5 ms·
Wow. I could see companies excluding CO just due to the regulatory burden alone, even if they agree with the spirit of the law. I mean why create new HR proce
by refurb 6y ago
Wow. I could see companies excluding CO just due to the regulatory burden alone, even if they agree with the spirit of the law.
I mean why create new HR processes when you have 49 other states to hire from?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoMy curent company shares an email about open promotional opportunities every 6 months. I am continously amazon how on hackernews expecting basic decensy from corporates is a 'terrible burden'
- weird-eye-issue 6y agoIs 6 months enough? Can't spots get filled between that time?
- privacylawthrow 6y ago6 months is not compliant. Employees have to be made aware of the posting on the same calendar day the job is posted. For jobs that are in constant demand, the company has to either send a daily email or have some kind of banner on its corporate intranet. There is also no geographic restriction so if a company has any offshore service centers, it would need to post any promotional jobs to its Colorado employees as well.
- inter_netuser 6y agoAmazing, they have to notify about jobs in Thailand to Colorado employees? Love it.
- rswail 6y agoWe're talking about a spreadsheet that is posted to an intranet. If someone in Colorado wants to apply for a Thailand based job and is willing to relocate for the position, then why shouldn't they know about it. Of course, Thai employers can still discriminate on the basis of gender, sex, religion and a bunch of other things that Colorado employers can't. And any company operating in Thailand has a local Thai company established, which would be the actual employer for the local employees. So the Colorado law would not apply.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoWhy not? When I worked at BT they did - a nice one or two year posting abroad on full ride expat status looks good on the CV.
- inter_netuser 6y agoBT has operations in Thailand?
- Mauricebranagh 5y agoAll over the world, this was in Kuala Lumpur I did some rereading up on the country and decided to pass, I would have had to cut my hair short for one. One of my co-workers did this but his asthma could not stand the humidity and he had to come back.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoOur promotions happen every 6 months, so position appear and are filled on that cycle. There is also an internal jobs portal where you can search whatever you want
- fennecfoxen 6y agoExcuse me. You're not expecting, quote, "basic decency." You are expecting compliance with a specific regulatory framework. One of these requires a soul, the other requires lawyers and paperwork and record-keeping.
- lmm 6y agoSince companies lack souls, the only way to get them to behave with decency is lawyers and paperwork and record-keeping.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe is nothing profitable a corporate bureaucracy won't do out of 'basic decency' Before we had 'spesific regulatory framework' companies enslaved people, exploited children, commercialised rape and commited serial murder to break up unions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain
- fennecfoxen 6y agoI am having trouble reconciling your assertions, in which you seem to think HN should expect "basic decency" from corporations while simultaneously asserting that "'basic decency'" has never actually served as a meaningful barrier. It seems to me that the later statement rather undermines the original. Maybe "basic decency" is a very bad phrase to describe things here, and we should just leave it out. It's probably useful as invective, and if one is already predisposed to sympathize with the point, can galvanize one to action, but it serves poorly as a tool to actually communicate. I propose that if we avoid it, we can talk meaningfully about how the company finds it more convenient to avoid business than comply with regulatory burdens without the distraction of moralizing the matter, and draw conclusions about whether the passage of the law was wise under these particular circumstances, or what circumstances or structure might have made it better, and the like. Perhaps your vintage-1921 blue-collar labor dispute is more of a distraction than a help, as well :)
- SkyBelow 6y agoBy that view, does anyone expect "basic decency"? For example, I could say that I expect "basic decency" to not kill each other. But I also support having a law making murder illegal. As part of that law, you have the possibility of people being jailed, possible for months are years, before we even get to a court case. They may be able to pay a large fee to get back to their daily life (while part of the money is sometimes returned, there are plenty exceptions to this). Then you get to the court case, where people are expected to spend days in courts and small fortunes on lawyers to prove they didn't murder someone. Lots and lots of lawyers and paperwork and record-keeping, not to mention the costs to an innocent individual wrongly accused. Good luck getting any payments to make up the debt you incurred. Yet as a society we accept that we have to do things the legal way because just the expectation alone does nothing to stop bad people. As such the concept of "basic decency" is completely gone from the modern world, so I think it is safe to give it a new definition which includes the enforcement of a legal framework.
- syshum 6y agoI am amazed that people do not understand that difference between Voluntary Action and Mandatory / Regulatory Burden. A Company could 100% already being doing everything to be in compliance with a regulation and still oppose the regulation, and take actions to ensure they are bound by that regulation
- ethbr0 6y agoGranted. But which of the following happens more often? A) Companies oppose regulation because of filing and compliance costs, despite already doing the required behavior B) Companies oppose regulation because they don't want to have a requirement to do and maintain the behavior It feels like really we're talking about (B) as a primary motivator, and (A) is a smoke screen for PR palatability.
- bluGill 6y agoDon't forget about C: companies that propose regulations because they know they can handle them and competitors cannot. Big companies will have no problem with these regulations. However small and medium sized companies need a bunch more busy work that needs to be done and so will avoid it. This last is hard to measure - regulations have a cost in this form but it is hard to figure out what would have been done but isn't.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoOnly as long as Colorado is the only state with this law. If California or New York adopts it, employers will probably just accept it nationwide.
- Finnucane 6y ago"This offer only valid in the former Confederate states, where they know how to treat labor."
- bluGill 6y agoThough it does seem like the promotion opportunity is one that any sane company will want to have anyway. It takes some time to learn the companies internal systems, and promoting from within saves a lot of that time.
- psychometry 6y agoApparently now it's a "burden" to do the ethical thing because one state requires it even though you should be doing it anyway.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]