6 ms·
reminds of the 'accidental glitches' after anti-Modi posts vanished in India, curiously enough shortly after India pressured social media companies into silenci
by Barrin92 6y ago
reminds of the 'accidental glitches' after anti-Modi posts vanished in India, curiously enough shortly after India pressured social media companies into silencing dissent.
People who think of centralised social media as an empowerement of voice of minority dissent have made a grave mistake. It's only contingently supportive as long as the position of the minority voices isn't in conflict with political or economic interests of the powers that be. And big anything be it government, business and so on is always run by people who come from the same power-centres that minorities are trying to speak up against.
- bobthechef 6y agoOr the minority known as the American oligarchy.
- darkwizard42 6y agoI think it is a LOT simpler than what you are suspecting. As someone in the comments has pointed out, mass reporting on certain types of articles or certain sources trigger automated review/removal of that content. Normally, consensus reporting is a good sign that something is undesirable. In this case it has clearly been weaponized. This is a TUNING problem and it seems like social media companies have to find a way to balance on this
- serf 6y ago>This is a TUNING problem and it seems like social media companies have to find a way to balance on this OK -- to play nice, let's say it's a tuning problem. Why didn't this 'tuning problem' get fixed the first few times politically motivated messages got 'disappeared'? At what point does the responsibility lie on those massaging the tuning methods? my personal view is that social media is heavily gamed by the three-letter-agencies and all of their equivalents abroad. The existence of internal 'squads' within most of these groups that focus on social media networks reinforces that personal view -- if it wasn't an important battle ground then why form squadrons to seize and control it?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoWhy do we assume that it can be fixed? Even if there were no time constraint at all, and you could abolish all moderation tools to spend an hour carefully analyzing each individual post, I suspect you'd produce a lot of valid moderation complaints from people with different but reasonable assumptions. I don't think there exists any good strategy for moderating such controversial issues.
- ALittleLight 6y agoThey could try to detect incipient political situations, similar to how they detect trending tweets, and then treat reports related to those tweets with greater than usual scrutiny. I don't think anyone expects Twitter or other social media companies to get this perfect. The nature of the problem means there will always be edge cases, debatable calls, and algorithms automatically doing unfortunate things. I do think there is a reasonable expectation for these companies to both do more and make progress.
- gipp 6y ago> I don't think anyone expects Twitter or other social media companies to get this perfect That's exactly what nearly everyone expects, for exactly their own individual definition of perfect.
- RandyRanderson 6y agoWouldn't Israeli posts have been deleted too, then?
- shitRETARDSsay 6y agoThis. Facebook is a small startup and don't have moderators to check the validity of the report bombing at all. It's totally a glitchy algorithm. They're totally not waiting to use the «glitch» argument to counter it the moment there is a public outcry.
- swiley 6y agoThis isn't a tuning problem. This is the result of letting cooperations own communication channels, something we were escaping until smartphone apps became popular.
- naruvimama 6y agoOn the contrary a lot of English educated elite are beholden to the pre-modi power elite, a relic of the colonial continuum. Meaning a lot of "moderators" are conditioned to be anti-modi and anti-hindu and pro communist or Islamic inspite of India's tragic history with both.
- majjgepolja 6y agoBruh. > anti-modi and anti-hindu and pro communist or Islamic You can be anti modi without being Anti Hindu. Lot of educated people are pretty rational. Opposing Hindu votebank politics is not anti Hindu. (Of course there are a bunch of liberal arts graduates posing as liberals but being actually anti Hindu, but no way they constitute the majority of "English educated elite".) your comment sounds like a collection of all insults that extreme right wingers throw around a lot. Sounds like you grew up in an upper caste household with all those conspiracy theories of India being suppressed from being a superpower by outside powers and colonial tendencies. I know this happens because I grew up in similar environment. :(
- naruvimama 6y agoAnd you sound like someone who grew up in a elitist cocoon, parroting "pseudo liberal" wishy washy. Unlike Nazis, colonialism did not face trial, so it continues on in its many old ways.
- majjgepolja 5y ago> And you sound like someone who grew up in a elitist cocoon, parroting "pseudo liberal" wishy washy. I grew up in a Brahmin household, and that's part of why I came to dislike and question all religions. I am not some pseudo liberal like you'd like to dismiss of (If you read my comment carefully, you will observe I have bashed them too). The biggest problem is elitist attitude among ourselves. We should accept we were not some innately superior civilization that somehow got looted and screwed by colonialists, and that we have things to learn from outside as well. That's what the right wingers in India would never get. Savarkar must be crying in the heaven seeing all nonsense "right wingers" perpetrate today.