6 ms·
There's an important message here: the money expands by that much and inflation is .. 4%? That shows the limits of a single number. It also shows up the "trans
by pjc50 6y ago
There's an important message here: the money expands by that much and inflation is .. 4%?
That shows the limits of a single number. It also shows up the "transmission mechanism" has been damaged; it doesn't affect wages or prices largely because so much effort has been expended over the last 40 years to prevent wages going up at all.
- bko 6y agoI would argue that much of the money expansion went to asset prices. Just look at the stock market, which is up 30% from PRE-covid levels. If you factor in reduced reduced demand from lockdown measures, then the market increase is even more astonishing. I wrote about the asset price increases before [0] This is unfortunate since it's essentially helping relatively wealthy asset holders as opposed to those most likely to be affected negatively by covid. [0] https://mleverything.substack.com/p/where-did-the-12-trillion-of-covid-76c https://mleverything.substack.com/p/where-did-the-12-trillio...
- listless 6y agoI agree. The economy is complex. You can’t tie 12 trillion of spending directly to inflation. Negative side effects manifest in ways we don’t expect. In this case, drastically increasing wealth inequality. It’s interesting to me that software developers don’t intrinsically realize this more than your average person. Nobody knows better than us that making changes to a complex system can have catastrophic downstream effects and has to be extensively tested first.
- bko 6y agoMost people assume that economics is like a washing machine where you have a few dials and knobs. Sometimes you need to tighten a screw here, apply some grease there, etc. But in reality, economics is more akin a complex biological system. We have a very rudimentary understanding of how it actually works. Sure, we can create drugs that calm us down or excite us, but we have very limited understanding of the underlying biological system. For instance, we still can't agree what the optimal diet for humans is with wildly contradictory regiments.
- ethbr0 6y agoIt's a great analogy, especially since at the end of the day economic shifts are rooted in... illogical meatbags (us). Economists like to pretend it's a science, and there are certainly scientific and experimentally-valid findings, but the innermost terms and interactions will always be obsfuscated. Like psychology, except with higher stacks of layered complexity. It's not as bad as steel deciding to change its tensile strength on a whim (because it heard other steel say so!), but it's not far off.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoFrom what I've seen, there are a lot of people in tech circles expressing anti-capitalist sentiment. However, very few of these people know or care how the economy works. This is very unfortunate, because I think it's useful to try and understand how the system works if you want to have any hope of improving it. Or at least, if you understand how things are trending, you might be able to better prepare and protect yourself and your friends/family. The average person doesn't understand what inflation is, why it happens, how it affects them and how the government uses inflation to reduce the significance of its debt. The average person also tends to believe government inflation numbers which, IMO, are manipulated and do not represent what is actually happening in the world. For instance, home prices (and thus rents) are rapidly increasing, and housing costs, for most people, are the biggest expense they have to think about, accounting for sometimes more than 50% of their take home pay.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> From what I've seen, there are a lot of left-wing people in tech circles expressing an opposition to capitalism. However, very few of these people know or care how the economy works. From what I've seen, there are a lot of right-wing people in tech circles expressing a support for capitalism. However, very few of these people know or care how the economy works. (A particular subgroup understands finance/trading pretty well, and mistakes understanding weather for understanding climate.)
- tachyonbeam 6y ago> From what I've seen, there are a lot of right-wing people in tech circles expressing a support for capitalism. However, very few of these people know or care how the economy works. Fair point. Most people don't know or care how the economy works, left or right. My main point was: it's to your advantage to know how the system works, and it's maybe even more important to understand how it works if you hope to change it. If you don't understand what is inflation and its impact, or basic economics, then politicians can take advantage of your lack of knowledge, in the same way a shady car mechanic can take advantage of uninformed customers. They might pretend that certain policies will help lower-income people when what they are doing is most beneficial to the ultra-rich.
- ObserverNeutral 6y ago> I would argue that much of the money expansion went to asset prices It can't possibly go to asset prices. For every buyer there has to be a seller. It's stuck in bank reserves
- simonsarris 6y ago"The FAAMGs reported aggregate 1Q sales of $321 billion, some $24 billion or 8% above consensus, for year/year growth of 41%." (zerohedge) What if the stock market is up because revenue and growth are up?
- listenallyall 6y agoWhat if revenue and growth are up because people received free money from the government?
- boplicity 6y agoMoney has to go somewhere. When the economy is shut down, there are few places to put money outside of the stock market. In short, people are willing to pay more for stocks, because the alternatives are not there at the same levels they used to be. Supply & Demand, basically.
- jraby3 6y agoDon’t forget about real estate prices. They’ve skyrocketed as well and are a very common way to park money.
- OldTimeCoffee 6y agoThey're up because housing has virtually no supply and massive demand, though. Houses are terrible assets as investment vehicles as they have very low returns and high disposal costs. They're really a last resort unless you want to be a landlord.
- jraby3 5y agoI disagree with this comment. Real estate can provide solid 5-7% after tax returns (in parts of the US) and due to leverage and low mortgage rates, a small annual increase in price can greatly increase the value of your investment. Most people only think of real estate as local, so if you look for returns in nyc or SF, you’ll be disappointed. But if you are willing to invest in property across the US you can find areas with much lower prices and higher rents.
- tryonenow 6y agoOr the 4% number is bullshit and we are in worse shape than the government and an overly sympathetic media would like to admit. Time will tell. Meanwhile if you look at individual commodities, some of them are quietly skyrocketing in price. Copper, steel, lumber, and a number of others. It's also possible that there's simply a long delay between flooding a struggling economy with cash and seeing the resulting tax on the middle class that we call inflation.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago> There's an important message here: the money expands by that much and inflation is .. 4%? I doubt this comment will age well. Macroeconomic effects don't happen instantly.
- MagnumOpus 6y agoA monetary expansion of similar magnitude happened after the GFC, and inflation didn't rise above this level for a decade... There just isn't that much of a relationship between base money and CPI as Friedman imagined 50 years ago. (Because banks also control credit supply and only give it to creditworthy borrowers... The Fed can drop rates to zero and give banks limitless money and they still won't lend it out to deadbeats.)
- ObserverNeutral 6y agoIt's a 2 way street. Fed can drop rates to zero but still people are too risk averse and have a negative outlook so they won't seek to submerge themselves with debt.
- missedthecue 6y ago2008 GFC is not comparable because QE (buying long term bonds to push down interest rates) does not result in a noticeable increase in the supply of money. Printing money and sending it to people does. Refer to the chart below. https://i.imgur.com/G35HlC9.png https://i.imgur.com/G35HlC9.png
- 542458 6y agoThis is why a single chart on imgur is bad and you should go to real sources. The way M2 was calculated changed in May 2020, a fact that should be on every reputable page containing that graph. https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/current/default.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h6/current/default.h... Also in a lot of ways M2 on its own is meaningless (money sitting under a mattress not being used doesn’t affect the economy) - velocity of money is more useful. Of course, inflation is complex and multicausal so this isn’t the whole picture, but it’s more useful than raw M2 supply. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2V https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2V
- JPKab 6y agoI studied applied economics in college. It's actually how I got into professional programming, due to coding for simulations as part of my major. It is way, way too early, based on my experience, to make any formal claims about why a given number is X instead of Y based on Z theory. People who are claiming there is going to be runaway inflation don't have enough data to suggest this, and your assertion is equally lacking in data to justify it. As always, economics gets contaminated by political biases, because so many prominent economists, including a hero of mine in college, Paul Krugman, have followed the profitable path of becoming full time political hacks. Likewise for Lafferty on the right and many others. Inflationary pressures typically, in historical terms and yes, in the simulations I used to model, have a lag and then start to build upon each other. We haven't had nearly enough time to properly assess any of this. Rest assured, if/when it does manifest, each side will have very firm talking points blaming the other, informing their sycophants exactly how to talk out of their rear ends about how it's the other team, and how their policies would have prevented it.