5 ms·
"Are those sacrifices worth it? I don't think so." What sacrifices? I won't use the term "straw man" but I'd at least like to humbly suggest you've made a whol
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
"Are those sacrifices worth it? I don't think so."
What sacrifices? I won't use the term "straw man" but I'd at least like to humbly suggest you've made a whole slew of assumptions about what might or might not happen. Most of these I take issue with.
I'm not crazy about oil. Personally, I'll be happy when we're off it. But, like I said, I don't sit around taking my personal feelings and try to control world markets with them. Seems kind of, well, presumptuous. If we can drill for oil offshore, and it's there, and we need it, I say have at it. There are all sorts of _possible_ dangers and warnings, but the markets indicate that there is a real, tangible need that's not going away.
Hey. I can pay for gas at 20 bucks a gallon. Not crazy about it, but I'm not letting it change my behavior. The people impacted are third world countries -- mostly the poor. I would think that "screwing the poor to make the world a more pretty place for me" wouldn't be much of anything to be proud of.
Note that I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, just trying to figure out where the limits of your argument lie. Would you agree with the statement above? Or would we immediately move into a wealth redistribution discussion?
- jacobolus 18y ago> Seems kind of, well, presumptuous. If we can drill for oil offshore, and it's there, and we need it, I say have at it. There are all sorts of possible dangers and warnings, but the markets indicate that there is a real, tangible need that's not going away. The environmental dangers of oil drilling are more than possibilities, and your dismissive tone doesn’t aid your argument. The current supporters of increased off-shore drilling are spinning up its positives and spinning down its negatives as a craven political ploy in an election year which coincides with oil prices higher than they were a few years ago, and general economic instability. Off-shore drilling is not going to solve our current economic crisis, nor is it going to bring down oil prices to any substantial degree—maybe the price will dip a few percent in 10 years when the oil starts flowing. > Hey. I can pay for gas at 20 bucks a gallon. Not crazy about it, but I'm not letting it change my behavior. The people impacted are third world countries -- mostly the poor. Your implication is that off-shore oil-drilling in America is the best way to help the third-world poor. That is absurd. (And hyperbolically casting natrius as some kind of heartless first-world imperialist doesn’t help your argument either. It makes your comments seem like trolling.)
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoFirst, I did not dismiss the environmental impact of drilling offshore. We did not discuss it at length. There were some sweeping statements made about my position and I pointed out I do not support those statements. Glad to have that discussion. Second, I made no comment about helping the poor. My comment was about the use of personal opinion to control markets. I used the poor as an example of those who could be impacted by our policies. I made no personal attack and posited no question that was supposed to inflame or outrage. I tried to the best of my ability to ask simple questions and make simple statements that I honestly support. As far as the poor comment, I used the statement as a way of advancing the conversation without it having to take another 50 posts. I obviously do not believe he would support that, and am interested in his reply as to where he thinks the limits of market control should be. You're welcome to join in, by the way. I don't mind the critique of my style, but discussing the substance of the matter might be more interesting for all concerned.
- jacobolus 18y agoThe substance of the matter is that America has relatively small reserves of off-shore oil, which if fully tapped today would only make a minor difference in global oil prices, but has massive demand for oil (25% of global demand). Off-shore drilling is not remotely a solution to the coming oil crisis (crises?), and is being used as an emotional appeal in the current political climate purely for partisan advantage, rather than for concrete benefits (not that it doesn't potentially have some benefit, but its current supporters don't particularly care about them). Current US energy policy, far from restricting fossil fuel companies, is hugely beneficial to them (even though it is highly regulatory), with a large array of subsidies and special breaks, not to mention political support. It is unreasonable to demand that energy policy always bow to the “free market,” as that has repeatedly led to bad outcomes all over the world, by providing opportunities for manipulation, and ignoring substantial negative externalities (dead villagers, air pollution, oil spills, etc.). A much more positive change would be to decouple the political system from financial dependence on coal, oil, natural gas, and biofuels/agriculture conglomerates, so that we can have a less tainted national debate on the subject.
- natrius 18y ago"What sacrifices?" The potential environmental damage and future value of that oil that I mentioned. Oil is becoming increasingly scarce. The areas of the planet that currently have a lot of it aren't exactly our friends. Saving that oil for when we actually need it as opposed to dropping the price of a gallon of gas by a couple of cents sounds like a prudent course of action to me. "I don't sit around taking my personal feelings and try to control world markets with them." The markets for natural resources are heavily influenced by people's personal feelings, so you should probably join the club. More people have a claim of ownership to a barrel of oil than a given widget, so those people will use their position to maximize their self-interest. I think you're trying to trivialize my concerns by referring to them as "personal feelings", but I don't think there's anything trivial about wanting to avoid environmental damage and minimize the damage to the American economy that will occur if the transition away from oil is too difficult. "There are all sorts of _possible_ dangers and warnings, but the markets indicate that there is a real, tangible need that's not going away." I don't see how that has any effect on the situation. Yes, everybody wants cheaper oil, but that doesn't mean more offshore drilling makes us all better off in the end. It will increase our current dependency on oil, making the transition harder when the effects of the new oil wear off. It has the potential to damage the environment. If we need oil for something more important than lowering the price of gas by a few cents in the future, we will have less of it. "The people impacted are third world countries -- mostly the poor. I would think that "screwing the poor to make the world a more pretty place for me" wouldn't be much of anything to be proud of." Ok... so what happens to the poor when we're out of cheap oil? It's incredibly myopic to suggest that we should drill more oil now for the sake of the impoverished. If this were a discussion about Pigovian taxation of oil instead of managing the supply of oil, then yes, we would immediately move into a wealth redistribution discussion. However, this has nothing to do with wealth redistribution. Poor people can afford fewer scarce goods. Oh no.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI guess I need to be more clear. When we get into "potential environmental damages", unless you're prepared to make a risk-reward argument with hard statistics we're treading on personal opinion ground. The Chinese seem to have a fairly high tolerance for air pollution, for instance. Other people don't. The Chinese are going to start drilling off our coast. We are not. I also take issue with your statement we are running out of oil. Not to be pedantic, but it depends on what you mean by "oil". There's shale, sweet, sour, crude, light, etc. And that's not even getting into biofuels (which I know you don't imply, but "oil' could cover those) Look -- I don't know where the market is headed. I guess that makes me unique, because everybody else seems to think they know exactly what's going on. I've heard dozens of experts announce we were at 'peak oil' over the last month, which I personally think is BS. I've read at least one article by an expert that makes the case that oil prices will drop, not rise, over the next 50 years. So I am by no means trying to trivialize your opinions. But I would point out that we certainly have a LOT of opinions about the topic. I've got mine. You've got yours. As a voter, we get to go slug it out at the polls, as it should be. I get the fact that you feel you have a good grip on where the markets are, what the risks are, and what's the best way to manage our transition. To me, that seems presumptuous. No hard feelings. Not trying to label you or somehow put you down or anything. As we both know, you have lots of company. Just doesn't seem right to me. "Ok... so what happens to the poor when we're out of cheap oil?" -- doesn't the market provide the most goods at the lowest prices, thereby helping the poor much more optimally than a government policy would? When you start fiddling with the markets, you're taking responsibility for the delivery of goods in that market -- like it or not. Guess what? I'm happy being an idiot. I don't presume to know how to deliver the most energy the cheapest way to the world's consumers, and I don't think it's moral for me to hurt or help one group or another based on risks that are not scientifically verified. At least not to this huge degree. If we were talking about something easy like the death penalty, sure, the standard of proof would be much lower. But you're talking about potentially billons of people who will have a harder time reaching their potential for decades while we re-tool. Don't count me in for that.