23 ms·
The problem with all those calculations is that storing hydrogen requires a lot of weight. If hydrogen were such a great idea, trucks would be already migratin
by marcosdumay 6y ago
The problem with all those calculations is that storing hydrogen requires a lot of weight.
If hydrogen were such a great idea, trucks would be already migrating to the in-between solution that is natural gas.
- thehappypm 6y agoTrucks maybe aren't, but city buses certainly are, all over the country. That's likely because of the infrastructure. You don't need to dot the entire country with LNG stops for your city buses, just a few fuel-up points here and there around town.
- marcosdumay 6y agoYes, buses and taxis are big adopters of it. Maybe there is something there and if we cut the cost of hydrogen enough (you know, all that extra solar power must go somewhere), it will be interesting for them too.
- albrewer 6y agoI second this insight. I'm a pressure vessel designer by trade. I got my numbers for all of this here[0] Liquefied hydrogen either needs to be stored cryogenically as a liquid, or at a very high pressure as a gas (65 MPa). I'm ignoring adsorption methods here. Given that we can't continuously maintain -253 °C all the time, this method is impractical for mobile usage. That leaves gaseous storage. To match the current range of diesel tractor-trailers, you'd need at least 4x the volume in hydrogen to come close to the standard of 600 miles between refills. I'm going to assume we need to store 1500 L of hydrogen to match the range. Other assumptions: The tank has a max overall length of roughly 2.5 meters. Inner and outer corrosion / gouge allowance of 6mm Design temperature of 200 °C (in case of fire). Material of construction is A-387 5 2 (5% Cr, 2% Mo steel) lined with something that prevents diffusion into and hydrogen embrittlement of the base metal. Vessel consists of a cylinder with spherical head on either end. Given: Inner diameter is 890mm, shell length is 1830mm, allowable stress is 178 MPa at the design temperature, we can use equation 4.3.1 from the ASME BPVC Section VIII Division 2 to determine the minimum thickness required for the given pressure. D is the corroded inner diameter of the vessel, P is the design pressure, S is the allowable stress, and E is the weld joint efficiency (assumed 1). D / 2 * (exp[P / (S * E)] - 1) + Corrosion 902 / 2 * (exp[65 / (178 * 1)] - 1) + 12 = 211mm wall thickness The weight of just the cylinder at that thickness with a length of 1.83m (without the spherical heads) is 11,000 kg. At that weight, batteries are pretty competitive. [0]: https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-storage-basics-0 https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-storage-basic...
- Gibbon1 6y agoNice to see someone doing engineering math. Based on this Semi with 150 miles of range and a 250kwh battery. https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a34876269/volvo-trucks-electric-semi/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a34876269/volvo-trucks-ele... Probably need 1000 kwh to get 600 miles of range. At 150wh/kg (based on a Tesla 3) that's 6,670 kg for equivalent battery. vs your calculation of 11,000kg for the tank.