4 ms·
> Regenerative ag with animals and produce on one farm seems to me to be the healthiest and most sustainable path forward. What's the evidence for that being h
by gruez 6y ago
> Regenerative ag with animals and produce on one farm seems to me to be the healthiest and most sustainable path forward.
What's the evidence for that being healthier? Moreover, what's the health improvement relative to the cost? SV engineers might be willing to pay 3x more for something that's 5% healthier, but not a single parent household making minimum wage.
>Also saturated and animal fats are good for you. Chemically expressed vegetable trans-fats are not.
This seems to be contradicted by the available scientific evidence.
>The effect of saturated fat on heart disease has been extensively studied.[23] There are strong, consistent, and graded relationships between saturated fat intake, blood cholesterol levels, and the epidemic of cardiovascular disease.[8] The relationships are accepted as causal.[24][25]
>Many health authorities such as the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics,[26] the British Dietetic Association,[27] American Heart Association,[8] the World Heart Federation,[28] the British National Health Service,[29] among others,[30][31] advise that saturated fat is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease. The World Health Organization in May 2015 recommends switching from saturated to unsaturated fats.[32]
>There is moderate-quality evidence that reducing the proportion of saturated fat in the diet, and replacing it with unsaturated fats or carbohydrates over a period of at least two years, leads to a reduction in the risk of cardiovascular disease.[23]
- nradov 6y agoIf you actually read the referenced studies from an evidence-based medicine standpoint they're pretty weak. They're mostly just observational with unreliable subject reported data. They haven't fully controlled for all confounding factors such as the healthy subject effect. And effect sizes are small. I'm not claiming that saturated fats are necessarily healthy. Just that it's premature to label them as unhealthy. They're probably like almost every other food: fine in moderation but problematic when eaten to excess.
- gruez 6y ago>If you actually read the referenced studies from an evidence-based medicine standpoint they're pretty weak. They're mostly just observational with unreliable subject reported data. They haven't fully controlled for all confounding factors such as the healthy subject effect. And effect sizes are small. The first citation (23) links to https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32827219/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32827219/, which analyzed 15 randomized controlled trials. The effect size is 17% reduction in "combined cardiovascular events". Considering that "heart disease" is the top cause of death in the US (https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/pdf/leading_causes_of_death_by_age_group_2015-a.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/injury/wisqars/pdf/leading_causes_of_dea...), that seems like a big effect size.
- reedjosh 6y agoI'm not seeing links to the numbered evidence. The book I linked "The Big Fat Surprise" is a breakdown of the bad science that has been the mainstream dogma for years. One good example is the seven countries study: > The major flaw with this study is that Ancel Keys had access to data from 22 countries but discarded the 15 countries that did not fit the hypotheses he tried to prove. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Seven_Countries_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Seven_Countries_Study Nutrition science has been basically captured since the 60s. This story regarding the sugar lobby's influence on recommended diet was on hacker news just a few weeks ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16202171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16202171 > Many health authorities The timing of these authorities recommending a low fat diet, coincides with an upward trend of obesity related diseases. > What's the evidence for that being healthier? Grass fed beef for instance contains more Omega fatty acids, and vitamins. Mixed farming replenishes minerals in the ground--thus producing foods with more nutrients in them. Food grown this way also tends to need less chemical input and is often grown organically as the soil is healtier--and thus the plants are healthier. All of this and more is in the second book I linked "Deep Nutrition."
- gruez 6y ago> I'm not seeing links to the numbered evidence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturated_fat >The book I linked "The Big Fat Surprise" is a breakdown of the bad science that has been the mainstream dogma for years. One good example is the seven countries study: And what about the Cochrane RCT? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27211025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27211025 >> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Seven_Countries_Study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Seven_Countries_Study Are you seriously linking to the comment section of a wikipedia article? >Nutrition science has been basically captured since the 60s. Nutritional science is captured, so we should just trust the opposite of what they advocate? >The timing of these authorities recommending a low fat diet, coincides with an upward trend of obesity related diseases. https://xkcd.com/925/ https://xkcd.com/925/ >Grass fed beef for instance contains more Omega fatty acids, and vitamins. [...] All of this and more is in the second book I linked "Deep Nutrition." source? I'm not going to pay $14 and read through 512 pages just to verify a citation, and I somewhat doubt that the book is where groundbreaking research is being published.
- AlanSE 6y agoPlant fat sources like peanuts, avocados, olive oil, etc. have a lot of fat, and this includes a lot of saturated fat. In the idea that it exists in lower portion? Is the problem really saturated fat itself, or the type of saturated fat... meaning, is the category of saturated fat just too broad to intelligently discuss it with these categories?
- reedjosh 6y agoI see no problem with the fats you've mentioned, and I also think animals fats are fine as well. People used to cook with lard and tallow. McDonalds fries were originally cooked in tallow. People didn't die of obesity related diseases in the sixties and seventies like they do today, and we've only moved further from these healthy fats.
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> People didn't die of obesity related diseases in the sixties and seventies like they do today, They also didn't eat huge portions or drink quite such vast quantities of sugary drinks.
- AlanSE 6y agoI'm completely sold on the sugar argument. It's a home-run. Sugar is the new smoking. Our food environment makes it difficult to minimize sugar, but it's an extremely straightforward rule, and you will join an rapidly increasing number of people who are on the crusade. I asked the question about fat, because I accept that chronic disease in developed nations does have other components. Exercise is similar to sugar, in that it's quite difficult to work into our lives, but it's a simple and obviously worthwhile rule. With fat, on the other hand, it feels like people are all over the place. Nonetheless, there are bad fats. I don't know what "bad fats" are scientifically, but I'm pretty sure potato chips have them.
- kwhitefoot 6y agoThe US has a worse version of this problem than most other western countries. When I used to visit the US on business I found it quite difficult to buy food in the supermarkets because the list of ingredients on even the simplest items had items that I had never heard of or that I could not understand the need for. The other thing that bothered me was that quantity in many restaurants similar places seemed to be regarded as more important than quality. I went into a grocery store once while out riding a bicycle to get some water. I picked a bottle that seemed to be water but which turned out to be sickly sweet even though it had no sugar. Don't get me wrong, some of the best food I have ever eaten was in US restaurants. I think the only solution is to bring up children without junk food. But I have no idea how that can be achieved. I had my family with me once and we visited a colleague's house for Thanksgiving dinner. Our host's wife was rather taken aback when my three children asked for water instead of soda, and all three of them found the food far too sweet. Mind you things are changing here too, when we moved here over thirty years ago one never saw a seriously overweight person. Now it is moderately common.