3 ms·
The comment you're responding to is actually a conservative perspective, one which I agree with - make big business and banksters suffer the preexisting rules,
by mindslight 5y ago
The comment you're responding to is actually a conservative perspective, one which I agree with - make big business and banksters suffer the preexisting rules, rather than changing the rules for some larger overall goal after they run into trouble.
The desire to narrow the scope of government comes from a place of wanting to help all people, believe it or not. The big picture is that both professional political parties have been captured by entrenched interests. You, empathizing with the grassroots left, naturally look at the intentions of your political allies, while giving a pass where the higher level falls short. But at this point, those higher level "failings" are fundamental to the system.
The more recent development is that the rightist party has seemingly gone batshit crazy - after decades of being frustrated by their moral prescriptions becoming irrelevant, they've turned down the path of destructive spite. But this doesn't invalidate conservative thinking altogether, and we still need the sane bits from both philosophical frameworks / modes of thinking.
- dsr_ 5y agoA sibling comment says that this is actually a libertarian perspective. One of you might be wrong.
- mindslight 5y agoI was using "conservative" as a synonym for rightist, as it is commonly (ab)used. The perspective is both rightist and libertarian. It's a product of rightist thinking - applying prescriptive rules to their logical conclusion. I consider myself a libertarian and think applying right-paradigm thinking is the most freedom-appropriate for this subject.
- imtringued 5y agoA lot of it boils down to the fact that conservative thinking is needed after we have exhausted the maximum potential of the economy. Right now the economy needs to be run as hot as possible so that everyone has enough money and once it is hot we need to immediately rearrange it to become productive again. That means republicans have to shut up for a while until the economy follows the textbooks again. It has to be done in this order. The longer it takes to reach the limits of the economy the more time exists for it to become unproductive and the needed correction will have to be bigger than absolutely required. If the entire economy consisted of money losing zombies (think Uber) then a small raise in interest rates will cause the entire economy to disappear at once, if there is competition for labor and pressure to innovate and be productive then zombies will stop growing and by the time we have to raise interest rates sharply there won't be many zombies left to take the economy down.
- mindslight 5y agoI wholeheartedly disagree. By alternating between philosophies, we get the worst of each, benefiting politically connected businesses at the expense of the people. If the plan is to bail out businesses when there is a credit crunch, then to be consistent, it needs to be illegal for those businesses to take on so much debt in the first place. When businesses need to be bailed out because executives looted their coffers into bonuses, those executives need to go to prison. Direct restrictions on companies to prevent undesirable behavior is part of the left's paradigm. Instead, such controls were rejected with the idea that shareholders would keep executives in check, because long term they didn't want to lose money. This is the right's paradigm, but its political function turned out to be only as a convenient unprincipled excuse - when it came time to follow through, there was no support. For this subject I'd personally favor the right-paradigm approach rather than the left-paradigm approach. But history has shown that the right-paradigm approach is untenable when the problem happens, and only plays as a justification to loot during good times. And so despite how I would prefer society to be structured, I'm forced to support the left's restrictions if I don't want to be played for a fool.