13 ms·
Oh boy, that ever useful boogeyman >“In December 2019, the Washington Post reported that Elbakyan was being investigated by the US Justice Department on suspic
by mc32 6y ago
Oh boy, that ever useful boogeyman
>“In December 2019, the Washington Post reported that Elbakyan was being investigated by the US Justice Department on suspicion that she “may” be working with Russian intelligence to “steal U.S. military secrets...”
When you start trotting that out, you know it’s a witch-hunt because if they had real reasons they’d have stated them, since they don’t they offer vague insinuations couched with ten ton weasel words like may and suspicion...
But now they “have cause” and that’s all they need to go to town on her.
And whatever happened to Apple who refused to work with FBI on the San Bernardino shooter but here is only happy to comply in a much less interesting case?
- laggyluke 6y ago> And whatever happened to Apple who refused to work with FBI on the San Bernardino shooter but here is only happy to comply in a much less interesting case? Nothing. It's just a matter of technical means. They had no means of unlocking that phone without potentially compromising all the rest of the phones they've made before that point. But Apple account / emails are "in the cloud", so Apple has full access to it.
- shockeychap 6y agoApple has always bragged about iMessage content being end-to-end encrypted, and thus inaccessible even to Apple. Why aren't they doing the same with email and other files, like other providers? (ProtonMail, to name one example)
- gok 6y agoIt is technically impossible to end-to-end encrypt email.
- __s 6y agoNot technically. You'd just have to apply encryption at a higher level Send email bodies encrypted to base64 along with a public key fingerprint, then receiver's client would decrypt if it had the private key for that fingerprint But this isn't compelling enough to get a network effect to topple in-browser gmail
- joshuaissac 6y agoThis could work on top of GMail, with the help of a browser plugin.
- input_sh 6y agohttps://mailvelope.com/en https://mailvelope.com/en
- kodah 6y agoCommon misconception. The three letter agencies do not really need to know the contents of your email body. They're much more interested in to/from, timestamps, and subject. Establishing that you communicate with a person and then getting their emails is much easier than playing with your encrypted email body.
- freshair 6y agoExactly right. The American government considers associations inferred from this "metadata" to be sufficient evidence to execute people via drone.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoOnly foreigners and Americans on foreign soil
- upofadown 6y agoI think this is a common misconception of its own. The three letter agencies would love to be able to see the content of messages. But the code makers have run so far ahead of the code breakers that this is effectively impossible. So they settle for only meta information and tell the people that are funding them that this is now sufficient for them to continue to do their job.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Denvercoder9 6y agoPGP begs to differ.
- msbarnett 6y agoAnyone who's worked on the PGP project would be the first to tell you that PGP does not and cannot encrypt the email's metadata (to/from, subject, timestamps, etc). All PGP does is encrypt the inner message body. All of the metadata that TLAs love to analyze is sent in the clear (at best inside a TLS connection, although the SMTP protocol unfortunately makes it incredibly easy for well-positioned network attackers to downgrade these connections to in the clear)
- giantrobot 6y agoWhile not a silver bullet, anonymous remailers can strip out a lot of metadata. Mixmaster remailers can also help against traffic analysis. While not as popular as they once were networks of remailers are fairly easy to spin up.
- msbarnett 6y agoNone of this has anything to do with the incorrectness of the assertion that PGP would “beg to differ” that end-to-end encryption of email is impossible. Playing 3-card monty with your message is something else entirely.
- seppin 6y agoThe other person you are communicating with has to use PGP for the e-2-e to work.
- upofadown 6y agoPeople routinely do end to end encryption with email every day using either OpenPGP or S/MIME. Heck, email encryption is where the term "end to end encryption" came from. When someone claims E2EE for some other sort of messaging system they have to at least be as good at it as the email case to be taken seriously.
- wolverine876 6y ago> People routinely do end to end encryption with email every day using either OpenPGP or S/MIME. Those solutions encrypt only the content and not the headers, which are just as important. Also, encrypting the content prevents some webmail services from functioning, such as search. Email can't really be made secure.
- upofadown 6y agoThe headers are mostly protected with the TLS used for the connections between the server and the clients and other servers. Email is no worse than most things these days and better than many. * https://articles.59.ca/doku.php?id=em:anonemail https://articles.59.ca/doku.php?id=em:anonemail
- wolverine876 6y ago(see my response to the other comment, above; thanks)
- dane-pgp 6y ago> Those solutions encrypt only the content and not the headers, which are just as important. There are implementations which encrypt the headers, for example Delta Chat, which says[0] in its FAQ: 'Many other e-mail headers, in particular the “Subject” header, are end-to-end-encryption protected, see also this upcoming IETF RFC.' If you mean that the sender's server and the recipient's server can see the recipient's and sender's (respectively) addresses, then I would say that this is equivalent to most other "end to end encrypted" messaging apps, which usually rely on a trusted third party to connect the two ends. In fact, I would argue that the situation with email is better, because although Alice and Bob's providers might know that they are communicating with each other, Carol's provider will have no record of this at all (and Alice and Bob may not know that Carol or her provider exists). The situation with email could be made even better than that, though, since email servers could provide a dedicated "switchboard" address, such that Alice sends her email for Bob as an encrypted inner-message of an email sent to Bob's server's switchboard address. That way Alice's server wouldn't know who the intended recipient was, only their server address. Similarly Alice's server could rewrite the headers of her outer-message so that Bob's server doesn't know that Alice was the original sender. This would effectively implement a type of anonymous remailer.[1] > encrypting the content prevents some webmail services from functioning, such as search. You've shifted the goalposts here from "email can't be secure" to "webmail can't be secure". In any case, I disagree. It is possible to implement a client-side full text search[2], even if it means decrypting the index for every search, and re-encrypting the index whenever a new email is added to it. [0] https://delta.chat/pt/help#how-does-delta-chat-protect-my-metadata https://delta.chat/pt/help#how-does-delta-chat-protect-my-me... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anonymous_remailer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anonymous_remailer [2] https://lucaongaro.eu/blog/2019/01/30/minisearch-client-side-fulltext-search-engine.html https://lucaongaro.eu/blog/2019/01/30/minisearch-client-side...
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoIf you do end to end encryption, you can't persist the mails. So when you logout or clear cache or change browser or email client your past mails will be lost, which drastically reduces the purpose of mail as a long term thing.
- ognarb 6y agoYou can persist end to end encrypted mails on the server just fine. The important thing is that the keys for encrypting/decrypting the mails are not stored on the server too.
- bumbledraven 6y agomodeless wrote here in Feb, 2021 (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25778758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25778758) : > It's also important to realize that the backup includes your encrypted iMessage messages, and the key required to decrypt them. Meaning that if you have backups enabled, all the "end-to-end" encryption in iMessage is defeated. Apple and by extension the FBI can read your messages. This is documented by Apple here: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202303 > Even if you disable backups, whenever you correspond with someone that has backups enabled those messages are still accessible to Apple.
- ndeast 6y agoI have long since switched to only doing local encrypted backups, but for some reason it never clicked that of course all of my messages are included in other people's backups. Frustrating that its E2E with a bunch of caveats.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoE2EE only applies to data in transit, not data at rest. Talking via E2EE chat client means only that third parties in between cannot read what you write. It doesn't imply the messages cannot be recovered from your device, or your conversation partner's device, and it definitely does not imply said partner can't just leak them, whether accidentally or on purpose. I'm not sure how E2EE came to be interpreted as to mean "totally secure against everything".
- iudqnolq 6y agoI think it's the colloquial meaning of "end", as in "be all end all". I'd think something like "full in-transit encryption" or even "phone to phone" would be clearer.
- oneplane 6y agoIt's also how data collection still works if you personally 'block' it but communicate with others who don't. Your messages, phone book, pictures you share with others etc. are still 'readable' on the remote end and thus still get collected. And if you connect the dots when you have a large collections your personal data can be reconstructed from that. If you have persons A, B, C and D in your phone book, but your phone book is 'secret', it doesn't prevent someone from knowing that you know A to D if those still have you listed.
- esolyt 6y ago> Apple has always bragged about iMessage content being end-to-end encrypted, and thus inaccessible even to Apple. Majority of iPhone users have backup enabled so Apple can certainly access most iMessages.
- NorwegianDude 6y agoAnd most people using iMessage is using it on iOS with basically zero control over the software it's running. If Apple wanted to they could make your phone send them whatever they want. It's end-to-end encryption* with an asteriks as Apple controls both ends.
- mtgx 6y ago> But Apple account / emails are "in the cloud", so Apple has full access to it. PSA: So are your iCloud backed-up "e2e encrypted iMessages".
- temp8964 6y agoIf the FBI can use the Russia thing on a presidential candidate, they can use it on anybody.
- spankyspangler 6y agoNot just a presidential candidate, but a president. Did you know that after all those years of investigations, all those years of the house intelligence committee chairman and others insisting that there was "ample evidence" that Trump colluded with Putin to hack the election... in the end, The Mueller report admitted that no evidence was ever found to substantiate Trump or his associates or campaign ever working with Russians to interfere with the election? I found that really crazy when I found that out. What's even crazier is that everyone just quietly kind of stopped talking about it. Nobody wants to confront the fact they were badly manipulated, deluded, and lied to. Or they're comfortable with their own reality in which their enemies are the ultimate evil and their side is pure and good. That's why these things will never be fixed.
- temp8964 6y agoBut the Mueller team was good at covering their own ass. At Least 27 Phones from Special Counsel’s Office Were Wiped before DOJ Inspector General Could Review Them https://news.yahoo.com/least-27-phones-special-counsel-212933558.html https://news.yahoo.com/least-27-phones-special-counsel-21293...
- teclordphrack2 6y agoAnd? Standard IT practice.
- gowld 6y agoNo, it's not standard IT practice for dozens of people (>10% of the team?) to suddenly spam incorrect passwords into their phones at approximately the same time.
- deleted 6y ago
- piokoch 6y agoI am only surprised child porn has not been found on her computer yet. And there is no report from some hotel room cleaner that he or she was raped by Elbakyan. Those "stolen" military secrets published in journals anyone can purchase for a few bucks does not even sounds scary. Apparently FBI got lazy these days, maybe because of all that Covid mess.
- fao_ 6y ago> Apparently FBI got lazy these days, maybe because of all that Covid mess. The FBI has always been lazy. They sent notes to MLK stating he should commit suicide, after all.
- dillondoyle 6y agoSeems more malicious than lazy.
- __blockcipher__ 6y agoOf course it’s malicious. In context they were making a tongue-in-cheek joke intended to expose those that never heard about the MLK letter(s) to their existence. In other news, I only learned about the assassination of Fred Hampton quite recently. That’s a fun one.
- defqon 6y agoTo save anyone a Google search: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton
- sam_4675 6y agoI am skeptical about FBI but 1969 was over 50 years ago and that was under Hoover. Different FBI now. They have jurisdiction over copyright issues so no need for any international intrigue. Maybe there actually is one here.
- fao_ 6y ago
- freshair 6y agoPerhaps Elbakyan should promptly convert to Islam so she can claim she's being persecuted by Islamophobic investigators. I'm only half joking. As dumb as that may be, I think it does actually have some purchase in America.
- tootie 6y agoI think it's equally naive to think that Russia doesn't have their mitts into a lot of shady business. You have a right to be skeptical but this could easily be true.
- p_j_w 6y ago>weasel words like may and suspicion On the other hand, do we want law enforcement to NOT use words like this, as though everyone they suspect of committing a crime is definitely guilty? I personally think it's preferable that they keep those "weasel words" in there until the whole "due process" thing has run it's course.
- userbinator 6y agoAnd whatever happened to Apple who refused to work with FBI on the San Bernardino shooter but here is only happy to comply in a much less interesting case? The unfortunate implication here is that Apple is more strongly against theft of Imaginary Property than it is against physical violence.
- jbpnoy6fifty 6y agoHonestly, I know of someone who was involved with the San Bernardino shooting. And the shooter was not the Muslim man that was a co-worker of my friend who was there during the attack. The guy who did it was light skinned (not dark), looked of Caucasian background based on skin, and was more than 1 foot taller than the accused assailant. The media explained a different story.
- pfranz 6y ago> And whatever happened to Apple who refused to work with FBI on the San Bernardino shooter but here is only happy to comply in a much less interesting case? For a bunch of years Apple was slowly moving in a direction where they couldn't offer encryption keys to law enforcement because only customers had access to encryption keys. I'm not sure if it was publicly announced or just internally planned, but they were planning to do it for iCloud backups, too, but never went through with it. Reporting says it was in cooperation with the FBI. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/21/apple-dropped-plan-for-encrypting-backups-after-fbi-complained-sources-say.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/21/apple-dropped-plan-for-encry...
- xtat 5y agoI was skeptical that apple was doing it for positive privacy publicity in the SB case and it continues to be the case. Many well meaning people think they have their back as a result. The illusion of security is worse than no security, etc etc