13 ms·
This feels like a propaganda piece written by a wealthy person trying to convince you, a not wealthy person, that you shouldn't support higher taxes on the weal
by jedberg 6y ago
This feels like a propaganda piece written by a wealthy person trying to convince you, a not wealthy person, that you shouldn't support higher taxes on the wealthy because they are just doing it to prevent you from being as wealthy as they are.
There is no evidence presented.
I know a couple of billionaires. None of them are even trying to get richer. Their investments are all made in an attempt to make the world a better place, from their point of view. Getting richer is just a side effect of that. They want higher taxes because they think wealth inequality is bad, but they know that if they just give away their own money, it won't solve the problem, because there needs to be systemic changes forcing everyone to give their money away, otherwise the people who aren't giving their money away will just collect it from the ones that are, via middle class and poor intermediaries.
- Pfhreak 6y ago100% my read too. The fact that the author doesn't make an effort to identify which taxes is a signal that they aren't really being truthful.
- roenxi 6y agoThe article is trying to provide a framework for why it is that very wealthy people might be vocal supporters of taxes. The observations you are making of your billionaire friends are more specific but broadly in line with the reality the article is arguing for; so it isn't obvious what more evidence you need. EDIT And any billionaire who says getting rich is a side effect is lying to someone. Possibly themselves. A billion dollars has never happened by accident.
- jedberg 6y agoNo, getting richer is a side effect. They very much intended to get rich to make the first billion. It's the investments after that that aren't intended for wealth building, but are intended to fund things they think make the world better. > The article is trying to provide a framework for why it is that very wealthy people might be vocal supporters of taxes. And I'm saying that it's wrong. They are vocal for higher taxes because they know that higher taxes reduce wealth inequality, and we know that inequality is bad for economic growth. But they also know that they can't just give their own money away to solve inequality, because then the people who aren't giving it away will just collect what they give away.
- roenxi 6y ago> ...and we know that inequality is bad for economic growth... If I look at a list of top billionaires [0] all the American ones are men who are poster children of driving enormous economic growth, and frequently a great deal of social good. Bezos, for example & picking the top, is responsible for rewiring and modernising a big chunk of the worlds logistic systems in a way that was not going to happen if he had been taxed into oblivion. The problem is the ossification of the upper class; and that is promoted far more by governments bailouts such as seen after the '07 financial crisis, or as will probably surface when people have time to go over what actually happened in the emergency COVID spending. Protecting idiots while they are in charge of the financial system is a much bigger drag on growth than the existence of wealthy people. Now if we were to talk about stopping those sort of welfare-for-wealthy-people policies then I'm sure we all agree. But taxes are a different policy, they imply we keep going with the welfare and then guess where it landed to try and take it back. I don't buy that the democratic process can handle that level of precision. Trying to tax billionaires out of existence while the existing ones enjoy a great deal of government support for the financial status quo is exactly the sort of kick-out-the-ladder behaviour the article would lead us to predict for people in quadrant 4 of the article's graph (which is where you're describing them). I'll even go as far as guessing they probably support policies that bring the US into line with Europe - because that is what the article would predict. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_World%27s_Billionaires#202...
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoBezos is also responsible for creating a new precariat who can only do their jobs by pissing into bottles because they aren't allowed the basic humanity to look after their needs. If you're going to try to persuade me this is a good thing and not a Hobbesian nightmare, you're not going to succeed. This isn't just about taxes. This is about humanism vs financial authoritarianism. It's also about the fact that the world was both more stable and more obviously prosperous when tax rates were much higher. Economies are supposed to be prosperity factories for everyone to enjoy, and not just billionaire factories for a few extremely privileged individuals whose wealth exists because they've placed unacceptable financial and personal burdens on the people who work for them.
- wernercd 6y ago"a billion never happened by accident" Being successful isn't an accident. Why should people feel bad for being THAT successful? Going to be a great world where success like that is "punished" in the name of "equality" or "equity"
- strken 6y agoI agree, but they also have a point about taxing inheritance or wealth and not just income.
- throw123123123 6y agoIf you need everyone else to do it for you to want to do it, you don't want to do it.
- iamgopal 6y agoIt is about solving a problem, not a race about who want to do it. Wealth inequality is the problem. Even uneven distribution of loan/debt is a problem.
- wernercd 6y agoand there is no solution to it. Why? because there's uneven skills, uneven effort, uneven luck, uneven work ethic, etc, etc, etc. As long as humans are involved... in all human history, in all societies, in all things there has been inequality and no effort so far has had any affect on it. In fact, most efforts have made it worse across the board. Socialism and communism are failed experiments with a 100 years of history as proof.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- namdnay 6y ago> In fact, most efforts have made it worse across the board Have they? Most social democracies seem to be going along fine. There is a sliding scale between Hayek and Marx you know.. it’s not a binary choice
- wernercd 6y agoInequality still exists and is growing worldwide... so I'd say... Yes. And the harder its pushed for "equality", the more it turns into bad times. "binary" I never said it was... I said increasing efforts generally trend towards increasingly bad consequences - and we are talking about pushes to end "inequality" in this chain of conversation... the harder the pushes, the worse the outcomes. At no point in any society has inequality been removed.
- qPM9l3XJrF 6y ago>A couple of years ago, former Obama and Bush officials estimated that only 1 percent of government spending is backed by any evidence at all. 1 percent. Perhaps unsurprisingly, then, evaluations of government-sponsored school and work programs have found that some three-quarters of those have no effect. https://www.vox.com/2015/1/19/7628801/obama-evidence-based-policy https://www.vox.com/2015/1/19/7628801/obama-evidence-based-p... As a billionaire, you're much better off donating your money to highly effective charities than lobbying the government to tax other billionaires so it will use the money from that to build bombs.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoGiven the sums of money involved, no. You're better off lobbying for taxes AND evidence based policy.
- gibrown 6y agoThat 1% seemed kinda off to me. The original article is kinda weird: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/07/can-government-play-moneyball/309389/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2013/07/can-gov... One example they cite is healthcare being more then 50% spent in treatments that don’t work. But they don’t say it is Medicare and Medicaid treatments. Even if it is Medicare+Medicaid alone is 38% of the budget, so it sounds like at least 14% or so is effective rather than just 1%.
- qPM9l3XJrF 6y agoSure, but the sad thing to me here is that no one even seems to care much about this. Note these articles are both from over 5 years ago. We aren't even capable of having that level of discussion nowadays. Our federal government is projected to spend $5.8 trillion in 2021 alone. The entire Gates fortune is $124 billion. And yet Gates probably does more for the world's poorest -- the federal government is overwhelmingly focused on serving Americans -- globally speaking, mostly wealthy white people: https://howrichami.givingwhatwecan.org/how-rich-am-i https://howrichami.givingwhatwecan.org/how-rich-am-i What good is being done with that $5.8 trillion exactly? Is the federal government with its military interventionism, agricultural subsidies, etc. really doing 1000x as much good annually as the Gates Foundation? (The annual budget of the Gates Foundation is around 0.1% as large, at around $5 billion.) The failed F-35 stealth fighter project alone has a total cost estimated at $1.7 trillion. Note that this has received almost no coverage. Defense contractors milk the federal government like there's no tomorrow and it doesn't get any attention because mentioning it doesn't serve either party's political goals. Suppose we hypothetically took the entire Gates fortune and added it to the federal budget, so the government spends $5.9 trillion this year instead of $5.8 trillion. Would you even notice? How would you expect the $5.9 trillion budget world to be different from a $5.8 trillion budget world? I'm pretty sure that people in developing countries will miss the work done by the Gates Foundation a heck of a lot more than already-wealthy Americans will appreciate another $0.1 trillion in the federal budget. Using evidence to focus on the most effective possible programs for helping the world's poorest goes a long way, and unfortunately the vast majority of the federal government's spending is not that. Increasing taxes on rich people isn't gonna change that. Before plowing more money into ineffective federal spending, we should first make it effective. "It's ok to waste trillions, the important thing is for us to feel really egalitarian about it"
- cscurmudgeon 6y ago> that you shouldn't support higher taxes on the wealthy because they are just doing it to prevent you from being as wealthy as they are. > There is no evidence presented. That is fair game when most arguments for the opposite are also presented without any evidence.
- anovikov 6y agoCan someone explain why wealth inequality is bad? Social exclusion is terribly bad and must be fought at all costs, true. Consumption/income-measured, absolute poverty is bad in all or almost all cases - true, we could probably afford sacrificing some of the economic efficiency to eradicate it. Relative consumption/income-measured poverty is not "bad" as long as it rises with overall income levels rising faster. And wealth... why do poor people need any wealth at all? If anything, in socialist-ish, European countries most people don't have any wealth at all, they own nothing, they live for generations in regulated rental apartment - that regulated rental contract they can pass as inheritance is their biggest (although intangible) asset. They don't need any "wealth" - government covers all their risks and funds their healthcare, unemployment, education and retirement and they can literally live hand to mouth all their life and don't feel at all precarious (and this is why wealth inequality is bigger in EU than in US, even as income inequality is smaller).
- DFHippie 6y agoRepeating myself from above: Why reduce inequality? Because inequality reduces social cohesion, promotes corruption -- it produces people who can buy government policy and action --, reduces democratic control of the government, and the mass of people lifted up by its reduction benefit much more than the few wealthy people suffer who are made poorer.
- anovikov 6y agoWealth inequality is not the same thing as income inequality. Moreover, they are inversely related: more income inequality usually means less wealth inequality (because people know government won't care for them so they save and invest cash to make up for it). And there is nothing morally wrong with wealth inequality: European democratic states that American liberals love the most, like Netherlands, Denmark or Sweden, are more unequal in terms of wealth than the U.S. - but much less in terms of income, and even less in terms of after-tax income including "free stuff".
- TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
- kelnos 6y agoAren't you proving the article's point with the example of your billionaire friends? The higher taxes they want won't affect them because they aren't interested in getting richer, and so likely don't have high incomes compared to what the article calls the "usurpers". Higher taxes for your billionaire friends, regardless of why they say they want them, will have the effect described in the article: your friends will remain just as rich, and it will be harder for other people below them on the ladder to climb up to them.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoIt's already almost impossible for anyone who isn't born into wealth to become a billionaire. How exactly would taxing ultra-high net worth individuals make it harder for everyone else to get rich?
- WalterBright 6y agoIn America it's very possible. For example, Oprah Winfrey went from welfare to billionaire.
- jedberg 6y agoShe is literally the only person on the billionaires list who was born in the bottom quintile. She is the most outlier of outliers.
- WalterBright 6y ago10 billionaires who grew up dirt poor: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/11/10-billionaires-who-grew-up-dirt-poor.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/11/10-billionaires-who-grew-up-...
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoCompared to how many who didn't?
- WalterBright 6y ago> that you shouldn't support higher taxes on the wealthy because they are just doing it to prevent you from being as wealthy as they are. The inevitable math is if income is taxed at 40%, it greatly diminishes the ability to grow wealth. Instead of taxing wealth creation, the government should be taxing pollution.
- kwere 6y ago>wealth inequality is bad wealth inequality isnt bad by any means, structural* poverty is. Stop this "equality" bullshit. *there are various types of poverty: absolute poverty should be allieviated and situational (functional) poors should be reintegrated into society by education,job,training or any other means
- md_ 6y agoIt seems obvious to me that we can break the discussion apart into one of: * equality of opportunity * equality of political representation * equality of means I agree that the last is the least important. Unfortunately, data and common sense both suggest that inequality of means results in inequality of opportunity (see e.g https://www.oecd.org/centrodemexico/medios/44582910.pdf https://www.oecd.org/centrodemexico/medios/44582910.pdf), and that, in a democracy where money talks, it translates to inequality of political representation as well.
- anoncake 6y agoEquality of opportunity and equality of means are the same thing. Everyone tries to make the best of their opportunities. Some just don't have the ability to do so, which is also a kind of opportunity.
- md_ 6y agoI think by the most deterministic view of human behavior everything boils down to inequalities of opportunity, but that may be a little reductive. I was looking at this more in the Rawlsian sense of “everyone should have the same chances, such that if they had the same ability they could achieve the same thing.” I don’t think I (or most “meritocratic” societies) believe that social equalizers should completely eradicate differences in outcome that arise from innate differences in ability—but perhaps those differences should be somewhat reduced. Concretely: if the same person were born rich or poor, they should be able to achieve mostly the same things. But if the same person were born stupid (or lazy) or smart, it’s probably ok if there is some resultant difference in outcomes, as long as all outcomes support basic dignity and needs, right?
- anovikov 6y agoI see the message of this article more as "the high vs low taxes game has nothing to do with the problems of the poor, it is about helping or preventing any members of the middle class to become rich". I tend to believe it. Trump shown us that the poor are so easy to manipulate into voting directly against their own interest that no one will be bothered to do much for their sake - it's not necessary at all for any politicians' goals. It's a balance of interest of rich (billionaires/centimillionaires) and middle class (the rest of the 1% or so). The rest of people are just taken along for a ride, some of them under false impression it has something to do with their interests.