4 ms·
Well, they don't just "feel" faster. They also complete lots of real-world tasks in shorter times, often significantly shorter than the last Intel Macbook Pro.
by coldtea 6y ago
Well, they don't just "feel" faster. They also complete lots of real-world tasks in shorter times, often significantly shorter than the last Intel Macbook Pro.
- oregontechninja 6y agoI was an unbeliever, but we got some M1 Mac Mini's and this is the result. They even beat the dedicated workstation many of our people have set up. I get when people say it won't quite match a new ryzen for compute power, but in all of our tests, the M1 beat out all our workstations.
- spockz 6y agoWhat workloads do you run? I’ve got a 16GiB M1 mbp and a 2019 maxed intel and when compiling Java/sbt projects the intel is significantly quicker, albeit also much loader and power hungry.
- alienalp 6y agoThat compiler most probably not native to m1 arm processor.
- spockz 6y agoIndeed, I was using the GraalVM jdk11 build which wasn’t available in a native version indeed.
- alecthomas 6y agoAs the sibling comment mentions, if you're running Intel JDK on M1 it will be slow. You can find M1 native JDK builds here: https://www.azul.com/downloads/?version=java-11-lts&os=macos&architecture=arm-64-bit&package=jdk https://www.azul.com/downloads/?version=java-11-lts&os=macos...
- hugi 6y agoJust for fun, Oracle has also started providing natively compiled EA builds of JDK 17: https://jdk.java.net/17/ https://jdk.java.net/17/
- chrisseaton 6y ago> when compiling Java/sbt projects Are you comparing a binary being run under dynamic binary translation with a native binary? Not really an honest comparison, if that's the case.
- formerly_proven 6y agoNo idea if that's the case, but I wouldn't have expected Java of all things to be run under binary translation.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> I wouldn't have expected Java of all things to be run under binary translation Why? The Java community has only just been working on ARM64 support at all over the last few years, and it's still a little limited, and macOS ARM64 support is only out a couple of weeks and only from non-Oracle third-party builders I believe.
- nicoburns 6y ago> I wouldn't have expected Java of all things to be run under binary translation Depends which version you have installed. It's a taken a while for the native versions to reach the mainstream channels, so unless you've specifically installed an M1 build you probably have an x86 build being run under translation.
- throwaway4good 6y agoYou have to install a Java VM compiled for ARM such as the one made by Azul. If you just get the openjdk from the main website it is compiled for Intel and will be much slower.
- biehl 6y agoNative support in the regular builds will arrive in september https://openjdk.java.net/projects/jdk/17/ https://openjdk.java.net/projects/jdk/17/
- spockz 6y agoWow, based on the comments here I decided try out the native M1 builds of Azul. I see a 4.1x speedup in compiling (including tests), excluding dependency resolution: Azul Native M1 java JDK11: ./sbt "clean;compile;test:compile" 254.86s user 11.84s system 519% cpu 51.375 total Azul java JDK11: ./sbt "clean;compile;test:compile" 490.04s user 59.48s system 269% cpu 3:23.81 total
- Eric_WVGG 6y agoThe author’s analysis sounds less like an explanation of how the M1 is faster, and more like an explanation of how it gets such amazing battery life. If someone could figure out a way to get all MacOS apps —including the system — to use the performance cores, perhaps the battery life would be back down to Intel levels?
- bombcar 6y agoI'm sure someone has run the battery dead using benchmarks that exercise the performance cores - I suspect that Apple designed a fast chip and an efficient chip and then married them together - that an M1Max with only performance cores wouldn't be that interesting power-budget-wise (though likely still an improvement).
- EricE 6y ago>If someone could figure out a way to get all MacOS apps —including the system — to use the performance cores, perhaps the battery life would be back down to Intel levels? Other than to prove an utterly useless point - why would you want to even remotely do that?!? If my time machine backup takes four times as long but my battery lasts longer still why would I care? The overall experience is a HUGE net improvement. That's the point being glossed over by the majority of commenters and the point the original author is making - benchmarks are interesting, but nothing beats real world experience and in real world experience there are a suite of factors contributing to the M1 and Apples SOC approach spanking the crap out of their competitors. There is more to life than rAw PoWeR ;)
- Eric_WVGG 6y agocuriosity? proving the thesis? knowledge that could improve competing laptops? yah never mind I don't care why these computers are impressive let’s just play macos chess and browse facebook jfc if you’re not interested why did you even join this conversation
- EricE 6y agoI don't care? "That's the point being glossed over by the majority of commenters and the point the original author is making - benchmarks are interesting, but nothing beats real world experience and in real world experience there are a suite of factors contributing to the M1 and Apples SOC approach spanking the crap out of their competitors." I don't know what point would be proved by maxing out the cores other than confirming what seems to be pretty obvious - a hybrid approach has multiple benefits - not just in power efficiency but the user experience as well. It's not just one aspect of the design choices - but all of them in concert.
- Spooky23 6y agoIt’s funny how many articles that just won’t say the obvious - it’s a faster computer. I have two laptops side by side, one is an M1, the other a HP in a slightly higher price point (more memory, bigger SSD). The challenges Intel has in the form factor are obvious — it’s a 1.2Ghz chip that turbos almost 2x as heat allows. In any dimension that it can do what you need, the Apple wins. Cheaper, faster, cooler, longer battery endurance. The detriments are the things it cannot do — run Windows/Linux or VMs or tasks that need more memory than is currently available.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- txdv 6y agolinux is comming
- rsfinn 6y agoIt can't run Intel-based OSs or VMs, of course, but the latest version of Parallels Desktop runs ARM-based Linux guests on M1 Macs, as well as the Windows 10 ARM preview. (VMware has implied that the next release of Fusion will support Apple silicon as well.)
- _kbh_ 6y agoQEMU already supports x86_64 on Apple silicon. It was just slow last time I checked not sure of the performance now.
- Rhedox 6y agoAs far as I know, besides the generating slow code, qemu also does not support multi threading when emulating strong memory ordering architectures (x86) on weak hosts (ARM).