7 ms·
> Employees deserve high-quality equity on par with investors. There is no reason that labor and time couldn't build equity, it's just that our current system
by heavyset_go 6y ago
> Employees deserve high-quality equity on par with investors.
There is no reason that labor and time couldn't build equity, it's just that our current system favors those who use capital to build wealth over those who need to sell their time and labor to build wealth.
A common reason I hear for the fact that investors get more equity is because of the "risk" they take on, as if losing some money is the only risk on the table should a business go under. What is ignored, or outright dismissed, is the risk borne by those who invest their time and labor in a business for little to no equity.
When a business goes under, the employees have just lost their abilities to feed themselves, keep a roof over their heads, see doctors, buy medicine and provide for their families.
Workers sacrifice time that they can never get back working for one business when they could have spent that time working at another. While money invested can be earned back, employees can never earn their time back. Sometimes, those workers are paid below market rate while they help make a business successful, but don't see much or any equity as a result.
It seems to me that there is more risk on the shoulders of employees than those of investors, and they should be compensated accordingly.
- lukevp 6y agoI think you’re hand waving away that money is a store of value, and indirectly of time spent. The money investors have also came from them creating value by doing some activity. It doesn’t materialize independently. And it is still a risk to lose that money that they earned by trading their own time in the past.
- B4CKlash 6y agoAnother term for VC is risk capital. A diligent investor will only put what they can safely risk into the market. While your correct that money indirectly represents time, you’re overlooking the incremental utility of money. An investor logically values each incremental dollar less, purely evidenced by the fact they were willing to risk it. An employee on the other hand will turn those funds directly into shelter/food/health. Seems like a false equivalency to value investment assets at the same level as the money you need to survive.
- alisonkisk 6y agoYou're saying that rich people should be paid less, a smaller multiple of what low paid workers get. You can make that debate, but it's not "equity vs wages". Someone getting paid $100M but no "equity" isn't worse off than someone getting paid $100M of valuated equity (ignoring liquidity discount blah blah)
- B4CKlash 6y agoIt is 100% equity vs. wages. That’s how a financial statement works. Revenue – COGs – G&A – Taxes & Interest = Net income. That net income moves to the balance sheet as retained earnings. The higher the COGs & G&A cost the lower retained earnings and the lower the retained earnings the lower proportion of equity. The premium equity achieves is largely as result of leverage – not value*. Employees might generate 100% of the revenue but get zero credit for the growth rate. In a book value sense both seem pretty even, but we don’t value growth companies at book… We value them with a DCF model (or a different model that takes into account future earnings). At T+0 you’re probably neck and neck, but as soon as you step into T+1, T+2, etc. the equity side will get credit for income it hasn’t earned yet while the wage earner is left the same (for the better or worse). *related to my parent comment and the diminishing utility of money. Equity investors can afford to be choosey because they have wealth = aka options.
- alecbz 6y agoThe more relevant factor IMO is not time vs. money but the proportional risk. A year of my time is a much larger fraction of my net worth than the typical VC's investment is a fraction of their net worth.
- alisonkisk 6y agoThis is a Marxist labor theory of value argument, disregarding market forces. For a different supply-demand function, labor could get paid far more than investors (imagine a 0 interest rate environment while inflation is happening.)
- alecbz 6y agoWell, sort of. There's an argument to be made that people should realize how much better a deal VCs are getting and stop settling for worse ROI. Part of the problem is exactly that supply is high, possibly because of a lack of knowledge/negotiation leverage.
- banannaise 6y agoLabor supply is high because it is forced to be high, in a way that capital supply is not. Investors can stop investing and simply live on their hoards, or even a tiny fraction of their hoards. Laborers cannot stop laboring and do the same.
- alecbz 6y agoThat explanation seems off? (Anyone who has enough to live off of can just do that, witholding both their capital and their labor.) But anyway I meant supply of labor for startups specifically. Like, people are too willing to forgo FAANG comp for low equity numbers at startups.
- midasuni 6y agoYet investors have made a fortune over the last year while there’s interest rates below inflation.
- pydry 6y ago>I think you’re hand waving away that money is a store of value, and indirectly of time spent. Not if it's as a result of natural capital gain, dividend on shareholdings, interest, inheritance or rent. In those cases it does materialize independently of time. Taxes are typically lower if you didn't labor for your money too. Probably because large political donations are not typically made by people who worked for their money.
- ithkuil 6y agoPlaying devil's advocate: But the employee's time is a replenishable resource (1 second per second). The Total risk is not losing your job. It's losing your job + struggling strongly to find another one (considering loss income while searching, stress, ...). Or workplace injury / death. An investor, while facing low to none risk of workplace injury / death, can permanently lose the investment and won't recover it ever (hopefully the investor hedges it with other investments)
- ska 6y ago> It's losing your job + struggling strongly to find another one (considering loss income while searching, stress, ...). This is what severance clauses are for. > Or workplace injury / death. This is what insurance is for.
- ithkuil 6y agoThat was exactly my point. They are part of your compensation package. Surely there is a risk that the severance is not enough to cover for coping with a depressed job market. Investors operate outside of these parameters. When it works out well , lucky you; but if it doesn't work you lose. The parameters to make this a worthwhile venture must be set so that the reward is higher than when you risk less.
- daveidol 6y ago> When a business goes under, the employees have just lost their abilities to feed themselves, keep a roof over their heads, see doctors, buy medicine and provide for their families. Yes, but that's always the risk of working at any company (and it's a risk the investor may also have if the company goes under). You can typically just get a new job and get these things back. I think an even more compelling argument here is the one of opportunity cost when working for a startup vs big FAANG company. Early startup tech employees not only invest their time but also lose out on real money they would have earned at another (bigger) company.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alisonkisk 6y agoOnly of they are paid partly in equity. If they are getting a lower comp package than FAANG because of intangibles they value highly (perhaps developing skills FAANG will pay more for later) that's their choice.
- rizzom5000 6y ago| Early startup tech employees not only invest their time but also lose out on real money they would have earned at another (bigger) company. Isn't that by design? With greater risk comes the potential for greater reward. If someone doesn't want the startup risk, they can choose to pursue a job at FAANG. If your goal is to minimize risk, then choose a job as a schoolteacher or the post office. That's the nice thing about freedom of choice. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/charlie-ayers-made-millions-cooking-googles-earliest-employees-jessi/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/charlie-ayers-made-millions-c...
- lumost 6y agoThis presumes that early employees are getting a fair shake. In many cases they are being sold a lottery ticket with a value of only a few thousand dollars even when the company sells/IPOs.
- CerealFounder 6y agoYour moralizing a non moral argument. Its simply harder to get access to someone else's capital than someone else's time. So people can charge a premium for the capital. I do believe that premium is probably a bit higher than it should be because it used to be EVEN HARDER to get that capital so people are pointing out the slightly outdated examples of cost in order to gain negotiating leverage. In the end our time and money have no intrinsic value, but try asking a friend to help you move and then try asking your friend to loan you money to hire movers and see which they are more likely to do.
- cortesoft 6y agoI think the big difference is that worker time can’t be saved in the same way that capital can be. While capital will lose value over time to inflation, it still holds most of its value if it is not spent (and there are very safe investments that can be used to hold even more of its value across time) An investor can choose to hold their capital for a better investment at a later time. For a worker, however, every minute of labor is use it or lose it... it isn’t like a worker can look at the available jobs and say “nah, I think I’ll just save up my time for now and wait for a better opportunity to spend my labor hours”. You can’t wait a few months and then trade all those months of labor for more money later.
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Your moralizing a non moral argument. I'm responding to a common moralizing argument: > > A common reason I hear for the fact that investors get more equity is because of the "risk" they take on > Its simply harder to get access to someone else's capital than someone else's time. So people can charge a premium for the capital. That's just another consequence of our current system favoring those with capital. There's a glut of capital, it's just allocated in manners that favor asset owners over those who work for a living. A more democratic approach to capital access wouldn't necessarily have to tip the scales in favor of those who already have it.
- andrepd 6y agoYou are justifying a system with the system itself. Why does it have to be hard to access capital? Worse that hard, why is there a very very tiny number of (undemocratic, unaccountable) people deciding who gets to access capital? Why couldn't we think of a more democratic way of allocating credit/capital/finance to people and businesses?
- dahart 6y ago> Sometimes, those workers are paid below market rate I like this justification above all the others; it seems both fair and easy to reason about. If I quit a $200k/yr job to work at a startup for $100k/yr in cash comp, then my time investment, or risk, is $100k/yr, and my stock compensation should reflect that financial value based on today’s valuation of the stock.
- ska 6y ago> based on today’s valuation of the stock. This is the tricky part, especially if you are very early. Really what you want is the (statistical sense) expected value of the equity be something like the opportunity cost, for it to make sense for you. But until the company has been around for a while and through a few rounds, valuation is mostly a fantasy...
- dahart 6y agoIt’s not that tricky, because the investors are getting a valuation. The money I risk/invest/forego now because it’s a startup maybe ought to get the same valuation the investors are getting, that’s all.
- chris11 6y agoI really agree with your point. I don't see how most startups could make competitive offers with unicorns/FAANG, unless it was for non-monetary reasons like a promotion.
- tomnipotent 6y agoBecause there are considerably more jobs outside of FAANG then within it.
- triceratops 6y agoGive out way more stock options, so that the pay is the same risk-adjusted.
- nonameiguess 6y agoThe more amusing (or disturbing thing) is that we have created an environment where, practically speaking, investors have less risk than everyone else. We were just hit with one of the largest global disasters of the past century last year and the immediate reaction was flood equity markets with $3 trillion to prop up financial markets. Owners of capital cannot lose. Even before these last few years of craziness, what I will never be able to get out of my mind is the story of Frank McCourt. I'm a lifelong Los Angeles Dodgers fan. He bought the team from Fox in 2004 and proceeded to treat a storied franchise in the nation's second largest city like it was his personal credit card. He didn't even use his own money to make the purchase. It was entirely with loans. He then proceeded to spend 8 years gradually bankrupting the organization until the league kicked him out and forced him to sell. What was his loss? Nothing. The team sold for 8 times what he originally paid, not because of anything he had done, but just because television contracts for the entire league had become so much more lucrative over that time. The man put up $0 of his own money and made $2 billion by being one of the worst team owners of all time and making the organization he owned literally bankrupt. I will never again in my life accept these econ theory gibberish about all the "risk" faced by business owners. If you own a salon or a restaurant or something, fine, I accept you might actually be out on the street. But if you're the right class of person that the banking system has accepted into the club, you can get infinite loans to buy whatever you want with no collateral, drive a business into the ground while spending the bulk of your time with hookers and blow, and make out with billions anyway.
- KirillPanov 6y agoThe Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks
- nuclearnice1 6y agoSaul Katz is the east coast Frank McCourt. Many years of mismanaging the Mets. Suspicious involvement with Bernie Madoff. All floated a long with generous debt finance. Sold the team last year for $2.4B
- beckingz 6y agoThe best part is that he sold the franchise and donated $100M to Georgetown University so that his wife wouldn't get as much of the divorce proceedings.
- routerl 6y agoThanks for this comment. You've clearly outlined something I've been trying to convey for years, especially to people who read too much Taleb: "skin in the game" cannot be a purely financial concept, otherwise it fundamentally misunderstands the notion of "risk". "Financial risk" is a proper subset of "calculable risk" which is a proper subset of "risk".