6 ms·
Working from Home for Some Threatens Mass Transit for All
- mlom 6y agotail wagging the dog
- giorgioz 6y agoAlso sales of cars have strongly decreased during the pandemic. Transportation in general has decreased. The article seems hell-bent on having people using mass-transportation. Mass transportation is a tool to an end. If we have a lot of hammers because we used to nail a lot of things, and now we don't, we shouldn't try to force people to use hammers just for the sake of using them.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoIf sales of cars decrease because using cars less there might be an uptick in use of mass transport, because it might not be cost effective to buy a car instead of taking a bus a couple times a month.
- ddingus 6y agoInvest in mass transportation, as well as walkable communities and more people will use it. But, everything costs something. There are externalities too. Which is it? Sell more cars, take those externalities, or live leaner, gamble on the economics working out differently and that being OK? Someone is gonna lose. Could be a lot of us losing, or maybe not, depending.
- pmoriarty 6y agoAnother option is transforming our communities to build workspaces closer to where people live instead of requiring long commutes to get to work. The documentary "The End of Suburbia" talked about this possibility: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3uvzcY2Xug https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3uvzcY2Xug
- ddingus 6y agoYes, I agree. Part of walkable should include work where possible. I have lived a scenario similar to the one we are sketching out here and it was great! Live, work, play... I also had the airport available. Could walk out my front door and end up on the other coast that same day.
- Der_Einzige 6y agoThis is not true!!! Demand for cars is at all time highs and car prices are also at all time highs...
- theandrewbailey 6y agoCar demand hasn't changed much, but there's fewer new cars being made right now. Less supply means higher prices.
- foobiter 6y agodo you have a source for the decline in car sales? seems like they’re up in many places as people avoid using public transport
- adrianN 6y agoOr, crazy idea, we just don't require mass transit to produce a profit and continue to reshape our cities so that mass transit, cycling, and walking become more attractive.
- burntoutfire 6y ago> just don't require mass transit to produce a profit Was it ever profitable in USA? Here in Poland, the income from tickets usually only cover below 50% of the costs, while the rest comes from subsidies.
- TingPing 6y agoNo. However its an excuse used here to not invest in it sometimes.
- HonestOp001 6y agoHow do you propose to evaluate success of a transit route? How do we evaluate trade off options. In California, they are wasting billions on high speed rail, Hawaii cannot finish its elevated circulator because of incompetence. These are pushed as benefits for all, yet, if we took that money and bought the needy a Prius instead, with a ten year life cycle, are the people better off? When we talk of just making transit free, there is no talk of what’s the alternative to the environment if we just enable people to drive by getting them a car. Rail is a waste, China even admits to it off the books. Look at how much expressway / freeway they have build and how they are slowing / stopping high speed rail projects. Transit is great when it is constantly evaluated for getting people from point to point. However, because of political issues (I want a large bus to make it appear my neighborhood is respected, when there are only two riders per day on it or I want a train stop near my house not near where all the users are at) we end up with less than optimal effects.
- adrianN 6y agoThe same way you evaluate the success of a road.
- 6y ago
- nathias 6y agoGreat, the pandemic showed that relying on centralized mass transit is a mistake and we should rethink the way we're doing public transit.
- adrianN 6y agoLet's all move into reinforced bunkers underground, WW2 showed that building cities above ground was a mistake.
- nathias 6y agoWell yes, we abandoned cities when they were being bombed, and would abandon them forever if the bombing was continuous and forever.
- SirSourdough 6y agoSo why does a temporary and rare event like the pandemic require a total overhaul of transit?
- nathias 6y agoBecause it's very sensitive to any event, and if you were completely dependent on mass public transit you now understand exactly how bad this is.
- chadcmulligan 6y agoWhy do trains have to make a profit but roads don't?
- thedrbrian 6y agoBut they do. I pay enough in road tax and fuel duty to cover the upkeep for the roads in the UK. Drivers here pay more than the government spends on the roads so the excess goes elsewhere. Ego the roads are profitable.
- tolbish 6y agoHow much tax money goes towards your roads vs your public transit system in the UK?
- stevesimmons 6y agoI pay enough in income tax to cover the upkeep for public transport in the UK. E(r)go everything is ok. Also, my spending on public transport reduces congestion on the roads. Drivers therefore get cross-subsidised. When will drivers reimburse me for that?
- dijit 6y agoJust a nitpick: road tax doesn’t go to roads. It’s just put into the pot for general things. Your road tax is most likely paying for Pensions and the NHS. Primarily. Normally council taxes are what cover roads, whatever can’t be covered by local council taxes is taken from the big pot, but only after civil servants at the local and national level bicker about it for a few years first.
- rnd0 6y agoWhy should roads have to make a profit?
- chadcmulligan 6y agoOther way round, they're a shared resource just like trains, but no one says roads should make a profit.
- clarge1120 6y agoThe word “threatens” gives the impression of something dangerous going on with remote work. It may be motivated by click traffic, but seems hyperbolic. The quantity of transport vehicles can be reduced to a point where it is in alignment with current needs. There are other ideas better than that. This isn’t a scary outcome waiting to happen.
- freakynit 6y agoAre tax dollars not enough for public services? If not, where are those dollars going? People giving away 40% of their earnings, and still are required to burden themselves with providing profits for public services.
- pizzazzaro 6y agoPublic transit isnt a thing you do to profit your city directly. You do it so people can participate enough to grow your tax base. There is no public transport system on earth which remains profitable for long. In fact, that would defeat the purpose! Such profit would add too much transactional friction, discouraging riders. The goal is cleaner cities and less clogged roads. The goal is enlarging the tax base with increased access. Paid parking at the metro? Pfft, guess Im driving, and adding to the parking-clog. We're too big to be an overgrown suburb like this, but I guess that's what we are.
- mouzogu 6y agoAm I the only one who treats headlines like this as rentier fud? I'm seeing an increase in these types of wfh is bad articles in the mainstream media.
- valdiorn 6y agomeanwhile, it's brought the UK rail system back from a near breaking point to something that might be a manageable level for the future. Ferrying 5 million people into and back out of London was not a long term solution. People are commuting up to 50 miles to get to work in London, and the platforms and the system have all been at saturation for several years now. With the reduction in use we might get back to a sane level of utilisation, where I won't have to stand up, squished between 20 other people on my 2x45 minute journeys to and from London.
- SirSourdough 6y agoIt seems premature to be claiming that people won’t return to transit given that in many major cities life is decidedly not back to normal, and mass transit seems like it would be about the last thing to bounce back. Events and in-person work are some of the biggest drivers of transit use and are still majorly curtailed, at least here in Canada.