5 ms·
> A statement from Safeway read at Thursday’s hearing blamed Proposition 47, which lowered penalties for thefts under $950, for “dramatic increases” in shoplift
by lupire 6y ago
> A statement from Safeway read at Thursday’s hearing blamed Proposition 47, which lowered penalties for thefts under $950, for “dramatic increases” in shoplifting losses.
$950 seems extremely high as the threshold for punishment (especially considering many crimes won't be caught and prosecuted), but also how can you shoplift $950 worth of stuff at a Walgreens?
- post_break 6y agoPrinter ink if it’s left out maybe? A few red bull cans.
- easton 6y agoPrinter ink in those quantities is probably only useful to businesses who don't really want to buy stolen printer ink (especially considering Walgreens is probably carrying genuine supplies when you can get 50% cheaper generic). Plan B is expensive, maybe that would work (I don't know if it's always locked up).
- sunshineforever 6y agoYou can resell the items on ebay and Amazon. I used to know independent stores that would purchase merchandise to stock the shelves with too. It doesn't necessary have to be fenced via a criminal org. A certain pocket sized paint tube from hobby lobby sells on Amazon for 10$. Criminals who are above the level of drug user/shoplifter, like a dealer, for example, can and do have to time to set up shops and sell online. Its all part of the larger hustle. If it makes money, they do it. Traditional economics and game theory all apply, its not following the law that differentiates the criminal.
- aeternum 6y agoI don't think the limit matters much. There was an SF crime ring that was designed to operate just under the limit. Have each person steal $900 worth of concentrated laundry detergent, razors, otc medicine. Setting the penalty threshold at $400 would only require more trips. They had an entire warehouse full of product: https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2020/10/06/major-san-francisco-bay-area-retail-theft-ring-busted-five-suspects-arrested-8-million-in-stolen-merchandise-recovered/ https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2020/10/06/major-san-franc...
- chii 6y agoif they can know about the warehouse, surely they can be charged with conspiracy to commit major crimes (like laundering those stolen items).
- tdeck 6y agoThese claims about prop 47 seem either ill-informed or disingenuous. Prop 47 reduced certain categories of crimes to misdemeanors. You can be sentenced to up to 12 months in prison for a misdemeanor, which seems like plenty for shoplifting. If nothing else, a year in jail prevents people from shoplifting for that year, and they probably would be less likely to do it openly the second time.
- refurb 6y agoYou’re unlikely to spend time in jail for a non-violent felony in SF. Nobody is going to jail for a misdemeanor.
- tdeck 6y agoThat's true, and it's because our prisons and jails have been beyond capacity for years. Elevating a bunch more crimes to felony status isn't going to change that fact.
- refurb 6y agoHaving zero consequences for criminal behavior will make sure the problem only gets worse.
- tdeck 6y agoWhat relevance does that have to prop 47. Ok, so we repeal prop 47 and we pick up a guy for shoplifting $600 worth of merchandise. Yesterday it was a misdemeanor, but in this hypothetical it's a felony today. Yesterday the jails were too full to prioritize holding that guy, and that's still true today because reclassifying crimes doesn't reduce our massive prison population or build new prisons. The consequences are the same. The only difference is that now the guy might have to start telling prospective employers that he's a convicted felon, which doesn't exactly bode well for his ability to pick up an honest job.
- refurb 6y ago
- cheriot 6y ago> $950 seems extremely high as the threshold for punishment Prop 47 made this the threshold for a Felony. Misdemeanor shoplifting can still be up to 6 months in prison. In practice it's not, but that's something to take up with the police, prosecutors, and judges.
- gnicholas 6y agoThe issue in SF is the prosecutor. Police decide whom to arrest based on what will be prosecuted, so that is a downstream decision. The judges could reduce sentences if these cases ever got in front of them, but in reality they never have the opportunity to weigh in.
- duxup 6y agoI don't think most folks commiting crimes are busy doing some sort of risk / reward calculation based on the cost of a fine.
- sunshineforever 6y agoThey do. Criminals are extensively aware of sentencing of crimes. Its one of the main subjects of conversion in jails. I know this from being acquainted with many criminals as a result of taking drugs for many years. "That's theft over 1000, Bubbles" -Trailer Park Boys
- thatguy0900 6y agoWhy wouldn't you? They arnt oppertunistically snatching some gum on the way out, they go to the store specifically to commit a crime. They have plenty of time to plan things out.