13 ms·
So far, Elon/Tesla: 1. Bought a bunch of Bitcoin. 2. Announced they were going to accept Bitcoin, sending the price up. 3. Sold a bunch of Bitcoin to pad out
by arcticbull 6y ago
So far, Elon/Tesla:
1. Bought a bunch of Bitcoin.
2. Announced they were going to accept Bitcoin, sending the price up.
3. Sold a bunch of Bitcoin to pad out otherwise poor earnings, citing their goal of "testing liquidity of the market."
4. Announced they were going to stop accepting Bitcoin, sending the price plummeting.
As though he didn't know the environmental impact a week ago? As though he didn't check for liquidity before investing one and a half billion dollars of company money.
- kgwgk 6y agoMaybe there was a 3b we don’t know about yet.
- quotha 6y agoThe use of coal power to mine bitcoins recently came to light.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoThey didn't sell all of their bitcoin, just a fraction, and this is probably another ruse to buy cheaper. There was minicrash earlier that tanked the value >> 10% but it was bought up almost immediately.
- arcticbull 6y agoSorry for the lack of clarity, when I said a "bunch of bitcoin" that's quantifiably 10% of their Bitcoin. It amounted to a hundred million dollar profit. Curious if they sold any after 4/1.
- rvz 6y agoYes. A very clever plan, executed to perfection. We don't know the price point of the BTC they bought at the time but it is likely to be somewhere around $30,000 - $40,000 and then they announced it to cause a run up close to $60,000 and then sold some of it for a >$101m profit. Now they somehow 'stop accepting Bitcoin' causing BTC to go down 12%. These same institutions are NOT interested in hodling. They are here to make money off of their BTC investment with only risking a small amount and cashing out 10% of it, while the retail investor hodls for their life savings at all time highs again.
- simondotau 6y ago> executed to perfection Except they still own nearly all the Bitcoin they bought, so I don’t see how selling a tiny bit of it and tanking the rest could be described as “to perfection”.
- rvz 6y ago> Except they still own a ton of Bitcoin No where in my sentence suggested they sold all of it. > so I don’t see how selling a tiny bit of it could be described as “to perfection” Telsa did not lose any money from their BTC investment and are still up >40%. At that time, they (and others on Twitter) caused a run up in the crypto markets to drive the BTC price up to new all time highs and got out a large profit even by selling a small amount and then causing it to drop 12% after the announcement, sounds like it was perfectly executed and it worked for them.
- simondotau 6y agoWhy is it clever to tank an asset that they own? How did the 12% drop benefit Tesla? You're not making any sense.
- agilob 6y agoand now, repeat with Doge, which is exactly the same as BTC.
- spottybanana 6y agoMeanwhile they started accepting Dogecoin at SpaceX just couple of days ago. Dogecoin has exactly the same energy spending incentives as Bitcoin. The whole set of actions doesn't sound very logical.
- morelisp 6y agoIt's absolutely logical when your primary criterion is M' > M.
- tromp 6y ago> Dogecoin has exactly the same energy spending incentives as Bitcoin. While the incentives are the same, Dogecoin has roughly 7.4x lower energy requirements than Bitcoin currently, so accepting Dogecoin instead of Bitcoin is a tad less offensive.
- La1n 6y agoWith a market cap that is 20 times lower, higher market cap means higher prices, means more miners and thus more energy requirement
- tromp 6y agoNot quite. Energy requirements correspond to daily dollar emission (column PoW produced 24h in [1]). Early in their emission, coins can have high daily emission and low marketcap. And dogecoin is at less than 1/3 of its 500B soft total supply [2]. [1] https://www.f2pool.com/coins https://www.f2pool.com/coins [2] https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-supply-1169a188d153 https://john-tromp.medium.com/a-case-for-using-soft-total-su...
- swinglock 6y agoOnly because it's not used. This is like arguing we should switch from using cars currently on the road because they use energy, to cars currently standing in a garage, because we measured and clearly the parked cars use less energy than the cars on the road. It's not even hyperbole, it's precisely equivalent and just as boneheaded as it sounds.
- bidirectional 6y agoThey also wrote the customer agreement such that they would refund Bitcoin purchases in either dollars or Bitcoin[1], depending on which was more profitable. This can be used to effectively get free options on a highly volatile asset[2]. [1] https://twitter.com/TBPInvictus/status/1375088089002094595 https://twitter.com/TBPInvictus/status/1375088089002094595 [2] https://twitter.com/macrocephalopod/status/1375099069497028615 https://twitter.com/macrocephalopod/status/13750990694970286...
- iamacyborg 6y agoThe alternative was to essentially provide free options to customers. It was stupid whichever way they did it.
- bidirectional 6y agoNo, the alternative was to issue refunds in the currency of transaction. There's no reason they would ever offer customers the choice of refund currency.
- rdsubhas 6y agoThat doesn't work. Say you purchase car for 0.5BTC today. Tommorrow BTC goes up. You ask for a refund and immediately buy the same car back for say 0.25BTC. Free discount. Who would not do it? Core of this is that BTC (atleast right now) is a highly volatile, speculative asset. There is no way direct payments in BTC will make common "market sense" until volatility stabilizes. Until then someone has to take responsibility for bearing that volatility, either the customer or the manufacturer. In this case, it's apt that the customer bears it (as they should, it's their gamble).
- Negitivefrags 6y agoWhen Tesla announced the initial move they received a huge amount of push back for the environmental concerns. And it didn’t look good for an EV company of all things. There is a trend I’ve seen of a company making a decison, everyone hating on them for it, then they reverse the decision, and they are still criticised. If a company turns around and reverses a decision citing the very reasons they were criticised for making it, shouldn’t we applaud them for listening? I mean, isn’t this exactly the behaviour we want to encourage?
- alvis 6y ago& I'd be surprised to know that Musk didn't know the environmental impact of bitcoin before he pushed bitcoin to the sky?
- Athas 6y agoNo, because this makes it seem like they are not making the right decisions because they are right, but only because doing the wrong thing made them unpopular. It makes you wonder what other wrong things they do that doesn't elicit enough of a popular response to make them reconsider. It's not like the environmental impact of Bitcoin was a subtle or obscure issue when they first made the decision. They should have known better, and it remains worrying that they did not.
- post_below 6y agoFor profit companies don't make decisions because they're right. Right and wrong have no meaning in capitalism. Companies make decisions based on profits. We might wish it were different, but it very clearly isn't. The best we can hope for is that public pressure convinces companies that right and profitable overlap.
- lbriner 6y agoThat is an absolute statement being applied to a relative world. The idea that a company won't make a right decision ever is patently absurd. The idea that there are good companies and bad companies is likewise absurd. Of course, a large company has to worry about money because their burn rate is so high, to imply otherwise is naive. It doesn't follow that a cash rich company won't decide to sustainably source materials or pay a fair wage for their employees. Whether companies should ever be allowed to get that large is a different discussion.
- mxcrossb 6y agoI wonder if someday we get even more absurd. Musk wagers company money on the Chiefs to win the Super Bowl, announces this on Twitter, then hedges his bet when Vegas moved the line after a bunch of pro chiefs action. I mean, it’s not like there aren’t hedge funds that do sports gambling already.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gonzo41 6y agoIs that not market manipulation?
- hkdobrev 6y agoBitcoin is not a regulated market and the SEC cannot interfere because of this. Someone might sue in civil court I guess. It's not market manipulation in the strict legal sense, more so in the moral sense.
- gonzo41 6y agoOh well, I guess bully to musk for a clever trick but he's shedding trust fast!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- headmelted 6y ago5. Asked on the same day on Twitter if they should accept Dogecoin instead. This whole thing has become as ridiculous as it is blatant.
- throwaway4good 6y agoIf Tesla bought and sold stock in another company, they would need to announce it immediately according to detailed regulations. With Bitcoin there is nothing that regulates. Tesla can buy it in secret, announce it and drive up the price, sell it in secret, announce it and drive the price back down.
- dartharva 6y agoClassic pump & dump. And of course, there's no one to complain as crypto markets are unregulated anyway
- mobilemidget 6y agoHe also mentioned dogecoin a lot in between.
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoIt seems Elon is playing pump-and-dump game, creating significant profit, betting on one "horse" and putting a curb to others.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JacksCracked 6y agoHe also suggested on another tweet that bitcoin incentivizes using renewable energy. https://mobile.twitter.com/christianmaioli/status/1392627196674592768 https://mobile.twitter.com/christianmaioli/status/1392627196...
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y agoElon is a con man. I can't find this youtube video of an engineer explaining why the Boring Tunnel is hyped up bullshit. It's just a slow car based subway with very low throughput due to by-design bottlenecks at the entry- and exit-points. Can't find it. Wouldn't be surprised to learn that Google/Youtube is shadow banning it. Somebody knows what I mean and can post a link?