7 ms·
Zulip is amazing. I'm of the opinion that Slack is actively bad for work, because it encourages ephemeral, disjointed chats that you can't easily find again lat
by stavros 6y ago
Zulip is amazing. I'm of the opinion that Slack is actively bad for work, because it encourages ephemeral, disjointed chats that you can't easily find again later.
Zulip is fast, light, and is a much more natural way to chat. The "river" of messages that you can zoom in and out of is just fantastic.
- sgt 6y agoStart treating it as async as possible, and the situation will improve. If team members get the impression you will always respond immediately, it will lead to a lot of wasted time and lack of concentration.
- StavrosK 6y agoThe thing is Slack's UX is geared against that. We can treat it as async, but the moment someone sends a second message about the same topic to the room, you're done, the conversation starts diverging. It's also dog-slow, I have to wait for it all the time. Editing a message is an exercise in futility.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI recently had to take screenshots of some 2 Year old messages in Telegram, WhatsApp and MS Teams. In Telegram it took 3 minutes to scroll through thousands of messages and load all that data, in What's app it took 25 minutes, and in Teams I never succeeded This is on an 8-core machine with a gigabit connection in 2021.
- pdimitar 6y agoOn my 2017 Xeon workstation and in Telegram, I can just press the Find shortcut, type a keyword and get results from back in 2015 in a manner of 1-2 seconds. It's amazing.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoAlmost like software should actually work
- pdimitar 6y agoOf course. That's what I was saying. It boggles my mind how something that basic is so hard in other apps.
- adimitrov 6y agoOn my 6 year old mobile phone, I can do the same thing in Signal. Takes seconds to find arbitrary strings in years long very active conversations. Honestly, I've no idea how we can accept bad performance in Teams and Slack. I can grep hundreds of megabytes of text in seconds on a raspberry pi. You have to actively try to make your software shitty to not be able to do that on a modern desktop.
- pdimitar 6y agoI am with you but I don't think anybody deliberately makes software shitty per se. It's more like "not my damned problem" and everybody picks a framework or a library for basic stuff and piles them on top of one another.
- spuz 6y agoI'm not quite sure I understand why you would need to scroll for 25 minutes to find an old message in WhatsApp when search is available.
- pessimizer 6y agoMy first guess would be because what you're looking for isn't tagged with unique keywords (maybe just a vague idea of a date), or because pulling up a single message may not pull in it's context "grep -A/B/C" style.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI needed evidence that 2 years ago I was in touch with that person - what was sent didnt matter, nor did i remember contents of the message at all. If what's app was not crap you could search by date, but I had to scroll.
- spuz 6y agoOk that makes sense - I think the best solution in that case is to try to think of a word that you may have used around that time and search for that - then if you get the right year you can at least scroll from there. Even so, I think WhatsApp's scroll is pretty fast especially compared to Teams. Teams only seems to be able to store 1 page worth of content in memory at any one time which makes scrolling for anything even an hour back excruciating.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoYou scroll whatsapp for a bit, and then it takes 30s to load messages. Telegram scroll is Instant, and trully endless, like a native app loading text should be
- stjohnswarts 6y agoYou'd think they would use the scroll bar like text editors do on huge documents. Just jump back to that point and keep +/- several screens rather than the entire freaking buffer. I wrote that for a basic text editor that I wrote for fun and it wasn't actually hard and would open gigabyte size documents almost instantly because I was only ever loading about a megabyte of info rather than the whole stinking file.
- IshKebab 6y agoNot sure what you mean about Slack encouraging disjointed chats. It supports threading too and people use it almost all the time at my work. I agree it is hard to find things again, but that's mostly because Slack's search is pretty bad, not because of any inherent properties. It's no easier to find old emails or old IRC messages or even wiki pages.
- bartvk 6y agoGmail search is pretty great.
- darkwater 6y agoI don't concur. If there is - and it's extremely ironic - a badly implemented feature in GMail, that's manual searching and especially filtering.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoPlease tell me what I'm doing wrong because it works just fine for me?
- IshKebab 6y agoTrue, but I can't use Gmail at work so that doesn't really help.
- windexh8er 6y agoA lot of people don't get threading. I'm in a small but active channel for our work team. It's roughly 15 people in a large company so it works well for us to engage and share. The problem is two others thread correctly, the rest just SPAM the main thread and when they do get the inkling to thread a reply it's often a new divergent thread off of a small conversation that someone threaded out earlier to be polite to the main. But the worst... The worst offender on our team thinks all of their replies must be seen by everyone. So they use the "Also send to #mainthread..." for every message they send. It's almost as if training on async chat is required for some as there's a total disregard for etiquette from some.
- dathinab 6y ago> you can't easily find again later. I sometimes have problems to find the new message I know I just got a few seconds ago due to how "non read messages marker" and "threads" (or however they call it) interact. I never understood why people where so hyped about slack while there most times where better alternatives. And let's not even get started about slacks audio/video chat function which is by far the worst I had used in recent times. Even the unliked MS Teams is miles better for voice or video chat. (Just to be clear I never used MS Teams for anything but voice/video chat.)