CoVID happens in bats living thousand kilometres from Wuhan - Wuhan had two institutes which, on record, did gain of function experiments on bat coronaviruses - Beijing purposefully destroyed DNA evidence, and obliterated the team who first sequenced the CoVID genome - Chinese authorities were scrambling, and suppressing reporting as early as November, seemingly with a very good idea what they are up to.
- bwilli123 5y ago"The Coronavirus might have been spreading quietly in humans for years, or even decades, without causing a detectable outbreak – Dr Francis Collins, Director, The National Institutes of Health." https://johnmenadue.com/who-had-covid-first/ https://johnmenadue.com/who-had-covid-first/
- Aeolun 5y agoI dunno. That would be coincidental. Given that we’ve never had a random outbreak of a new disease similar to this in the past 100 years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- henearkr 5y agoNopah virus, ebola, these are two examples where we have been very lucky, and the only reason they did not spread too much internationally was that they originated in regions with very strong political regimes.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoLuckily, it's not too difficult to contain Ebola considering the symptoms and how transmission occurs.
- 5y ago
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.md/dP09I https://archive.md/dP09I
- LatteLazy 5y agoImho, it's an interesting question but we will never know whether the virus started at the lab or the market (or somewhere else). Either way, it's China's incompetence and reckless endangerment of the rest of the world that has caused this. So the more important question is what we will do about it? So far the answer seems to be "nothing because the price of cheap plastic shit might go up 2p a tonne and that's more concerning than a global pandemic".
- Udik 5y ago> Either way, it's China's incompetence and reckless endangerment of the rest of the world that has caused this. After seeing the response from Western countries, (delays, denialism, half measures, etc.) I really doubt we would have done any better. Probably worse.
- LatteLazy 5y agoWe already did much better: we never created a pandemic in the first place. You don't need to be great at dealing with plagues if you don't make them. That's the take away here, China can be as denialist as we are, but they have to fix their food hygiene (and lab security maybe?)... (none of this excuses how shit my government, UK, have performed)
- DebtDeflation 5y ago>we will never know whether the virus started at the lab or the market It didn't start at the market. They tested every animal there and found nothing, yet they found many infected people there and found the virus all over surfaces there. The market was an early superspreader event, not the origin.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI think there are too many unknowns to state either case as a fact: Did they test every animal that had been there? How? Weren't half of them sold and gone already? Do we know none got loose or came from outside?
- ngcc_hk 5y agoAnother two cases needed to investigate is a) whether many of the cases are along the railway between Wuhan lab and the airport to where the bat lived and b) there was a case of infection well before that on bat to Human during the bat study. The whole thing is sad that it is humanity at stake but we have a country so powerful it is in the way to prevent further study. Sigh. Let us see.
- bingbong70 5y agoI expect the fact that this virus emerged in Wuhan during the World Military Games makes the Chinese very cautious about allowing in 'investigators' from countries that potentially deployed this biological weapon.
- bingbong70 5y agoInteresting that this is downvoted without a reply. I guess people have conclusive evidence that a foreign country didn't just attack China? Feel free to share/link it if you do. HN feels like the same kind of echo chamber that would have attacked me for saying not to invade Iraq in the early 2000s... Anything our historically dishonest intelligence agencies imply about foreign countries is eaten up like gospel truth without any skepticism.
- dbsmith83 5y agoI think it's because if you think about it critically for more than 3 seconds, you will see that it is a tin foil hat idea with many, many holes.
- thu2111 5y agoFrom Nicholas Wade's article (it's now the canonical reference for this stuff): "Steven Quay, a physician-researcher, has applied statistical and bioinformatic tools to ingenious explorations of the virus’s origin, showing for instance how the hospitals receiving the early patients are clustered along the Wuhan №2 subway line which connects the Institute of Virology at one end with the international airport at the other, the perfect conveyor belt for distributing the virus from lab to globe." https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-the-clues-6f03564c038 https://nicholaswade.medium.com/origin-of-covid-following-th... (third to last paragraph)
- 0xy 5y agoThis highlights further damage to Dr Fauci's credibility, after his lies about masks not working and his insistence that the U.S. not close international arrivals from China. Dr Fauci recklessly claimed in May 2020 that it's "very, very strongly" impossible for this to have come from a lab. [1] When will public officials actually be held to account for their flip flopping, often times leading to massive distrust from the population and killing people? How many people are refusing vaccines because officials like Dr Fauci have lied repeatedly? [1] https://edition.cnn.com/2020/05/05/politics/fauci-trump-coronavirus-wuhan-lab/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/05/05/politics/fauci-trump-coro...
- thu2111 5y agoWell, he said it was "very, very strongly leaning toward this could not have been artificially or deliberately manipulated". There are multiple related claims that fall under the umbrella of lab leaks: 1. Did it escape from a lab? 2. Was that lab manipulating the RNA of the virus? 3. Was the lab doing so for nefarious/biowarfare related ends? The CNN article is the usual manipulative bilge we might expect from them, because the headline is "Anthony Fauci just crushed Donald Trump's theory on the origins of the coronavirus", but Trump was claiming the virus escaped from a lab (claim 1) and then Fauci makes a counter-claim that it wasn't manipulated by a lab (claim 2). The claim it escaped from a lab was always pretty strong given the long history of lab leaks and where it started. The claim the lab was manipulating it originally had to rely on RNA evidence, which is rather complex to understand, ambiguous and disputed. But recently people seem to have dug up documentary evidence that the US NIAID (led by Dr Fauci) was directing funding to the WIV specifically to manipulate bat coronaviruses, so claim (2) is starting to look pretty strong too. Claim 3 looks very weak and is getting far less attention as a result. There's no evidence for it and COVID makes for an objectively very poor bio weapon. It's also not the most parsimonious explanation that works. Virology researchers had convinced themselves that GOF research was something important that they should be doing, and were able to work around US bans on it by doing it abroad and getting it approved by high level enough figures who could override the bans. They had clear incentives to do the work at low bio-safety levels, and appear to have done so (again from documentary evidence). As is often the case they thought they were doing something good for the world, and that the ends justified the means. They were wrong. No more complex explanation is necessary.
- RickJWagner 5y agoWhen the dust settles, there should be a follow-up investigations into media and scientific community behaviors. It's starting to look like a lot of people took big steps to spread false information, perhaps for political purposes.
- zepto 5y agoI’m guessing those political purposes were something like - “we don’t need an international conflict at the same time as trying to contend with this virus”. Or maybe even just a generic desire not to point fingers. I’m not saying this isn’t bad - just that it’s pretty easy to understand why people would downregulate the lab leak hypothesis without anything special going on.
- aazaa 5y ago> The Wuhan Institute hasn’t shared raw data, safety logs and lab records on its extensive work with coronaviruses in bats, which many consider the most likely source of the virus. Nevertheless, the gain of function research with coronaviruses has been documented in the peer-reviewed literature. The lack of new information from the Wuhan Institute, despite its longstanding research activities, is probably the most compelling evidence in support of the lab escape hypothesis. If the evidence pointed elsewhere, it would be released. The most likely explanation is that the Institute's fingerprints are all over this thing. The second most compelling evidence is that to date the reservoir species has not been found.
- arbitrage 5y ago> The lack of new information from the Wuhan Institute [...] is probably the most compelling evidence in support of the lab escape hypothesis. or it's just china being 100% opaque about an accident that has already damaged their international reputation, and they're controlling the narrative hard at this point. you know, like they do.
- sudosysgen 5y agoIt took over five years to find the reservoir species for SARS, and decades for most viruses. It's not evidence at all because the facts match the expected result. I don't know exactly what information you would want. Every single paper about virology research from the institute was published with western authors. Had there been something wrong in the raw data or safety logs those authors would have said so. Instead they say that everything is normal. There is a weird double standard here of ignoring data that goes against this hypothesis and interpreting things that happened for every single other zoonosis in the world to be indicative of a lab escape. Such as, for example, three people out of six hundred presenting with symptoms of seasonal illnesses in the appropriate season.
- kshacker 5y agoJust because something took 5 years last time does not mean it should take the same this time. - Our SOP should be better to analyze the information. - Given the magnitude of the problem, more eyes should be on it - tools and technologies should be better It may still take longer, but all things being equal, we should not justify anything based on the past track record. Your other point is valid though: if 3 people showed up in 1, 2 or 3 hospitals with severe flu, I would not think much of it, no one would.
- magwa101 5y agoAuthoritarian regimes kill the truth.
- namelessoracle 5y agoIf a new variant of Ebola suddenly showed up in Atlanta, Georgia. Lots of people would immediately jump to the US / CDC having a leak or being responsible. And they would do that just based on geography. This has alot more smoke than just geography.
- woodruffw 5y ago> If a new variant of Ebola suddenly showed up in Atlanta, Georgia. Lots of people would immediately jump to the US / CDC having a leak or being responsible. In part, presumably, because Ebola appearing in Atlanta would be extraordinarily unusual. East Asia has a history of novel respiratory diseases, the same way that other parts of the world have a history of mosquito-borne blood diseases. Put another way: everything we know so far is circumstantial, and some pieces of circumstantial evidence are (or would be) stronger than others. An Ebola outbreak next to a BSL 4 lab in the United States would be a significantly stronger piece of circumstantial evidence than a coronavirus outbreak in a transportation hub city in East Asia.
- dundarious 5y agoExactly. From the project proposal[1] for the gain-of-function research at WIV: > DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): This project will examine the risk of future coronavirus (CoV) emergence from wildlife using in-depth field investigations across the human-wildlife interface in China, molecular characterization of novel CoVs and host receptor binding domain genes, mathematical models of transmission and evolution, and in vitro and in vivo laboratory studies of host range. Zoonotic CoVs are a significant threat to global health, as demonstrated with the emergence of pandemic severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV) in China in 2002, and the recent and ongoing emergence of Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS-CoV). Bats appear to be the natural reservoir of these viruses, and hundreds of novel bat-CoVs have been discovered in the last two decades. Bats, and other wildlife species, are hunted, traded, butchered and consumed across Asia, creating a large scale human-wildlife interface, and high risk of future emergence of novel CoVs. This project aims to understand what factors increase the risk of the next CoV emerging in people by studying CoV diversity in a critical zoonotic reservoir (bats), at sites of high risk for emergence (wildlife markets) in an emerging disease hotspot (China). For a novel coronavirus to emerge in the part of the world containing the institute is not sufficient to implicate them. They are set up to do research in that part of the world, because such viruses are known emerge in such places. And yes, their research involved a lot of testing and categorization that requires some proximity to the wildlife and markets. > The three specific aims of this project are to: 1. Assess CoV spillover potential at high risk human-wildlife interfaces in China. This will include quantifying he nature and frequency of contact people have with bats and other wildlife; serological and molecular screening of people working in wet markets and highly exposed to wildlife; screening wild-caught and market sampled bats from 30+ species for CoVs using molecular assays; and genomic characterization and isolation of novel CoVs. And Daszak's role as part of the WHO investigation is similarly plausible. If you (unwisely, but just as a thought experiment) assume for a moment that it is impossible for the source to be a lab leak, he would be a perfect choice -- he is connected to some of the most relevant and nearby research! I am supportive of further/proper investigation into the lab leak hypothesis, and do think some degree of public and political pressure is required. But the tenor of the "lab leak" conversation I have with friends and that I see online (including here) is more like that of Russiagate (a mostly unsubstantiated, years long, liberal media conspiracy theory). Alternatively, it's like the idea that Iraq had WMD (some plausible concern, but info published from unnamed intelligence sources, using tiny amounts of raw and unverified intelligence data, taken from the least trustworthy informants imaginable, all to satisfy a pre-existing conservative grudge). I have seen people say the lab leak story reminds them of the doubts about WMD in Iraq, which is ironic, because again, I see it as more like the invention of WMD in Iraq. [1] https://reporter.nih.gov/search/xQW6UJmWfUuOV01ntGvLwQ/project-details/9491676 https://reporter.nih.gov/search/xQW6UJmWfUuOV01ntGvLwQ/proje...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andyxor 5y agoSo it’s not a “debunked conspiracy theory” after all? Orange man was right all along.
- sixothree 5y agoHe was very wrong to use what was a conspiracy theory at the time to conclude there was no need for personal responsibility. Hundreds of thousands of lives could have been saved.
- o_p 5y agoWhere are the soy reddit fact-checking fools now?
- 02020202 5y agobut teacher, a bat ate my lunch!
- hedora 5y agoWhether or not COVID-19 was a half-baked biological weapon that was accidentally released, it would be great if we took this opportunity to actually end biological weapons research globally. There’s no reason to think it’s more likely for China to screw up like this than the US, Russia, or the scores of other nations with similar programs.
- themacguffinman 5y agoWe shouldn't assume that it was designed to be a biological weapon. The Gain of Function research suspected to be the origin of this has many benefits for non-military uses like vaccine development & outbreak containment.
- hi41 5y agoLay person here. What does gain of function mean? Thank you, kindly.
- greycol 5y agoBasically the whole term Gain of Function Research is referring to any research that involves deliberate alterations to pathogens to make them more transferable(including the ability to infect other hosts) or deadly.
- cronix 5y ago> according to a previously undisclosed U.S. intelligence report that could add weight to growing calls for a fuller probe of whether the Covid-19 virus may have escaped from the laboratory. Here's the US Dept of State "Fact Sheet" for Jan 15, 2021, which (previously disclosed) states much of the same info that WSJ is now just getting to 4+ months later and reporting it as "news": https://2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan-institute-of-virology/index.html https://2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan...
- manuelabeledo 5y agoHere we go again. Not only is this old, as it was first released earlier this year, but it fuels the conspiracy theory by being sufficiently vague to let people hypothesize about a "biological weapon". For all we know, these workers could have been affected by the H1N1 flu strain, the main one at the time. I guess that is not worth mentioning.
- theknocker 5y agoITT we watch a bunch of Chinese shills pretend it’s hard to figure out covid escaped from a Chinese lab.
- nscalf 5y agoLot's of conspiracy theory people and no investigation ever people in here. I don't have any view on either side, but I think it's appropriate to investigate the possibility that the point of origin was from a lab. Honest question, for those who are against investigating this, what evidence would be needed to soften your view on that?
- techcode 5y agoDoes anyone recall/knows/can find an article (blog post) written by USA based investigative journalist that previously looked/reported on various problems/viruses/deaseases accidentally released by CDC and such? I can't find the article/post now ... I recall it was written just as initial international investigation happened and released statement that "It's highly unlikely Covid-19 originated from Wuhan research center". Guy mentioned things like lab technician carrying box with vials (with faded labels made using type writer) from one building to another and some of vials breaking (luckily not the one containing smallpox). And there was also something about specific room/lab (I think in CDC) in new/rebuilt building where door didn't quite have a good seal - being fixed by duct tape. And we'll the gist of it is - there's a long history even within USA/CDC to downplay/hide such accidents.
- techcode 5y agoFound it - https://eu.usatoday.com/in-depth/opinion/2021/03/22/why-covid-lab-leak-theory-wuhan-shouldnt-dismissed-column/4765985001/ https://eu.usatoday.com/in-depth/opinion/2021/03/22/why-covi...
- MilnerRoute 5y agoOne disease expert working with the WHO told CNN in February that the lab's researchers were tested and there was no evidence found of Covid antibodies. https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/23/politics/us-intelligence-report-wuhan-lab-researchers-coronavirus-origin/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/05/23/politics/us-intelligence-repo... It just seems weird to me that that's not a part of the media's discussion of this.
- nikolay 5y agoIt's not like antibodies circulate indefinitely.
- dazsnow 5y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2021/05/20/no-science-clearly-shows-that-covid-19-wasnt-leaked-from-a-wuhan-lab/?sh=22ac74d15585 https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2021/05/20/no-s...