15 ms·
The best result for customers is that there are alternate ways of putting apps on their own phones that do not require apple's permission. Then the customers t
by m463 5y ago
The best result for customers is that there are alternate ways of putting apps on their own phones that do not require apple's permission.
Then the customers that trust apple to protect them will just stay with the app store.
The customers that try the alternate ways may find problems, but they will also find enormous positive changes in their ability to do new things on their phone.
Personally, I would like the ability to see what apps - including apple apps - are doing, and firewall my phone.
- fartcannon 5y agoI'd like to use these unbelievably powerful portable computers like general purpose computers. Develop applications right on device! My dream.
- Angostura 5y agoYou can, there are plenty of development environments on iOS. What you can't do is distribute those apps. They are stick on your phone.
- saagarjha 5y agoThey also don’t make standalone apps.
- fooey 5y agoThe pretty obvious solution is to not buy Apple devices I have never owned an Apple device, but they clearly believe locking them down is part of the appeal of the devices in the first place. If you want an impartial platform get an android; if you want a curated ecosystem get an apple
- skohan 5y ago> but they clearly believe locking them down is part of the appeal of the devices in the first place. Do they believe that? Their behavior and stance could equally be explained by pursuing their economic best-interest
- kergonath 5y agoThey most definitely are. But they figured that aligning their interests with their users’ brings in quite a lot of money. Security and privacy certainly is part of the appeal of iOS devices, and strict sandboxing and app vetting is part of that. So is not having to leave your card details on the developer’s database every time you buy an app.
- fartcannon 5y agoYou can still have that even if it's open. There's literally nothing preventing them doing all that while letting others choose not to.
- kergonath 5y agoYou can’t, because no app can install other apps. So sandboxing would need to be significantly changed. Every big software publisher having its own store implies that our details will be stored in more databases, which increases the risk of hack or leak. The alternative would be to not get apps that we can currently get without risking much. It is hard to see this as a progress.
- EvanAnderson 5y agoGoogle did this right with developer mode on Chrome OS. Flip a physical interlock and your device becomes simultaneously "yours" and untrusted by Google. Apple could do the same thing. They won't because the reason for the walled garden is revenue. The user privacy and security gambit conveniently aligns with generating revenue.
- stale2002 5y ago> The pretty obvious solution is to not buy Apple devices But there are other solutions. The other solution is that people are allowed to do what they want, with phones that they own. And you don't have to download other app stores, if you don't want to!
- fartcannon 5y agoI think the better solution is to persuade them to open up their computing devices.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoThat does not sound desirable at all for anything other than basic toys..
- skohan 5y agoMaybe you feel that way because you've only ever had mobile devices which hamstring any possible developer tools
- baron816 5y agoIt should just be like on Mac—you can go through the App Store, or you can download directly, but with a warning. I think that would be killer argument for Epic—Apple already allows you to download apps onto their devices that don’t go through their store and everything is fine.
- voisin 5y agoThis argument was made and their response yesterday was that there is an unacceptable level of malware on macs because they are not locked down the same way.
- grishka 5y agoSo the subscription scams in the iOS app store are an acceptable level of malware. Got it.
- shagie 5y agoYou open up 'general', you go to 'subscriptions', and select that. Any subscription on the iPhone can be canceled right there. As this is done through Apple's payment processing, Apple/iPhone knows about every subscription and can cancel it easily. However, if the subscription is processed through a third party, then you may have more difficulty with canceling it... but it wasn't bought through the app on the phone. Additionally, by default, renewal receipts are sent for each subscription and are visible under the purchase history. If Epic wins and you've got subscriptions set up using payment processors other than Apple, this will make it harder to manage these subscriptions.
- grishka 5y agoIt also makes it harder to subscribe. You can accidentally tap the fingerprint scanner on the home button, and there were apps that made use of that, but you can't accidentally enter your credit card and then accidentally confirm the transaction with a 2fa code. The payment form alone is a huge deterrent IMO, even if it says "you won't be charged, free trial, cancel anytime".
- mason55 5y ago> Then the customers that trust apple to protect them will just stay with the app store. The problem is that if it’s possible to trick grandpa into downloading a malicious app then it will happen. The only defense is to not make it possible. You can argue if that’s a worthy goal or not but thats what Apple has to do if they want to make it impossible to trick people into downloading malware.
- wmf 5y agoApple definitely needs to keep working on the sandbox both for defense in depth and so that sideloaded apps (if the court forces it) can be secure enough.
- Turing_Machine 5y agoIt's possible to trick grandpa into sending money to Nigeria, too, but we don't use that as an excuse for forcing him to do business with a particular bank.
- kergonath 5y agoNobody sane would argue that our current approach to banking security is fine, though. There definitely is money to be made with more secure and convenient money transfer, as proved by the quite large number of start-ups in the field. Among these, quite a lot work only among users of the same app without anybody being outraged about it.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoStartups, Banking, Secure? Wirecard and Theranos called, they want their fraud back.
- toast0 5y agoThis need might be better handled by allowing delegation of approval to a trusted contact.
- trboyden 5y ago
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoThe best outcome for everybody is that the maximum % commission of these stores is regulated, perhaps to a maximum of 10-15%. Do that and the need for alternate stores, alternate payments etc. goes away.
- bitcurious 5y agoIf I want an alternate store, it’s not to safe ~$20/year in commission, it’s to gain access to functionality to which Apple restricts access.
- mrkramer 5y agoApp is not necessity good, you can not impose price controls for apps like you can for food for example.
- fooey 5y agoBasically every other comparable store charges the exact same 30% rate Google, Steam, Xbox, PlayStation, Nintendo The ones that don't just prove that charging a lower rate doesn't actually change the price the consumer pays in any way.
- ginko 5y agoThey should be forced to open up as well. The whole software platform business model needs to die.
- 5y ago
- manicdee 5y agoMost phone users aren’t interested in developing software on their phone. They aren’t interested in developing a better systemd. They have no idea what malware actually is. All that is going to happen if Epic gets their own store is Epic will be collecting the 30% rather than Apple, and the user will get apps that are poorly designed, chew battery, and don’t conform to the UX standards that Apple has set (eg: accessibility) and exploit undocumented APIs which change from iOS version to version. Epic will blame Apple for all these problems, Apple will blame Epic for not doing sufficient QC, and we’ll be back in court with various store managers demanding that Apple stop changing things. If you want third party stores, there’s the Android ecosystem. Keep your grubby mitts off the Apple ecosystem.
- benrbray 5y agoThe point is opening it up so users have a choice. Third party stores will emerge, and it is up to the consumer, not Apple, to decide whether the extra features are worth the new apps being a little rough around the edges like they are on Android. If it's as bad as you say, the new stores will not be successful anyway.
- threatofrain 5y agoWhy do users care about this choice? What are some top experiences available to Android which aren't available to iOS customers? In fact, isn't it often the other way around? iOS gets things and Android doesn't? Or are users seeing awful prices for the app store? Where are Customers complaining the most?
- skohan 5y agoWell I can imagine if 3rd party stores were allowed, I could have a Steam client on an iPad for example, and share my library of games without paying for it a second time for iOS.
- pindab0ter 5y agoBut there’s no Steam on Android either even though they do support third party app stores.
- rektide 5y ago> The best result for customers is that there are alternate ways of putting apps on their own phones that do not require apple's permission. Should Apple still be allowed to prevent Chrome from running it's own rendering, javascript, & other web platform engines? How much editorial & technical control are we going to let Apple keep, if we do allow alternate distribution mechanisms?
- chrisandchris 5y agoThat‘s a very different discussion (there were some HN about that few days ago). If Chrome will get full access to iOS, we are back to the year 2000 with 1 company deciding what the standards regarding Web are and a standardization organization having nothing to say. Not saying that I love the walled garden (not saying the opposite too), but if we love the web, we have to keep this walled garden.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoI would like to see "feature phones" return, not to replace, as a privacy-friendly alternative to, "smartphones", but this time with Lua instead of Java.
- danychok 5y agoI have never side loaded an app on my Android phone in the 6+ years I've had one. All I've ever heard is that it is risky to do so. I could *maybe* see doing it if the vendor were directly offering me their software - and I had some amount of trust of that vendor - like if Microsoft offered an app to directly install one my phone. But I've never heard of or encountered that. So I'm guessing it isn't a thing.
- igornadj 5y agoThe argument against an iPhone being a general purpose computer is that it first and foremost needs to be a phone, and do various other critical things. Imagine being stuck out in the middle of nowhere and your phone not working because of an app you installed from a non verified source messing things up.