7 ms·
Isotope study hints ancient Greeks used foreign fighters in key battle
- variable11 6y ago"Ancient Greeks" spans a ton of history, multiple centuries. Military and political structures change over time. Over-hyped headline.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoGiven the colonialism of Greece, couldn't they have been Greek mercenaries? The Herodotus source linked just says the Greeks in Sicily fought, not the Greeks of Sicily.
- alchemism 6y agoScythian archers were paid to guard the walls of Athens, so there was a clear understanding in doing business with barbarians (which is their word).
- mc32 6y agoWeren’t Scythians also Greek? Or rather Greeks came from one of the Scythian tribes? Or am I mistaken in my recollection?
- Bayart 6y agoThose we call Scythians now are a group of Eastern Iranian horse-ridding people living on the Eurasian Steppe between modern Romania and Kazakhstan. What Greeks called Scythians was anybody riding a horse and living a bit North. Starting from Late Antiquity they've been completely pushed out of the steppe, at least culturally, by nomads that came from further East (Turkic peoples). The last Eastern Iranian group living North of the Caucasus is the Ossetians.
- w0de0 5y agoIn as much as they probably shared deep ancestors in the Yamnaya culture, haha. But no, that’s not the origin of the Greeks. You’re probably thinking of the Scythian-Greek syncretism that occurred in Greek Crimean colonies during a the Hellenistic (post Alexander) and early Roman periods.
- Bayart 6y agoGreek colonies employed mercenaries rather than the other way around. But Greek mercenaries were quite popular in Greece proper (between city-states) and around it. Egyptians and Persians used them extensively. One of the famous stories of the ancient world (you can find it in the Anabasis) is that of the Ten Thousand : an army of Greek soldiers left stranded in Persian territory after their Persian employer, Cyrus the Younger, died in battle.
- w0de0 5y agoThe context of the Anabasis, it always seemed to me, was that Greek hoplites had just finished whooping a massive Persian invasion - and the whole near east took notice of such highly effective heavy infantry.
- arseniyandru 6y agoI wonder why does he think it is a popular lore
- boomboomsubban 6y ago300 presumably, one of the battles the corpses were from supposedly happened the same day as the Battle of Thermopylae. If Herodotus was wrong about this battle, his records of Thermopylae become more suspect. Kinda silly though, as "popular lore" already ignores the thousands of other Greeks at the battle, as well as the also concurrent Battle of Artemisium.
- edgyquant 6y agoDoes anyone take Herodotus as factual? He’s widely known as the father of lying in historical circles and is expected to play up a Romantic view of Greece.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoPopular lore arguably does. Also, was the capitalization of "romantic" a mistake? I've never heard Herodotus described as overly pro-Rome.
- edgyquant 5y agoYes it was a mistake
- watwut 6y agoYes they do. I have also heard claim on podcast that 300 movie is acutely historically accurate and argument was that it fits Herodus.
- dingoegret 6y agoHerodotus is not well regarded due to.. well constantly lying. His accounts are basically classical tabloid news.
- englishrookie 6y agoThis is so true! I was waiting in the checkout line in the supermarket, and people all around me were discussing how the ancient Greek armies were composed entirely of male Greek citizens. Popular lore can be so wrong! ;-)
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI have been whooshed so hard. Never in my entire life have I heard or even dreamed of people in supermarket discussing things like that. I think it is time to start a new trend. Next time I am out grocering, I will be sure to mention that Carthage must perish ( and how Rome fell, because of communism -- gotta lure people in somehow )!
- Judgmentality 6y agoMake a YouTube video.
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoWhat. I thought it was pretty well known that Greece used lots of non "Greek" soldiers and mercenaries. Same with Rome. Is this really a non-mainstream idea?
- kodah 6y agoI don't think it's non-mainstream. It was taught to me in school that the downfall of the Greeks was outsourcing their army to mercenaries and I've heard it again and again in reference to Spartan lore.
- slibhb 6y agoIt's well known among scholars but I think the title here is aimed at popular culture. Hoplites (shield, spear, helmet, greeves) were rich citizens which is how they could afford their armor. Many of the men who fought in the Classical era were slaves or foreigners or teenagers, often from Macedonia, called peltasts or psiloi.
- Cybotron5000 6y ago…and Carthage famously, no?
- tgv 6y ago> She adds, “The Greeks were obsessed with being Greeks,” considering all those who didn’t speak the language “barbarians.” But "barbarian" meant something like "speaking another language".
- dylanwisor 6y agoIt’s a tricky sentence to parse, but I think the divide between those who spoke Greek and those who didn’t was what she intended to communicate, not that they affixed the modern connotations of the word “barbarian” to non-Greek speakers.
- tgv 6y agoI'm pretty sure that was the intention conveyed there, but I'll be damned if I can find the quote. It seems to have disappeared from the page.
- coldtea 6y agoYes, a modern close to the spirit of the original translation would be "blah-blah-rian", "yak-yak-rian" or "indicipherable-rian". They however had no ideas about the inferiority of those (except that they preferred their own lifestyles which considered free-er). Ancient slavery also was not about race, but about e.g. losing the battle and being caught or debt. Greeks could be (and often were) slaves to other Greeks.
- cryptonector 6y ago"barbarian" == "people who say bar bar bar bar bar" == "people who speak gibberish" "barbarbar" ~ "blahblahblah"
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> "barbarbar" ~ "blahblahblah" I don't think this is right. "Blah blah" implies someone who is overly talkative. "bar bar" [1] is an onomatopoieia of someone speaking a non-Greek language, like "arf arf" is for a dog. I'm not even sure it has the meaning of "speaking gibberish" that you give it. I think it was literally just the way that some ancient language that was not Greek sounded to Greek ears. A bit like with the Swedish chef in Muppet show. _________ [1] Actually, "var var". In Greek it's "βάρβαρος", pronounced "varvaros".
- bpodgursky 6y agoMaybe I am missing something, but the study I'm looking at just looks at mass graves after a Carthaginian attack, so they could very easily have been Carthaginian mercenaries? Which would not be surprising at all; Carthage was a nautical trading state which is known to have used mercenaries extensively.
- duxup 6y agoThe Greeks were known for having lots of colonies / communities across the Mediterranean: "like frogs around a pond" -Plato Presumably this required some skillful diplomacy, alliances, and the ability to call for help when / if it was needed. Mercenaries seem like a logical tool in that case.
- B1FF_PSUVM 6y ago> some skillful diplomacy I think you're projecting modern population density into pre-classical times. Colonies were just a bunch of people from one place that decided to grab some available land somewhere else.
- duxup 6y agoI don't know what you mean. You're going to have to trade with others and get along with your neighbors regardless.
- w0de0 5y agoI believe you’re projecting your modern assumptions about how the world worked in “savage” antiquity. The Peloponesian War began with a dispute with Athens over the government of Corinth’s ancient (at least 400 years at this point) Adriatic colony of Cocyra. There is today in the museum of the Acropolis a stele recording a treaty between Cocyra and Athens agreed during this crisis. Corinth maintained mother-city ties - and disputed Athen’s influence. Later in the same war, the Athenians launched an ambitious invasion of Sciliy, pursuing empire against their enemy Sparta’s ally Syracuse (and other cities of Magna Grecia). After the war, a multinational Greek force famously marched all the way to Mesopotamia as mercenaries (and only a few generations later Alexander would come the same way). Those mercenaries were saved when the returned to the very edge of the Greek sphere at Trebizond (Thallata! Thallata!). From there they were plugged back in to a network of communication, commerce and diplomacy that stretched all the way down the Mediterranean to Marsielle (the colony of Marsala). This diplomacy and internationalism of the Classical Greek Mediterranean was a change from the dark ages of the Bronze Age collapse, where a colony may indeed be another world. But before that there was another cosmopolitan period of treaties and internationalism (of a sort). We associate that period with the relations between Mesopotamian states (Akkad etc), Mediterranean states (Egypt, Knossos, Acheans) and Anatolian states (Hitties, Hurrians, etc). Complex diplomacy between these states is recorded in cuneiform clay.
- coldtea 6y ago>But did warfare really play out that way? Teeth found in fifth-century B.C. mass graves in Sicily suggest otherwise Teeth found in one city (out of the major cities of mainland ancient Greece, Sicily's was more recent-ish colonies) is not exactly proof of widespread mercenary use "against popular lore" (which includes existing history and centuries of scholarship). (They did use Scythes for something like guards/cops in Athens, and ocassionally made use of others, but nothing major).
- w0de0 5y ago“Sicily” was not a a Greek colony, the many Greek cities on the island were. Some of them are very much more ancient than you think - older than the Persian wars, and existing longer than our reliable record of classical Greece exists. The first wave of colonization, in the ~8th century BC, included Syracuse and Himera - about 300 years before the battle discussed in this paper. Syracuse had been part of a pan-Mediterranean Greek culture for longer than the US has so far existed when its tyrant raised a multinational force to defend Himera.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beloch 6y agoThe paper compares two battles in the same area, one (480 BCE) in which historical accounts say a Greek colony was defended by a coalition of Greek allies, and another, later battle (408 BCE), in which it stood alone and was defeated. They establish a baseline of what they expect local strontium isotope composition should be both from local flora and fauna samples and from burials not associated with the battle. They then compare this to the greek combatants of these two battles. They find that 67% of Greek soldiers from 480 BCE are likely non-local, while 36% of Greek soldiers from 408 BC were non-local. Up to this point, the paper supports historical sources and seems to be quite well done. After this point, they speculate that the non-local individuals present were mercenaries based solely on the strontium isotope ratios in their tooth enamel, and further speculate on where specific individuals might have originated. This is where the authors might be going out on a limb. Greek colonies were widespread at this point in history, and it's very likely that some "mercenaries" were just from distant colonies. This doesn't seem to be adequately addressed in the paper. It's also possible that soldiers ate a different diet than the locals, possibly higher in fish or imported foods, which could have made them appear non-local. It's also possible soldiers moved around more, and that might have affected their levels in difficult to predict ways. Bottom line, strontium isotope analysis is great at the population level, but there's a lot that can go wrong when dealing with individuals. I find the notion that Greek's hired mercenaries plausible, but this paper doesn't provide strong evidence for it.
- estaseuropano 6y agoThanks for spelling this out, i know nothing about the topic but felt too there was a stretch between biology and social/political guesses. What i was wondering: Does the strontium ratio in teeth change over the course of your life or is it determined by where you grew up/your teeth developed?
- jhgb 6y ago> they speculate that the non-local individuals present were mercenaries From the infamous Mauro Nero company?
- deleted 6y ago
- keiferski 6y agoI was not intending to go beyond Italian and recent examples, but I am unwilling to leave out Hiero, the Syracusan, he being one of those I have named above. This man, as I have said, made head of the army by the Syracusans, soon found out that a mercenary soldiery, constituted like our Italian condottieri, was of no use; and it appearing to him that he could neither keep them nor let them go, he had them all cut to pieces, and afterwards made war with his own forces and not with aliens. - Machiavelli, The Prince, on Hiero II of Syracuse (308 - 215 BC)
- lr4444lr 6y agoNo mention of slaves, which were internationally trafficked? Just because these people were put into mass graves doesn't mean they had core combat roles purportedly reserved for local citizens.
- dang 6y agoUrl changed from https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/contrary-popular-lore-ancient-greek-armies-relied-foreign-mercenaries-180977752/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/contrary-popular-l..., which points to this. Also, the original article title ("Contrary to popular lore, ancient Greek armies relied on foreign mercenaries") seems to have had linkbait powers, resulting in some reflexive objections in the comments here. Keep that in mind as you read them.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoDidn't Romans always deploy recruits from one conquest to another territory? To keep them from favoring certain locals or some such. Perhaps the Greeks did a similar thing.