16 ms·
Noted elsewhere: The Belarus plane hijack is a small reminder why it's generally not a good idea to let governments know who is going to where. I'm not sure wh
by dredmorbius 6y ago
Noted elsewhere:
The Belarus plane hijack is a small reminder why it's generally not a good idea to let governments know who is going to where. I'm not sure why governments that like to think of themselves as democratic don't see the risks.
-- Alexander Bochmann https://mastodon.infra.de/@galaxis/106285985254850170 https://mastodon.infra.de/@galaxis/106285985254850170
I'd made a similar point following the assassination of Kim Jung-nam in 2017:
Travel and hospitality databases are widely accessible and shared amongst a tremendous number of organisations. State intelligence organisations might readily have access through their own state-run airline, or through private operations or plants within same. Similarly for terrorist, narco-criminal, money-laundering, or other organisations. Financial, banking, and payment-processing systems, only slightly less so. A P.I. license or position on a fraud or abuse desk at a major online retailer, or any skip-tracing agency, can have access to such information.
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5ud243/data_are_liability_book_your_assassination_now/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/5ud243/data_ar...
What is your threat model?
Note that your own threat model may not include possibilities which put others at risk.
(In fairness, it appear that Protasevich was followed onto the plane itself, suggesting that in-flight availability of manifests played little role. The question of what pre-flight intelligence methods were employed remains open.)
- stjohnswarts 6y agoI don't see this happening though. It would seem reasonable to limit the countries seeing the passenger list to those countries that the plane is taking off from/leaving though.
- ReptileMan 6y agoExcept you have the emergency landing possibilities which require cooperation. And after all a country has a right/obligation to know who moves trough its territory.
- baybal2 6y agoImagine, it wasn't the case prior to mid-nineties. International air travel was possible with paper tickets. Heck, you could've travel, immigrate, and settle all around Europe without papers prior to a certain mentally challenged emperor deciding to ruin it all.
- smegger001 6y agoprior to a certain mentally challenged emperor deciding to ruin it all You might have to be more specific there have been more than a few of those in European history
- Cullinet 6y agoa close friend of mine who settled in the UK after he only survived the war by fluke being Polish Danzig born but with a step uncle a unfortunate gauleiter (he was on the run one way or another consequently) still to this day hurriedly produces his German Police certificate of good conduct and freedom from trouble with the law, despite being here because he spied for us he cannot be persuaded that any of the 3rd reich or subsequently 4 powers or West German authorities hold any less power over his individual freedoms and liberties and right of abode and living, not one smallest bit less in all that time. And I believe my friend is perfectly correct to think that this is the case.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- Cullinet 6y agoI doubt that the pilot or copilot could have done this themselves, but I would be very surprised if they never asked their corporate control operating command to explain and establish what exactly was going on and whether they're going to be compelled to comply with the Belorussian diversions request... assuming that the escort fighter jets didn't simultaneously arrive on their wings to punctuate the "request" effectively. Can anyone with FAA / CAA (the UK civil aviation authority) or EU airspace rules knowledge clarify what protocols exist for these situations?
- mike_d 6y agoThe generally accepted worldwide rule is that airspace is owned by the country under it. You actually pay overflight fees for use of a countries airspace and are subject to its air traffic control. The corporate response will always be "don't get shot down." In the US and most everywhere else, when you willfully ignore ATC they scramble fighter jets. Every pilot is trained in what this looks like and how to respond, but the safe next step is always to respond in the affirmative and land. https://www.boldmethod.com/learn-to-fly/regulations/inflight-interception-procedures-for-pilots/ https://www.boldmethod.com/learn-to-fly/regulations/inflight...
- bombcar 6y agoNote that many VFR flights are NOT under direct ATC control (though requesting flight following is always recommended) so unless you appear to be flying erratically or otherwise attract attention you may not even be noticed - it’s standard to send an interceptor if they have reason to believe your radio is inoperable and they need to get in contact (there are established intercept/no-contact procedures). In reality it is highly unlikely for a commercial airline to ignore a direct ATC command (unless the pilot believes the plane is in distress) - and in a case like this where ATC reports a hazard onboard and divert it wouldn’t be unexpected to see an escort (even if just so that there is a witness if the plane were to actually explode). After 9-11 the chance that the interceptors are armed is probably 100%. Fun fact: the max speed of a normal GA plane (think Cessna) is below the stall speed of many interceptors which can result in amusement.
- bayesian_horse 6y agoIt's reasonable for the country owning the airspace to know who is on the plane. There are such things as emergency landings. And most countries will probably just refuse overflight privileges if they don't get that information.
- lovecg 6y agoIf a government cares enough to deploy fighter jets to hijack a plane like this in violation of every international norm, you can be sure it has the resources to know where you are at all times regardless of how tightly those databases are locked down. Edit: for improved discourse as pointed out
- trhway 6y ago> to deploy fighter jets to hijack a plane like this in violation of every international norm it is pretty standard practice in case of a bomb threat around the world as no one knows where the bomber(s) would force the plane to fly to : https://abcnews.go.com/US/16s-scrambled-escort-jets-bomb-threat/story?id=28454445 https://abcnews.go.com/US/16s-scrambled-escort-jets-bomb-thr... "An apparent bomb threat against two passenger flights that was tweeted today resulted in two F-16 fighter jets being scrambled to escort the two airliners. The two flights were both enroute to Hartsfeld-Jackson International Airport in Atlanta, where they landed safely NORAD said."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 6y agoYour shallow dismissal not only ignores a substantial portion of my linked article concerning risks and actual case history, but even the portion quoted above. Information is not power, information is a power multiplier. It enables actions (including attacks and defences) to be specifically focused and targeted. In the case of Kim Jung-nam, two women (by all accounts innocent accomplices) managed to kill a significant political target in what they thought wasn an entertainment prank by splashing him with liquid, on the ground, at an airport. Critical to the success of that attack was not access to supersonic military jet fighter aircraft, but simply knowing where and when the target would be in a specified location. Information that's now broadcast to accuracy of centimetres and seconds on many hundreds of millions if not billions of people worldwide right now. To give another example I've noted previously, what rights to privacy should a rhinocerous have? https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/25ll1v/does_a_rhinoceros_have_a_right_to_be_forgotten/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/25ll1v/does_a_...
- rodgerd 6y agoSomething similar has happened with the Thai government - seizing people from transiting flights to apply Thai lese-majeste laws to foreigners who were not expecting to end up in Thailand.
- dredmorbius 6y agoAny examples you could cite?
- 1cvmask 6y agoI think it is quite common: https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna13907293 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna13907293
- 55555 6y agoThis is regarding a guy catching a connecting flight. This is more standard.
- Cullinet 6y agothe arms dealer who was the model for Nicholas Cage in The Lord of War was finally arrested in Thailand on behalf of the USA. for some reason non Americans always seem to think that SE Asian people won't help the Feds. But as anyone American who has visited the region could tell them, SE Asia is about the last place you should try hiding from the Feds. edit : Vietnam and the region is very friendly to Americans and even Brits who avoid alcohol (apologies I'm British born with family in both countries and actually casual drinking alcohol is probably the number one error made by British business people when travelling) but the logic behind cooperation with the USA is simply keeping the USA off their regional collective backs. Just consider how much drug trade is at risk if you upset American interests in SE Asia... edit the 2nd : actually trying to hide anywhere where life itself is cheap is fundamentally the worst error possible to make if you are hiding from existential danger of really motivated people.
- katmannthree 6y ago
- anovikov 6y agoYou are right, but yeah, wouldn't help in this case. This guy informed people in his telegram channels where he was going, and he was followed by KGB spies in Athens airport who verified he was going onboard and even tried to make photos of his documents.
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoReminds me of that Huawei lady who was pulled of her private jet in Canada because the US had a warrant on her.
- morelisp 5y agoWanzhou was not "pulled off her private jet"; she was detained after Canadian customs processing for something that was a crime in both the US and Canada.
- FpUser 5y agoGary Botting, Canada's leading expert on extraditions disagrees with that "crime in Canada" part. Reading "Legal Commentary" section of Wikipedia's article about Wanzhou leaves the impression that Canada had decided to play poodle for whatever reasons. Trump's comment about the case and the way the US had acted in similar matter with Ericsson also leaves impression that the case is largely of political nature.
- morelisp 5y agoI mostly agree with you; I just don't agree it can be characterized as "pulled off her private jet" nor that the case has anything in common with diverting a commercial passenger jet via a fake bomb threat to arrest a journalist.
- FpUser 5y agoI did not characterize it as her being "pulled off her private jet" and never said it has any relation to a fake bomb threat. I was replying strictly to someone's point about why she was arrested at all.
- morelisp 5y agoWell if you're just going to ignore any context in statements, so will I. (Besides that: Fraud is a crime in both Canada and the US; the arguments presented in the Wikipedia article amount to "it's weird to extradite a specific person for this level of fraud", not that it's legal to commit fraud in Canada. I also agree with this!)
- thepangolino 5y ago>The Belarus plane hijack is a small reminder why it's generally not a good idea to let governments know who is going to where. I'm not sure why governments that like to think of themselves as democratic don't see the risks This is absolutely true. No mater what, there WILL be abuse. It's also what worries me most about the normalization of "COVID passports". What's to stop me from putting a bounty on the owner of COVIDpass abcxyz? All you'll have to do is use an alternate scanning app and upload a video of you suckerpunching the owner of COVIDpass abcxyz to receive a 5k prize.
- DougN7 5y agoHow is that different from any other identifier? Passport, driver’s license or even just someone’s name?
- addicted 5y agoWhat does that have to do with a COVID passport? Citizen just put a bounty on a homeless guy with no ID at all. A COVID pass based bounty seems way more cumbersome than an old school WANTED poster.