4 ms·
I am generally on the 'wrong' side of these conversations on HN, but... > did South Korea stop everything whenever North Korea did a Nuke test? I believe the
by vkou 6y ago
I am generally on the 'wrong' side of these conversations on HN, but...
> did South Korea stop everything whenever North Korea did a Nuke test?
I believe the two threats are not remotely equivalent. In a world of MAD, nuclear weapons are only a credible defensive deterrent, because offensive use of them is suicide. The US would start a nuclear war, in response to a North Korean first-strike.
Whereas with respect to China and Taiwan, nobody, including the US is going to start a nuclear war over that aggression, and nobody, including the US is going to start a conventional war against a major nuclear power.
If you have any doubts on this - consider that you are alive to read this post... Because the US did not start either a nuclear, or a conventional-with-good-possibility-of-turning-nuclear war over Russian adventures in Crimea.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- staticman2 6y agoIn real life, people sometimes commit suicide in what's called "suicide by cop", they attack police so the police kill them. The idea that we or China can't have a commander in chief who commits suicide by war, or otherwise behaves irresponsibly and takes the rest of us with them, strikes me as a tad optimistic.
- vkou 6y agoYou could say the same for the US. What checks and balances are going to protect you from a mentally unstable, delusional president who lost an election months ago, is about to be removed from power, and just this morning decided to play a game of nuclear football? What evidence do you have that similar checks do not exist in China? It's also worth mentioning that any nuclear submarine commander in the UK can, at any time, order the launch of their submarine's ICBMs. They do not physically require any authentication from Westminster to launch. I'm assuming the same is the case for US, and Russian submarines.
- staticman2 6y agoYou misunderstand me, I didn't say a U.S. president was less likely to kill us all.
- baybal2 6y ago> The US would start a nuclear war, in response to a North Korean first-strike. US will possibly do a limited retaliation, but not a full scale war. Norko is effectively China's 24th province. US generals are not onblivious to that fact.