3 ms·
> Looking back, state lawmakers who passed the bill resetting property taxes for New York couldn't have dreamed of a skyscraper boom almost 35 years later. Rea
by paxys 6y ago
> Looking back, state lawmakers who passed the bill resetting property taxes for New York couldn't have dreamed of a skyscraper boom almost 35 years later.
Really? New York politicians didn't realize that skyscrapers and luxury condos were a thing in the 1980s?
This article lays out all the tax code shortcomings and writes it off as expensive condo sales being a new and unique phenomenon in NYC, which is bizarre.
Here's a simpler explanation – these laws are working exactly as designed.
- Scoundreller 6y agoKinda like land-transfer taxes that we have in Ontario Canada. Except corporations and trusts don’t transfer the land from generation to generation, so it’s basically a tax on people who’s living situation changes (upsizing, downsizing, death, divorce). So much for being a tax on speculators.
- auxym 6y agoAdd to that list: being laid off and having to move for a new job.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIn fairness, the phenomenon of Russian, Chiinese, Middle Eastern etc. oligarchs parking funds in unused apartments and buildings in places like NYC, London, Vancouver, etc. is fairly recent, and has indeed triggered a boom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billionaires%27_Row_(Manhattan) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billionaires%27_Row_(Manhattan...
- WillPostForFood 6y agoReally? New York politicians didn't realize that skyscrapers and luxury condos were a thing in the 1980s? I think that's overly cynical, and lacks historical context. In 1981, New York had gone through a decade of population decline. It was famously on the brink of bankruptcy before being bailed out by the federal government in 1975. There was New York City blackout of 1977. It was a much different, distressed, city at that time, and the idea of 90 million dollar condos would have seemed ludicrous.
- bobthepanda 6y agoIn that sense the tax code is working as designed but now overcharging the real estate market, given that NYC has traded Detroit-existential issues for gentrification ones.