8 ms·
> The canonical point of a workplace is to come together to fulfill the aims of the entrepreneurs. I disagree. The notion that humans turn into employer-owned
by wpietri 5y ago
> The canonical point of a workplace is to come together to fulfill the aims of the entrepreneurs.
I disagree. The notion that humans turn into employer-owned production machinery for 8 hours a day is one very particular way to conceptualize work. But it ignores both the individual as a whole person and the society that contains and enables the workplace to function.
To me, even as a former and perhaps future entrepreneur, I think it's a giant mistake to see a workplace as a place where the entrepreneur is a tiny god-king. Work is a social and societal activity at least as much as it is an economic one. If people want to play-act as robots, I won't deny them their kink. But that's not what interests me about work, and it's not the kind of person I hire.
- yyeess 5y agohttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/pdf/wage-labour-capital.pdf https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/pdf/wag...
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI don't think the argument is that it's some separate sphere entirely disconnected from normal human interaction. It's like saying "the point of a movie night is to hang out and enjoy a movie together". If me and my friends were halfway through a movie, and I stood up and staged a loud political protest against something one of the characters said, my friends would be pretty rightfully unhappy with me.
- rStar 5y ago> my friends would be pretty rightfully unhappy with me. most people don’t go to work to recreate, so this is a bad example.
- jckahn 5y agoThat’s fair, but if a character in said movie was making brazenly anti-Semitic views (for instance) I think it would be reasonable to share that it made you uncomfortable and have a discussion about it at some reasonable time shortly thereafter.
- catgary 5y agoYeah, once I was watching the Ottoman Lieutenant with my wife and parents - I turned it off because the film seemed to be denying the Armenian genocide.
- caspper69 5y agoYou must be fun at parties. In my day, we had to constantly pick and choose our battles so we didn't come across as assholes. I guess going the opposite direction and airing every single tiny grievance to any person who will listen eliminates that minor inconvenience; everyone gets offended. But on the plus side you don't get offended anymore, and that's all that matters nowadays anyway.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoIf the person you’re responding to is Armenian Who lost family members to the genocide I don’t think a movie denying that is a minor inconvenience.
- caspper69 5y agoI would think any sane person on this Earth would have the decency not to show such a film in the presence of a person with the background you describe. More likely, this person was offended and had no vested interest, as is all to often the case.
- catgary 5y agoI’m sorry that I’m aware of the Armenian genocide and get weirded out when people act like it didn’t happen or was justified. Would you keep watching a movie that took the stance “slavery wasn’t so bad” or “well we can all agree Hitler took things overboard, but you know the Jewish people in Europe weren’t perfect neighbours”?
- catgary 5y agoI’m sorry I’m aware of Armenian genocide, and the genocide denial aspect of the film is well detailed in the movie’s Wikipedia page so it took all of ten minutes to confirm what was happening. To be fair, I think it helped that it is a pretty easy movie to leave halfway through. Nobody seemed to mind.
- wpietri 5y agoOh? What are the kinds of things in a movie that might make you do that? Let's suppose you're black and go over to a white friend's house for movie night. He puts on something super racist (say, Birth of a Nation, or a collection of blackface routines). You object, but all of his guests mock you for being "too sensitive" and "too political". You say, "I'm not sitting here for this," and leave. Were they rightfully unhappy with you? I would say no, that your friends are assholes. That you aren't obliged to silently endorse your own oppression. And I think it's the same thing at work. Would I want endless off-topic discussion at work? No. But some of what people denigrate as "too political" is entirely material to the workplace. Indeed, the Basecamp mess shows clearly that "no politics" rules are about suppressing discussion of things that are relevant, and are necessary because they are relevant.
- ramblerman 5y agoI agree with your sentiment that we are more than replacable robots. But I think for a long time 'a whole person' referred to your character, your hobbies, your family, your quirks. And politics was a small, and usually private part of that. We are in a time now where politics is tribal and has usurped a huge part of people's identities. To the point they see the other tribe as the devil merely by association. And I could see how that would cause conflicts in a business that are detrimental to the bottom line
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nick-of-time 5y agoPolitics is an expression of your moral values. It's always been an important part of a person.
- gryfft 5y agoPeople who huffily decry "politics" also tend to have political beliefs which they feel are apolitical. Examining and unpacking those beliefs is "political," however, so that the net result is "I just don't want my politics questioned or examined, even when it affects other people."
- collaborative 5y agoBelieve it or not there are plenty of people who live their lifes outside of politics. They don't vote, they don't have any favorites in the political arena Politics is divisive and agressive. Some people are put off by the easy narratives of good vs bad Only dictatorships have historically wanted to permeate every aspect of life with politics. The USSR used to say "everything is politics". There are plenty of examples... politics needs moderation. I wish that people could vent their passions with football like in the old days. At least everyone knew no one was "really serious" about why their team deserves world domination There is a time and place for politics (not at work). God knows how many times I've had to put on my earphones just to disappear from the latest office brawl about politics
- StanislavPetrov 5y ago>I think it's a giant mistake to see a workplace as a place where the entrepreneur is a tiny god-king. It isn't about being a god king, its about people being capable of collectively doing a task without saddling the execution of that task with all of their personal, political and emotional baggage. >If people want to play-act as robots, I won't deny them their kink. But that's not what interests me about work, and it's not the kind of person I hire. If people want to play-act as priests of some new secular religion, I won't deny them their kink. But that's not what interests me about work. What interests me about work is collecting a paycheck so that I can pay my bills and have the economic freedom to pursue my personal interests when I'm not at work. The idea that those with whom I work feel entitled (much less obligated) to police my personal interests (that are completely unrelated to my time on the job) is anathema to me. Those are not the kind of people I would hire, or work with.
- helmholtz 5y agoHow about when the grievance has to do with work itself? Something like James Damore. Or the inverse, someone bringing up a mysogynistic culture company-wide? What if the company implicitly looks down upon people with left/right leanings, depending on whether it's in Alabama or California? I agree with the general sentiment that going to the office, collecting your paycheck and going home is the smoothest ride for everyone, but honestly, beyond a certain size, I think it's unavoidable to have these kinds of frictions.
- pdimitar 5y agoWell, for many NOT being a sexist in a work setting is a common sense practice. Business owners of this stance will enforce it mercilessly and will still not think of themselves as having a certain political inclination. I suppose this circles back to the loose definition of "common decency".
- wpietri 5y agoGosh, you want to collect a fat paycheck and have freedom to do what you want in your off hours? That sounds very political. What are you doing bringing up politics in relation to work? And you might think I'm kidding. But those views would have made you a complete radical in 1867. By 1967 it wouldn't have been radical for a white man, but it was still radical for anybody non-white or non-male. By 2017, it was somewhat better for women and racial minorities, but in many places it was still radical to suggest that gay people should enjoy those rights. So "no politics at work" ends up being code for IMGFY. It's not a lack of politics. It is politics, just defending the status quo.
- cercatrova 5y agoIf I work somewhere, I am the tool that the founder uses to have wrought forth their vision. I accept that and do what must be done. Therefore, at the same time, if I create a company, it is mine to do with as I please, to command forth to fulfill my vision. I don't really understand the purpose of bringing "the whole person" if it doesn't matter to the work being done. It can not only be useless but actively harmful, as people get into tribalistic bouts without doing work.
- helmholtz 5y ago"Do as you please" isn't really true. You'll have local zoning laws to follow, taxes to pay, minimum wages to respect, health codes, fire safety codes and on and on. So already you're at the behest of regulations. Then, you're not employing tools or widgets. Tools are inanimate objects created by humans. Humans are thinking beings that have emotions. It's a fantasy to think you can abstract it away just because you pay them in some cotten/linen paper.
- pdimitar 5y agoBut it is fairly realistic to expect them to do their work without making political statements or refusing to work with others due to their political beliefs.
- wpietri 5y agoThis emperor-or-minion dichotomy is exactly what I'm objecting to. It's both morally repugnant and entirely false. Having started a few companies, I can promise you that it is not yours "to do with as I please, to command forth to fulfill my vision". What you'll actually be doing is desperately seeking to satisfy customers and pacify investors while working hard to keep good staff. Once you get a good business going, you'll have more of a margin to indulge any tastes you have for being a tinpot dictator. But that's always a personal indulgence that in the long term detracts from building the business. Look at WeWork as an example: that guy was absolutely in the "do with as I please, to command forth to fulfill my vision" mold. And how many billions has he lost?
- deepGem 5y agoI tend to agree to this viewpoint. Most of the impactful products are built by people who are inspired to build the product, sometimes even to the extent of hating the entrepreneur. For them work is almost a part of life.I don't mean that such people think of work all the time and don't have other interests in life, but largely what they are building is kind of ingrained into their life. It's really difficult to separate what they do from who they are. Almost every leader wants their team to exhibit these characters albeit on a spectrum. But what comes with that is the personality attributes, political viewpoints etc. It's hard to disagree on some fundamental traits and still continue to work together. At least in these teams which tend to get closely knit. This could potentially lead to homogenous teams which we don't want.We want teams to hash out diverse and conflicting ideas. Really hard balance to achieve.
- lazyeye 5y agoIs "the kind of person you hire" likely to share your politics? Because we are talking about workplaces where there is diversity of thought (if thats your kink)
- swiley 5y agoI'd totally agree if we were still required to be in the office. With WFH though you can actually more or less pick who you're spending those 8 hours with, in that case maybe keep the politics among the people you're physically around.
- koonsolo 5y agoDo you know the expression 'no politics or religion'? That is because you can't create a nice and fun environment where people start clashing over these topics. You can discuss personal things, make jokes with your colleagues, etc. I think that is a very healthy environment. An environment where people have strong opinions on politics an religion is never a nice environment. Never. So I think it's fair that in a work environment, we decide "hey, we don't what that shit here".
- darkerside 5y agoPeople with strong opinions can still talk about them and get along. See every time interfaith community leaders collaborate on a food drive, charity event, etc. The key is to remember that not everyone agrees with your strong opinion, or even cares about that, and that shouldn't make them any less important to you as a person. And yes, these environments exist, I've worked in them.
- DebtDeflation 5y ago>See every time interfaith community leaders collaborate on a food drive, charity event, etc. I'm guessing they tend to focus their discussions on the food drive, charity event, or other task at hand. Not whether Jesus is the messiah or whether Isaac or Ishmael is the rightful heir to Abraham.
- christophilus 5y agoMy favorite conversations are with those who disagree with me. Even better, if we’re smoking cigars around a campfire. My least favorite conversations are those that are regularly foisted upon me with no consideration of whether I even want to talk. Hint: at work, I want to write software, not listen to you talk (for the 50th time) about why you’re voting for Rick Santorum.
- moron4hire 5y ago> People with strong opinions can still talk about them and get along. While it is mathematically true that people can do this, the vast majority prove they choose not to nearly every single day. And once called out on it, it becomes another "tone policing" issue.
- slibhb 5y ago> If people want to play-act as robots, I won't deny them their kink. But that's not what interests me about work, and it's not the kind of person I hire. If you want to see how far some people have lost the plot, consider that this poster is boasting about only hiring people who agree with his politics. You can be damn sure he wouldn't hire a passionate Trump supporter.
- wpietri 5y agoThat is not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that I won't hire people who are excessively deferential to authority in a way that they suppress their individuality and their concerns about the society in which we work. Why? Because I think the work we do requires attention, care, and concern about the impacts of the work. I build software for actual people to use, and that requires caring about the actual people who use it. I build software in a collaborative, team-oriented context, and that requires caring about the actual people who are one's colleagues. Of course, there are people I won't hire for their politics. For example, racists and misogynists will not get hired. That's because we're making software for all sorts of people, and being hostile to those people is a dealbreaker. It's because I aim to hire all sorts of people, and being hostile or unwelcoming to colleagues will get them fired in a hearbeat.
- danmur 5y agoYou can have fun and socialise at work without devolving it into constant arguing. At my current job everyone's fairly mature and I think that even though there are lots of radical opinions it stays very congenial because people back off when it's unwelcome. I don't think there's anything to do with the bosses being gods, or people pretending to be robots. There are plenty of places where you can have heated discussions, it doesn't have to be at work. Additionally: my employer pays me to fulfill their requirements. That's what I'm there for. If I don't enjoy some aspect of the work (or if it's a shitshow of unrelated and unresolvable arguments that I can't opt out of) I'll leave, I'm free to do that.