3 ms·
this was exactly my experience and I remember the paper that I read that finally convinced me. It turns out the author had intentionally omitted a key step tha
by dekhn 6y ago
this was exactly my experience and I remember the paper that I read that finally convinced me. It turns out the author had intentionally omitted a key step that made it impossible to reproduce the results, and only extremely careful reading and some clever guessing found the right step.
There are several levels of peer review. I've definitely been a reviwer on papers where the reviewers requested everything required and reproduced the experiment. That's extremely rare.