4 ms·
This is promising. Anecdotally though, I know people in India who got covid (with symptoms) twice or even thrice over the last 12 months. I imagine antibody gen
by paxys 6y ago
This is promising. Anecdotally though, I know people in India who got covid (with symptoms) twice or even thrice over the last 12 months. I imagine antibody generation is different for different people, and/or response to variants of the virus is different.
- PraetorianGourd 6y agoNot that I doubt you, but it is pretty common here in the USA to _assume_ every cold/allergy etc. is COVID-19, even without a positive PCR or anti-gen test. Did the folks you know get positively tested, or did sx just match?
- singhrac 6y agoSo not to pour more anecdotal fuel on the fire, so to speak, but I know of someone who had a confirmed case of COVID last spring in the US, then was tested for antibodies this spring and had few, and then caught it again in India a few weeks ago. Each time was symptomatic. Again, a single data point, I'd be happy to believe that there's lasting immunity.
- saalweachter 6y agoWith the re-infection rate given above -- 1 in 1000 -- if people ~know about 100 people, you'd expect about 1 in 10 people to have an anecdote about someone getting COVID twice.
- maxerickson 6y agoNeed to account for % infected. I know of ~3 people that I know that have been infected. That's not counting a few people at work that I don't really know and things like that.
- singhrac 6y agoI appreciate the attempt at analysis, but I'm not sure the numbers are so easy. The number of people I know of who had COVID a year ago runs around 5-10 (this is all second degree connections), so that'd be 1 in 100-200. True, we don't know how many people visiting this page are willing to share similar anecdote. But as a personal matter it's enough to change my behavior and concerns.
- saalweachter 6y agoYeah, as per the other person's reply, it's probably more accurate to estimate that 1 in 100 people will have anecdotes of someone catching COVID twice, based on the measured reinfection rate. If we knew the number of distinct people reading this, we could estimate how many people we could get anecdotes from, but I would be unsurprised if 10 or more people could chime in. There might be other factors that would push the reinfection rate higher (eg, if people are less likely to get another COVID test after having had it once, because they assume that's the one thing it can't be), and it's also worth remembering that a 1-in-1000 reinfection rate combined with ~10% of the population catching it means that closer to 1-in-100 people don't develop a lasting immunity [and the other 9-in-1000 just didn't catch it a second time].
- timr 6y agoThis sounds apocryphal. Second infections are incredibly rare, let alone three in twelve months. Like clockwork, every discussion of this matter on a discussion board brings out at least one person claiming to know people who have been re-infected, yet the number of confirmed examples is measured in the low hundreds, worldwide.
- dboreham 6y agoConfirmed examples perhaps, but if the reinvention rate is 1 in 1000 as stated elsewhere here then the true number worldwide is orders of magnitude higher than a few hundred.
- timr 6y agoIt isn't 1 in 1000, or we'd be confirming far more than a few hundred examples. The lack of examples isn't for lack of trying to find them -- immunity escape is currently the #1 pre-occupation of every national health service around the globe. The immune system works, and the failure cases here are truly exceptional, whereas the likelihood of rumor is high. Most of these "{my friend} got Covid twice" stories are either hearsay, or people imagining that their allergy symptoms were Covid, while never getting tested properly.
- true_religion 6y agoI think it’s low because in the beginning no one could get tested for COVID. I had an illness back in March 2020 that knocked me out for 2 weeks. Could have been COVID but my state had 0 available test kits so no one can confirm it. February 2021, I’m I’ll again for 2 week. This time it’s confirmed COVID. If we expect immunity to only last about 12 months, then it could have been reinfection especially considering by 2021 there were 4 more strains to get.
- timr 6y ago1) You're illustrating my point - you didn't have a first test, and are assuming it was Covid. It probably wasn't. 2) We don't "expect immunity to only last about 12 months". It's been about 12 months since the first cases were confirmed, so that's as far as we can say.