4 ms·
Wow, Google+ really got the timing right. Facebook looks to me like they're on the defensive... if FB aren't directly reacting to Google+, I hope they've had t
by r00fus 15y ago
Wow, Google+ really got the timing right.
Facebook looks to me like they're on the defensive... if FB aren't directly reacting to Google+, I hope they've had time to get the kinks worked out.
This is getting very interesting.
- brudgers 15y agoThere seems to be more evidence of a cohesive strategy on Microsoft's part given their investment in Facebook and purchase of Skype. On the other hand, given the invitation only rollout of Google+ it looks more like Google was forced to do something quickly before they were ready. Being first out the gate is a tactic, not a strategy. As for Facebook having the kinks worked out - with the better part of a billion users they've got the big one solved.
- r00fus 15y ago> As for Facebook having the kinks worked out - with the better part of a billion users they've got the big one solved. Not sure where you're going here... Facebook and video chat aren't synonymous, so how does having millions of users mean they're going to get it right? > Google was forced to do something quickly before they were ready Can you explain why you think Google+ isn't ready? What's "broken"?
- brudgers 15y agoFacebook has solved the big problem for social networks - lots of people use it. The evidence that Google+ wasn't ready to be a Facebook killer is that it is invitation only. Living in a college town, I was around Facebook when it was exclusively for students. Facebook's growth from exclusive to pervasive was enabled by the fact that students move on get married and have babies - looking at pictures of her first granddaughter is what sold Facebook to mom. On the other hand, the bloggers and programmers invited to Google+ will remain bloggers and programmers. They're already married and have kids and more importantly already update Facebook with photos for grandma and uncles. Don't get me wrong, Google will make money off this thing even with limited adoption and the assumption that it will ever roll out of perpetual beta (or preview in this case) is not a settled matter based on Google's history.
- dannyr 15y agoRemember that you can say the same about Friendster. Lots of people were using it. Twitter started with just blogger- and programmer-types too.
- tonfa 15y agoYou seem to forget that Google+ is in field trial, and was launched only 2 days ago. I don't expect any product as big as that to fully launch overnight.
- carbonica 15y ago"The evidence that Google+ wasn't ready to be a Facebook killer is that it is invitation only." Google knows the best way to release a product - especially one in unfamiliar territory like the social space - is not to flip a giant switch and hope that when the whole world starts using it, nothing goes wrong. For one, the scalability issues when you're Google are enormous: they know they'll have tens of millions of 7-day users the first 7 days. You don't want to screw that up. That doesn't even touch on product design.
- saurik 15y agoBut taking a random sample of people and getting a hopefully-large-enough subset of their friends is not what you want for a social product: you want all of your friends in it, or you just get frustrated and go back to your previous solutions. Facebook /nailed this/ with their multi-year long staged rollout by targeting colleges: already self-contained social ecosystems where almost all of a student's friends are going to be other students; you start with one college, then two, then slowly ramp up until you can flip the big switch. Google simply does not understand this, and keeps falling back to their experience with Gmail, which was a fundamentally different beast.
- vijaydev 15y agoCan you tell what would you have them do instead of going invite based? Also, considering the constraints that others have mentioned.
- danjones 15y ago@brudgers Google typically releases new products to the market slowly whilst announcing them, look back at services like Gmail, that was initially invite only and in beta for a number of years. I doubt this is actually Facebook's answer to Google+ most likely something they've had on the cards for a while. They've still got plenty of time whilst G+ is in it's infancy.
- brudgers 15y agoGoogle also releases new products slowly and then lets them die. Gmail as a commodity product doesn't have the chicken and egg problem that a social network does - and there's no good example of Google solving a chicken and egg problem which depends on brand loyalty rather than technology (qualifications due to the possible argument that advertising revenue based search was a chicken and egg problem albeit one which was solved based on technology rather than consumer loyalty). I don't think that Facebook/Skype is a response to Google+'s rollout. I think Google+ is a tactical response to a strategy has been developing for a long time (measured in internet years). On the other hand, Facebook's announcement probably is a tactical response to Google's timing given the massive investment in buzz creation which has manifested itself in the last few days.
- redthrowaway 15y agoAndroid was successful because it was attractive to carriers and handset makers, but consumer faith in the Google brand had a lot to do with it, as well. I wouldn't say it was the deciding factor, but the fact it was made by Google rather than random company x probably influenced buying decisions.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- espeed 15y agoFrom the OS wars, to browser wars, and now the full-on social wars. Game on!
- natmaster 15y agoYeah, I don't think even Facebook has the ability to create something like this in a weekend.