12 ms·
I think this is a really good article, but I think that one of the things it misses is that a huge reason the math works out so badly for startup employees is b
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I think this is a really good article, but I think that one of the things it misses is that a huge reason the math works out so badly for startup employees is because founders and VCs take the lion's share of the gains.
I mean, in my experience at startups, founders typically own around 40% of the equity. The option pool for all other employees is around 10-20%.
Now, I certainly believe startup founders deserve far more equity than anyone else, but this highlights that the risk/reward trade-off really only makes sense for founders. I mean, what founders risk in terms of opportunity costs and lower wages is usually only slightly more than very early stage employees, but their reward is ~10-30x. The reward, in rare cases, may also make sense for C level hires at proven startups that are already growing like gangbusters, because they'll get a ton of equity. For rank-and-file, though, the issue is that even if the startup hits it usually becomes more like a nice bonus than life defining wealth.
- eecc 5y agoThat’s what Wiener suggests in Uncanny Valley, when she describes the windfall when Microsoft bought the GitHub shares she had the option to buy during her time there. It wasn’t life-defining, plus she noticed that many other employees didn’t have enough savings to actually exercise.
- adflux 5y agoCouldnt a bank front the cash to exercise the options? Not familiar with the matter but it seems like an easy thing to get a loan for
- eecc 5y agoI guess it’s still a question of borrowing money for a speculative investment, you just get a significant discount that makes profit more likely. Depending on your indebtedness (outstanding student loans, mortgages) savings and current earnings a bank could still refuse to lend you enough money, if at all
- wayoutthere 5y agoIf you’re making a high enough salary to be getting enough options that you can’t afford to exercise them, you’re making enough to borrow about $100k. I had no trouble getting an uncollateralized loan at a reasonable rate for $75k; and I had $100k in student debt, a $500k mortgage and little else in the way of assets. And when I say “no trouble” I mean I applied for the loan, was approved 30 minutes later and had the money in my bank account within 2 hours. That loan is paid off now, but if your income is high enough banks will lend you money on that alone (I was making an equivalent salary to a principal developer at the time).
- vmception 5y agoIf you’ve ever taken any risk with credit and failed or simply had a disruption in income anytime in the last 10 years prior you would have been denied. Its nice everything worked out for you, that has nothing to do with your ability to perceive a simple solution available to you.
- ptero 5y agoThe only risk is that one exercises the options, but by the time one sells the shares (which they got as the result of exercising options), the price of the stock falls below the strike price. To avoid this risk, do a quick sell after exercise. This makes risk minimal; in case of bigger companies effectively zero. Bigger risk comes in if someone wants to do an exercise and hold to sell much later, which can bring tax advantages. But this is a different game entirely. In the case of employee with little spare cash (to the tune of borrowing money for the exercise), not doing exercise and sell is really leaving money on the table. My 2c.
- ghaff 5y agoOne thing I learned during the dot-bomb era is think hard about holding too much of your company's stock and, especially, think really hard about exercising options and then not selling. Fortunately the stock drifted back up a ways over time and then my former company was acquired for a nice spike. So between that and tax loss offsets, I didn't do that bad. But I've been careful since. (Of course, more recently, I'd have been better off holding more for longer but I can't really complain.)
- vinay_ys 5y agoRegular startup employees borrowing and buying their stock options is far riskier than them borrowing to do options trading in publicly traded stock markets because they have very little information about their company's future prospects. What goes on between the founders, board, current investors and likely future investors is likely known to very few amongst them, if at all. Even if you believe strongly in the product and know the market-fit is bang on, you don't know if the option is currently priced correctly.
- toast0 5y agoIf it's to exercise at the close of a deal, the acquirer could also setup a loan too. I had options which were subject to revesting (lame, but worked out ok), and the acquirer fronted the money to exercise everything that wasn't already exercised and then took payments automatically when the chunks vested. Because of the strike prices we had, it didn't feel very risky.
- spoonjim 5y agoYes, but then you’re holding illiquid startup stock that can easily to go 0 in value.
- alasdair_ 5y agoMost option contracts forbid the employee pledging the shares for anything, including a loan to pay taxes. Its kind of absurd.
- barrkel 5y agoThe way it should happen with a liquidity event is that you simultaneously exercise your options and sell them, pay off the taxes and bank what's left over. Savings should only come into it if you're leaving before the liquidity event.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Savings should only come into it if you're leaving before the liquidity event. Which is another way some startups screw people. If the company is not willing to budge on the "standard" 90-day exercise window, there shouldn't be any negotiation. Just walk away.
- hellcow 5y agoThere are two types of options, NSO and ISO. You want ISO as an employee because it's better for taxes, but that has a 90-day exercise window set by the IRS. You can push for yourself paying higher taxes in exchange for more flexibility, but it's a tradeoff. https://carta.com/blog/pte-90-day-window/ https://carta.com/blog/pte-90-day-window/
- rjzzleep 5y agoZach Holman one of the first github employees didn't get to exercise any of his options for the aforementioned reasons. When they tell you to throw your life away to believe in the vision, nobody tells that 24 y/o to get a lawyer to understand what that actually means. He compiled a list of startups with sane exercise windows: https://github.com/holman/extended-exercise-windows https://github.com/holman/extended-exercise-windows
- robocat 5y agoAt the bottom of that link: “It's worth noting that Andreessen Horowitz has come out in strong favor of the 90 day window. If you feel strongly about extended exercise windows, it might be worth considering whether a16z portfolio companies are a good fit for you.” with a link to https://a16z.com/2016/06/23/options-timing/ https://a16z.com/2016/06/23/options-timing/ The a16z link is astonishingly self-serving. Their top line solution was: “One existing solution to the ‘dead equity’ problem has been — and still can be — to make exceptions where appropriate for certain exiting employees. In fact, employers make exceptions all the time for certain employees, depending on their contribution to the company, critical skill set, and so on.” Riiiiiiight - asking nicely for a handout when you are quitting is a great strategy!! And I would love to know how they come to this conclusion “In our model, we estimate that moving from the current 90-day window to a 10-year window will cost the average remaining employee as much as 80% in incremental dilution.” - just, wow.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- an_opabinia 5y ago> I mean, what founders risk in terms of opportunity costs and lower wages is usually only slightly more than very early stage employees, but their reward is ~10-30x. A first employee is, by another definition, someone to whom a professional investor would not give money.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYou're being downvoted, but as the author of the post you responded to, I don't really disagree. I've been an early employee and have learned I don't have the temperament or skills to be a founder. My primary argument is just that if founders and VCs don't loosen their purse strings, though, they will find employees are wising up about wealth distribution in a startup and will see they have better options elsewhere, as this article suggests.
- an_opabinia 5y ago> I don't have the temperament or skills to be a founder If only everyone were as mature and introspective. > are wising up about wealth distribution... will see they have better options elsewhere Truthfully, all those people will discover is that the distribution of educational pedigrees - the real predictor of "better options elsewhere" - is far stickier, nepotistic and unfair than a 9 percentage point difference in equity.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoBut they do. They pay salaries, benefits, overhead. Its a team that gets funded.
- NeverFade 5y agoBingo. As a senior engineer, I get startup offers at the Staff-Principal levels, and even those grant no more than 0.1-0.5% equity at most, on top of ~$180-200k salary. That simply isn't competitive with big established companies like FAANG that offer me $400k+, far better career growth prospects, and far lower risk. For most startups, the equity will be worthless, and the whole company will either shut down or get acquired, which means you won't have a straightforward career path no matter how hard you work and how many impressive accomplishments you achieve. Meanwhile your friends over at FAANG will be earning twice as much and climbing the promotion ladder simply for doing a good job. Finally, let's not forget the abhorrent tax treatment that screws you, especially as a senior engineer: while your options will likely end up worthless, you'll have to pay tax for them as if they're worth their weight in gold. That puts a whole new level of risk on the already bad and risky deal of working at startups. It's beyond me how that tax treatment was allowed to continue given how bad it is for startups, and how much it advantages big established companies that are already deep in anti-trust territory, though I guess that could also be the answer to why it's still the rule.
- throwaway78123 5y agoNot sure where you live, but in the US, options are typically granted with a strike price equal to the latest 409A valuation, which makes the grant neutral from a tax standpoint. I don't see a world where you have to pay lots of taxes for worthless options, unless someone really screwed-up (i.e. messed up the 409 Safe Harbor election etc...) Now... if you exercise the option, that is a different story. At least in theory you would only exercise if things went well and the stock went up vs the strike, which makes sense why one would have to pay taxes then.
- NeverFade 5y ago> Now... if you exercise the option, that is a different story. You exercise if you leave, and startup IPOs can take many years, and most startups don't have a compelling options package for you after the first 4 years anyway. So a senior engineer who got their full 4 year equity and wants to leave, which is the most typical scenario, will indeed have to exercise and get hit by the tax bill.
- hellcow 5y ago> what founders risk in terms of opportunity costs and lower wages is usually only slightly more than very early stage employees Maybe this is different for others, but my co-founder and I spent 2 years bootstrapping before we got our first customer. We gave up 2 years of wages and consumed our savings to do this with no assurance of success, and even after that first customer it was another full year before we had any sense of stability. Years of time and money. I consider that quite a bit more risk than our first employees who got stable income, healthcare, 401k's, etc. on day one.
- Eridrus 5y agoStable doesn't really describe early stage startups at all. Just because there is a paycheck doesn't mean there will be one when a big account falls through. But anyway, I would urge founders to think more about the logarithmic utility of money and whether it makes sense to take 30x+ the gains of early employees. In particular, think of the number that make it all worthwhile and ask if you need to capture all the gains above that, or whether you could be more generous if you hit it out of the park, and if there is a way to write that into your contracts.
- achillesheels 5y agoWhy should leaders and team builders be more “equitable” than what is transactionally afforded by their diligent appreciation of their assets? How is the utility of money not best suited for those who created something from nothing versus those who entered into the tent after it was pitched? Aren’t there gradients of personal ambition being demonstrated between the two parties? If so, wouldn’t society be abler if the leaders were able to do more after having created the opportunity in the first place? The generosity emerges out of the availability for lending the capital to strangers in society thanks to the successful investment realization.
- Eridrus 5y agoWe're in a thread talking about how equity compensation at startups is generally not sufficient to overcome the pay cut that folks would take from working at a top tier tech company, so even if you come at this from a purely transactional perspective, you may want to be less stingy with equity. You can do whatever you want of course, but I think people should ask themselves if trying to hold onto all the returns is helping them achieve what they actually want.
- break_the_bank 5y agoAlso it's impossible for me to tell whether my below market base salary startup offer from a seed/series A startup is at market or not. Especially the equity bit, is 1% equity enough for the second employee(and engineer)? Especially when I am taking a 50% cut on base salary in addition to losing some very real liquid stocks.
- vinay_ys 5y agoIf you are the second employee (first engineer) at a tech startup with a solo founder company, most likely you can get more than this. Nobody will give you more than what they have to unless you educate yourself and negotiate on your own behalf. You are taking the same risks as the founder and you being there is directly helping the founder raise funds and hire other engineers. Don't under-value yourself. Your previous total comp was base + public/liquid stocks. You should compute the growth in valuation of those liquid stocks (if it was similar to FAANG stocks, its growth would have been 50%+) plus the return on investment of your savings. Add that to your total comp. For your startup comp to beat this total comp, given your 1% stocks, compute backwards the valuation your startup has to achieve. Does it look feasible or too crazy? How long will it take? Do market research to understand how much revenue and profits a public company in similar sector does to achieve that valuation and how much capital investment and tech innovation is needed to get to that. Ask questions to your founder boss, meet their investors to understand their thinking. Very important to consider what happens if you quit before it got there. If you have to pay to exercise options, or your options get bought back by the founder at a discounted valuation etc. (some startups have started doing "stock appreciation rights" which are somewhat unfair) understand those for what they really are and factor that into your calculation. Understand how cap tables, dilutions, liquidation etc works and factor the risks into your calculation. Finally, remember that founders get fired/replaced; your direct boss is going to be someone else very shortly (especially if the company grows fast) etc. so don't go by verbal promises. If you are looking to make millions, invest time and energy to understand and negotiate your employment contracts properly.
- break_the_bank 5y agoIn this particular scenario I'd be the second employee, not counting the two founders as employees. I did similar math as you said and I didn't find the numbers fair. I figured how much would I be losing per year at the current valuation and my pay cut seemed more than what the investors got for the last round. I wish there was more public information about startup salaries at various stages of employment, while the company is still a tiny company. Finding information about FANG salaries is so easy but startup salaries is tough.
- rjzzleep 5y agoFrom my own household/wife I have a person who's worked her ass off for a hugely incompetent CEO who has a majority stake. When I say ass off I mean 12-14 hours a day even on weekends. A promise of unlimited holidays and then coercing all employees to work during government mandated holidays and now he's trying to scam her out of her less than 1% options by coercing her to write a maternity leave policy that would make sure she doesn't get to vest. This is a sequoia invested company. I don't think this company has even 10% of equity allocated for all the other employees. No way it's that much. She's sacrificed her own health, the health of her child and her personal relationships for someone who's coerced a bunch of people who are to scared to talk to a lawyer into a bunch of labour law violations. When I myself interview with startups and they try to sell me on their BS vision fantasies, I tell them that I'm not available 24/7. I'm not on call duty either and if they have issues with that I'm happy to use my experience to help them transform/automate their business into a situation where they are more efficient and don't need to burn out their employees. Some people respect this as a sign of experience and others, especially the valley considers this not aligning with their "values". This is exploitation plain and simple. They cheat their employees into thinking taking abuse is acceptable, because that's what you have to do to change the world. If anything such people change the world for the worse if you ask me. EDIT: also, due to the lack of experience it's clear that some of the directions actually come top down from whatever VC is involved in it.
- bostonsre 5y agoThey're not all that bad. I've worked in a horrible startup before and they absolutely forced everyone to work harder with longer hours instead of working smarter. We had a few ~12-16 hour deploys that started after a full work day where the entire engineering department was required to stay and the oncall was brutal 2 week long slogs because no effort was allowed to be put into actually fixing stuff. But on the other hand, I've also been at ok jobs that were pretty great companies and the one I currently work at is absolutely amazing and it's a joy to work at. The pay has been pretty awesome as well. Larger companies in my experience can be soul crushingly beaurocratic and the slower pace means your skillet grows more slowly (no big tech companies in the valley, just some large public companies after startup acquisitions). It's just anecdotal from my experience and I'm not really sure how big of a haystack the amazing startup needles are in but they are out there. Work is work, but you spend a huge portion of your life at work, if you can enjoy it thoroughly, you can live a happier life.
- skohan 5y agoI think what's also missing from the equation here is the fact that part of the reason which startup compensation is not competitive is because FAANG salaries have been set in such a way to attract talent which might otherwise go to startups.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoHow true to do suspect the following hypothesis is: FAANG overpays for top talent they do not need purely to keep it out of the hands of startups and competitors who do have a present concrete need for the top-shelf talent pool?
- skohan 5y agoI don't know to what extent that's an explicit strategy, but I would find it plausible to imagine that FAANG could spend a lot less on engineering - both in terms of salaries and head count - to keep their current velocity on product development, but they see a strategic interest in controlling that talent pool which they have an opportunity to exploit via capital advantage.
- ariwilson 5y agoThe other side of this is mentioned in the OP - at scale, if you get top talent for $$$ and can squeeze 1% more revenue out of your products, it's still worth your time.
- StandardFuture 5y agoThis seems to inherently assume a strong correlation between "talented" and "risk-averse". A startup is potentially far more valuable than working at a FAANG, especially so if you are a founder. So, why ever work for anything other than your own company? And, even if the "talent" takes a job at FAANG, what stops them from having a 2-year turnover rate where they make some money and then go risk starting their own company, and if that fails then just go back to making a steady paycheck? The FAANG strategy for hiring talent seems to be something along the lines of: "Sure, not all talent will be risk-averse, but a (large) percentage of talent will be, and we can grab those risk-averse talented people with higher-salaries than smaller companies." In other words: if you are not a founder, relatively high-equity early employee, or a FAANG employee then you are game-theoretically either second-tier talent, really hate FAANG companies, and/or you are not actually aiming high enough.
- tisFine 5y agoAt least with the founders I’ve worked for it’s hard to agree they are owed that much more. They fund raised. Poorly. They offered zero direction, touted a big number as potential revenue. They traveled ostensibly to fund raise, but usually just brought back personal stories of fun. While we all slogged on “their” vision, which meant rearranging deck chairs to the march of some alpha non-contributor who can brown nose. It was effectively our company with some entitled assholes name on the paperwork. I’m guessing there’s many more founders like that, as I’ve had the “fortune” to work for 3 in the past, versus the one I work for now, who knows the problem space, has worked directly on solutions for years, and shows up everyday with new customers chomping at the bit to sign up. So I feel confident saying: Most founders are idea people with no skills. Just a used car salesmen personality and a richer network.
- mathattack 5y agoVery true. The system overweights the rewards to the founder. And anyone can be a founder if they are willing to take more risk and go without getting paid.
- _hyn3 5y ago> what founders risk in terms of opportunity costs and lower wages is usually only slightly more than very early stage employees Very early stage employees (before VCs get involved and impose the 10-20% option pool that you allude to) tend to get an outsized offering. (and, to me, a pre-VC employee sounds an awful lot like a co-founder, unless they're not committed heart-and-soul the way the founder is.) You might not be aware of the risks that a founder experiences versus a pre-VC employee. These risks are substantial. Many are not even quantifiable. Everyone likes to joke about rewarding failure, but the reality is that the reputational risk is very high. If you are instead talking about post-VC very early employees, there is an even wilder difference in the risk that those employees shoulder by taking a job with a VC-backed company compared to the founders. Let's face it; working for and/or founding a startup is really, really tough and possibly even hazardous to your health. It's not for everyone. In fact, it's really not for almost anyone. But it's one of the few shots at winning a lottery where you can actually change the rules of the game while you're playing it.
- neilv 5y ago> what founders risk in terms of opportunity costs and lower wages is usually only slightly more than very early stage employees Excellent point. And there can also be huge differences in non-monetary value that make the opportunity cost more worthwhile for founders. If the startup fizzles, but the founders were spending most of their time getting startup founder experience, and building their professional network and personal brand, then the opportunity cost would probably be well-spent, despite the fizzle. Of course, worthwhile experience value can definitely happen for junior non-founder ICs. Worthwhile experience value can happen for already-experienced non-founder developers who can get experience/keyword in some very marketable thing they couldn't pick up on their own. (For example, the necessary capital expenditure means they couldn't get experience with Quantum Deep Learning Transhuman Interfacing from their kitchen table. Or they need a team of full-time collaborators to together accomplish something they couldn't do by just organizing hobbyists on an open source project.)
- khazhoux 5y agoOr this: * Startup doesn't outright fail, but gets acquihired... * Founders gets executive positions with bonus on top of bonus. Their resume has taken a huge leap forward, and if they stay at the acquiring company for just one year, they'll amass enough cash to take another couple of years off to try another startup. * Employees get regular salary, and some small bonus to make it "worth it". They may as well have never done the startup, because it's an overall net-negative. Oh, and the employees still have to individually interview at the company, and several won't make the cut.
- emerged 5y agoThis is why I’ve found a balance. I like to work at a startup, but they get the amount of hours they invest in me. Typically that means I get to spend much of my day enjoying fitness/outdoor activities but still get the potential for a nice bonus if the equity amounts to anything. I’ll never again work obscene hours without obscene compensation. Even with the compensation I’m highly unlikely to do it.