10 ms·
Commander X16
- hvs 5y agoI'm a big retrocomputing enthusiast (in the C64 and Apple // realms) and the people doing this project are well-known in the community, but I just have trouble believing this will be successful. I don't want a computer that's kinda like a C64. I have a C64, and anyone who really likes that platform can either buy one on ebay or emulate it. A new platform that is a shadow of a platform from 40 years ago is such a niche market that I have trouble seeing how it'll ever be popular enough to get the price to a reasonable level. Maybe I'm wrong and there's a huge untapped market for retro-like computers. Pico-8 shows that there is some market for retro-like emulators, but asking someone to pay $14 is a lot different than $100 (or more).
- richardstephens 5y agoYou're probably right, but I'm going to order one as soon as they become generally available (providing the price isn't too expensive). I'm not interested in owning a real C64 because of its complete absence of modern conveniences (VGA, external keyboard, etc).
- vidarh 5y agoDefining success is tricky for these. For some of them I think the people creating them are perfectly happy with just getting something for themselves and a handful of enthusiasts. I agree with you, though. If I absolutely wanted physical hardware, I'd get a real one, or an FPGA reimplementation on a general board like MiSTER [1] that'd also let me run other cores, or something like the Ultimate 64 [2] (fit's in a real C64 case). I'd be more inclined to buy one of these "8-bit alternate reality continuity" thing, if something like the (FPGA based) Mega 65 [3] becomes reality. [1] https://misterfpga.co.uk/ https://misterfpga.co.uk/ [2] https://retrogamecoders.com/ultimate64-review/ https://retrogamecoders.com/ultimate64-review/ [3] https://mega65.org/ https://mega65.org/
- anyfoo 5y agoAn FPGA implementation is missing the big educational aspect though, namely that this product probably intends for it to be feasible (just like it was with the 8 bit computers back then) to fully understand the hardware, prod it, modify it, and interface to it. Usually up to IC boundary, but the key there is that the ICs are distinct and (hopefully) not too complex. Even a fully "open" modern platform is usually just way too complex, integrated, and often full of abstraction layers. With an FPGA, you in theory have that within the FPGA design itself for the most part, but it's still integrated and wrapped away so much that the directly relationship between current and logic, and things like an actual external bus with traces you can probe and hook into, is just not as tangible.
- vidarh 5y agoTo be clear when I wrote about my preferences above it was from a perspective of what I'd like to have and to use myself. I absolutely agree with you that many of these are great for educational purposes, so I absolutely think it's great some people are doing these too. That said, for that purpose I'd have stuck with something a more direct analog to one of the existing 8-bit machines myself. But it's not my projects so he is of course entirely free to make it however he prefers.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI personally didn't find Verilog all that hard to learn, and it's frankly simpler to understand and modify the "hardware" in that form than using a multimeter and logic analyzer and futzing with solder. I built myself a simple retro-style machine around a RISC-V core and my own custom designed video controller in a few weeks, without any prior Verilog experience. Although I am a software engineer, I don't feel like those skills actually helped that much.
- crispyambulance 5y agoKudos to you if you can go from zero to your own custom video controller implemented in an fpga in a few weeks. But for normal humans that just want to get involved with hardware and dabble somewhat with software/firmware in the context of vintage computing, taking a detour into fpga-world would be a deep unpleasant rabbit hole unless one was specifically interested in fpga's and there was no other viable option (which in the case of custom ASIC's is admittedly quite possible). Compared to the nightmarish complex toolchains used for fpga's, digging up some datasheets and working with a DMM, scope, and logic analyzer is a breeze and actually quite pleasurable.
- jhbadger 5y agoI think part of the excitement over real hardware is the potential that clever programmers can find ways to get more out of the hardware than it was designed for as in the real 8-bit era. While I think things like Pico-8 are interesting, there really isn't the possibility for things like new graphics modes that weren't programmed in by its creator the way real hardware can surprise you.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago"Hey, Retro-8 owners! I got a new hack for you — burn this new image onto your FPGA to get a dual-core 6502 that supports 32-bit addressing!" Yeah, not the same appeal.
- II2II 5y agoI think it will be successful, for a reasonable definition of success (e.g. fulfilling a dream of designing a computer and turning a small profit in the process). There is some precedent for this: retro-like computer games, for both modern computers and the original hardware; peripherals that support vintage computers; vintage computer clones that are based upon emulation or FPGA; hobby computer kits offering similar specifications. While none of those examples are the same, they demonstrate that people are willing to spend money to recreate rather than replicate an earlier era of computer history.
- kstenerud 5y agoWhat I see is a system designed specifically to be tinkered with and learned from. You have large, simple components, lots of expansion possibilities, fixed up BASIC, etc. I learned on computers such as these and it was a GREAT help in understanding how they actually accomplish basic things like talking to devices, handling memory, dealing with problems, communicating with other computers, etc. This brings back that magic while also removing some of the more unsightly warts of the original systems, and also interfaces easily with many conveniences of the modern era. For $100 that's a great toy to learn on.
- rbanffy 5y ago> I have a C64, and anyone who really likes that platform can either buy one on ebay or emulate it. Anything that has actual retro hardware is bound to be niche. I am extremely happy with my C64 Maxi. It’s emulated, has an HDMI output, USB, can be a C64 and a VIC-20 and is a reasonably accurate physical replica of a VIC-20. I already have a dozen actual vintage computers, but the other ones require attention and care that this one doesn’t and that’s a killer feature: it can be used pretty much the same way one would approach a computer in the mid-80s - it’s a computer, not a museum piece. You attach it to a TV, not to another carefully preserved artefact. The physical mimicry is, what I think, the most important part. You relate to a physical object that feels the same as the original and that allows you to explore what the original was and felt like. I’d love to see more of this, because it’s easy to manufacture and inexpensive enough to be put in the hands of children who can then have a blast exploring a bit of our past. My 8yo loves it. Now I wish they added C16/Plus 4 emulation, and that they did C128 and C65 ones.
- detaro 5y agoI'm also really curious to see. Something about it appears weird to me more than other "retrobrew" projects, and I'm not quite sure what it is. E.g. the RC2014 ecosystem is also a totally new system around old designs, and somehow I see more appeal in that.
- bluescrn 5y agoThere’s now quite a few of these ‘new retro’ projects around, but right now you can’t actually buy any of them from stock (Foenix, Commander X16, Mega65, ZX Spectum Next) These projects often seem to get bogged down in the costs and practicalities of creating the plastic parts rather than the electronics/software. Large injection-molded enclosures aren’t cheap (for lowing-volume products) and custom keyboards/key caps are even harder to do. (Still waiting on Amiga key caps from a Kickstarter about 4 years ago… apparently it’s still happening eventually…) That can lead to long delays and high prices.
- bartread 5y agoI have pissed and moaned at length about the ZX Spectrum Next so I'm not about to recapitulate all of that here. OTOH David Murray (The 8-bit Guy on YouTue), who is leading the Commander X16 project, does have a strong history of executing well and shipping. I haven't been that interested in other "new retro" computers, apart from the ZX Spectrum Next (which at least retains 100% compatibility, and for which I have significant nostalgia), but I'm interested in the Commander X16 simply because I tend to enjoy David's work in general.
- sparcpile 5y agoHis previous work has been software games, which make up a fair share of his income along with YouTube ads. He quit his real job to be a YouTube personality and sell software on the side. The design goal of the X16 was to try to make a 8bit computer out of modern stock for close to $100. The concept was to have an easily fixable computer with no bespoke parts. That goal got blown out of the water due to the realities of custom system design. The costs shot up in order to fulfill other requirements like the graphics and sound. Originally, David didn't want any FPGAs at all, but had to do that to get a viable graphics port. From what I remember others says, even the 2MB RAM might get knocked down to 1MB or less. The entire project itself is the nostalgia of a 8bit home computer, but the need to have it connected to modern parts like mice, keyboard, and displays.
- bartread 5y ago
- Theodores 5y agoIt is like model railways. You are selling to an older demographic with little interest from younger people. Older people do have money though. In 1983 it was not possible for them to upgrade to a C64 from their ZX81 or VIC-20 because they lacked the money and Christmas only came once a year. Nowadays though they can buy these toys without having to leave their chair.
- rasz 5y ago8-bit guy is known for destroying rare prototypes with his lack of engineering knowledge https://twitter.com/textfiles/status/1309664882283950081 https://twitter.com/textfiles/status/1309664882283950081 https://www.reddit.com/r/retrobattlestations/comments/izuswa/gore_the_8bit_guy_finds_what_he_thinks_is_a/ https://www.reddit.com/r/retrobattlestations/comments/izuswa...
- asddubs 5y agocalling someone a sociopath over making a mistake that affects only an inanimate object that was already defective is maybe a bit of an overreaction
- rasz 5y agoI didnt call anyone anything, just cited one of the things he is widely known for in vintage computer circles. for example https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=76713 https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=76713
- asddubs 5y agoI was referring to the twitter thread you linked, not yourself
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI thought this was going to be about that time he hooked two power supplies up to the same machine [0]. That time was worse in my opinion because anyone who knows anything about how a switching power supply works could tell you that was a bad idea, but I still have a hard time getting worked up about it. The torx bits thing doesn't even really register. It may be rare and special to us, but at the end of the day it is just hardware.
- asddubs 5y agoyou didn't post a link for your footnote! What happened? I can see how this would interfere with the voltage correction (if you don't decouple them e.g. using somewhat low value resistors) but if they're not put in series, I can't actually immediately see how this would cause damage
- scj 5y agoI think a reasonably priced RISC-V psuedo-retrocomputer that boots directly into Lisp / Scheme on simple to use hardware would be a great computer to learn programming on. Should be just as understandable to a newbie as a 6502 / Basic combo, but with a much better path to current computing environments.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI was working on exactly this (though not to Lisp, per se) before I got distracted and COVID came. I was calling it "Retro-V". In Verilog, I had a RISC-V core hooked up to my own home-built video logic, and was working on the SD card controller before I shelved it. In the meantime various RISC-V SoCs have come to market which could probably do the job well.
- LeonM 5y agoFor those unaware, this is the 'dream computer' specified (and partly designed by) David Murray, whom you might know as 'The 8-Bit Guy' on Youtube. David did a couple of episodes where he goes through the desired specs, and later the design. A lot of the design comes from the community.
- aniou 5y agoSpeaking of "modern retro computing" there is already a player in the town: C256 Foenix [1]. Based on 65c816, affordable, powerful and - most important - already available and well tested. It definitively deserve for user interest. For curious - there is an emulator available [2] (even one-and-half, because mine [3] is rather limited and created mostly for Forth [6, 7] development). 320x240 (double-pixel), 640x480, 800x600 all with 8 bit colors - 2 to 4MB of RAM, SD-card, IDE, FDD, joysticks, DVI for modern monitors - there are even expansion cards (second monitor(!), Ethernet) already available. Community is - currently - small and it affects the amount of software available, unfortunately - but it is a matter of time, I hope. There is a wiki [4], but discussions and deep technical details are available mostly on project Discord [5]. 1 - https://c256foenix.com/ https://c256foenix.com/ 2 - https://github.com/Trinity-11/FoenixIDE https://github.com/Trinity-11/FoenixIDE 3 - https://github.com/aniou/go65c816 https://github.com/aniou/go65c816 4 - https://wiki.c256foenix.com/index.php?title=Main_Page https://wiki.c256foenix.com/index.php?title=Main_Page 5 - https://discord.gg/wvM2vABR https://discord.gg/wvM2vABR 6 - https://github.com/aniou/of816/tree/C256/platforms/C256 https://github.com/aniou/of816/tree/C256/platforms/C256 7 - https://github.com/aniou/retro816 https://github.com/aniou/retro816
- wott 5y ago> https://c256foenix.com/ https://c256foenix.com/ Based on 65c816, affordable, powerful and - most important - already available and well tested. I went to the link: Available: it's all sold out. Admittedly, it exists more than the project of this post, which was announced 2 years ago and still has to deliver. Affordable: disputable, this is priced $220/$260 for a bare board (no power supply, no case) so you can find cheaper Amiga/ST FPGA boards; but it is not ridiculously expensive either and some of those Amiga/ST boards are unavailable too.
- aniou 5y agoRe: availability - a victim of own success. ;) And chip shortage too, unfortunately. Re: affordable: I come rather from 8-bit Atari and - in my opinion - it is not a cheap hobby. Modern extensions like Sophia2 or VBXL aren't cheap, memory extensions also require some bucks. Not mention about SD-card interfaces, although they are cheaper. And re-implementations like already assembled EclaireXL or Atari 1088 XEL are even more expensive.
- nottorp 5y ago> Multiple output formats (VGA, NTSC Composite, NTSC S-Video, RGB video) at a fixed resolution of 640x480@60Hz Hmm. Please HDMI? Please wide screen? (I mean 853x480 or even 426x240 not 1080p). I don't see the retro monitor this is supposed to be paired with for sale.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoAgree with HDMI. But you can get plenty of new 4:3 aspect ratio displays — primarily meant for security cameras, backup cameras and the like.
- nottorp 5y agoAren't those postage stamp size? And normal people are much more likely to already have a bunch of 16:9 displays and about 0 4:3.
- yc-kraln 5y agoI think the lack of USB, as irritating as it is to implement, relegates this to the "curiousity" bin--not for keyboards, per se, but for storage and other connectivity. Still a cool project, though.
- selfhoster11 5y agoI imagine you could always use third-party peripherals for this.
- rzzzt 5y agoThere is an SD card slot on it that you can use for storage.
- codeflo 5y agoSomething I’d buy, and that the Raspberry Pi almost might have been, is a computer running a “retro OS” (instantly boots, BASIC-like commands, direct access to hardware) on a semi-modern ARM chip with a few megs of RAM and HDMI out. That would be fun to tinker with and program for. The problem with this is that it’s so incredibly hard to do anything in 8-bit, I can’t imagine many people going to all that trouble if they’re not even getting the badge of honor if running on real retro hardware.
- user-the-name 5y ago32-bit, megabyte-order-of-magnitude is a much more interesting place to be than C64-equivalent hardware. You can actually make things that look and feel good, but you still need to be clever about it. Nintendo GBA and DS are very much in this space, and are great fun to work with.
- codeflo 5y agoI’ve actually tinkered with GBA programming, and you’re exactly right. It’s surprisingly accessible. Of course, it’s built as a console, not a computer, so you can’t actually program on it. But give it more RAM instead of ROM, a keyboard, and you’re almost there.
- jhbadger 5y agoMaybe it is a feature of how old you are? To me at 50, GBA/DS just doesn't seem very retro. It's just a slightly worse version of modern gaming with no real charm of its own. But I suppose if you are 30, it has nostalgia value because it was what you grew up with.
- codeflo 5y agoWell I'm 37. We might split hairs here about what is and isn't retro. The GBA came out in 2001, which admittedly isn't that long ago, but in many ways, it was simply a modernized, mobile variant of the SNES. Indeed, many of its most successful titles were simply ports of SNES games from the 90s, like Super Mario World. So in my mind, it's a mobile 16-bit console in spirit (I know it actually has a 32-bit ARM CPU). That's less true for the DS. And I don't think many people would argue that 16-bit gaming had "no real charm", I consider it to be the peak of the 2D era. In fact, Super Mario World is often held as one of the best platformers of all the time. With all its fan mods, it's still widely played to this day. It's the early 3D era that followed that's mostly forgotten.
- chalcolithic 5y agoWhile I love, love, love retrocomputing I don't understand why 99% of it is "retro-next" computing - instead of designing computer from some era people like to design much beefier next-gen machines. 2MB of RAM? 640x480? Why not use Amiga instead? Designing a machine that would beat c64 is insanely appealing to me. Designing a machine that would beat c64 because it came out a decade later and had larger ram chips and much larger gate count in a video chip? Meh...
- selfhoster11 5y agoAt a guess, it's harder to get your hands on weaker chips in larger quantities. Larger chips are dirt-cheap, while for weaker ones you'd either have to raid NOS from warehouses, or fab it yourself (which is expensive, and sometimes outright impossible - I don't think we've got the tech to fab a SID chip any more, for instance).
- talideon 5y agoThe SID's major difficulties are due to it being an analogue-digitial hybrid. That's why most of the efforts have went down the emulation route, though there's apparently an FPGA SID replacement in development that's pretty close. The original 6581 is super impractical as each of those is different, but the later 8580 is much more practical to rebuild in FPGA form, even if emulating the analogue side is still awkward.
- selfhoster11 5y agoThat's part of what I was referring to. The analogue-digital hybrid is one of the things that's difficult to replicate with the current manufacturing technology for fabbing new chips.
- chalcolithic 5y agoThat is totally understandable, but do they have to use the whole chip?
- talideon 5y ago
- kwanbix 5y agoWhat I would love is an affordable Amiga 500 clone. Extra points if it can also work as an Atari ST. Anyone knows if such thing exists? By affordable I mean 100~200 USD. HDMI and SATA for SSD/HDD. Thanks1
- mattowen_uk 5y agoThe MiST does all of that: https://amigastore.eu/en/358-mist-midi-fpga-computer-with-midi-add-on.html https://amigastore.eu/en/358-mist-midi-fpga-computer-with-mi... 221,95 Euro (Approx 271 USD)
- kwanbix 5y agoClose enough. Do I need to buy the "Full Amiga Configuration" or can I build that myself since I had an Amiga? EDIT: some other sellers: https://www.amedia-computer.com/en/accueil/275-mist-midi-13-board-black-metal-case.html https://www.amedia-computer.com/en/accueil/275-mist-midi-13-... https://www.dragonbox.de/en/consoles/other-consoles/mist-fpga-14-plus-transparent https://www.dragonbox.de/en/consoles/other-consoles/mist-fpg...
- boomlinde 5y agoYou can build that yourself, provided you have images of the Kickstart ROM and Workbench disks. You can boot the thing off of a hard disk image, the same kind used by modern *UAE emulators, or you can boot it off a floppy disk image.
- mattowen_uk 5y agoWhen David Murray (8-bit-guy) first announced his 'dream computer' I was quite excited. His early descriptions were akin to something like a C128 but with more colours, faster CPU and modern connections, all in a single case, like the C128(not D) or C64. Plug into a screen or TV and just 'go'. Somewhere along the way serious scope-creep happened, and now we've got something that looks and feels just like a mini-ITX Desktop PC running some sort of BASIC 'shell' (even though it's not). It just doesn't exude any Retro-vibes. I could build something almost identical out of off-the-shelf parts, and run a bare-metal Retro-OS emulator on it, and the end experience would be 99% the same. It's a real shame... and like other commenters have said, I can't see this ending up as a commercial success.
- Pet_Ant 5y agoWhere did it lose the retro vibe for you? I see a board with very few simple chips where you could reasonably understand the whole system top to bottom. The hardware is still very limited.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wvenable 5y agoThe outside might not give you retro-vibes due due the case/keyboard design but inside it's still pretty retro. It's running an 8bit CPU and Microsoft BASIC. Nothing is stopping you from buying the board and 3D printing a retro case/keyboard for it.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoAll these machines end up involving one or more FPGAs -- to varying degrees -- simply because of the requirements and logistics. There's varying types of purism involved ("FPGA only where we would have used a custom chip" or "FPGA but not for the CPU" etc) but once you start down that path the whole thing starts to seem silly as with many of these machines the entire functionality could be done on a single relatively inexpensive FPGA but isn't for purist reasons. And then you start realizing how arbitrary many of these projects are. They're admittedly nostalgia projects, but everyone's definition of what nostalgia is for them differs. Attempts to make it more "canonical" are made by locking down the FPGA use, or keep the source to it closed, but again... arbitrary. In a way this is why I'm personally more interested in the MEGA65 project because it's all-in on the FPGA angle, all open source, and has focused more on the stuff that makes these projects actually logistically tricky: cases, keyboards, packaging, distribution, toolchains, OS, etc. And backwards compatible with the C64/C128, which is something the X16 and the C256 can't be. It's taking a long time to finish, but I think it's really neat. And I feel like the developers are taking themselves a little less seriously/dogmatically and seem fun. https://mega65.org/ https://mega65.org/
- II2II 5y agoIn a lot of cases, they aren't left with much of a choice. Many chips aren't in production any longer, either due to them being custom chips or due to them serving a need that the market no longer has. Stuffing everything into an FPGA isn't really a solution in this case since it effectively makes it a hands-off machine. What do I mean by hands off? In terms of software, it doesn't make much of a difference. You can still develop for the machine and it will appear to be the genuine article. In terms of hardware, it is a different ballgame. At best, slots and ports may be exposed so stuff can be added to the machine. It will be a bit like using a modern desktop, albeit with the opportunity to develop your own expansion cards since the expansion bus can be more accessible than PCI-e. On the other hand, most modifications to the hardware itself must be made through the FPGA. The FPGA route will be more flexible, but it requires an entirely different skill set. Relatively few people have the skill or interest to deal with FPGAs, particularly if they are seeking something more comforting than modern hardware. How is replicating something like the video chip with an FPGA somehow acceptable? Presumably it is because it has to interface with the rest of the system in a conventional way and since people were unable to modify the video chip in vintage computers anyhow. Since it is interfacing with the system in a conventional way, you can also mess around with the video circuitry surrounding the chip.
- mhd 5y agoThe retro designs that I really want to see made real would be the ones done by "Arne"[1]. Most of the designs would be impossible, being pretty steeped in trademarks, but they've explored some interesting ideas, like alternate keyboard layouts (ABC, 4 rows etc.) and mashups of all kinds of "retro" machines. We're also not seeing that many 16-bit faux-retro designs (i.e. not straight-forward Amiga/Atari clones). Either because they tend to be more complex, or because this follows the same trends as fashion and music, where we e.g. had 80s synthwave followed by 90s vaporwave and now more 00s sounds and looks. Since the time for that should've come by now, I think it's more the complexity angle. "Just" hooking up a 6502/z80 seems an order of magnitude easier than coming up with whatever the equivalent of custom chips would be. Never mind that because of the scale economy, you'd have to do the latter with FPGA, which is a step down on the ladder of retro authenticity. [1]: https://androidarts.com https://androidarts.com
- fallat 5y agoAlways loved this. I wish people would dream more like them.
- Zenst 5y agoAh, I still recall the April 1st joke about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWBUMgAl7wY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PWBUMgAl7wY which was one of the better ones by far this year. The channel "Retro recipe" on YT been mostly driving this and has few video's over time with updates and news nuggets upon the progress and now - finally here. Worth checking out the channel if your into that kinda stuff and one of the better ones for that retro nostalgia.
- terminalserver 5y agoThe esp32 would have been a good graphics controller and would have been very cheap and simple. It would have provide VGA NTSC, PAL and wifi. The fpga graphics controller seems like overkill to me.
- rasz 5y ago>Pictured: Commander X16P concept art clearly art https://imgur.com/Y36FUCg https://imgur.com/Y36FUCg
- billpg 5y agoI don't get it. I get building a C64 (or other retro systems) but with HDMI ports and components that can be sourced without dumpster diving. I don't want to replace a bunch of capacitors to play 80s games either. But why would I spend good money on a Commander X16 when I could buy a (say) Raspberry Pi. If I'm going to buy a modern system, then why not buy a modern system?
- naikrovek 5y agothere are subtle differences. some people want the real hardware. some people want to need a stack of cartridges or tapes and to go through the motions of committing to a decision such as which game to play. if it is virtual, or emulated, there's almost no weight to decisions you make, because it's so easy to switch games if you don't immediately like the game you chose. I find that I don't give things a chance as I would if I had to get up and walk to change a cartridge in a real SNES, as an example. if emulation works for you, then emulate. go crazy. I don't get emulation, and I'm not going to tell someone that they're wrong for liking it, because they aren't. for some, emulation isn't enough, that's all. there are also technical reasons people don't like emulation, but most people don't care about those as much as they care about the experience of the old school systems.
- wvenable 5y agoBut it's not a modern system. At it's core is an 8Bit CPU.
- billpg 5y agoIts architecture was literally designed within the past few years.
- wvenable 5y agoThis is true, but it's in the same style as a C64 architecture. These guys already own C64's. You can convert the signal to HDMI if you want a C64 with HDMI. You can get C64 Maxi if you want the physical experience with emulation. All possibilities are out there. The purpose of this is to be something new, solving some of the problems of the C64, while retaining the same architectural style.
- conradev 5y agoI bet the input latency on this will be better than any other computer on the market
- kwdc 5y agoI think this is a good idea. If successful, it will create a stable platform for 8 bit 6502 people to target their creations and talk about as a community. Those involved are making compromises as time goes on as the ideas hit reality. From what I can see the compromises seem appropriate. I can easily see a small island of activity around this platform. Plenty of scope for wikis, social media, youtube, etc etc.