9 ms·
I think this is an excellent comment. What makes me very sad is that during the past 14 months the divide between those who own assets and those who don't has r
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I think this is an excellent comment. What makes me very sad is that during the past 14 months the divide between those who own assets and those who don't has reached gargantuan proportions.
I mean, in my raging inferno of a housing market, over the past couple of years home prices have easily doubled. So a 400k house from 2018 now sells for 800k. Yes, if I want to move to another house in my area I'll pay similarly astronomical prices, but that just means it's about a wash for me, and of course I have many more options like moving to a cheaper locale or a cash out refi.
But if I (or my parents) don't already own a home, it means my chances of ever owning a home in my area just went to about zero. People made vastly more money just sitting around in their houses in the past couple years than I made in my job as an "essential" worker over the past decade.
I just don't see how this ends well.
- fortran77 5y agoTaxes even that out a bit. The person with an 800k house pays twice as much in property taxes. In many states, the amount that the state can raise taxes on someone whose house may have "increased" in value is limited.
- ta988 5y agoThey don't because houses don't produce income (unless you rent them). So if you had your house when you could afford it but cannot anymore you get made even less wealthy with the property taxes. Taxes should be proportional to income. There should be a more fair way to do that: to not tax main house when in use, tax only at the time of sale on benefit only (corrected by inflation).
- an_opabinia 5y agoYou have a lot of reading to do about property taxes in California.
- skeeter2020 5y agoThat's rarely true. Property taxes are typically set by dividing the budget by the total value of all real estate to set the mill rate and then allocating it by the specific value of your property, so if the entire market increases the tax impact based on assessed value doesn't change much. You only see dramatic changes when certain areas in a taxed area increase or decrease significantly relative to others.
- chasebank 5y agoNot in California. Prop 13 keeps property taxes at the value when you purchased your home. IMO this is a massive contributor to inflated property values, now leaking into other state economies.
- adolph 5y agoWhat is your theorized mechanism for the freezing of property tax rates at the purchase price causing inflated property values? I could see it making an upward or downward trend worse. In an upward trend buying before increase would be tax advantaged. In a downward trend buying after anticipated decreases would have the advantage. All in all, more people would be advantaged by just staying in place. Maybe that reduces total inventory, making the remaining properties on the market cost more?
- jayd16 5y agoIts way more simple than you think. Lower taxes just lower the yearly cost of a house. That means you can get a bigger loan instead.
- chasebank 5y agoIt's really simple. California has a housing supply problem. If taxes are never raised, housing supply is even more suppressed. Owners have zero incentive to sell. Here's an example. My mother inherited a beach house in Carpinteria. My grandparents purchased it for $14k in 1924. It's worth north of $10M. Annual taxes are under $5k. She can rent this out during summer months for over $50k/mo. Why on earth would she ever sell? She has an asset that appreciates at or above index funds and pays amazing dividends. This is an extreme example but it works the same at every level. Prop 13 encourages people to accumulate housing / property and removes basic market economics. Artificially low housing supply leads to artificially inflated housing prices.
- mcguire 5y agoI remember Prop 13 from a case study in a government class. I had totally forgotten about it until you mentioned it. Prop 13 was pushed by rental property owners---primarily apartment complexes, because they don't change hands very often. It's one thing to enjoy the value increase on a house you own for 5-10 years and another the increase on an apartment complex that you own for 20-30.
- zpeti 5y agoI would love to see a parallel universe where in 2008 no one is bailed out and bankers are either on the hook for the risks they took or actually are sent to prison. Taking it further back, what if the tech bubble of the 90s is allowed to collapse, interests aren't set at almost 0, and a housing bubble isn't blown by exploiting minorities. And last year airlines, and other corporations who didn't account for black swan events, go bankrupt, and new management take them over (or employees), or they disappear altogether and new startups can fill the void. I am convinced the USA is in the place it is because since about 99, no rich person has been allowed to fail or lose money, not really. I'm not a leftie, but it really is capitalism for the poor, socialism for the rich right now. But I have to say, the problem is collusion between the rich who are close to politics, and the problem is the GOVERNMENT enabled all this. The problem is NOT all rich people. Only the ones who are part of this system. And this distinction needs to be made, otherwise the US is headed for a communist disaster of hating the rich. But the problem is the corrupt rich, not all rich.
- dsr_ 5y agoThe only wrong thing you've said here is "I'm not a leftie". Why do you reject that generally accurate label? There are decades of propaganda in US society equating the left with dictatorships and totalitarian states. Only in the last few years have large numbers of young people realized that all the good things coming from society working together are being labelled as socialist: libraries, schools, firefighters, even roads and water systems. The view of the far right has narrowed the acceptable scope of government to national defense, enforcing contracts, and enforcing the existing social order via police. If you want the US government to work on behalf of all the people, your natural allies are on the left.
- NikolaNovak 5y agoI see what you are saying; coming from Europe, I'm frequently astonished how much "Socialist", "Leftie" or even "Liberal" in USA is a dirty word of political death.
- throwaway3699 5y ago
- throwaway6734 5y agoThe solution is to move to an area with cheaper housing. Moving to opportunity is the American way
- JKCalhoun 5y agoHmmm.... I've been looking at real estate in the midwest — Kansas City, Omaha — and surprised by how much it has skyrocketed there as well. At the same time (as seen on HN recently) they're "giving away" land in small-town Kansas and Nebraska. No jobs. You are responsibly for building the house. Lots of other caveats. I think a real-estate collapse or a sustained wave of affordable housing starts is more likely.
- bradleyjg 5y agoThe government will not allow real estate to stay collapsed. Look what happened after 2008: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=EcTD https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=EcTD
- NikolaNovak 5y agoThat worked for early movers at beginning of Covid. In Canada, 12 months later, previously "cheap" provinces have doubled in prices too. Still cheaper than Vancouver or Toronto of course; but given lower income in those areas, and the growing pains they're about to have in catching up their infrastructure etc, it's no longer a straightforward gain anymore.
- pjc50 5y agoCheaper housing => longer and more expensive commute. Or worse job opportunities. Then people tell you to move where the jobs are. Which has really expensive housing. The free market tends to flatten this stuff out
- baq 5y agoThe free market caused this situation in the first place.
- bradleyjg 5y agoPeople made vastly more money just sitting around in their houses in the past couple years than I made in my job as an "essential" worker over the past decade. This is not an accident. It’s a result of deliberate policy choices. The incumbent homeowners voted themselves massive returns. And they felt self righteous while they were doing it to boot.
- e40 5y agoWhat are you talking about?
- mindslight 5y agoThe Federal Reserve's overt mission is to dump new money into the economy to create inflation. But since they only pump it into the overgrown financial sector, we get asset inflation rather than general price inflation. Every time interest rates are lowered, land prices go up, because the monthly (financial) rent remains the same. Similarly with down payments (20% -> 5%). The next step will be lengthening mortgage terms past 30 years. Each of these steps is aimed at making it more affordable to buy a house, but economic feedback makes sure that is only temporary. Meanwhile as asset valuations go up, one's ability to ever pay off that mortgage goes down.
- duped 5y agoTheir dual mandate is to maximize employment and manage inflation. Their mission is exactly not to create inflation (or at least, too much of it).
- mindslight 5y ago"Manage" inflation means to create it. An economy naturally tends towards price deflation, through optimization and technological progress. Business looking for ways to cut costs to compete is intrinsic to a market.
- 5y ago
- readams 5y agoExcept you have to pay capital gains tax when you move after 250k or 500k for married. So it's not a wash. Especially if you're talking about more expensive markets.
- selectodude 5y agoOnly if you don't buy a new house within the year.
- encoderer 5y agoYes that’s true but the $500k goes pretty far. You add all previous home improvements to your cost basis and then deduct real estate agent fees. You can have a million of paper appreciation and not pay very much cap gains tax on it.
- kingsuper20 5y ago>Yes, if I want to move to another house in my area I'll pay similarly astronomical prices, but that just means it's about a wash for me, In California you may well have doubled your annual property tax bill.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYes, and prop 13 makes all kinds of ridiculous impacts whereby one person living in a 2 million dollar home pays a tenth of the property taxes of their neighbor also living in a 2 million dollar home.
- tamiral 5y agofellow Canadian here ?
- skybrian 5y agoTech stocks are a similar story.
- jjav 5y ago> People made vastly more money just sitting around in their houses To be fair, that's not exactly making money. Value on paper, based on comparative sales nearby, has gone up in many places. But that's not money one can use to pay bills or buy food. It can also evaporate same way it showed up, just like the gains from early 2000s evaporated in 2008. Unless one gets lucky timing the market and buys low and cashes out at the peak, it's not real money.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> But that's not money one can use to pay bills or buy food. I know several people who have refinanced (a good idea in my opinion) and taken cash out (a bad idea in my opinion) to do things like remodel kitchens or and pay other bills.