3 ms·
> I consider crypto currency as it is to be an elaborate Ponzi scheme (personal view) Off topic, but as someone with very little understanding of economics and
by throwaway894345 5y ago
> I consider crypto currency as it is to be an elaborate Ponzi scheme (personal view)
Off topic, but as someone with very little understanding of economics and no stake in cryptocurrency, I don't understand where "legitimate currency" ends and "Ponzi scheme" begins. I get that a Ponzi scheme is one which produces little or no value, and the majority of "earnings" are just wealth redistribution from the bottom of the "pyramid" to the top (and yes, I understand that pyramid schemes and ponzi schemes are different); however, I don't understand what legitimate value ordinary currency produces. Can anyone help me understand?
- imtringued 5y ago>I don't understand what legitimate value ordinary currency produces. You can exchange your local government currency for services and goods. With Bitcoin you first have to convert them into a local government currency and then buy services and goods. This only works because those local government currencies exist in the first place. I'll pull this out of nowhere and say that 95% of the value of Bitcoin is derived from government currencies by that I mean the reason Bitcoin is valuable is that you can exchange it for government currencies. The other 5% are services and products that you can purchase with Bitcoin directly. That portion needs to grow if Bitcoin wants to become a "legitimate currency" but if everyone abuses the currency by hoarding it and doing nothing with it then it might as well not exist.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> You can exchange your local government currency for services and goods. With Bitcoin you first have to convert them into a local government currency and then buy services and goods. This only works because those local government currencies exist in the first place. I'll pull this out of nowhere and say that 95% of the value of Bitcoin is derived from government currencies by that I mean the reason Bitcoin is valuable is that you can exchange it for government currencies. So to be clear, bitcoin becomes "legitimate" when some critical mass of vendors accept it? This seems to imply that once the ponzi scheme becomes big enough it becomes legitimate (provided of course that we accept that btc is a ponzi scheme), which feels counterintuitive?
- eropple 5y ago> I don't understand what legitimate value ordinary currency produces. Can anyone help me understand? I'm not sure what "legitimate value" means in this context, but the most terse way I can think of to answer what I think is the spirit of your question is that currencies can be used to pay taxes and so there is an inherent demand, if geographically limited, for them; since you have to pay taxes, it makes sense to settle debts denominated in that currency because you have a use case for it going forward. This inherent demand creates stability--and yes, everyone loves to talk about hyperinflation but at the same time hyperinflating currencies are usually those of governments who are not long for this world! If you want to go further, I would submit that a modern currency is one where the supply of it can be controlled in response to other economic factors, and my personal position is that that control turns crashes and depressions into dips and recessions. But this is an opinion, and reasonable people could disagree. (Though candidly--in my experience, few who do, are.) Cryptocurrencies instead function more as commodities, and as they have few enough actual uses that are not by and large self-contained ones that require a certain amount of willing participation for them to have value at all (whereas gold is pretty and doesn't corrode, you can eat wheat, etc.) they are functionally inherently speculative vehicles. They lack any sort of external stabilizing factor because nobody needs them and so as a "legitimate currency" I can't see why anyone would ever tack on the phrase "legitimate currency" to that sort of virtual porkbelly.
- Macha 5y agoUltimately, fiat currency is backed by the fact that the people with guns who expect taxes to be paid to them expect said taxes to be paid in fiat currency. The goldbugs believe that is insufficient as a basis and we should all go back to gold standard where it was backed by a promise of a government to give you an amount of gold (or further back, was just made out of that gold). The crypto people believe even that is more basis than needed, and as long as people can agree it has value, and they all agree with each other that bitcoin has value, then it can be a currency.