10 ms·
How Lucky Is Too Lucky in Minecraft?
- TameAntelope 6y agoI hate, immensely, how effective "double down and never admit guilt" is, but I don't think there's anything we can do about it as a society. Thank goodness most people don't have the guts to hold firm long enough to get away with it...
- ripper1138 6y agoSeems like the only benefit to admitting guilt is for ones own conscience, but clearly that’s not enough for many.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoour society is also not structured anymore to allowing one to admit guilt, and be absolved by some sort of community process after which you can return to a normal life; if you are guilty now you are forever cursed.
- chaorace 6y agoI think that's because, thanks to the internet, "now" never truly ends. You're often just one Google search away from reanimating any significant event in someone else's life.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoright, hence right to be forgotten laws in some places.
- smogcutter 6y agoWhen was it structured that way? Serious question - I generally believe the same thing, but looking at it from the outside I’m finding it hard to reach a worthwhile example.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoAs chaorace above you suggested, it was so structured by the arrival of the technology to keep track of everything you ever did that was bad and put it online for future reference. The tendency to do it was already in place, it is likely that you see someone from high school that was a jerk and you think that jerk once did this, even if it was 15 years ago. That's a sort of normal human tendency. Some people are so notorious for rather innocuous things that they are outcast - Monica Lewinsky is an obvious example - I believe she was ostracized for a little more than a decade. Legally there is already the habit of judging people unfit for crimes, even if they have served their time. American society is structured to make people with felony convictions harder to employ. Now add in technology and imagine being able to treat anyone you have never met like that jerk in High School forever. The final step of structuring is then provided by people who can see ways to profit off of the fact that people who have done non felonious things might still have done things that society will find objectionable, and that the technology exists to keep this in people's eyes.
- smogcutter 6y agoI agree with you, but that’s a subtly different claim than that we used to have a community process (or ritual, but that’s adding some baggage) for forgiveness/reintegration that has since been lost. Not having the technology that creates a social record is different than actively forgiving and forgetting.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agowell the community process thing is sort of a more complicated thing - some argue that the old process of putting people in the stocks / public humiliation was a more humane way of treating people because they then paid their debt and could be reintegrated. Not saying I agree but the argument at any rate is there was a community process. I am at any rate open to the possibility that this was a good aspect of a system that in many other ways was bad. If so that community process was destroyed and replaced with a system that would never forgive you for your transgressions. However the system was imperfect and thus people could move, reinvent themselves and reintegrate themselves by exploiting the imperfections. Technology is now working to remove this capability. So it was not that the community process was removed by the arrival of technology, it was removed and later the technology arrived to strengthen what had been put in its place - creating a system in which transgressions and punishments are eternal.
- branko_d 6y agoThere are great benefits for the society, and dare I say species. Conscience, after all, is not an accident. Its a product of our evolution. We lived in small groups for most of our existence, and the very survival of the group was tied pretty directly to how well the group members worked together. Lying had consequences for a group that would not make lying have consequences for an individual. The problems is that we now live in groups much larger than anything we experienced before.
- coddle-hark 6y ago> Conscience, after all, is not an accident. Its a product of our evolution. We lived in small groups for most of our existence, and the very survival of the group was tied pretty directly to how well the group members worked together. Lying had consequences for a group that would not make lying have consequences for an individual. Be careful making assumptions like this. I mean, you're right, having a conscience is a product of our evolution... but so is the ability to lie. You make it sound like disadvantageous qualities would be filtered out by evolution but that is clearly not the case.
- branko_d 6y agoIt's a balance between the (evolutionary) advantage for of the group vs the advantage for the individual. Some lying may be beneficial for the individual as long as it doesn't harm the group too much. Lie too much though, and the group gets less likely to survive as a whole, meaning individuals within the group are less likely to survive as well.
- simonh 6y agoFor most of us there are only a handful of people we need to maintain our credibility with personally or professionally. Once it’s gone, it’s gone.
- imtringued 6y agoYeah, it's a game of numbers. When you have 22 million subscribers and half of them don't trust you anymore, then you still have 11 million subscribers.
- codeflo 6y agoThat’s a pessimistic way to put it, but you have a point. This depends on the target audience though. Some people seem unable to be convinced by hard evidence and reason. If you’re able to pick your audience — which is the case for content creators and politicians — you will always be able to address those people. In most professional settings, you’re more dependent on the goodwill of someone specific, and I think there the strategy is less effective.
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoIn this case it wasn't so much that Dream chose his audience, but that his audience is primarily impressionable young kids. I looked through the Reddit threads that got posted around the time this happened and there were clearly a lot of young people who either chose to believe Dream because they didn't understand the statistics well enough to know it was BS, or were trying to rationalize that Dream was innocent based on some weird logic.
- codeflo 6y agoThat’s mostly my point though, if “doubling down” works best with impressionable, unreasonable (in this case, young) people, then the strategy limits you to that audience.
- numpad0 6y agoCould something like that possibly be a requirement for a self-sustaining life? Like you can’t be both alive and reasonable?
- reedf1 6y agoIt seems like this strategy didn't work so well in the past - do we know the reason why?
- michaelt 6y agoPerhaps politicians lying is business as usual, and it only seems to have increased because society gradually forgets things as they recede into history. Just in the past the lie was "Iraq was behind 9/11 and has WMDs" or "The war in Vietnam is important to fight and easy to win"
- thanatos519 6y agoIt's troubling when individuals do this, but I find it especially brutal that "double down and never admit guilt" is the go-to strategy for most nation states and corporations.
- vinw 6y agoWhat is a "nation state"? edit: Wikipedia says there are around 20 nation states. I don't know why you're picking those out specifically though.
- infimum 6y agolmgtfy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation_state
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 6y agoThe rest of the world would call "country", but American govspeak has decided to call "nation state" for some weird reason.
- bonoboTP 6y agoThe English language is horribly ambiguous and confused around words like nation, state, nation state, country, nationality, citizenship, ethnicity, race etc.
- pjc50 6y agoYes, but I've not seen an explanation of which useful cases are covered by "nation state" but not by "country" or even better "government". I don't think it even solves the problem of countries which cause other people to get mad if you acknowledge their existence (Taiwan, Palestine) Meanwhile, does "nation state" apply to the Plurinational State of Bolivia?
- SilkRoadie 6y agoDeception can be planned or opportunistic. In this case, Dream planned to deceive people by tweaking game randomness. It is impossible to justify when hundreds of people are following the rules. This is why people double down. You mostly see apologies when opportunity got the best of judgement.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wexq 6y agoThe article recommends watching the video by Matt Parker, and so do I. Great refresher on probability (or luck, if you will) For convenience: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ko3TdPy0TU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ko3TdPy0TU
- geoduck14 6y agoFor those who don't want to watch the video: He totally cheated
- torvald 6y agoI wonder how kubernetes do.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI'm not going to invest 40m watching the new video because I couldn't care less - but Dream hired a statistician to debunk the numbers in the first video. I can believe he's cheating but I don't consider it probable. Dream's success doesn't come from record settings, so I don't think he has any incentive to cheat. If anything, I believe more the allegations that his manhunt videos are staged, given that's the interesting content. He makes money by creating long and entertaining videos (about modded Minecraft and his insane reflexes). This ticks off the YouTube algorithm which measures how much of a video viewers watch and how much time they watch a channel, contributing to exponential growth. On top of this, Minecraft fans are a niche that lives on YouTube. Dream never became popular because of his speed records, he gained initial traction by creating content on PewDiePie (an infinitely more popular YouTuber). This is exploiting the YouTube's algorithm which recommends videos: by talking about someone famous you'll eventually end up being recommended to their huge user base.
- chmod775 6y ago> I'm not going to invest 40m watching the new video because I couldn't care less Going by the rest of your comment, you would've learned something.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoAs I mentioned, I can very well believe he's cheating, I don't need to be convinced. I can tick the box in my head which says dream is cheating - but it's not a smart move from where is standing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cycomanic 6y agoWell you should watch the video, because it's a great video and explains very well why it's essentially impossible for dream to have achieved his results. Your opinion if it makes sense or not really doesn't matter. To give the gist to everyone (still watch the video, it's well worth it), if all 10 billion people on earth would be playing minecraft for every second (actually playing the whole speedrun in 1s, but that's details), for 100 years. The chance of his result happening to any one human is 1/1000. Alternatively, dreams result is 10 orders of magnitude less unlikely to have happened than the next "lucky" event that happened which was in craps.
- nottorp 6y agoWhy would you speed run a game about making huge builds that take years anyway?
- gizmo 6y agoYoutube should ban cheating channels altogether. You can make over a million, get caught cheating, face no punishment, and can continue to rake it in. Fix the incentive.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoBut why though? If I make a YouTube channel where I break world records in various sports by using some banned equipment and people want to watch it, who says that’s bad? I agree it’s not honest if I tell people that I’m not using equipment but YouTube can’t be verifying everything a video says. I actually do thinking they should do more manual quality control but that’s for actually harmful content. If Microsoft and YouTube had an agreement that this sort of thing is not allowed then fine, but that’s not practical I think.
- faeriechangling 6y agoI've had other people bring this up and they framed it in this wavering "Well maybe he cheated, maybe he didn't, but it was suspicious" kind of way. The idea that Dream was NOT playing on a rigged version of Minecraft is so astronomically unlikely as to be ludicrous. People go to prison based on far far less reasonable doubt, if be consider dream innocent we may as well let everybody out of jail, since they could be innocent too. The most likely way I can imagine he was innocent is if a third party broke into his computer, manipulated the RNG, and never told him, but regardless his speedrun record cannot stand. I'm not really concerned with the cheating at Minecraft. I'm more concerned at how easy it is to convince people of reasonable doubt where none exists.
- flaubere 6y agoI can only imagine the reaction of all prisoners in large Federal corrections institutions if one sunny morning they are lined up and processing for the release of every single inmate starts to take place. "What's going on, officer?" "Supreme court just ruled on the Minecraft speedrun case." "What's that?" "This Youtube asshole got sued for playing a video game or something. I don't know. Hughes, what was it?" "He mined a diamond on his second try." "This asshole mined a diamond on his second try. Now all youse are getting released." "So what's going on, we're gonna get a retrial or something?" "Nah. Everyone here is going home." The release of all incarcerated felons in the United States passes off almost without incident, although police leave in Chicago is cancelled after several homicides in the downtown area on a single night. These are believed to involve released prisoners, but this was never confirmed. Pawnshops and liquor stores in several areas of the country hire extra security for the following week after viral WhatsApp messages warn of a crime wave, but the expected spike in criminal behavior never takes place. On the afternoon of the second day of releases two Marshalls and a adjunct professor of mathematics get out of a rented car outside FCI Marion, having flown to Chicago from the nation's capital. They are too late to stop the release of the man convicted of ripping off the 'McDonald's Monopoly' lottery game. A numerate intern at the DoJ noticed late on the first 'release day' that the chance of every single large award in the fast food prize draw between 1995 and 2000 being won by one person's associates or family members, technically exceeded the new probabilistic standard for reasonable doubt. They are ten minutes too late, the fraudster having departed by Uber. For the first time in its history the FBI Most Wanted list consists of a single name, for nine days until his recapture at Canadian border. The email alerting prison staff to his upheld conviction had been sent to the email address of a recently retired prison officer, a fact cited in his retrial as evidence that "he's just a lucky guy, you know?"
- skocznymroczny 6y agoHmm, depends on the definition of speedrun. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SasazfBr5_Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SasazfBr5_Y there are speedruns of Diablo 1 like this, and most people wouldn't consider this a fair speedrun because the maps generated are always optimal and have the stairs down right next to the stairs up.
- bigwavedave 6y ago> Hmm, depends on the definition of speedrun. > https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SasazfBr5_Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SasazfBr5_Y there are speedruns of Diablo 1 like this, and most people wouldn't consider this a fair speedrun because the maps generated are always optimal and have the stairs down right next to the stairs up. While there are definitely different speedrunning categories where glitching and modding are allowed, the category Dream was speedrunning was v1.16 Random Seed Glitchless, so there's not much ambiguity about what would and wouldn't disqualify a run.
- jmchuster 6y agoI would recommend Karl Jobst's video for those who are interested in this topic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8TlTaTHgzo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8TlTaTHgzo He is a very experienced speedrunner who has done a lot of videos about both speedrunning records and cheating, and as such, has a great section in his Dream video better explaining the thought process behind why top speedrunners cheat.
- Scaless 6y agoAnyone who even remotely looked at the numbers and followed the situation can tell Dream cheated. The only people I see claiming otherwise are either infatuated with his cult of personality or otherwise just don't give a shit, "It's just a kids game who cares"? I care. I am heavily invested in speedrunning culture, but myself am mostly involved in the Halo community. I have a couple of world records of my own, and I also do routing and other technical things for the community. Halo has its own long history of cheaters, many of whom were also pivotal founders of the community. In the wider speedrunning scene there are many examples of similar situations. I do not think that speedrunning necessarily has a higher percentage of cheaters, if you compare against other competitive sports and activities the rates would likely be comparable. But that number is far from zero. I am working on developing TAS (Tool-Assisted Speedrun) tools for the Halo games. With the tools you can create frame-perfect recreations of gameplay that are indistinguishable from actual play. I am honestly at a stand-still on whether I should ever publicly release a working version of the tools. The main worry is that the tools will be used to submit "fake" runs passed off as human gameplay. I have built in basic safeguards to deter the most basic cheaters, little things that you would never see as a casual player but if you know what to look for would stand out in a video. But there is always the chance a sophisticated user could reverse those changes and fly under the radar. On the one hand it could open a floodgate of awesome content, tricks, and discoveries. On the other it could potentially completely ruin the integrity of the leaderboards. I am quite conflicted on how to continue with this project if anyone has any insight that might be helpful.
- Olreich 6y agoI can already do this for most popular speed games, and it’s not a big problem. The TAS tools will help the community much more than they will hurt integrity.
- gvx 6y agoDisclaimer: I am not part of the community (for example: I wouldn't even have known about the Dream scandal if it weren't for the video by Matt Parker), so feel free to take my opinion with a bucket of salt. It might be an idea to decide as a community that the time of completely unassisted speedrun leaderboards has passed, and shift the competitive element of your community to technological advancements in TAS tools.
- afarviral 6y agoA few hot takes of mine: - Something small is throwing off someone's calculations ... Perhaps some small fact about the RNGs that is not common knowledge - I'm a 31 year old and followed the events and was thoroughly on Dreams side, and accepted his (handwavey despite hiring a math person) explanation, mostly on character and verisimilitude - The consensus of most people seems to be that he cheated and is a convincing liar, sort of a magician in a way - The fact his cheating is the crowd consensus among adults made me question my initial beliefs - I don't have time to go down the rabithole but I also don't really care if he cheated as his achievments as an entertainer stand alone. If he did cheat, he's just loveable scum In summary... He cheated?
- faeriechangling 6y agoLets put it this way. The RNG in Dream's version of Minecraft was acting so astronomically far outside of the norm, that we can't consider Dream's world record run as being valid. He was essentially playing a different game, and it would be absurd to give somebody a world record for the good fortune of playing on a busted version of Minecraft. The linked video is a response to the anonymous statistician associated with Dream. Now, I think there's one explanation that's more likely than others as to how Dream ended up playing on a rigged version of Minecraft.
- pityJuke 6y ago> Perhaps some small fact about the RNGs that is not common knowledge The MC speedrunning team reviewed the Minecraft RNG.
- olivierva 6y agoWhy not share the seed of the map? This in combination with the coordinates visible on screen would make it possible to check if there is cheating involved. It would be even better if the seed was generated and handed out by a trusted party. Do all the speed runs live and it would be quite hard to cheat.
- ORioN63 6y agoNo, it wouldn't. He is accused of cheated by messing the probabilities of Blaze drops and Piglin trading. The map seed is not related to either.
- njibhu 6y agoLoot rates are not related to the world seed. The problem here was that he modified loot rate tables. The world seed only matters for the world generation.
- robga 6y agoBBC's radio show More or Less did a great piece on this recently. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p09ch7qv https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p09ch7qv It is related to Matt Parker's youtube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ko3TdPy0TU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ko3TdPy0TU which has already been mentioned on this post.
- pdkl95 6y agoMinecraft speedruns are fun, but the HN crowd might enjoy the technical insanity of the 29.19 second TAS[1]. (explanation video: [2]) [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Wv_jJQ3XCE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Wv_jJQ3XCE [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5obPdgmaao https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5obPdgmaao
- Smithalicious 6y agoIs a bugged game ruled out here? There's no way this is luck, of course, but something in the technology stack not functioning properly and leading to this result sounds at least possible. Of course, cheating is still the far more likely explanation.
- fenomas 6y agoThat was my thought as well. He's known for trying out lots of wacky random mods, so one could imagine a case where he believes the runs were legit, but actually he had left a mod enabled by mistake, or similar. Or (much less plausibly), it's at least superficially possible that there could be some minecraft bug related to mod handling, such that his game client wasn't in a vanilla state even though he really had removed all non-standard mods.
- lovetocode 6y agoLet's say that this person did cheat. We can generally agree that cheating is not ethical. But what happens when their celebrity sits upon a foundation of lies and because of their celebrity they amassed some serious wealth. If they built such a large viewer base from cheating, is there any legal recourse here? Or will they be allowed to walk away with their bags of money and the mark of shame?
- rasz 6y agoWhat do you mean walk away? He is just getting started.
- rcxdude 6y agoProbably the biggest thing is he became famous from creating completely different videos. He didn't get his viewer base from cheating, he most likely cheated because he felt his skills deserved a good time but he didn't want to put in the grind which an RNG-heavy speedrun requires to get a good time. I recommend Karl Jobst's video on it, where he points out that skilled speedrunners don't cheat to get a better time, they cheat to get a good time faster.
- stevekemp 6y agoThis was covered by Karl Jobst, last year, in a clear and easy to understand fashion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8TlTaTHgzo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8TlTaTHgzo
- GauntletWizard 6y agoThe buried lede here is the 1960s game-show scandal; The fascinating story linked[1] within is far more interesting than the drama of Dream's cheating minecraft server. [1] https://www.closerweekly.com/posts/heres-what-happened-with-the-tv-quiz-show-scandal-of-the-1950s/ https://www.closerweekly.com/posts/heres-what-happened-with-...
- 8note 6y agoI don't see the point in tracking speed runs for a game that can be affected so heavily by luck Making these drop rates deterministic for speed running would solve this issue. Same with not using a random seed
- simonpatchin 6y agoHi, are you in search of how to get your ex lover back that broke up with you?... With the help of Lord Zakuza, you can get your ex partner back within 48 hours. WhatsApp and text him now via +1 740 573 9483 or you can send him email to Lordzakuza7@gmail.com for a permanent solution to your relationship problems.