3 ms·
This is starting to remind me of when Intelligent Tracker Prevention(tm) was released and instead was a super cookie leaking history. http://blog.lukaszolejnik.
by refulgentis 6y ago
This is starting to remind me of when Intelligent Tracker Prevention(tm) was released and instead was a super cookie leaking history. http://blog.lukaszolejnik.com/curious-case-of-privacy-vulnerability-in-intelligent-tracking-prevention/ http://blog.lukaszolejnik.com/curious-case-of-privacy-vulner...
I'd be much more comfortable with Apple being Privacy, Inc. if they kept their commitment to it, too often it looks like engineers got overrode by marketing. It's v unlikely a privacy engineer signed off on something, with so many side channels, with real world consequences, compromising a billion + iOS devices
- conradev 6y agoThis blog post actually demonstrates the opposite of the point you are trying to make.
- whoknowswhat11 6y agoUm - I think you are totally missing the point - Apple is doing probably the only fully encrypted system - vs tile and friends where everything lives in a database. This is not compromising billions of iOS devices, which frankly remain FAR FAR more secure than 80% of the competitor handsets which in many cases seem to ship with backdoor built in by their mfgs.
- refulgentis 6y agoHmm, lots to unpack there, I'll stay focused on my iPhone,...I'm not so sure...the lead article on HN yesterday showed you can track people unrelated to tag's routes, live. https://www.intego.com/mac-security-blog/i-mailed-an-airtag-and-tracked-its-progress-heres-what-happened/ https://www.intego.com/mac-security-blog/i-mailed-an-airtag-... I've gathered there's a beep if this is going on for 3 days, but...still not comfy with this. And this isn't a particularly fringe opinion, plenty of comments on the article wondering how to opt out:
- bngybmgrglflps 6y ago"Beep as anti-stalking measure" is somewhere between marketing spin and gaslighting. A lost AirTag chirps to serve its primary function of being recovered. The timer is 3 days[1], which observers (Forbes, WaPo) agree is surprisingly unreasonable for this use case. We can infer it was never a serious design consideration. On Android, decent Bluetooth is a gamble, but scanning will theoretically find one[2]. [1] https://daringfireball.net/linked/2021/04/20/moren-fine-print https://daringfireball.net/linked/2021/04/20/moren-fine-prin... [2] https://lifehacker.com/try-using-a-bluetooth-scanner-app-to-find-unwanted-airt-1846829920 https://lifehacker.com/try-using-a-bluetooth-scanner-app-to-...
- fastball 6y agoYou only read the title, didn't you?
- refulgentis 6y agoNot constructive :( Getting downvoted through the floor on Apple comments for the first couple hours is a time-honored HN tradition at this point, but I'm hoping you can help us break that habit: a big contributor is aggressive comments like this that assume an agenda. I know you can come up with something more substantive than guessing I didn't read the article. To wit, easy quote that backs what I read, and I assume I'm mistaken, given your feedback: 'The details should come as a surprise to everyone because it turns out that ITP could effectively be used for: - information leaks - tracking the user - fingerprinting'