4 ms·
Simply looking at the number value might be too surface level for this. The bay area has high wages because of the cost of living - due to the housing crisis an
by judge2020 6y ago
Simply looking at the number value might be too surface level for this. The bay area has high wages because of the cost of living - due to the housing crisis and overall pay required to live in the area, FAANG and non-FAANG alike pay more simply in order to have employees that can actually afford living somewhere within an hour of the city - and with remote work, companies are docking employee pay to more competitive rates if they move out of SF[0] (although, with Covid, every metropolitan area has began gravitating towards this issue[1]). While this might mean an overall higher standard of living and nicer cars, it isn't crazy and, after the mortgage, chances are it's closer to the SoL in other cities and possibly Australia.
0: https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-companies-cutting-salaries-outside-bay-area-twitter-facebook-vmware-2020-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-companies-cutting-salar...
1: https://www.zillow.com/home-values/ https://www.zillow.com/home-values/ (12% YoY for two years is scary).
- s17n 6y agoThis is backwards, the high cost of living in the bay area is a result of the high salaries (and the barriers to expanding the housing supply).
- bobthepanda 6y agoIt's not really backwards, it's a cycle that reinforces itself. House expensive -> salaries jump -> people have more money to pay for house -> house becomes more expensive. This is like arguing about the chicken or the egg. More housing supply would help to a point but it would take an order of magnitude change to make a dent in the current self-reinforcing cycle, and probably would need that level of increased production for a period of time.
- hardwaresofton 6y agoI'm no expert on the history of SV or your housing (I've never lived there, probably never will), but I thought the general story was something like this: 0. California existed 1. Government investment comes to the valley during the cold war in early SV companies 2. Innovation happens in leaps and bounds thanks to the government checkbook 3. Profit is made hand over fist by some people/groups/entities 4. People/groups/entities from (3) buy more of everything 5. More People & entities come in search of interesting ideas/cutting edge technology/profit/fame/etc 6. return to (3)
- bobthepanda 6y agoDepending on how far back you want to go 1 isn't even really the start of it. Stanford was founded by Leland Stanford, the robber baron who owned the Central Pacific, which built the transcontinental railroad. This has more or less been the cycle since the Gold Rush.
- imtringued 6y agoYou got it completely backwards. The maximum possible salary doesn't change because of more expensive housing, only your ability to negotiate for a salary rise does. Therefore expensive housing will let you get the maximum possible salary at most. There is a self reinforcing cycle but it has nothing to do with housing. You're saying that expensive housing is the only factor in salaries which is completely wrong. The self reinforcing cycle is that developer salaries rise in Silicon Valley, people start moving there, which kicks out existing residents. You can enact rent control and rent prices will stay the same but you still end up kicking people out because nobody is building anything. The reason why it is self reinforcing is that developers living in close proximity results in agglomeration effects, each additional developer makes every other developer more productive.
- bobthepanda 6y agoIt doesn't really matters that all salaries don't jump the same way. It matters that someone whose salary jumped can still pay more for a house. I've never claimed that rent control works. But house prices would not keep rising if no one had the salary to afford the mortgage. People still do, they're just all concentrated in the one profession, and due to bumper results they can demand more. You probably couldn't negotiate SV level salaries in, say, Tulsa, and pretty much every large company I have heard of expanding remote work is doing so with geographically adjusted pay downwards from SV. (I never really got the angle of people who thought they would get to have their cake and eat it too with SV-level salary and dirt-cheap COL; employers aren't blind.)
- s17n 6y agoIt is true that higher housing costs lead to labor scarcity which leads to higher salaries, and also that employers do cost of living adjustments, but these effects are small compared to the core "companies offer higher salaries to attract the best talent -> housing becomes more expensive" driver.
- bobthepanda 6y agoAnd housing factors in offering the higher salaries to attract the best talent. It takes a lot of money to eventually buy property in the Bay Area and if you manage to apply to companies there unaware of that fact you probably literally live under a rock.
- unishark 6y agoIf pay is increased solely to compensate for house prices, then working in a higher cost of living area is still better because the job buys you a more valuable house. Imagine if house prices were a non-issue because companies just give you a free house when you start. Would you consider still the job in a cheap housing area equal? Anyway at the senior levels the pay is even more stupid high in SV, way more than anything you'd need to live on. How high do salaries go in Australia?
- nsonha 6y agoindividual contributors top at around 140k (AUD180k package), but the 90% tops at 128k which is a "tech lead salary". I don't have the experience to tell how high tech leads go, but I'm guessing 200k. Some outliers are Optiver (a prop trading firm) paying 160k (half of which is bonus) and Google paying (up to I heard) 125k to grads. However the number of companies like that in Australia you could count on one hand (Amazon, Atlassian, Canva), so there is nothing to drive average salary up like in SV. RSU is way less common. There are also cases of double standards such as companies founded in Australia expanding to the US offers way better perks and RSU to US staff but stop offering RSU to new Australian hires.