3 ms·
There is a level of confidence in your post which is wholly unwarranted given how complicated the human body is. There is no design committee at work here, nobo
by roenxi 6y ago
There is a level of confidence in your post which is wholly unwarranted given how complicated the human body is. There is no design committee at work here, nobody is telling any body what the bits are supposed to do. It is all evolutionary equilibriums. The point of this drug is to shut the coronavirus down to the point where it cannot restart; it is not at all out of the question that something obscure but important in the human body uses the same mechanism and would similarly be permanently disabled.
New technologies are all very well, but this is not the sort of approach that should be rolled out in an emergency. If someone has 10 years of safety data from some trial and can put their hand on their heart to swear there are no suspicions of a problem then that is one thing, but otherwise there is no way this approach is safe for an emergency mass deployment. It probably won't be relevant for the current pandemic.
- ithkuil 6y agoNot disagreeing on the caution angle. But, let's imagine we find, by the usual trial and error, a chemical compound whose effects are that of curing patients from the coronavirus. Trials show that it has some rare side effects, like many other drugs. How much do we need to "understand" its first, second and third (and fourth) order effects before deciding to use it?
- roenxi 6y agoIn this case it is using an unproven mechanism that requires proof of a negative ("nothing important in the body uses this mechanism"). It cannot be done safely and quickly. Just because someone survives 12 months and feels fine doesn't tell us anything about the safety of that mechanism. We could literally be injecting people with HIV and it'd only be showing "rare side effects" for the first 12 months as far as symptoms go.
- xorfish 6y agoI don't think that the idea is to disable it forever.
- roenxi 6y agoIf we disable oxygen to the lungs for 30 minutes then switching it back on doesn't help. The lung owner is probably dead. Some of this stuff causes permanent changes. There is reason to be optimistic, because if for it to be really bad then there'd need to be: * Permanent change * Causing negative symptoms * Which took a long time to be symptomatic (which, coincidentally, HIV/AIDS exposure is a great example of) Now if frameskipping supressing drugs are something we expose people to as a matter of course then very well, probably would work out great. But if this is new then it is absolutely not safe to do a mass rollout in the next decade. There are obvious risks.
- Clostridium 6y agoThere are always risks, and ignoring a novel approach is also a risk. The issue is to gauge risk intelligently, based on extensive prior medical, biological and physicochemical knowledge and modelling, and on sound clinical testing using randomized controlled trials (the kind of trial that proved dexametasone and disproved ivermectin, hydroxyquinoline etc. as a therapeutic for covid).
- pessimizer 6y agoAnd the final step, declaring that disabling a cell mechanism cannot possibly have long term effects.
- ithkuil 6y agomy point was: in this case we know this is an unproven mechanism; because we are designing a drug that makes use of a mechanism. But we're using empirically discovered drugs since forever, where we had no idea on how the thing even supposed to act, let alone the consequence of this action.
- avereveard 6y agoEmpirical drugs also came from an age where the alternative was cutting the part that hurt and hoping for the best. You have to do better than the alternatives, and it was easier at a time when alternatives had 60% mortality. That said, this could be a good alternative than straight up dying for those in critical conditions. It would however tell us nothing about its safety, as people in critical condition have some deal of damage taken by the coronavirus itself and it'll be hard to control for each secondary effects.
- Clostridium 6y agoCorona virus exploiting frame shifting using a pseudoknot is not a at all unproven, has been known and researched since 2005
- sokoloff 6y agoIf it cures COVID-19 patients, you can use that drug on exactly those people whose case is severe enough to justify the risk. Many chemotherapy drugs have terrible side-effects. We break people’s ribs from CPR all the time. No one argues we should stop breaking those ribs as that’s a fairly easy balance to strike versus a vaccine that you give prophylactically to healthy people. Far more caution is warranted there. (This article is about a therapeutic drug concept, meaning it’s the former case, but I’d still argue caution and where traditional supportive and therapeutic measures are working, I’d not rush to use this mechanism on mild cases.)
- Clostridium 6y agoAu contraire, this is exactly the thing that we should look into in an emergency! RNA-slippage is a well-known mechanism that a healthy cell has safeguards against. The corona virus exploits this slippage, so disabling it using a drug is a novel and smart approach as this presents a likely very specific attack surface (meaning side-effects will likely be few). Ignoring this mechanism would be very imprudent. What makes you think the usual precautions (cell lines, animal models, phase I, II, III trials) will not be taken as per usual?
- roenxi 6y ago> What makes you think the usual precautions (cell lines, animal models, phase I, II, III trials) will not be taken as per usual? You've skipped one of the usual phases, which is Phase IV trials. Cell lines -> Phases III trials aren't enough to catch long term side effects, because they are all done quickly. An experimental mechanism passing Phase III trials is insufficient to prove it is safe. It proves that any negative events aren't evident quickly. The drug will probably prove to be safe in time, and I don't mind if people want to take that risk, I'm pretty free market. But it is, nevertheless, risky. We can't be confident that the body isn't using the same trick somewhere or somehow for something delicate that breaks quickly and shows symptoms slowly - biology is complex. If the mechanism is novel then it wouldn't be suitable for a mass rollout to deal with this pandemic.
- Clostridium 6y agoPhase IV trials are only undertaken after formal approval by FDA and EDA; they are not relevant in the current context. The current vaccins (including Pfizer, moderna which clearly use a novel mechanism for delivery) also don't have phase IV data yet. Thank God they have been approved though, they are currently clearly the way out of a pandemic that so far has claimed 3.4 million deaths. I really don't understand what you on about, sorry.
- Kiro 6y agoYou are allowed to raise concerns without being labeled an antivaxxer.
- flybrand 6y ago> There is a level of confidence in your post which is wholly unwarranted given how complicated the human body is. Thank you for saying this, there is a great deal of over confidence bias in the approach to this virus.
- simion314 6y agoCould be a possible treatment that would have only temporary effect. So after the treatment is done the things would return to normal, this could be tested for and give you peace of mind.