3 ms·
QM interpretations don't really make predictions. They all use the same underlying math. They just rearrange the terms so that some of them correspond to someth
by jfengel 6y ago
QM interpretations don't really make predictions. They all use the same underlying math. They just rearrange the terms so that some of them correspond to something familiar, with the hopes of minimizing the confounding effects of the others.
They're all like trying to fold a map onto a globe: somewhere, something isn't going to fit. You just try to squeeze it into the parts you don't care as much about. Except somebody always cares.
It may be that somebody will discover one that's so effective that we declare it to be Correct. That's much like what we went through with heliocentrism. Geocentrism plus epicycles is also a perfectly valid interpretation, but it's vastly more complicated and less elegant. Even so it's incredibly useful and actually remains the dominant interpretation for a lot of activities.
It would be great if one such reformulation helped us reconcile with relativity, but I'll admit that I'm skeptical. I suspect that any unified theory will be so radically different in structure as to require a completely different interpretation, totally unrelated to any of the low-energy QM approximations.
I doubt any of them will be helpful -- especially superdeterminism, which I view as shoving the weirdness from "All events are decided randomly and then distributed FTL" to "All events were decided at the beginning but locked away so you can't know them until you get there". Neither one really gives us access to anything new -- which is to be expected.
- dekhn 6y agoI didnt mean quantum interpretations (which are boring to me). I mean: transisitor theory is quantum theory and we wouldn't have developed the transistor to the point we have if QM wasn't a great model for solid state physics. Nobody thinks event outcomes are distributed FTL, that's the whole point of QM.
- jfengel 6y agoThere are interpretations that make use of FTL communications, though they're not the most popular (and still don't actually allow you to communicate FTL). It was just a way of making a contrast with superdeterminism, but I think I was talking at cross-purposes, so I made my own point moot. Sorry 'bout that.
- dekhn 6y agoIf there's an interpretation that implies events are transmitted using FTL, then that interpretation almost certainly predicts that we could exploit the phenomenon (in the same way we exploit many other QM phenomena) to send data FTL. Much as I would like that to be true, until somebody shows it with an experiment the community can understand, believe, and reproduce, such theories are ... not useful.
- jfengel 6y agoI was referring to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie%E2%80%93Bohm_theory which uses FTL terminology, but doesn't support FTL communications. So it's not "real" FTL.
- dekhn 6y agoDe Broglie Bohm is highly underrated. It's deterministic but nonlocal, so it's not FTL (we agree on that). Personally, I prefer it to the Copenhagen interpretation and it even makes some interesting predictions that are supported by experiment. I see DBB as being on a continuum of deterministic theories.