4 ms·
Non fiber upload is a farce. I assume when they sell you more upload, they’re just placing you in a higher priority in the 30Mbps they have allocated for the w
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
Non fiber upload is a farce. I assume when they sell you more upload, they’re just placing you in a higher priority in the 30Mbps they have allocated for the whole neighborhood.
It is a hardware limitation as far as I know, so unless you see utility workers running new fiber, I would not expect much.
- katbyte 6y agoI have 1000/100 cable and my upload is consistently 110-120
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI have never seen a cable internet provider even advertise upload bandwidth, much less actually deliver it. They don’t even bother promising 2Mbps. Check Comcast/Spectrum/Cox/etc websites. I assume the only reason they do not is because that is how little upload capacity they have.
- cptskippy 6y agoI haven't had Comcast in a couple years but they did advertise upload speeds at one time and for the majority of the time (over 15 years) that I had them the speed was at or better than advertised. The last speed teir I had with them was 150/75 in 2019.
- adventured 6y agoRecently signed up with Comcast, they did promise an associated upload speed with the no frills Internet package I selected (200/5, $35/month) and listed it in the description when I chose it. I typically get 5-6 mbps up (although I rarely use it).
- katbyte 6y agoI don’t live in America? So maybe that’s why. I was advertised 1000/100 and I get that.
- zbrozek 6y agoMost cable providers allocate spectrum to prioritize download. Even the DOCSIS standard is built around that asymmetry. Much depends on the level of over-subscription in a neighborhood. In my old neighborhood, Comcast appeared to have a relatively low over-subscription ratio. My promised 1000/40 service pretty much always hit exactly that and I was a pretty happy camper. In my new neighborhood, the Comcast over-subscription ratio is far, far worse. My neighbors complain that realized speeds never approach promised speeds. And I was unable to get service at all (despite all of my neighbors on the same street having service). After a year of tooth-pulling, I got an F-U quote from Comcast at $210,000 to connect my house. So I banded together with neighbors in the community on a couple of adjacent un-served streets and we trenched and laid fiber. Now I have 10000/10000 service and it's awesome. Edit: I actually can't measure how close my service is to meeting the promise. I run out of CPU first. That's OK.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> So I banded together with neighbors in the community on a couple of adjacent un-served streets and we trenched and laid fiber. Now I have 10000/10000 service and it's awesome. That’s fantastic! One might even scale this community up to a few more blocks and call it a government. Too bad it’s such a bad word for many.
- nybble41 6y agoIt's not a government until you get the guns out and force people to join up and pay dues whether they want to or not. What zbrozek described is just a co-op, or something less formal along the same lines: an organization designed to provide benefits other than financial profit for its (voluntary) members, who are also its shareholders. Co-ops are great. I wish people would use them more often rather than clamoring for unnecessary government involvement.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoCo-ops are good for a farm. Or maybe in a rural area without lots of easements. Logistically, everyone will want fiber, and there’s no reason it cannot be dealt with like water/sewer/gas/electric. I do not see a volunteer based co op making progress in an urban area.