4 ms·
Your whole line of reasoning rests upon the faulty premise that there's a "free market" for oil in this country, and that encouraging alternate forms of energy
by timr 18y ago
Your whole line of reasoning rests upon the faulty premise that there's a "free market" for oil in this country, and that encouraging alternate forms of energy is somehow "tampering" with the unfathomably complicated mechanisms behind that market. All of which is utter nonsense.
We subsidize the hell out of oil consumption in this country, and we've done it for as long as we've been consuming. Once we stop doing things like funding highway construction, suburban infrastructure and corporate oil exploration with our taxes (no, not just gas taxes!), maybe then we can start to talk about the "free market" with a straight face.
- siculars 18y agosubsidized consumption? or subsidized production. the article specifically points out that higher consumption taxes are offsetting income taxes. the question is not taxing consumption but rather what exactly we do with those taxes. personally i think those funds should go towards funding and expanding renewables.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoMy line of reasoning says that the free market provides the best solution for energy production and delivery. Yes, the market is already subsidized. No, there's no such thing as a pure free market. No, trying to rationalize markets one way or another is a fool's game, but we still try (as any commodities trader will tell you) No, I did not say encouraging other forms of energy was tampering. Yes, my argument against tampering was our recent history of not providing energy for our own country, including nuclear, oil, and refining capacity for the past three decades. I made the extension that the offshore drilling now in question has been on the table for a long time. We should drill. (And in ANWR) Not because it solves the world's problem but because getting out of the way is sometimes better than continuing to be part of the problem. No I do not think that solar, wind, or any number of a dozen other areas are somehow tampering, at least not when compared to the other shenanigans we've been doing. And no, I don't think anything we do this year is going to stack up to shooting ourselves in the collective foot for that long. I'm all for them. It's best to correct the premise once you actually understand it.
- timr 18y agoDon't be snarky. This thread started with a single, reasonable comment: "I disagree that drilling will help. The key point of the article is that it was a cultural rather than a resource based shift that helped Denmark become energy independent." To which you replied with something simultaneously vague (do you pose all of your arguments as questions? Are you practicing for Jeopardy?), and a straw-man misrepresentation of the original comment: "I take it you're happy we haven't drilled any of our resources, haven't built a refinery in decades, and haven't built a nuclear power plant since the 1970s...are you saying that because we've basically forbidden the energy markets to work efficiently inside our country, energy prices are going high, and it's a good thing because maybe the culture will shift like Denmark?" ...which you followed with several long expositions about the virtues of the free market, and your inability to adequately predict the complexities thereof. So based on my reading, to the extent that you're making any argument at all, it seems to be that regulation is the primary cause of energy price increases, and therefore we should lower production regulations (...and also drill more...) to lower prices. This argument has little to do with the OP (that we need to use less energy), and as I pointed out, it teeters on the (faulty) premise that if only we could de-regulate energy production, we'd somehow be moving closer to the Efficient Free Market Utopia That Will Solve All of Our Energy Problems (tm), while ignoring the fact that we heavily subsidize wasteful energy consumption. So, at the end of the day, I'm led to the same conclusion as the OP: in a "free market" where we subsidize the hell out of wasteful consumption, and do little (or nothing) to promote systemic energy efficiency, the obvious first policy step involves reducing our wastefulness -- not drilling for more oil.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI see you're not responding to any of my criticisms of your argument. In addition, you seem to both state the subject as mucking around with markets in order to change the culture (which it was) and the role of regulation as being the primary cause of energy price increases (which it wasn't) My thesis was for this thread that it is not a good societal trade to cripple our own energy market for 30 years for some larger cause of cultural change. I saw this attitude in the original post and was wondering if that was what we were talking about. If that were the case, as I felt the OP was, its both ludicrous and presumptuous. Thanks for the Jeopardy plug. One usually asks questions to learn where somebody else is coming from. I forgot about the Jeopardy angle. Could be in to make some big bucks down the road. And BTW, I tried to make double-sure there was no straw-man argument involved in my posts. Each time I made the case for what I thought the other person was saying I tried to do so in a question, as in "Do you mean..." If I forgot to flag a couple of these, it was an oversight. I've got better things to do than to make up positions for other people and then argue them. But I will ask questions and make presumptions about where the discussion is going in an effort to move things along. But heck, when I use a question, then it seems to get you all bothered. What can I say? One does the best that one can. I'm honestly interested in the other person's opinion, not in critiquing their debating style or sticking their argument in a box somewhere. In the last day I've been called trollish, snarky, voted down without explanation, my commenting style has come under withering attack. Everything but honest discussion. Heck. If I had all day I'd be glad to go after every post here, including the one about per-capita California consumption going down (ever think that manufacturing being driven overseas has something to do with this?) but I don't have the time. I joined in here, quite frankly, because I was bored with the code I was cranking out yesterday and wanted a bit of a diversion. Hey. However the community works, fine with me. But I'm still curious. The only thing I've heard in response to my question is a bunch of hand-waving. Has there been a discussion of offshore drilling likely impacts? Nope. Has anybody commented on my question about 30 years of no new nuclear plants? One person. Anybody take up the issue of no new refineries, or the fact that each state has it's own fuel standards now? Or spent fuel reprocessing? Or the impact on ANWR of drilling? How about the limits of consumption reduction in a world market? Anybody care to talk issues? I know that wasn't the purpose of this thread, but gee, seems like we're doing anything but really having a discussion. All I hear is "reduce consumption". Fine with me. I'm all for it. But you don't make the production problems go away by jumping up and down and waving your arms about consumption. Especially when consumption reduction is both a relative and fickle thing to measure. It's feel-good ideology: we consume therefore we're bad, and we should do the right thing and take a bike to work or something. Bah humbug.