3 ms·
I guess I need to be more clear. When we get into "potential environmental damages", unless you're prepared to make a risk-reward argument with hard statistics
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
I guess I need to be more clear.
When we get into "potential environmental damages", unless you're prepared to make a risk-reward argument with hard statistics we're treading on personal opinion ground. The Chinese seem to have a fairly high tolerance for air pollution, for instance. Other people don't. The Chinese are going to start drilling off our coast. We are not.
I also take issue with your statement we are running out of oil. Not to be pedantic, but it depends on what you mean by "oil". There's shale, sweet, sour, crude, light, etc. And that's not even getting into biofuels (which I know you don't imply, but "oil' could cover those) Look -- I don't know where the market is headed. I guess that makes me unique, because everybody else seems to think they know exactly what's going on. I've heard dozens of experts announce we were at 'peak oil' over the last month, which I personally think is BS. I've read at least one article by an expert that makes the case that oil prices will drop, not rise, over the next 50 years.
So I am by no means trying to trivialize your opinions. But I would point out that we certainly have a LOT of opinions about the topic. I've got mine. You've got yours. As a voter, we get to go slug it out at the polls, as it should be.
I get the fact that you feel you have a good grip on where the markets are, what the risks are, and what's the best way to manage our transition. To me, that seems presumptuous. No hard feelings. Not trying to label you or somehow put you down or anything. As we both know, you have lots of company. Just doesn't seem right to me.
"Ok... so what happens to the poor when we're out of cheap oil?" -- doesn't the market provide the most goods at the lowest prices, thereby helping the poor much more optimally than a government policy would? When you start fiddling with the markets, you're taking responsibility for the delivery of goods in that market -- like it or not.
Guess what? I'm happy being an idiot. I don't presume to know how to deliver the most energy the cheapest way to the world's consumers, and I don't think it's moral for me to hurt or help one group or another based on risks that are not scientifically verified. At least not to this huge degree. If we were talking about something easy like the death penalty, sure, the standard of proof would be much lower. But you're talking about potentially billons of people who will have a harder time reaching their potential for decades while we re-tool.
Don't count me in for that.
- timr 18y agoYour whole line of reasoning rests upon the faulty premise that there's a "free market" for oil in this country, and that encouraging alternate forms of energy is somehow "tampering" with the unfathomably complicated mechanisms behind that market. All of which is utter nonsense. We subsidize the hell out of oil consumption in this country, and we've done it for as long as we've been consuming. Once we stop doing things like funding highway construction, suburban infrastructure and corporate oil exploration with our taxes (no, not just gas taxes!), maybe then we can start to talk about the "free market" with a straight face.
- siculars 18y agosubsidized consumption? or subsidized production. the article specifically points out that higher consumption taxes are offsetting income taxes. the question is not taxing consumption but rather what exactly we do with those taxes. personally i think those funds should go towards funding and expanding renewables.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoMy line of reasoning says that the free market provides the best solution for energy production and delivery. Yes, the market is already subsidized. No, there's no such thing as a pure free market. No, trying to rationalize markets one way or another is a fool's game, but we still try (as any commodities trader will tell you) No, I did not say encouraging other forms of energy was tampering. Yes, my argument against tampering was our recent history of not providing energy for our own country, including nuclear, oil, and refining capacity for the past three decades. I made the extension that the offshore drilling now in question has been on the table for a long time. We should drill. (And in ANWR) Not because it solves the world's problem but because getting out of the way is sometimes better than continuing to be part of the problem. No I do not think that solar, wind, or any number of a dozen other areas are somehow tampering, at least not when compared to the other shenanigans we've been doing. And no, I don't think anything we do this year is going to stack up to shooting ourselves in the collective foot for that long. I'm all for them. It's best to correct the premise once you actually understand it.
- 18y ago
- natrius 18y agoWhen I say we're running out of oil, I mean we're running out of cheap, easily accessible oil. We'll have oil for quite some time; it will just get more expensive. Maybe I'm wrong and the peak of global oil supply is still a ways off. In that case, we'll have made a less painful transition than we would have otherwise. The longer we continue to use energy as we currently do, the more infrastructure will be built based on that consumption, and the more new infrastructure we will need to build in the future to accommodate lower energy use. "When we get into "potential environmental damages", unless you're prepared to make a risk-reward argument with hard statistics we're treading on personal opinion ground." It is personal opinion. I don't see the problem with that. I like my shorelines sans oil spills. I don't think the risk is worth a couple of cents a gallon off of gas. Any quantification of the risks and rewards of offshore drilling will be equally subjective as my assertion that it isn't worth it. If the rest of the country agrees (which looks unlikely at this point), then more offshore drilling won't happen. "doesn't the market provide the most goods at the lowest prices, thereby helping the poor much more optimally than a government policy would?" Yes. Cheap energy for the poor would be nice, but the decrease in price of energy caused by offshore drilling isn't worth the potential environmental damage in my opinion. "But you're talking about potentially billons of people who will have a harder time reaching their potential for decades while we re-tool." It sounds like you're talking about more than just offshore drilling here, as that would have a tiny effect on people reaching their potential. As far as broader governmental efforts that will raise the price of oil, I don't think we should go any further than pricing in the externalities of oil usage. Paying for the damage you cause isn't that radical of a notion.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoOk. I'm happy that at least we're discussing opinions here. Looks like the Chinese are going to develop off Cuba and the Russians have plans for the North Pole. You must feel we're in a pretty strong position to give up the cheap energy close-by and plan on a transition of unknown qualities and length. I mean, I'm all for the transition too, as I've pointed out, but to _manage_ the transition? Wow. It's a breathtaking position. As an example, our behavior over the last 30 years sounds like: hey look -- the world energy market isn't to our liking. Let's stop local energy production and transmission and then it'll transition to something better! This "what is a pretty beach" or "what is a pretty sky' question is going to continue haunting us, and it's quite frankly the reason we've screwed the pooch so long by not building anything. For that reason, I am dubious that we can ever come to a national consensus. It's something the politicians have figured out that they can keep us fighting about. I'd like to see several hundred nuclear power plants built over the next 30 years. I'd also like a pony. I'd like to see the fuel re-processed, like France does. If entrepreneurs want to continue work with wind and solar let's encourage them by offering prizes for measurable goals.