5 ms·
> IMO, we need some way to declare a company "Big" and apply special rules to them. If those rules are onerous, that might create some organic pressure to split
by oblio 6y ago
> IMO, we need some way to declare a company "Big" and apply special rules to them. If those rules are onerous, that might create some organic pressure to split and/or help smaller incumbents compete.
Past a point, they should be regulated like an utility.
- dalbasal 6y agoIDK if it's "past a point," but in some cases maybe. I'm torn on that though. EG, what would it actually mean if FB or twitter became "regulated like utilities?" Interoperability? Portability? IMO, these are pretty finicky problems for a regulator. I think it would likely look like the mandated personal data dumps we have today. Some clunky feature that few use, and don't change the structure of the market. Useful transparency, but not really game changing. Regulated equal access? Court-like proceeding to confirm bans? I'm not feeling it. I suspect it will entrench monopolies further. A Telecom or EnergyCo is fundamentally different from a FB or Google. Regulators needed to make sure everyone had access, because it's always more profitable to just exclude certain people/areas. Prices are an issue because infrastructure monopoly. Also because government/regulators typically fund a lot of the capex. There is almost no cost, marginal or fixed, associated with instant messages, shares, likes, links, etc. If Facebook and Twitter folded tomorrow, we would still have plenty of all of these because they are not scarce. Maybe there's a case for cloud computing as a utility, but even here I'm hesitant. Enough with analogies to 19th century monopolies. Platform monopolies should be regulated as platform monopolies, not utilities. New thinking. In any case, google is the perfect target for actual trustbusting. Separate search from adwords and android. Ban default buying. Ban mergers. The old challenge was (eg) trust busting steel without harming the actual production of steel. Today's problem has little to do with production. It does have a lot to do with share prices. Is there really an appetite for turning Alphabet from a $1.5trn company into a $150bn company?
- ripdog 6y agoGenerally good comment, but if search is separated from ads, how does it make money? I'm totally on board with splitting up Google, but losing Google search (or search becoming notably worse) would not be worth it for me. The competition is just so bad, and always has been.
- salawat 6y agoPart of why searching is as painful as it is is because it has been deemed acceptable to pollute the search space. SEO should be neither encouraged or allowed. It is nothing less than adversarial corruption of a shared index. Boolean searching works. Go back to a library catalog sometime and be amazed at how quickly you can get relevant results when every Tom, Dick, and Methuseleh aren't shoveling extra irrelevant feces into the index.
- scarface74 6y agoSays someone who never used Altavista…
- nradov 6y agoThere is no practical way to disallow SEO. Search results have to be ranked somehow in order to be usable for most people. And site owners will always figure out tricks to game the ranking algorithms.
- zo1 6y agoIt's not SEO that's the problem. SEO is a symptom of the perverse incentives. So Google has created incentives (via ad embedding in user-sites) for entities to generate content and compete with each-other for who can show the most ads. This in turn "pollutes the index" as the other poster phrased it, which makes it more and more difficult to find actual real (unique?) content, which then Google turns around and supposedly "helps" us with. Let's be honest. Despite it's surface-level gigantic scale, the internet is actually very tiny when it comes to real genuine content. My wild estimate is that 99% of it is spam. Even in the case of user-generated content, for every genuine blog where someone shares their thoughts and unique insights or content, there are a thousand blogs which are just there to get ad-views by generating any content that might get someone to look there. I can't even find the former type of blog/site anymore. The only place I still encounter those on occasion is when it's linked to from HN. And the ones I do encounter that way, I find that even when I try to, I can't find it via any sort of generic search (i.e. not cheating by using the site name / author / unique phrases). Splitting Google up won't fix this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jsmith45 6y ago> Court-like proceedings to confirm bans The EU's initial proposed version of the "Digital Services Act", requires that when a service takes down information that they think is "illegal" or incompatible with the terms of service, They are required to provide the "facts and circumstances" used to arrive at that decision, as well as reference to the specific term of service they think is violated, and why they feel the information violates that. Furthermore, they must provide an appeals mechanism for both information takedowns and any account suspensions/bans associated with them (and besides things like non-payment, I'd bet the majority of account suspensions/bans on online services are due to some posted content the company finds objectionable). Lastly, if the internal appeals process fails to satisfy the user, the user initiate a what is basically an electronic binding arbitration process with a certified " out-of-court dispute settlement body" of the user's choosing, with this body having the power to overturn the companies decision. That last part sound an awful lot like "Court-like proceedings to confirm bans". I suspect the final law may not be as pro-consumer in these areas as the initial draft is (many big companies will not be happy about this part of the law and will try to kill it off). If it does survive it would be much better then all too common: "We are banning you because we think you broke an unspecified part of the terms of service. We won't be more specific because we don't have to be, and are scared that people trying to break the rules could learn how they got caught. We won't even tell you that this was a fully automated process with no humans involved, that gets things wrong x% of the time. There is no appeal, unless you can get Twitter or the news media sufficiently riled up against us."
- dalbasal 6y agoHmm. I didn't know that. I suppose we'll see how it works out, assuming it does become law. There is devil in the generalities here, but plenty of devil in the detail too. Detail-wise.... Compliance, currently, is the art of ticking boxes while not changing anything fundamental. Too often, politicians and advocates have their eyes on the spirit of (proposed) laws while corporations and their advocates put their eye on how "compliance" will actually work procedurally. The latter approach is more effective. That doesn't mean no goals are ever achieved, but it does dampen a lot. EU transparency laws, right to be forgotten and such are good examples. They might establish moral rights, but they don't affect really achieve big practical goals. Generality-wise... I think the problem for (eg) free expression is the platform oligopoly itself, not their corporate policies. That's not my main concern here though. My main concern is: These laws are only necessary because monopoly. The danger is that the laws entrench monopoly, by applying them unnecessarily to smaller platforms. That said, we'll see when/if it happens. Thanks for the info.
- bagacrap 6y agobecause our utilities work so well and don't function at all like monopolies
- oblio 6y agoUtilities are super heavily regulated. I'm not sure for the US, but for example frequently they can't enter new markets, so they can't leverage their monopoly to crush competition in other markets. And regarding working well, aren't a lot of people in favor of municipal broadband (an utility) vs Verizon & co. (oligopoly, not even a full blown monopoly)?
- jjaammee 6y agoCalifornia PGE which provides electricity and gas to big portion of public is a moving train wreck. It's corrupted and dangerous. Pipeline explosion, electricity transmission line caused fire burn a whole town happened with worrying frequency. Heavy regulations don't prevent big bonus to executives and degrading infrastructure.
- ncphil 6y agoMaking an electric or gas company a government entity would at least provide a chance to prosecute its corrupt operators for official misconduct and criminal fraud (see the slow moving train wreck called CalPERS, some executive frog-marching would fix that quickly).
- dalbasal 6y agoUtilities aren't regulated to function like "non-monopolies," generally. They're regulated because (ATT, at least) they were seen as inevitable "natural" monopolies. There really isn't one "theory of monopolies" that is useful in all times and places. Social Media is not Telecom or electricity. Amazon is not a railroad. Trustbusting is an anti-monopoly strategy, and it doesn't really work in spaces where monopoly is unavoidable.
- kavalg 6y agoAnd we need an effective regulator. For example, I am baffled by the level of oligopoly allowed in the EU cellular/telecom industry. It is quite obvious that prices are synchronized between providers if you watch their dynamics over time. They are currently killing prepaid cards as well.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoThere are now countless eSIM offers (mostly for data) that are way cheaper than the previous prepaid options, so I'm not convinced of this. (I'm sure the roaming fee limits played a big part in this, because it effectively allows any mobile operator to resell data at the wholesale rate, or even below it because data is usually sold in packages that are rarely used up in full.)
- thegrimmest 6y agoDoesn't that effectively mean that these companies will become further entrenched and nearly impossible to dislodge from their market positions? A prime example is Google Fibre, who tried to dislodge existing cable/internet companies, and failed primarily because of regulatory entrenchment. Why not allow the market to be more inclusive? This will help create exactly the competitive pressure that we all benefit from.
- Nasrudith 6y agoTheir goal isn't a more inclusive or competitive market clearly, it is regulatory entrenchment.