10 ms·
The Colonial Pipeline Was Fine, Shutdown to Make Sure Its Owner Would Get Paid
- mrweasel 6y agoIf that is true, it's that an admission that you do not view fuel supplies as critical infrastructure?
- Guthur 6y agoEven so, some one has to pay, and the government wouldn't be keen on just handing out free fuel either.
- erentz 6y agoIf the power grid in your area loses its billing system should it just shut down? What I don’t get is why they couldn’t gather the data manually to keep things running and sorted it out after the fact. They didn’t have any DR planning for something like this? Station people with clipboards and cameras at all meters. Measure the inputs and outputs as they occur. It seems there was just no real impetus to act responsibly here.
- daniellarusso 5y agoWho do you hire to do that? How quickly can you train them? Where do they send the collected information? How is the collected info processed and aggregated? How much money is lost doing the above versus just shutting down? I think their DR was fine. It is the HA that was not. $5mil from net revenue of $400 mil is less than 2% of profits, and it has been operating for 80 years. Honestly, I think the environmental damage the pipeline has caused is much worse.
- salawat 5y agoThat's expensive. You have to have someone do all that paerwork, the paperwork has to exist (printing and doc management), and there needs to be a hard copy of the business agreement on a per customer basis. I mean, I'm kinda old timey, so ot"s not infeasible from my point of view; but in today's hyper-optimized, bottom-line over-fault-tolerance world, I don't see that happen all that much. Heck, I have trouble getting a straight answer out of the youngin's to "What is a filing system?"
- colechristensen 6y agoThe author of this article comes off as really very clueless. Yes, in fact, if a store's computers go down they don't just let customers walk out the door with products and hope they get paid eventually? As far as I understand colonial is basically a big gas station connected with a series of tubes. Look ma, the gas pump still works but it doesn't keep track of how much we pumped or charge us any more! Of course they shut down if they couldn't bill? It's being treated like some kind of greed when in reality they didn't want to give away millions of dollars of fuel they couldn't track or bill for. The colonial pipeline was fine... except it couldn't do the thing it does which is sell gas to distributors, it could only give it away. Sigh. This isn't "fake news", but it is... shitty news? News which gives facts and a ridiculous analysis? I'm still trying to find out what actually happened in Israel but god forbid a news source or commentator actually lay out the details of a complicated situation... (if you're not getting everybody pissed off about X, then you're not doing your job as a reporter?)
- sam_lowry_ 6y ago> if a store's computers go down they don't just let customers walk out the door with products and hope they get paid eventually? This is exactly what we expect them to do in a crisis situation. This is also how Hollywood portrays ethical behavior. The store owner in Jericho (2006 TV series) is the first to come to mind, but there should be plenty of other examples. And good deeds come back to us.
- andrewstuart2 6y agoI think maybe you have to think about the total economic impact for the article and frustration to make more sense. Fuel is a very fundamental part of our economy and almost always goes toward producing much more value than the value of the fuel itself. Add to that, shortages can and do contribute to irreversible losses like loss of life. If every gas distributor shut down because ransomware hit them all, you could completely grind the country to a halt. It's not too far fetched either to hope that their customers would be willing to self-report. Sure you might get some people who'd take advantage of the situation, but it's not a the total loss scenario of giving away your product for free that you're talking about. Add in the opportunity cost and shutting down delivery if you have alternatives that may not be 100% accurate billing is probably a net loss for the company, though it's impossible to say. > I'm still trying to find out what actually happened in Israel but god forbid a news source or commentator actually lay out the details of a complicated situation... (if you're not getting everybody pissed off about X, then you're not doing your job as a reporter?) It's a bit ironic to take a morals-over-profit stance on reporting right after having taken the profit-over-morals stance of gas pipelines.
- eps 6y agoCan we get the title fixed please? Even if it's misspelled at the source. ..., shut down ...
- throwaway378037 6y agoBoth are valid, it’s journalistic headline abbreviation. It can be read as: > [the] shutdown [was] to make sure Or with your correction it would be read as: > [it was] shut down to make sure So it’s not incorrect in the source article, it is just using the noun shutdown, rather than the verb to shut down.
- eps 6y agoYou are being way too generous. Your first expansion is a very big stretch.
- throwaway378037 5y agoPerhaps, though I’m not arguing that it was a good headline. My point was only that it is a valid headline, as long as you understand that shutdown is the noun.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- darkwater 6y agoHow come that billing is basically ALWAYS the typical system that - no matter what - runs on Windows? SMEs software, big enterprise software and everything in between, you can have 99% of your core systems running on whatever operating system you want, or several of them, but the billing/payroll/accounting system will ALWAYS be Windows. Even if SAP has Linux/Unix versions.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ComodoHacker 6y agoI bet their billing system is custom and was developed in times when Windows was a better choice. And nobody was able (or even tried) to justify a switch since then.
- Stranger43 6y agoAt what point in history was that? Unix(tm) and mainframes predate windows server by a far margin and was never seen as inferior to windows by the wider sysadmin community, there might have been a time when windows server had merit as the discount solutions for people who could not afford highly available Unix boxen, but it was never seen as superior or particularly well suited for critical infrastructure. I think that's kind of whats in play here, few finance systems were designed as critical as well finance was that department that generated a few reports that nobody really read and rarely interacted with the core productive business to the point where flaws/bugs in finance systems could have an real impact until very recently so what you have is a bunch of aging discount/non-critical system that have been promoted to critical infrastructure nearly by accident. The same goes for the desktop support infrastructure build around AD and SMB file shares, where systems that used to be auxiliary nice to have for clerical workers ended up as critical for the actual productive divisions without ever receiving any real hardening.
- cube00 6y agoThick desktops were ruled by Windows so if you wanted a custom application it was Microsoft Visual Basic or Visual C++, Java as desktop apps didn't seem to catch on for the enterprise. Even if you tried to bring an application to the web back in the 90s you could still end up caught in the Microsoft ecosystem via ActiveX.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> didn’t actually shut down the pipeline. It impacted the billing system at the Colonial Pipeline Co., which shut it down because they were worried about how they’d collect payments. What? Did the author think that the ransomeware literally locked valves?
- Dylan16807 6y agoPlease try reading the article again. "the operational network that controls its pipelines and distributes fuel is separate from the corporate network and wasn’t infected" The article thinks it matters whether the ransomware gets on the operational network, not your strawman.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Did the author think that the ransomeware literally locked valves? In the early times of the pipeline shutdown this was exactly what was feared. Malware attacking, damaging, destroying or abusing industrial embedded devices to persist in to survive cleanups is nothing new. Stuxnet was just the tip of the iceberg.
- Animats 6y agoIs there good info on this somewhere? Colonial Pipeline is a common carrier, "moving gasolines, kerosenes, home heating oils, diesel fuels and national defense fuels" (the US military runs on something which has the additives to be used either as JET-A or diesel fuel) "to shipper terminals in 12 states and the District of Columbia." Some pipelines switch from one product to another, usually with a slug of water in between for separation. There's valve switching, tank filling, and tank emptying going on. If you can't coordinate that, the wrong product ends up in the wrong place. If they lost the system that tracks what's where and where it's going, they have to shut down, or, as they seem to have done, dropped the pumping speed way down so they could operate the system manually. It's not just one pipe that carries one product.
- qalmakka 6y agoIMHO, the USA has made the mistake of privatizing too much of its crucial infrastructure, ignoring that certain things are inherently monopolistic in nature and do not benefit at all from being in private hands. Privatizing infrastructure is extremely positive if there's any chance for competition to arise - for instance, Italy has moved from a monopolistic state phone company to a well regulated and open free market, which has caused a boom of competing companies that has massively driven prices down. I now pay €27/mo for unlimited 1Gbps/300Mbps fiber and €7/mo for my phone plan with 50 GB of data, unlimited calls and unlimited SMS. This is offset by the sad state of our highway system, which has been handed off to private companies a long time ago. There is obviously no way to create competition in highways (what are you going to do, build a cheaper highway next to the already existing one?), so the main company (API) has been neglecting mantaining infrastructures up to the point that a few bridges have collapsed, killing people and creating huge preventable disasters. Tolls are also crazy expensive, often amounting to half the cost of a road trip (and here petrol costs €1.50 per litre). There's no incentive for a private company to invest a single cent as soon as it becomes a monopoly, it is something that has been known since the dawn of man.
- silviot 6y agoCompetition is not only ineffective in monopolistic markets. Also oligopolic markets are very inefficient. In Italy's example the price you now pay for your mobile plan (7 €/month for 50 GB) was made possible by Iliad, a new ISP that broke the Italian oligopoly and forced all competitors to bring prices down (or better data caps up) ten fold in the span of a few months.
- alanfranz 5y agoNo, not tenfold. Iliad entered a competitive market, but my pre-iliad price was around 10 eur/month, albeit with smaller data allowance. Iliad helped lowering prices by offering a lower end service.
- girvo 6y agoAustralia has followed America in making that mistake too, sadly. Other countries as well I assume. The politicians that push this, seem to make sure it’s their cronies that are the ones that get to make billions off said privatisation, too.
- HPsquared 6y agoIf ever there was a good candidate for a company to bailout to prevent damage to the wider economy, this is it.
- josho 6y agoOn the flip side you are bailing out a company for neglecting to have a disciplined security practice and a failure to build and execute their disaster recovery plan. Rather than bail out the company perhaps nationalizing it is the better recourse. It would certainly make other companies seriously reconsider how they invest in DR and security.
- ggm 6y agoBill them the same this month as you billed them last month. Adjust the bill next month, in the light of figures.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe author here is misrepresenting his sources to spin a specific agenda point, in order to construct a false narrative. It's as fake as fake news gets. From the author's own sources... > Colonial’s corporate IT network and the process control network are connected and exchange information about how much fuel each supplier or distributor receives in order to bill them for it. > ...they could change [data about the] flow rates, they could modify the data > Although infecting Colonial Pipeline’s process control network would be disruptive, it isn’t the only concern. Colonial’s control system also connects to the control systems at tank farms that feed fuel into Colonial’s pipeline.... An attacker can potentially pass through Colonial’s control systems into the control systems of these farms. I really hate advocacy journalism. It's such a fundamentally dishonest medium.