10 ms·
Now your car is a cybersecurity risk, too
- corty 5y agoIs there a good list of things that I as a customer can do to mitigate the risks? E.g. pulling various SIM cards, not ordering feature X, avoiding producer Y? Of course one could always drive a historic car... ;)
- sandebert 5y agoI suppose a "historic car" should be called "feature car", the same way as old-school mobiles are called "feature phones".
- sgt 5y agoThat's funny! So, I would argue that "feature cars" are amazing value right now. Even early 2000s or early 2010s are exceptionally reliable (unless you buy a 7-series E65 BMW or some nonsense) and cost almost nothing to run. Much more sensible than paying $80k for a new Tesla, even though it's clearly better and a shiny new toy.
- bombela 5y ago* unless you buy a 7-series E65 BMW or some nonsense But they drive so smooth...
- Pasorrijer 5y ago* When they drive
- sgt 5y agoAsk Hoovie https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdXfFEt21aQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdXfFEt21aQ
- maccard 5y ago> Much more sensible than paying $80k for a new Tesla, even though it's clearly better and a shiny new toy. There's a huge middle ground between a 10 year old civic and an 80k tesla.
- sgt 5y agoI sort of agree - yes, there's a big middle ground in terms of luxury, but in terms of the main reason for having a car, they do exactly the same. They take you from A to B in relative comfort.
- maxerickson 5y agoAn 8-year old Accord?
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoI don’t know where is a good article with a comprehensive list of all the things you can avoid, also cause if you don’t use all of the features of a new car, I suggest you to buy a mid ’90 car. Some services rely on the internal e-sim of the car, so you can’t disable at all it. I think the most secure thing to do is don’t use an old keyless entry key fob, or don’t leave your car near the key or leave the key inside something that can shield the key signal: https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/technology/how-to-protect-your-car-from-keyless-entry-hacking.html https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/technology/how-to-protect-y...
- SyzygistSix 5y agoUnfortunately the modern feature people are most likely to use is the crash protection and life saving features of modern cars when in a crash. I don't like modern electronics in cars but the safety features make buying a modern car compelling.
- UweSchmidt 5y agoAbsolutely. When my next car is due, I'll try to find the "last good year" of low-enough tech cars (kinda similar to the last-good year for Macbooks that used to be ~2015) that do the job without half-baked cognitive load increasing features. After that the mess is hopefully sorted out and we'll have rented electric cars - the operating company will should sufficient incentives to provide a robust and safe experience for their customers.
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agothe Land Rover Defender (or old V8 Toyota) might be an option. Been driving Defender this since 2006, and I will never sell it. The car literally hasn't changed its optics since the 80ies and a few dents only give it more "character". I got sick of being ripped off in the garage (and that car is known to never be free of flaws but never is fully broken either - classic British engineering:)) ... I downloaded all explosion charts from RU websites and the parts catalog can be found in popular LR forums for OEM or the much cheaper wholesale parts (10-20x less the price in some cases). It's a learning curve but instead of spending money on in garage (and get ripped off) over the years I invested it in tools and try to repair anything myself. Sometimes I'm back on the road within 24 hours sometimes it takes me a month. Meanwhile I made friends driving similar cars who can help out. Not an option for everybody (space & patience), but I know my car now better than most mechanics. It turned me into a massive engine nerd too and I also got all the diagnostic tools to look at and clear error codes over the OBD-II. If a large 4x4 isn't your cup of tee then a Lotus Elise can result in similar fun. My latest project is a Caterham which I'm building from scratch and hope to have it on the road later this summer (https://www.caterhamcars.com/it https://www.caterhamcars.com/it) Anything battery powered or electric for me would never be an option. People say it's "not so green" but my opinion differs. I think getting the latest model of X every 2-3 years is far more toxic to the environment.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI'm passionate about Defenders (I've commanded a squadron of them) but even I'm not massively thrilled about driving one these days - they didn't even have air bags or any kind of collapsable steering column until 2020.
- DyslexicAtheist 5y agoyes true. I think that the Defender's low number of driver casualties might be due to the type of people who drive them (conservatively). Unlikely that somebody wants to race in that car. My previous cars were BMW's and these things turned me into a reckless douche the minute I sat behind the steering. The saying is Defenders "don't go fast but they can go everywhere". I changed my driving habit and attitude on the road considerably (I started taking the scenic routes and learned to enjoy the ride, with an unusually high sitting position, wave at other defender drivers if I see them, and could fit all friends of my kids inside). AFAIK the pedestrian safety rating for them is why older models (after the Ford/Puma engine) was abysmal and they discontinued. If you hit a pedestrian or cyclist that's probably it. That has always been my main worry. But I think the safety for the driver/passenger is pretty good when using common sense and when not driving them like the stig. I hit a wild pig once in a forest in France and it was splattered across the front but not so much as a dent in the car. They also come with roll-over cages on the US market which tells something about what can go wrong if you lose control. Never got one since I don't drive rallys. Still their handling (directness of the steering) is much better than a Wrangler (where the steering is horribly "spongy").
- WalterBright 5y agoPut your car in a Faraday Cage.
- nix0n 5y agoI've got a 2009 Toyota and when I upgraded the stereo to add Bluetooth, I just didn't connect the wire from the head unit to the CAN bus. (The installation kit from Crutchfield included the pinout.) On a newer car, I'd probably install a toggle switch for that wire. (I'd love to hear from anyone who's actually tried that.) Edit: Also, I always open the door with the physical key, and I don't even carry the button.
- bruce343434 5y ago> but there is a long road ahead to get every ECU in the car protected against increasingly cyberattacks Increasingly _what_ cyberattacks? Frequent?
- Hamuko 5y agoMaybe they forgot a space - "increasingly cyber attacks".
- corty 5y agoI'd guess frequent and devastating. There is potential for both. For frequency, more cars with more problems means more attack surface, and the longer on the market and more widespread they are the more exposure wannabe attackers get to them. For devastation, in-car firewalls between different systems and buses have been proven ineffective, so remote steering is possible. And some cars even provide remote steering as a feature, like automatic parking. So for an attacker, it is possible to create a lot of property damage and even kill people, so there is the huge potential of ransom and general havoc. For a harmless and maybe easy example, just imagine all cars by a popular manufacturer suddenly deciding to engage the automatic unparking, the stopping and locking down and blocking all the parking lots in the process. For a less harmless and hopefully more difficult one, imagine all those cars suddenly steering hard left when over 80km/h.
- StavrosK 5y agoIncreasingly cyber attacks. They're getting more and more cyber.
- tails4e 5y agoAirgapping critical functions needs to be a thing. Infotainment that's online should be no where near driving, safety or engine management functions. If those fictions require an OTA update, then it could be done by enabing a physical switch temporarily so firmware can be downloaded.
- corty 5y agoProblem is, current trend is integration. Infotainment touchscreen now controls increasingly more of the important functions, so airgapping is no longer an option.
- smolder 5y agoIt's like we need a Ralph Nader book to inspire automobile regulation around putting stupid electronics in them. Some better design could come of it. Unfortunately connected cars aren't going away. There's future automatic driving and the surveillance state both demanding real time location tracking.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoI imagine that the first time many customers flipped that switch on, would be the last time it was off.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoIt would still be an improvement. In situation like you speak of people's cars would be as insecure as they were without the switch but at least the capability is there for those who want it or learn to be security conscious.
- Arrath 5y agoOne-way solenoid. Once the update completes, the car clicks the switch back off.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoI guess they could add an annoying beep every 5 minutes to make sure the switch is switched off if it doesn't need to be on. Or have a function that the engine can't start if the switch is on (because during an update the engine should be off, although obviously the onboard computers need to be on).
- froh 5y agoI hope the automotive vendors will embrace the security maintendance experience of the likes of suse, redhat, canonicalfor their Linux based performance ECUs. I sense however the yocto style patch everything and tweak it to my likings embedded chaos will reign for a while. the reluctance of the arm ecosystem to mainline their BSPs doesn't help. but how do you explain the value add of a built once used and validated everywhere binary? and a standardized security architecture and frozen version maintenance? to yocto embedded folks?
- varjag 5y agoPackage management systems are available in Yocto as well. Nobody uses those because running package based updates on headless, operator-inaccessible, embedded devices is corporate suicide. Full image update is a better engineering practice, that's why it is done this way.
- froh 5y agothat's deployment. yocto only has half baked support for a binary layers, let alone binary sdk layers, where you add more packages, for the target or the build host, and more layers come further down. this is for you to use the binary packages to build your images. which you then deploy, as you suggest. key thing: you use suse/ubuntu/redhat binary packages to build and create your add-ons which you then deploy, as image-on-the-fly (created on target during traditional Linux install/update), or as precooked image (qemu, container or, new: embedded flash image)
- varjag 5y agoWhy on Earth would you use a third party binary package when the true upstream source is available?
- qwerty456127 5y ago> the multiple potential in-car and remote access points such as OBDII, USB and SD ports, keyless entry, Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, embedded modem, sensors, infotainment or smartphone apps and the multiple connections via telematics and other cloud systems that access car systems. I want a car without all these. I don't mind OBDII but all the rest has no real reason to be there let alone be integrated with the car itself.
- a-dub 5y agowill be interesting when the first lawsuits appear over nonfunctioning, yet perfectly functional heavy equipment that ceases function because it can't phone home or the software/associated support/backend infra/service/security patches are eol'd. maybe we can crush the still totally usable cars, paint them white and use them as filler for the melted ice caps?
- hrktb 5y agoIs the car that last bastion that will make the masses rise in anger, when every single part of our lifes are already touching that spot ? I recently discovered the motorcycle airbag monthly subscriptions. I kind of see it as sign.
- jiofih 5y ago> other cloud systems that access car systems Is that a thing besides Tesla?
- stefanfisk 5y agoThis is a thing at least https://driving.ca/bmw/auto-news/news/bmw-to-make-owners-pay-for-features-like-heated-seats-via-subscription https://driving.ca/bmw/auto-news/news/bmw-to-make-owners-pay...
- saberdancer 5y agoYes. Some cars offer web app that you can access to see some details about the car, such as fuel usage, location, set warnings for speed or leaving a certain location. In some cases you can even unlock or start your AC remotely.
- smolder 5y agoNot mine, because I'm not willing to be part of the cohort of people who find out how bad of a problem insecure tech in connected cars can be for us. We are going to make mistakes before people learn, and I'll be driving an older unconnected car.
- chrisseaton 5y agoThe biggest threat to you in your car is a crash, and driving an older car from an era with lower crash standards is a far bigger risk than connectivity.
- smolder 5y agoThat's fine, I know how to drive and maintain vehicles. Crash safety has been pretty great since the 00s, especially if you shop for it.
- kylegordon 5y ago> I know how to drive and maintain vehicles Do others? You are but one in the massive herd Disclaimer: My daily is from 1981
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I know how to drive Everyone thinks that they 'know how to drive'. Even if you do, the point is other people may not know how to drive and may crash into you.
- skeeks 5y agoYou're not the only one driving on the streets and often, other drivers are the greater danger.
- avereveard 5y agoabout half the crashes are single vehicle accidents, and pileup drive the statistic for multicrash vehicle count, it's quite less likely being collected by a bad driver than flat stat would imply.
- ano88888 5y agoSomeone should start an electric car company with minimum software and no internet connection or remote control
- WJW 5y agoBe the change you want to see.
- JI00912 5y agoAlmost every major change is made by convincing others to act because there is only so much one person can do. The probability that ano88888 is positioned in such a way as to start a car company is pretty close to zip.
- WJW 5y agoMeh. The pen is only mightier than the sword when there are few writers among many doers. In this age of social media and microblogging, the pendulum has swung the other way and those who act stand out from the sea of voices passively demanding "change".
- gpm 5y agoThe mighty weapon is still the pen, it might is just dependent on how you apply it. Tesla doesn't exist because Elon et al. went into his backyard and made a car, it exists because Elon et al. convinced a bunch of other people to cooperate on making a car. Same with Jeff Bezos et al., and Amazon. Steve Jobs et al. and Apple. Bill Gates et al. and Microsoft. Just posting on social media doesn't make your pen mighty, reaching out to people and convincing them to work on something does. On the other hand, social media is not a terrible place to "test" ideas to try and get an idea whether or not you'll be able to rally people to the task at hand.
- Joker_vD 5y ago> it exists because Elon et al. convinced a bunch of other people to cooperate on making a car. Surely you meant to write "Martin and Marc", not "Elon".
- ulzeraj 5y agoImagine getting your car being affected by ransomware while on the road with your family.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoOr the government using their 0-day to stop you because reasons.
- nexuist 5y agoIsn't that just called getting pulled over?
- cryptos 5y agoI expect to see more mysterious, deadly car crashes of oppononents of some regimes ...
- brewdad 5y agoSaves the trouble of having to follow your target down a deserted road with your high beams on trying to run them off the road.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoI have an older car that missed Carplay by one year. I want to replace the rather crappy dashboard screen with poor touch sensitivity with a nice new carPlay dashboard so i can navigate and listen to my podcasts. Last time I asked it was 1500 quid plus install from the dealer. I could probably get under a grand now. If there existed a car with no entertainment system at all, and I just stuck a specially adjusted tablet in there, with industry standard connectors, everyone would be happy, and if anyone hacked my entertainment system they would not be close to the important stuff Cars should be the mobile equivalent of a dumb TV screen. But no-one wants to make them.
- sen 5y agoAlmost any car that doesn’t have CarPlay/etc can have the standard entertainment stuff stripped out and a CarPlay head unit put in using a double-din dash conversion. Costs about $4-500 for the head unit and $1-200 for the dash conversion depending on your car. I’ve done it on both my and my wife’s cars. They now have standalone CarPlay units for music and maps and calls, yet zero integration into the car itself and it’s perfect.
- antattack 5y agoWould you recommend the unit you have?
- sen 5y agoDefinitely. I’ve got 2 different Pioneer units (DMH-W4660NEX and another I forget atm) and I’d basically recommend any of theirs. Just get the best one you can afford from their series. Even the cheaper ones are decent but obviously get even better the more you spend. I wasn’t a fan of the JVC one we had previously though. Not very responsive and the lag made it annoying to use. The Pioneers are fast and pretty much perfect in comparison. For most common cars you can also use the steering controls adapter kit which lets all your factory steering wheel controls for volume and answering/making calls.
- rograndom 5y ago
- WalterBright 5y ago> Over-the-air software updates There's the fundamental problem right there. Over the air software updates means malware can always be installed. One day, security engineers may remember (or reinvent) critical technology from the 1970s. This was when, to write to the ROMs, there was a physical electrical switch called "write enable". Now, if the car's embedded systems have a physical write-enable switch, then malware won't survive a reboot. Next, have the system reboot every time the car is started.
- sneak 5y agoI have a preorder in for a cybertruck. I will not be accepting delivery if I cannot be assured that it is built without wireless WAN. An automobile is the last thing on Earth I want suddenly working differently on Tuesday than it did on Monday. Actually, scratch that: a plane is the last thing. An automobile is the second to last (because I'm not an amputee with a prosthesis).
- WalterBright 5y agoThere needs to be a physical "OFF" switch for the wireless connectivity, too.
- sneak 5y agoI want it without a radio transceiver of any kind: permanent "off". It's possible I could compromise on wi-fi or bluetooth, because those need to be paired to communicate. Hard no to cellular of any kind, if for no other reason than it means that the car's location is being continuously tracked and logged for all time by the carriers and national military.
- chopin 5y agoFor the EU that ship has sailed as there is a mandatory automatic emergency call capability for every new car. I hate it for the fact alone that it enables location tracking via cellular connectivity as I assume that the SIM is connected all the time.
- aschatten 5y ago> The automotive industry started taking cybersecurity seriously about six years ago and started investing in designing and deploying cybersecurity solutions. This might have been the report that made them pay attention: https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/ https://www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-hig...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kkwteh 5y agoTaps head meme: Your car can’t be a cyber security risk if you don’t own a car.
- switch007 5y agoYour security is a risk greedy companies are willing to take ! Which of the features which are a cause for concern aren't: a) used inflate prices b) used to gather/sell data to make more profit c) to save costs ? (I know some things like rear cameras are legally mandated in some places) Some of the cost savings are directly impacting safety and it needs to stop. For example, hiding often-used things behind menus. It needs to be called out as the greed it is.
- FlyingSnake 5y agoI purchased a VW e-up! and one of the main criteria was the absence of any fancy touch panel and related gimmicks. The lack of distraction is a God send.
- nullifidian 5y agoI would buy any new car (with high safety ratings) that has "completely power off all modems" option.
- alberth 5y agoAre we at the point where we’ll need something like Cloudflare fronting our automobiles to prevent someone from DDoS our cars while driving.
- variable11 5y agoUsless electronics in things that work fine without them is stupid, not just on a green level, but on a civilizational level.
- LinuxBender 5y agoPlease forgive me I am not a car ECM engineer, but the approach to this I would take would be to have dual controllers and a staging sandbox on its own board. I assume perhaps incorrectly that the updates are already signed. The update process must validate against multiple consensus servers hosted in multiple regions and those servers must be validated constantly by Tesla and their operations team. I would have the car give the owner options for update frequency and options require things like "wait until car is being charged". I would also give the car owner options to manually apply available updates after validating a code against the manufactures website. The website should list all the firmware updates, fixes, checksums, etc... The owner should have the ability to roll back an update at least one revision. If the update fails the secondary controller should become active similar to how some computer motherboards have the option to store an active and rollback BIOS. It should be designed impossible to put the controller into update mode unless the car is powered down and on the charging system and the batteries are at some charge percentage and meet other safety requirements. These options should allow updates to occur when the person is not planning on using the vehicle, such as going to bed. Is this already the case? This is just my preference personally, I would require a physical switch that powers down all transceivers. This will be a requirement for me on all modern cars for ODB3 regardless. I also want the ability to review all data that will be uploaded in JSON. If I can not review this data, I will violate terms/AUP/laws and upload my own image. Even non EV's have remote updates and telemetry with ODB3. This is more common on cars manufactured after 2018. For now I am sticking with used older vehicles.
- amelius 5y agoCar updates should always go through some independent third party. This ensures that the software can be tested for a sufficient amount of miles before the update is released to the public. The independent party should (at a minimum) check that the software has not been changed in the last X months before it is deployed, which is easy to enforce if the independent party is doing the deployment. Allowing car companies to update the cars themselves is going to be a recipe for disaster.
- 0xhh 5y agoYes! If we can some how access the debug interface like JTAG or UART, then it is possible to add backdoors to the firmware. Even if the debug interface is protected, there are methods like side channel attacks or fault injection attacks that can set a certain bit to enable the debug interface. If a hacker could access the car's Over-the-air software updates server, then its pretty much over for the car company.
- speedcoder 5y agoWhat is the last car year without built-in radio transcievers? Did some manufacturers hold out longer than others? Will these cars eventually go up in value?
- 1970-01-01 5y agoOne idea I don't see on the table is 2FA for vehicles. Make it so a Yubikey must be tapped if something is connecting/installing.
- reflexe 5y agoWith the chip shortage, looks like we are safe.